ipl-logo

My Ántonia By Aristotle Character Analysis

1546 Words7 Pages

Does one need other means besides virtue to obtain happiness? In Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotle, he discusses this topic. Throughout the book, Aristotle claims there are other means necessary. Through the examination of a passage from My Ántonia by Willa Cather, this idea is proven further. Virtue is something needed to obtain happiness, but along with Virtue, one also needs sufficient means, such as external goods and the absence of misfortune. Establishing Aristotle's definition of virtue helps prove this idea further. Aristotle claims that there are two types of virtue, those being "that of intellect and that of character" (Aristotle 1103a.14-15). Intellectual virtue comes about through "teaching" (1103a.15). An example is wisdom. Aristotle …show more content…

In My Ántonia, the book ends with Jim paying Ántonia a visit after not visiting her in years. Ántonia has "a fine life" now, as Jim says (Cather 235). Ántonia has ten children and is married to a man named Cuzak. While examining Ántonia’s life, Jim claims that "[he] wondered whether the life that was right for one was ever right for two"(235). Through this observation, Jim is implying that Ántonia has the life that is right for her. Jim believes that this is not necessarily the life that Cuzak wanted, but he believes it is the perfect life for Ántonia. During Jim’s visit, Ántonia possesses the virtue of generosity. According to Aristotle, generosity is the mean of "wastefulness and stinginess" (Aristotle 1107b.10). Ántonia very much expresses that she has this mean during Jim’s stay. She is very welcoming to him, offers to let him stay, makes his food, and teaches him about all of her children. In Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle makes a claim that relates to Ántonia’s adulthood. Aristotle says that "no activity is complete when it is impeded, and happiness is something complete"(1153b.14-15). This means that when a person achieves happiness, no other things are interrupting it. Further on, Aristotle talks about how different misfortunes can cause happiness to be impeded. This relates to Ántonia’s life while she is an adult because while she is an …show more content…

Throughout Ántonia’s life, she experiences many great misfortunes, but a very impactful one is the death of her father. Ántonia is always very worried about her father, and she constantly reminds Jim that her father does not "look good"(Cather 59). After Ántonia makes her last comment about this, Jim finds out that her father has committed suicide and that Ántonia and her family were in "great distress"(62). Once Jim finally sees Ántonia after this disaster, she hugs him, and Jim notes that "it seemed to [him] that [he] could feel her heart breaking as she clung to [him]"(74). Ántonia’s father's death has brought great sadness into her life. This is also another instance of when Ántonia's life was not "right" for her (235). During this time, Ántonia possesses the virtue of courage. According to Aristotle, courage is the mean of cowardice and rashness (Aristotle 1104a.19-23). Ántonia is very courageous after hearing about her father’s death; she is not afraid and even goes on to continue his work in the fields (Cather 79). Ántonia was not too cowardly, and she most definitely was not too rash during this time. This experience of Ántonia and her family also relates very closely to a passage in Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics. Aristotle says, "People who claim that the person being tortured or the person who has fallen on very bad times is

Show More
Related
274 Words | 2 Pages

In Eudora Welty’s autobiography, One Writer's Beginnings, employs emotional diction and imagery while describing the reading that took place in her childhood. Welty’s purpose is to describe the elder figures in her life that shaped her love of reading and how it impacted her later career. She adopts a sentimental tone while reflecting on Mrs. Calloway’s strict ruling of the library, her mother's fierce attitude, and her motivation to read. Welty begins her tribute by characterizing the strict librarian who commanded the library all by herself.

Read More
382 Words | 2 Pages

Antonia and Jim both traveled to Nebraska leaving places that they loved. Jim had just lost his parents while Antonia left her homeland that she loved dearly. Her father’s sadness was noticeable to Antonia and she held that burden close to her heart. She longed for her father to overcome his sadness of missing their home in Europe. She recognizes that her family was not the same.

Read More
354 Words | 2 Pages

Regardless of all of the difficult circumstances she made the best outcome of all of her hardships and difficulties. `After Antonia and her family got there and they went to Jim’s house telling them about her Papa’s friends this made me feel like she was happy for her family even despite moving away from her normal

Read More
1589 Words | 7 Pages

Even through all of the hardships, Antonia was able to stay positive and upbeat and handle all of the challenges she was presented. Antonia was also portrayed as strong-willed throughout her journey. Even when Mr. Shimerda committed suicide, Antonia did not give up. She set her life, future and goals aside and worked long and hard days in the field to help support her family through the the hard and rough times of living their lives as immigrants on the prairie. "School is all right for little boys.

