ipl-logo

Mozi Vs Mencius

636 Words3 Pages

The issue of governance has captivated political philosophers for ages. While typically seen as a Western concept, ideals of governance span all political thoughts. Specifically, within Chinese philosophy, thinkers such as Mencius, Confucius, and Mozi stand out. While Mengzi and Confucius’s ideals share many similarities, Mozi’s ideals contrast them. Nevertheless, by examining topics such as human nature, social and political responsibilities, and meritocracy, Mencius, Confucius, and Mozi provide commentary on the role of government and how men should behave in society so as to advance it. According to Mencius, the proper role of government is to advance virtuous acts. As seen through his response, “Why must Your Majesty say, ‘profit’? Let there be benevolence and righteousness and that is all.” (Mencius 1A1), Mencius argues that questions of benefits or costs are out of the picture. Furthermore, Mencius believed that a humane ruler would be a successful government. He argued that a ruler who “return[s] to the fundamentals” and has the “old to wear silk and eat meat” would always become the king of the society (1A7). Through these writings, Mencius stresses that rulers should act like parents, so as to be compassionate and kind. …show more content…

As such, Mencius prescribes such legitimacy within the Tian, which for Mencius includes aspects of fate, nature, and deity. He believed that through Tian, deeds and actions popular to society would be revealed (5A5). Moreover, the rule of a moral king is compared to the rule of Tian. Mencius attributes certain values such as “Benevolence in relation to father and son, righteousness in relation to ruler and minister, […] the sage in relation to the Way of Heaven” (7B24) to Tian. As a result, Mencius sees a ruler to be legitimate if he posses such virtues, is conferred with divine sanction, Tian, and rules with popular

Show More
Related
1175 Words | 5 Pages

In Doc 1 written by the Roman historian, Florus in c.150 says that there should not be a war with slaves and men should not be forced to follow the rules of a cruel ruler. Also, he stated that since the rulers/masters were cruel to their people, the ones that escaped tried to take revenge. On the other hand, in Doc 2, written by Han fei tzu, a Legalist philosopher, believed that the kingdom would be weak if the laws were weak. To prevent this, he said that there should be one supreme ruler that has absolute control over everything in the way that he wants to so as to not lose power and authority. This is significant because these liabilities and benefits show how, depending on how the government was run, and how the rulers treated their people,

Read More
310 Words | 2 Pages

As the administration system became more advanced, people expected their rulers to be virtuous and have good morals. In Document 5, the Chinese bureaucracy discusses the way a government should rule. One debater mentions that the landlords and the elite should not take an extreme advantage of their positions. Those at the top of the social ladder should be fair to both their equals and their subordinates. He also mentions that one of the main bonds between the Chinese commoners and the ruler is that there must exist some sort of trust.

Read More
2993 Words | 12 Pages

2. What is Confucius 's argument for virtue? They want to have a good leader and have faith on people and want people that follow rules. Ji said," What is killing good for?" Master knows that people will learn from that and will remember what they did wrong

Read More
1677 Words | 7 Pages

The Primary objective of all leaders should be to control citizens. A society that allows authority to be challenged will never succeed. This source depicts an authoritarian or totalitarian view of what a governing body should look like. The author suggests that the primary objective of government should be the “control of the citizens”, and therefore that the individuals should entirely obey said government.

Read More
650 Words | 3 Pages

For Aristotle states, “As long as this is unclear, the best regime must necessarily be unclear as well; for it is appropriate for those who govern themselves best on the basis of what is available to them to act in the best manner, provided nothing occurs contrary to reasonable expectation” (Pol. VII.i 1323al). In other words, rulers must act justly in order to be considered ‘good’

Read More
1561 Words | 7 Pages

This essay will compare and contrast the role and scope of government in the Qin and Han dynasties. It is often difficult to compare governments due to the spatial and temporal intricacies involved, however, due to the fact that the Qin and Han dynasties occurred consecutively the discussion is more appropriate. The Qin dynasty was guided by Legalist principles, and that dictated much of the role of the government. The Han dynasty shared some Qin principles, but built upon them as the dynasty progressed. Confucianism became the official state philosophy, and the emperors even began to include Confucian principles into the official governmental policy.

