ipl-logo

Multiple Illustrations Of Ruth's Relationship With Dr. Foster

788 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Racism in Toni Morrison's works

Why are the multiple recounts of Ruth’s relationship with Dr. Foster?

Roshni Babal

Prior to reading Song of Solomon, by Toni Morrison, I had established a very clear view of what was true and what was not. In my head, there was always a definitive division between the two ideas; there was either the full, unexposed truth or a dishonest representation of events. However, upon reading the novel, I was faced with multiple recounts of Ruth’s relationship with her father- Dr. Foster- leading to me wondering about whether Ruth really did have an incestuous relationship with her father. This question had many responses, based on which character was answering; yet I was still unable to find the underlying truth about what had really occurred or …show more content…

Foster’s relationship through two very different direct perceptions: Macon Dead II’s and Ruth’s. After being punched by Milkman- who was trying to defend his mother- Macon Dead II attempted to explain his problem with Ruth’s father and herself, stating “ ‘ I knew then they’d ganged up on me forever- the both of them- and no matter what I did, they managed to have things their way ’ ” because of Ruth’s insistence to have her father deliver her children (71). Macon’s perception of the events are soaking with jealousy as he gives a one-sided story demonstrating his suspicions about his wife’s close relationship with her father until Dr. Foster dies and Macon Dead II sees Ruth “ ‘ In the bed...Laying next to [her father]. Naked as a yard dog, kissing him. Him dead and white and puffy and skinny, and she had his fingers in her mouth,’ ” (73). Macon Dead II paints a biased picture about Ruth’s initial jealousy and suspicion against Ruth and her father. As a result, Macon’s version of the truth shapes Milkman’s view of his own mother, as he begins to view her with disgust and contempt until he follows her to the graveyard and hears her own perception of the …show more content…

And for that I would do anything,’ ”, explaining why she loved him so much (124). However, when faced with the accusations of sleeping with her father, she states, “ ‘I did kneel there [in the bed] in my slip at his bedside and kiss his beautiful fingers. They were the only part of him that wasn’t...” (126). While her statement differs from Macon Dead II’s biased interpretation, Ruth shows how she was so close to her father because of his genuine care for her life, and even though she admits going into bed with him after he was dead, she claimed that she did it out of love and respect for him rather than lust- as Macon II stated. Milkman’s perception of his mother is once again affected because of her viewpoint of her relationship with her father, ending all suspicions against

Show More
Related
251 Words | 2 Pages

Throughout Toni Morrison’s Song of Solomon, Milkman Dead’s name serves as a constant reminder of his unhealthy relationship with his mother, Ruth Dead, which in itself is a reflection of her deep-rooted issues with her own personal life that are out of Milkman’s control. The significance of Milkman’s name has multiple layers to it. For example, it is important to recall that his real name is Macon because he makes a significant effort to distance himself from Macon Jr. and prove himself to be different from him. Ruth’s breastfeeding him well past his infancy results in his being stuck with the nickname “Milkman” before he is even old enough to understand the situation.

Read More
891 Words | 4 Pages

I looked up when he said this, startled by such a pathetically inadequate observation. Was that really what mattered to him right now—the condition of Ruth May’s soul?” (368). Leah has clearly begun to question the importance and validity of both religion and her father due to Ruth May’s death. While the passing of Ruth May is evidently overwhelming for the Price family, it also facilitates Leah’s rebellion against Nathan Price.

Read More
1096 Words | 5 Pages

Furthermore, Ruth’s endless, captivating love restricts Milkman and thwarts his personality’s development to a mature man. His search for his self cannot be satisfied at home since he has no space to become independent or is regarded as a separate

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

She grows old with the self-condemnation of staying with Nathan for as long as she did, for if she mustered up the courage to leave the Congo earlier, Ruth May would not have died. Ruth May’s plea for Orleanna to forgive herself, just as Ruth May has forgiven her, presents the possibility of repentance for anyone, no matter how great of consequence their mistakes are. Though she never passed the age of 6, Ruth May seems to have learned better than most the importance of finding strength from and learning from wrong-doings. Urging her mother to “Move on. Walk forward into the light”, Ruth may passes along her own moral reassessment to anyone whom will listen, telling the error in letting so-called sins weigh down ones self forever

Read More
1813 Words | 8 Pages

One example of how Ruth’s sorrow is shown to the reader is early in the story when the narrator introduces Ruth, saying that “Ruth’s arm, linked with Matt’s tightened, he looked at her. Beneath her eyes there was swelling from the three days she had suffered” (111). This introduction to Ruth’s character is able to display her feelings of loss because of the fact that one of the first traits the reader learns about Ruth is that she had cried for three days after the loss of Frank, which does clearly show her sorrow because of the fact that three days is definitely a strangely long time to be crying for, especially since it seems like the entire family, besides her, had already moved on from crying about the loss. Another example of how Ruth is affected by loss is shown the night of Richard’s murder when Matt reflects on how “he believed Ruth knew... When Ruth said good night she looked at his face, and he felt she could see see in his eyes the gun, and the night he was going to” (116-117).

