ipl-logo

Mexican Gothic By Silvia Moreno-Garcia

756 Words4 Pages

Ibrahim Saidajan

Mr Hay

ENG4UE-00

25 July 2023

Mexican Gothic" by Silvia Moreno-Garcia: A Marxist Literary Analysis

"Mexican Gothic" by Silvia Moreno-Garcia is a haunting and captivating novel that explores the complexities of power, class struggle, and exploitation, seen through the lens of a Marxist literary theory. Set against the backdrop of 1950s Mexico, the novel unravels the story of Noemí Taboada, a young socialite who ventures to High Place, a decaying mansion in the Mexican countryside, to rescue her cousin, Catalina. As we delve into the narrative, we witness how the characters are entangled in a web of social hierarchies, reflecting the Marxist perspective of society's inherent class divisions. This essay aims to analyze …show more content…

This is shown when Francis, a member of the Doyle family, refers to the indigenous workers as "the help" (Moreno-Garcia, 2020, p. 40). By using this demeaning term, Francis reinforces the idea that these workers are nothing more than expendable labor, emphasizing the power dynamics between the upper class and the lower class. Another example of this is when Virgil Doyle, the patriarch, exploits the workers' fears by spreading rumors of a deadly disease in the area to discourage them from leaving. He exclaims, "It's all over now. You can't run away. The sickness is here, and it's going to get you" (Moreno-Garcia, 2020, p. 266). This tactic not only keeps the workers bound to High Place but also ensures their continued compliance and …show more content…

The indigenous workers at High Place are not only physically isolated but also culturally segregated, leading to a sense of disconnection from their own identity. This is demonstrated through the character of Marta, who tells Noemí, "We aren't allowed to speak Zapoteco" (Moreno-Garcia, 2020, p. 140). The denial of their native language further alienates them from their roots, making them feel like outsiders in their own land. Additionally, the novel portrays how the wealthy exploit the vulnerability of the working class, further exacerbating their alienation. When Noemí confronts the family about the horrible working conditions, Francis coldly replies, "We give them work, and we give them food. That's more than they'd get from anyone else" (Moreno-Garcia, 2020, p. 187). This statement underscores the unequal power dynamics that leave the workers feeling voiceless and

Show More
Related
1348 Words | 6 Pages

Jovita Gonzalez & Eve Raleigh’s Caballero: A Historical Novel, took place during the Mexican American War. While military officials from the United States were occupying Texas, Mexican men such as Don Santiago de Mendoza y Soria resisted the presence of the Americano. The novel focuses on the many injustices that occur within the Mexican population. One main problem that is presented is the social viewing of race and class. Mexican people with Spanish ancestry were more likely to be respected or accepted, while those whose blood was mixed were perceived as inferior.

Read More
750 Words | 3 Pages

Rylan Schutz Ms. Ivers World Literature 18 April 2023 Mexican Revolution Through the Marxist Lens “There are some things in life that shouldn't be given so much importance if they don't change what is essential.'' (Esquivel) This quote shows that no matter how high or low you are in society the essentials should be more important than the materialistic items. By analyzing Like Water for Chocolate by Laura Esquivel from the Marxist lens one can better understand more about how the economic lives of the characters affect the outcome of the book.

Read More
804 Words | 4 Pages

Marxist Criticism focuses on class struggle and power structure in a literary piece (Davidson). In the Time of the Butterflies by Julia Alvarez can be analyzed using Marxist Criticism to show how power is maintained in the novel. Trujillo maintains his power by convincing girls to live in his homes, jailing citizens who try to overthrow him, and killing citizens that he has large problems with. Trujillo uses his authority to make all of his citizens obey him so that he can keep his power, or else they must deal with severe consequences. Trujillo acts this way to prove that he is the man in charge and ultimately prove that he is unbeatable.

Read More
788 Words | 4 Pages

Bobrow-Strain deftly highlights the structural inequities that prevent Latinx people from moving ahead in society. The author emphasizes the enormous discrepancies encountered by Latinx communities and provides attention to the structural constraints they meet via Aida's experiences, such as her mother's low-wage employment and her own restricted access to decent education The growth of Aida's character serves as an example of the tenacity and power typical of Latino cultural settings. Aida refuses to let her surroundings alone define who she is despite the difficulties she endures. Her pursuit of education and her participation in activism to bring about change in her community demonstrate her drive to overcome her circumstances.