Read More
783 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout Bless me Ultima, the protagonist Antonio experiences intensive trauma that would paralyze most children in fear. He preserves through his childhood trauma and instead of submitting and quitting due to the traumatic events of his past, Antonio instead embraces his experiences, learning from each one. Although all the traumatic experiences Antonio went through were traumatic and impactful, a particularly impactful event Antonio experienced which allowed great development of his personality was witnessing the death of his friend Florence. Witnessing the death of Florence caused the most trauma to Antonio, which led to the biggest changes of Antonio’s character. One example of why Florence's death was so traumatic was because of his close relationship with Antonio.

Read More
268 Words | 2 Pages

On the contrary with Aristotle, right off the bat he says that most people will not reach true happiness. When one knows off the top that they will not accomplish something, one of two things will happen. They will either give up or they will push or work even harder. The question then changes for Aristotle from what is happiness, to will enough people challenge themselves enough to reach for the impossible? It is those people that push themselves harder that will reach true happiness.

Read More
644 Words | 3 Pages

Thus, Antonia demonstrated herself as a hard working girl, both before and after the death of her

Read More
1019 Words | 5 Pages

As Antonia’s life becomes more difficult after a long gruesome winter. She faces death, and self-sacrifice while still keeping her strong emotional connection to life. She starts to take on more of her fathers responsibilities, and helps her brother work in the fields. The way Antonia handles the situations

Read More
513 Words | 3 Pages

She loved the Harling children as her own. She served Jim’s grandparents as if she was their bondservant. Whatever she did, she did wholeheartedly, tending the seeds of love and hope she had planted. And this did not fail her, for at long last she harvested the love, admiration, and respect of everyone around

Read More
1025 Words | 5 Pages

Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics begins by exploring ‘the good’. Book I argues that, unlike other goods, “happiness appears to be something complete and self-sufficient, and is, therefore, the end of actions” (10:1097b20-21). In other words, happiness is the ultimate good. But how does one achieve happiness? Aristotle formulates this in the context of work, since for all things, from artists to horses, “the good and the doing it well seem to be in the work” (10:1097b27-28).

Read More
1210 Words | 5 Pages

Thus, when human function is done well, it is in accordance with virtue and best human life is achieved. In addition, it can be inferred that since Aristotle’s definition of happiness is to be virtuous, performing rational activity well can lead to happiness. In addition, Aristotle states, “if there are more than one virtue, in accordance with the best and most complete” (1098a18). This means that eventually there will be one virtue that is inclusive of all virtue and that displays an end, and this virtue will be in line with the self-sufficient and inclusive concept of happiness as the chief good. If this inclusive virtue and good is achieved, ultimate happiness will be achieved as well.

Read More
814 Words | 4 Pages

She loves learning new things. Antonia loves her lessons to learn and read english. The narrator tells us this when he states that "Almost everyday she

Read More
1087 Words | 5 Pages

In Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, the concept of happiness is introduced as the ultimate good one can achieve in life as well as the ultimate goal of human existence. As Aristotle goes on to further define happiness, one can see that his concept is much different from the 21st-century view. Aristotelian happiness can be achieved through choosing to live the contemplative life, which would naturally encompass moralistic virtue. This differs significantly from the modern view of happiness, which is heavily reliant on material goods. To a person in the 21st-century, happiness is simply an emotional byproduct one experiences as a result of acquiring material goods.

Read More
1413 Words | 6 Pages

It is critical to recognize Mill’s argument that a degree of contentment can exist in periods of less happiness. However, Aristotle’s view of perceiving wellbeing or goodness as ultimate is more pronounced. Worth emphasizing, Aristotle deeply explores his arguments basing them on functions of a rational man and virtues out of habits. Today, a virtuous citizen is one whose actions are inward, in response to conscience and moral obligations as a member of society. Such a person, not waivered with intensities of pleasures, honor, and wealth but seeks to have a satisfactory level of happiness with friends, co-workers, and family among other

Read More
908 Words | 4 Pages

At the end of everyone’s lives, the goal appears to be about attaining happiness. Describing how to obtain happiness has been an issue that was debated in the past but is still talked about now . In Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle expands on his view of happiness and he focuses particularly on how reason helps recognize and pursue what will lead to happiness and the good life. I feel that Aristotle’s philosophies on happiness are important works within the field of philosophy and he considered one of the………of it . In this paper, I will explore Aristotle’s beliefs regarding happiness then compare and contrast them to those of Martin Seligman.

Read More

More about My Ántonia By Aristotle Character Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document