Read More
722 Words | 3 Pages

When Toni Morrison began her novel, Song of Solomon, she introduces her readers to a world in which Caucasian Americans have full power over their African American neighbors. Detailing the pessimistic treatment of African Americans, readers come to believe in the stereotypical “weak, black man,” of African Americans who allow themselves to be dominated, who see the dangers that are forced upon them and bow down to them, obliging to the torture and prejudice they face every day. This portrait of acceptance is broken, torn into a million pieces when Morrison goes in depth into the secondary character of her novel, Guitar, during the sixth chapter. In the previous 154 pages of Song of Solomon, Guitar is elucidated as simply the best friend of the main character, Milkman, as someone who is only present in the tale to listen to the problems of his friend and give knowledgeable advice. Until chapter 6, Guitar is nothing but a clear definition of “best-friend-forever,” someone who helps the main character but does nothing else, while Milkman is the reverse of him as he gets receives all of the attention of Morrison, detailing his character traits and identity.

Read More
500 Words | 2 Pages

Milkman discovers his family name and history, and while on his journey, Milkman finds happiness, understanding, and a sense of identity. While the actual findings of his family is important, Milkman’s discovery of his own identity through his family’s history is the true take-away from the

Read More
818 Words | 4 Pages

In Song of Solomon, written by Toni Morrison, deep concern for not only the existence and development of the black community is shown, but also for human beings in general. Questions such as “Why and how are individuals isolated from society?” , “What voice is created in isolation?”, and even “How does an individual resolve conflict between personal ethics and social morality?” strictly apply to Song of Solomon. Milkman, the protagonist, embarks on an unwitting search for his roots and ties to the black community, all while feeling isolated from society.

Read More
866 Words | 4 Pages

Without familial ties and history, Milkman lacked the wisdom that comes with knowledge of the past, causing a disconnect between Milkman and his people. Milkman’s journey provides him with the answers to his identity problem allowing his family’s past to provide instruction, and protection, and a certain kind of wisdom necessary in finding his true self. Although Milkman must ultimately define himself, he is also defined by his relationships. He cannot learn these lessons in isolation but only within the context of the present community and relations of

Read More
800 Words | 4 Pages

In Song Of Solomon by Toni Morrison, the setting takes place near Lake Superior in Detroit, Michigan around the black community. The story revolves around the character Milkman who is born in a wealthy colored family. The motif of flight plays a significant role in Milkman’s action in his journey. The motif flight represents escape from one's life burdens, freedom and life. Throughout Milkman’s journey to become more independent, and learn his family history.

Read More
1552 Words | 7 Pages

His social awakening also inspires a change in attitude towards the treatment of women. Initially, Milkman objectifies Hagar and treats her as an inferior, but when he encounters Sweet, he begins to reciprocate her affections and treat her with respect. Furthermore, Milkman’s change in motivation for his flight south illustrates the development of his maturity through his pursuit of his family’s history, proving that attaining wealth is no longer his sole purpose. During his time south, Milkman was maliciously pursued by Guitar. His attempted murderer of Milkman creates the illusion of a resurrection to which Milkman develops social awareness.

Read More
1227 Words | 5 Pages

Milkman’s identity begins taking shape as a child with his family that constantly coddles him

Read More
1288 Words | 6 Pages

She was the sign of misfortune in the entire novel: deprived of sexual interaction with her husband for twenty years, delivering Milkman as a consequence of a shock from a frightening accident, and withstanding the physical violence of her husband even in front of their children. She was never respected or seriously loved by any male characters in the novel—Milkman was ashamed and careless of her, Macon her Husband hated her, and even her father was somewhat embarrassed by their intimacy which Ruth intended. Ironically, she was the daughter of the great Doctor who has a street named after him and the wife of Macon Dead, who is the richest person in town. This contrast emphasizes the tragedy of the character that despite her superior or seemingly advantageous status quo, she still led a miserable life. Morrison quoted that she started the book as an attempt to shatter some of the common stereotypes the 1960s has brought to African American community, which, as she reckons, has left out an enormous portion of the racial character for over-emphasizing the beauty and strength and thereby

Read More
1334 Words | 6 Pages

1. Beloved, the novel by African-American writer Toni Morrison is a collection of memories of the characters presented in the novel. Most characters in the novel are living with repressed painful memories and hence they are not able to move ahead in their lives and are somewhere stuck. The novel, in a way, becomes a guide for people with painful memories because it is in a way providing solutions to get rid of those memories and move ahead in life. The novel is divided into three parts; each part becomes a step in the healing ritual of painful repressed memories.

Read More
898 Words | 4 Pages

Yet, at home, she devotes love and curiosity to her family. This contrasts to multiple other characters, as the relationship between Ruth and her single mother is inspiring. Accordingly, she respects her mother, who provides encouragements like, “It is better to light a candle than curse the darkness.” With pure gratitude, Ruth seeks to apply her mother’s words. When bullies trouble Philip, Ruth can empathise with him.

Read More

More about Multiple Illustrations Of Ruth's Relationship With Dr. Foster

Related Topics

Open Document