ipl-logo

My Sister's Keeper Essay

597 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The Moral dilemma of abortion

What is your understanding of the Catholic Church’s teaching on conscience and informed conscience?
Conscience is an integral part of being human. It is defined as an individual’s moral sense of right and wrong, which enables the judgement of the moral quality of a concrete act (Boland, 2017). The Catholic Church teaches that for an act to be moral, the objective of that act, its intention, and its consequences must all be ‘good’. If one of these aspects is breached, then that act cannot be considered morally good (Boland, 2017).
The Catholic Church encourages its followers to “follow your conscience” (beginningCatholic.com, 2016), but also teaches that humans have an obligation to develop their understanding of what is right and wrong in …show more content…

An individual cannot live a moral life whilst neglecting the duty to inform their conscience, because they have failed to equip themselves with the knowledge gained from Catholic teachings to differentiate between sinful acts and good acts (beginningCatholic.com, 2016).
Identify one moral dilemma presented in the film My Sister’s Keeper:
In the film My Sister’s Keeper, Kate’s parents were given the option of manufacturing a child (Anna) to help keep Kate alive. However, Anna would consequently experience a significantly lower quality of life.
• Identify the value/moral being challenged or supported.
The film challenges the morality of a family having a child for the primary purpose of keeping their cancer-stricken daughter Kate alive, whilst condemning that child to a significantly lower quality of life due to constant limb donations and operations (My Sister's Keeper, 2009). Thus, the quality of life for both Kate and Anna would need to be taken under consideration by the family. Anna’s struggles with limb donation are highlighted throughout the

Show More
Related
1830 Words | 8 Pages

Some of the biggest ethical issues today were highlighted in this book. James McBride not only covered how his choices affected him but how his mother’s choices affected her and her

Read More
684 Words | 3 Pages

To be our brothers and sisters keeper means that we have to watch out for them and care about even if it 's not our favorite thing to do but we do it because we care about them. John Steinbeck wrote this book in 1937, The book is about two farmers who had dreams of having their own farms and one of the characters named george looks out for Lennie because he has a mental disability. He wrote the book to show that if you are your brothers keeper you will do what 's best for them. A brother 's keeper watch out for them, does what 's best for them, and it 's part of their responsibility because we care for them.

Read More
888 Words | 4 Pages

A conscience is known as an inner feeling or voice that acts as a guideline for the morality of one’s behaviour. In Lorna Dueck’s “Why conscience (or lack of it) is in the news”, she portrays the purpose of a conscience in an individual’s decisions and actions. Dueck questions individual’s conduct then provides solutions to achieve a better world. She includes other sources to strengthen her argument on how one’s conscience reflects their behaviour. As well, Dueck uses a logical perspective to convince the audience the importance of a morally shaped conscience.

Read More
1367 Words | 6 Pages

The people behind the scene who took care of the soldiers were as important to the people who were fighting in the front lines. The heritage minute clip on the Nursing Sister is effective, although it only highlights two nurses, in particular, Eleanor Thompson and Eden Pringle, the true meaning is to recognize the contributions of all the Canadian women who volunteered as nurses during the First World War. This paper will examine the purpose of the clip, how the event contributed to Canadian identity and accurate representation of Canadian history. Nursing Sisters video demonstrates a clear objective of what the meaning behind this particular heritage minute clip is. Prior to the 19th century, women becoming nurses was considered unacceptable,

Read More
196 Words | 1 Pages

In every day life, we face many situations that require a moral decision. We have to decide what is right and what is wrong? Not always is this an easy task thus, it seems important to analyze how we make our moral decisions. I will start with an analysis of how we make decisions in general

Read More
944 Words | 4 Pages

Brian Fitzgerald, the father of Anna, Kate and Jesse Fitzgerald, is a firefighter and spends his days battling the fires, both real and symbolic, which destroy other people’s lives. Unfortunately, he is unable to fight the fires within his own life, and this leads to the destruction of his ability to save his family from the difficult situations they face. The Fitzgerald family’s medical and moral issues that stem from Anna being born as a medical donor for Kate affect each of the characters in different ways. In My Sister’s Keeper, fire is the mechanism used to symbolize these problems that the Fitzgerald family faces. Fire in a general sense is the combustion that occurs when fuel reacts with oxygen to release heat energy.