Read More
284 Words | 2 Pages

Confucianism acknowledges that the best way to make people behave is to govern them with virtue

Read More
719 Words | 3 Pages

How often do people judge the contents of a book based off of the cover? Seriously though, people often judge the contents of a book based off it’s cover. Many people think that by looking at the cover of a book, that it instantly determines the story of the book, whether the story is good or bad. Oftentimes, these judgments are misleading and don’t actually give people a good understanding of someone.

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

What– according to Gilgamesh, Hammurabi, Plato, Thucydides, Confucius, and the Koran– makes a good society? Thanks to the long lasting scriptures of these ancient thinkers and rulers, today, we are fortunate to be given the knowledge to understand the thoughts of sages; who lived thousands of years before us. Through myths, poetry and legal codes, these wise men express their philosophy on what it takes to create a good society. It is evident in all the texts, a presence of a Supreme Being or “God”, who dictates to the people how to behave, along with its respective consequences.

Read More
576 Words | 3 Pages

As Confucius states, “if good men were to govern the domain for a hundred years, they could wipe out violence and put an end to killing,” (Analects 90). While Aristotle and Confucius disagreed on the role of law in society—Aristotle thought that laws could make people moral where Confucius thought that if people could respect their leaders, then they would try to emulate them—the ideas of the two are more similar than they are

Read More
1353 Words | 6 Pages

Although both Confucius and Mencius have a lot in common with regards to governance, the two do have varying opinions on certain matters such as the legitimacy when rulers are overthrown, and the relationship between the ruler and his people. In precedence to coming up with policies and administrative measures, one has to first consider the issue of human nature as it plays an essential role in the development of a state 's political system. In the Confucian philosophy, the belief is that goodness is innate in humans and that everyone shares this same trait [子曰：“性相近也，习相远也。”] (Analects, 17.2). Mencius further elaborated on this doctrine by stating that it is mankind’s natural tendency to be kind to others, just as water would naturally flow downwards (Mencius, 6A2).

Read More
1232 Words | 5 Pages

He justifies the need for democracy, aristocracy and monarchy depending on location. The three philosophers use their judgment and prior knowledge on each other’s work to validate an ideal society, especially for the uprising continent of America. Governments are an established institution in every society. Though there are multiple types of governments, their purpose is fundamental to determining the influence on a civilization.

Read More
1047 Words | 5 Pages

While Confucius would emphasize the good of the old sage-kings, Han Feizi emphasized that it was not virtue that allowed any sage-king (which the Legalists hardly believed in to begin with) but rather a combination of “timeliness of seasons, the hearts of the people, skills and talents, and position of power” (Chan p. 254). Without these attributes, no amount of virtue can resolve disorder. Legalists, rather than focus on resolving disorder with virtue and filial piety, would therefore look at a leader’s ability to enact law and enforce statecraft. Han Feizi writes “if the ruler has no statecraft, he will be ruined . . . if ministers are without laws, they will become rebellious.

Read More
1212 Words | 5 Pages

1 INTRODUCTION Power and authority are the most important aspects of politics as such way of thinking comes a long way from the earliest thinkers such as Plato and Aristotle to mention few. They are the fundamental features of state in politics, focusing on who should have the power and authority over the people and who should rule them. During the time prior and after the birth of states, political authority has always been a major concern with regards to who should rule and how and who shouldn’t. Therefore this issues need to be addressed in a way that will at the end benefit the society. Plato is the thinker or theorist who came with addressing who should rule in a political environment in what Plato outlined that only Philosophers should rule.

Read More
2266 Words | 10 Pages

(Quote 5) “one must be transformed by the example of a teacher and guided by the way of ritual and rightness before one will attain modesty and yielding, accord with refinement and ritual, and return to order” This quote, is similar to Mencius’ view, as although both believe differently in the nature of humans, the two philosophers both stand for the importance of education, where teachers and rituals play a very big part in the development of a

Read More

More about Mozi Vs Mencius

Related Topics

Open Document