ipl-logo

Mistaken Identity In A Midsummer Night's Dream

665 Words3 Pages

How Mistaken Identities Cause Out of Balance Love
In William Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream, the comedy element of mistaken identities causes the aspect of love to become unbalanced. The element of mistaken identities is when a character is confused with another character. Mistaken identities can lead to complications in the plot that must be resolved, such as love out of balance. This is when love is upset and the characters are not paired with their correct match, or if two characters love one, and another is left behind. Identities being mistaken in A Midsummer Night’s Dream causing love to be out of balance creates the main conflict of the play. The comedic element of mistaken identities is used frequently in Acts II and III …show more content…

He declares that the flower must use its full power on the man, because he has no love for the woman. Puck also confuses Hermia for Helena when he expresses sympathy for the woman. The element of mistaken identities is being demonstrated because Puck has mistaken Lysander for Demetrius, causing him to apply the love juice to Lysander. This leads to love becoming out of balance because Lysander will no longer love Hermia and will instead love Helena. This is an example of Shakespearean comedy because it is the crucial point in the plot since it causes the main problem. Shakespeare also uses the element of mistaken identities in Act III, Scene ii after Puck gave Demetrius the love juice. Now, both men are fighting over Helena, who is their new love, and insulting Hermia. The men have decided to settle their disagreement by going deeper into the woods to fight for Helena’s hand. Puck must stop the two before they get injured. To do so, he mimics their voices to get the two lost and separated so he can reverse the …show more content…

speak thou now.”
Demetrius (Puck): “Here, villain; drawn and ready. Where art thou?”
Lysander: “I will be with thee straight.”
Demetrius (Puck): “Follow me, then,/ To plainer ground.” (3.2.419-423)
Puck confuses Demetrius as well until both men are drowsy. The men sleep and he gives Lysander the antidote. This demonstrates the comedic element of mistaken identities because Puck successfully convinces each man that he is the other. This point in the play can be analyzed as Shakespearean comedy because it was incorporated to solve the play’s main conflict. It resolves the main conflict by allowing Puck to give Lysander the antidote, but not Demetrius who still loves Helena. It restores balance to the aspect of love in the play because the four lovers are split into two couples. Love is in balance after Lysander is given the antidote. Lysander loves Hermia and Demetrius is left under the effects of the love juice and loves Helena. Love is in balance and all is well since the problem forged by mistaken identities has been

Show More
Related
1255 Words | 6 Pages

In the play A Midsummer’s Night Dream by William Shakespeare, many of the characters relentlessly pursue their goals in the face of illogical decisions, and, while fictional items such as the “love-in-idleness” flower are used to explain the character’s sudden love for each other, the play does illustrate how love and ambition can lead to unforeseen consequences. For example, when Puck accidently anointed Lysander’s eyes with the “love-in-idleness” juice, he started a chain of events leading to Lysander and Demetrius fighting over Helena while Hermia is treated as though she is worthless. Moreover, at one point, Lysander and Demetrius even threatened to duel each other when Lysander awoke after being anointed with the flower 's juice and said, "Where is Demetrius? O, how fit a word is that vile name to perish on my sword" (61). This shows how the character’s love for certain other characters, and their ambition to pursue said love, can lead to the destruction of previous relationships and lead them to make dangerous decisions.

Read More
485 Words | 2 Pages

I know not by what power I am made bold" (1.1.55-56). This quote shows that Hermia is willing to stand up for herself and take control of her own fate, even when it means going against societal expectations. However, despite her agency, Hermia is also subject to the whims of fate and the supernatural. In Act 2, Scene 1, Puck mistakes Lysander for Demetrius and uses a love potion to make Lysander fall in love with Helena.

Read More
561 Words | 3 Pages

In A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Helena thinks that both Demetrius, Lysander, and Hermia are all playing a prank on her by making Demetrius and Lysander act like they love her. Helena delivers a monologue where she is accusing Hermia of being in on the prank. In Helena's monologue, Shakespeare portrays her character as a hurt, confused, and sad friend. Shakespeare cultivates this character through the use of accusatory and negative diction, symbolism, and similes.

Read More
735 Words | 3 Pages

The quote from Sigmund Freud, “One is very crazy when in love.” is very relateable to Shakespeare's play A Midsummer Night's Dream. Love is the dominant theme of the play. With the major conflicts surrounding the topic of love. Shakespeare demonstrates two major types of love.

Read More
757 Words | 4 Pages

  Hermia, much to her father 's dismay, is deeply in a mutual love with a different nobleman, Lysander.   In addition, Hermia 's childhood best friend and Demetrius were in love prior to his sights turning towards Hermia.   This crushed Helena, causing her to lose self-confidence, but still: she yearns for Demetrius 's love.   Hermia and Lysander 's love, Egeus 's harsh rule, and Helena 's unrequited love for Demetrius causes the lovers to leave Athens.