Read More
1318 Words | 6 Pages

It is unpleasant, but it was what she could afford, “By reputation, the Overseas park is a nest of crime and crack…” (274). Low income workers have limited options when choosing a home, where their best options are places like the Overseas park. Mantsios’ claims on class standing can be validated through Ehrenreich’s personal experiences living in an unsecure, but convenient area. If Ehrenreich had a better class standing, she would not live in

Read More
991 Words | 4 Pages

Jennifer Chun in her chapter “The Symbolic Leverage of Labor,” discusses the powers which workers, especially marginalized workers hold, and strategies through which the workers can increase their power. In this paper, I will first discuss the impact of globalization on declining structural power. Then, I will discuss how changing public perception in classification struggles and public dramas can be used to increase symbolic power.

Read More
526 Words | 3 Pages

The thick viscous tar further symbolizes the oppressive weight of the capitalist system that keeps farmworkers trapped in economic hardship. Through this example Viramontes is able to convey the way that societal norms pull down on immigrant families and these pits serve as a parallel to the thought process that no matter how long one can live in America there will still always be an immigrant part to a person and it becomes insult over injury if one is of lower class status, and one will always have that part of oneself pulling them

Read More
899 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout “The Mexican in Fact, Fiction, and Folkore” examines the term “Mexican” as it is applied in Southwest literature and argues the Anglo society has made a conscious effort to misrepresent Mexicans (Rios 60). He states the people of Mexican descent are viewed as un-American because they are perceived as filthy, lazy, and dumb. Ricatelli adds to the conversation of Mexican stereotypes by examining the literary expressions of Chicanas and Mexicanas in the literature of both the United States and Mexico. In “The Sexual Stereotypes of The Chicana in Literature” Ricatelli explains how in Yankee literature, the Chicana is referred to as the “fat breeder, who is a baby factory” meanwhile the Mexican is described as an “amoral, lusty hot tamale” (Ricatelli 51). He makes note of these stereotypes in order to highlight the ethnocentric and nativist points of view that dominated Anglo literature.

Read More
437 Words | 2 Pages

The House on Mango Street is set in a poor, primarily Hispanic neighborhood. Author Sandra Cisneros creates an atypical, yet easily digestible world for the reader to experience while learning about Esperanza’s childhood. The culture of her environment influences Esperanza’s development as she becomes a young woman, and contributes to the book’s driving theme of self-empowerment. Mango Street is the source of Esperanza’s growth through her childhood, and it hides sadness and longing underneath stereotypes of Hispanic people. The characters that live in the broken-down neighborhood all seem to represent pigeonholed views of Latino individuals.

Read More
1033 Words | 5 Pages

These corporations became increasingly powerful and influential, controlling vast amounts of wealth and resources. However, the success of these corporations came at the expense of workers, who often endured

Read More
547 Words | 3 Pages

The small village is inhabited by the mill workers, most of whom are men. In her description of the workers, the author refers to them as masses of men who work have bended to the ground, their bodies begrimed by the smoke and ashes of the mills, their lives imprisoned by the circumstances they find

Read More
1117 Words | 5 Pages

Esperanza is often humiliated not only by where she lives, but also by her physical appearance, hence causing a restriction in her climb to a higher social class. Esperanza is frequently ashamed of her family’s broken-down house in an urban, poor

Read More
1577 Words | 7 Pages

The work was also dangerous with not much supervising by the government. Workers, on the other hand, had little or even no bargaining power to leave the unsafe conditions. Nowadays, When Americans only pay attention when extreme work strike, levels of abuse are the norm hidden in the factories around the globe. Although the condition seems much improved, consumers don’t know the true fact- “Today, American citizens simply cannot know the working conditions of the factories that make the products they buy.

Read More
896 Words | 4 Pages

A Homage to Feminism Feminism revolves around the notion that men and women are equal, an idea that is seldom accepted or embraced at the end of the twentieth century in Latin America. In the autobiographical novel, The House of the Spirits, Isabel Allende weaves a story about the lives of women through four generations during the revolution of 1970. The idea of male dominance is prominent throughout both the political and social arenas of Latino communities. However, Allende uses members of the Del Valle family to portray the theme of feminism evolving during this time. Isabel Allende’s The House of the Spirits, highlights the intertwined lives of two Latin American women, Clara and Alba, to parallel the feminist attitudes that associate with

Read More
1476 Words | 6 Pages

In Mexican American society , women are deemed inferior to men, evident in traditional family roles, the male is the head of the family who provides for the family , while the woman stays at home to look after the children she is expected to provide for her husband . In the third vignette of ‘The House on Mango Street’ titled ‘Boys and Girls’ the reader is informed of the division between men and women when Esperanza refers to herself and her sister Nenny , and her brothers, “They’ve got plenty to say to me and Nenny inside the house. But outside they can’t be seen talking to girls”. The male dominance begins at a very young age.

Read More

More about Mexican Gothic By Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Related Topics

Open Document