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

In the stories “My Sister’s Keeper” and “Rules of the Game” there are many similarities and differences between them. One similarity between Anna from My Sister’s Keeper and Mei from Rules of the Game is that they both have awful childhoods. The awful childhoods are caused by their mother’s wishing for a better life. On pg 354 in My Sister’s Keeper ____ says “well, sometimes to get what you want the most, you have to do what you want the least.” I think that this is representative of how both the mother’s feel about making their daughters’ do things they don’t want to to get to a better life.

Read More
1495 Words | 6 Pages

Those who commit wicked acts because they can not see what is truly good have a skewed point of view for a reason.  Their character is tainted by vice because they have habitually committed vicious acts in the past.  Since they originally had a conscience, they must have willingly committed wrongdoing to warp their perception of what is good.   Therefore, those who pursue an apparent good but commit wrong acts, due to a skewed appearance of what is good, are still responsible for their

Read More
1009 Words | 5 Pages

Critical Literacy, in my opinion, is the ability to read texts and be able to analyze, interpret and understand social inequalities that are present in society. Using this ability allows individuals to see the world in a more critical light and are able to challenge the norms that are set. This is important in teaching because educators are able to encourage students to scrutinize issues and critique the norms by demonstrating how these norms are not experienced by all members of society. One effective way of challenging these norms is by the use of non-mainstream children’s books that are available; reading these to the classroom and allowing students to understand it is a great way of getting them to gain that critical lens.

Read More
822 Words | 4 Pages

Imagine how it feels to be stuck in a tiny, miniscule room for almost two years, not able to make a sound or movement and if heard by someone,death or concentration camp is the destination? The Diary of Anne Frank by Frances Goodrich and Albert Hackett is about a small family which consists of Anne, Margot, Mr. Frank, and Mrs. Frank who were in a shock of fear, and went into hiding during the Nazi occupation of the Netherlands. Over the course of the story other characters join the family into hiding such as Mr. and Mrs. Van Daan, and their son Peter. During the time of hiding, Anne kept a diary to write down all her thoughts, fears, and feelings and was later known to be the most important piece of literature from the times of the Holocaust. The story takes you through their everyday lives of hiding in the annex which also includes arguing and times of happiness.

Read More
859 Words | 4 Pages

In life, we are not guaranteed a long life or even a pain free life. The author talks about a very emotional decision that a young couple must make concerning their critically ill daughter and their journey of choosing to do everything possible to save her life but regrettable not being with her when she died. As the family and the medical team reflect on the life of Charlotte, the young little girl that died, many questions were asked. Did the medical team accurately assess the situation? Did they provide immediate lifesaving treatment?

Read More
1871 Words | 8 Pages

Kate crisis also put an extra strain on her sister which caused her to be sick sometimes from donating. Kate was unwilling to let her illness break her spirit as it was doing to her mother. Her mother allowed Kate’s situation to keep her from recognizing the other people in her family needs. Kate had been through multiple surgeries, and she always tried to put her best foot forward although there were a few times that she felt angry, and she started acting unlike herself by doing things like drinking alcohol. It came a time in Kate’s life when she knew her situation was not getting better, so she wanted to stop all the medical operations.

Read More
765 Words | 4 Pages

The event that has shaped me into who I am today is that I am a big sister. I am a big sister to my brother and sister. It has helped me to become a better student in school and class. Having a brother and sister, though it has been a rollercoaster in my life, it has shaped me into who I am today in school and class. I was an only child until I was almost three when my little sister was born.

Read More
1414 Words | 6 Pages

Moreover, another instance where one can see lack of conscience, albeit in an understandable way, would be the child soldiers. These kids were programed to follow their leader, superego, and kill when they had to, proving the loss of conscience. Even when face-to-face with his father, one of these soldiers still acted in accordance

Read More
455 Words | 2 Pages

Henry Louis Mencken describes our conscience as “the inner voice that warns us somebody may be looking”; however, this is not the case in reality. This idea implies the conscience acts only to help someone save face and protect his/her reputation; it stops us from doing what is wrong only to maintain one’s own image. Our conscience actually does this and more. Conscience stops us from doing bad not only to protect our image but also—to put it simply—just to stop us from doing what is wrong. Conscience is our moral compass that makes us do what is good simply because it is what we believe is right for us to do.

Read More

More about My Sister's Keeper Essay

Related Topics

Open Document