Read More
1182 Words | 5 Pages

On the first view to say, to swear, I love thee.” (Shakespeare 3.1.64-68). As noted earlier, Egues had chosen a man for Hermia to marry. This man was Demetrius, although Hermia was not in love him, Demetrius was madly in love with Hermia. Puck is instructed to place lotion into

Read More
669 Words | 3 Pages

In William Shakespeare’s timeless play Romeo and Juliet, two star crossed lovers are faced with great adversity as they hide their romance from their feuding families. As author James Lane Allen once said, “Adversity does not build character, it reveals it”. Romeo, a Montague, struggles to hide his love for the Capulet daughter, Juliet, from his family and friends. The challenge of lying to his closest companions, and going against his family’s ways to secretly marry Juliet causes Romeo to act erratically and carelessly. Throughout Act 3 Scene One, Shakespeare exposes the lovestruck Romeo’s mercurial nature and impulsivity through his thoughtless actions.

Read More
779 Words | 4 Pages

Toba Beta once said: "“Justice could be as blind as love.”   Shakespeare 's play A Midsummer Night 's Dream captures the blind bias of both love and justice.   Egeus, a respected nobleman in Athens, arranged for his daughter, Hermia, to marry nobleman Demetrius.   Egeus tells his daughter that she must obey his wishes: if she does not, she can either choose to become a nun, or die.   Hermia, much to her father 's dismay, is deeply in a mutual love with a different nobleman, Lysander.

Read More
523 Words | 3 Pages

Control can get out of hand when given to one single human being and can create major egregious problems to others. An infamous example is how Adolf Hitler attempted and almost succeeded to eliminate the entire Jewish population because he believed they were an inferior race. In Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream, the characters constantly try to control each other for the sake of who they love, to gain control over people’s lives, as well as the sole idea of revenge. A vital point in, A Midsummer Night's Dream is using control along with manipulation to gain love.

Read More
848 Words | 4 Pages

The strong effects of love makes Helena a bit foolish and blind in the ways she reacts to it. In scene one of act one, the readers learn that Helena still loves Demetrius even though he loves her friend, Hermia, now. When Helena is first introduced, she demonstrates her jealousy and insecurities by asking Hermia for some of her beauty to win Demetrius back. Hermia and Lysander inform her that they are running away, and that

Read More
958 Words | 4 Pages

The power of true love is evident in the play, the depiction of love reveals its true nature as in its pursuit it causes the characters to become irrational. True love in this play stems conflict from the troubles of romance by the actions of the lovers. The friendship between Hermia and Helena is at stake because of the romantic love that exists between the different parties in the play. Helena mistakes her obsession with Demetrius with love even though he is very rude to her.

Read More
948 Words | 4 Pages

In our scene, lines 42-179 of Act One, Scene One, the characters who try to force love upon others are seen antagonistically, while Hermia and Lysander, who strive for true, naturally occurring love, are seen as protagonists whose love should be defended. The overlying message of the play is that love should not and cannot be forced. Theseus, Egeus, and Demetrius use their power, both as nobles and men, to try and force Hermia into marrying Demetrius. Egeus, in an attempt to bully Hermia into marrying Demetrius says, ‘‘‘She is mine, and all my right of her I do estate unto Demetrius’’’ (1.1.97-98). He sees his power as Hermia’s father as a way to force her into a marriage that will benefit him.

Read More
1780 Words | 8 Pages

Unconditional love is a prevalent theme in A Midsummer Night 's Dream, and the blind nature of this love can be a great thing, especially since ignoring a romantic partner’s flaws can lead to a happier relationship. However, in A Midsummer Night 's Dream, Shakespeare takes his characters’ love to an irrational extent - so much so, that a prevalent theme of the play is the foolishness and folly of love. Context After being enchanted by Oberon’s love potion, Titania is awoken by Bottom, who she then falls madly in love with. She starts swearing her to love to him, to which Bottom responds: Analysis

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

Although Lysander does have the magic taken away from him, Demetrius never does, therefore he spends the rest of the play, in love with a woman he was not interested in for the first two acts of the play. By the completion of the play, just as in all of Shakespeare’s comedies, each person concludes the play with the person they wanted to be with in the beginning, other than Demetrius who still seems content to be marrying Helena. Although the nectar causes much of the discomfort and issues in the play, it is also what helps the woman who did not believe she deserved love, to believe that another person could love her for her, and luckily enough she does not seem to understand that her husband did not intend on living out his life in this

Read More
483 Words | 2 Pages

With many of the different scenes throughout the play, the theme of “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” is that love is difficult. In the play when Hermia 's father tries to tear Hermia and Lysander

Read More

More about Mistaken Identity In A Midsummer Night's Dream

Related Topics

Open Document