ipl-logo

Naturalism In Edith Wharton's The House Of Mirth

582 Words3 Pages

In his article entitled, “The Naturalism of Edith Wharton’s The House of Mirth” Donald Pizer discusses Wharton’s focus of naturalism in her novel, The House of Mirth. Pizer argues, “The House of Mirth may best be read as a form of naturalistic fiction” (241). Though some people disagree on what type of naturalism Wharton’s novel is, Pizer states “Whether Lily’s fate is shaped by the capitalistic exchange values of her society or by its patriarchal power structure or by some variation of these two central readings the novel” is naturalistic (241). Overall, Pizer maintains that Wharton used a specific form of naturalism—challenging that naturalism exclusively pertains to social determinism—that is distinct from her contemporaries: …show more content…

Pizer argues that, “Nettie’s progress from ‘victim’ to ‘victory’ within her own category of social determinism”, which shows Lily that “victory is also possible…within her own seeming manacles of environmental conditioning” (244). Consequently, Nettie’s “powerful will and the providential actuality of a man willing to take a chance on her” is what separates her from Lily (244). Pizer maintains that through the contrast between Nellie and Lily’s situations, Wharton is defining naturalism, “not…as fully and destructively conditioned for all mankind; rather… the powerful effect of environment and heredity on various and specific kinds of temperament and experience” (245). Moreover, “all are exposed to and deeply affected by the conditioning forces of life, but some not only survive but even triumph” …show more content…

For instance, when Selden goes to Lily’s death bed and has a “this moment of love, this fleeting victory over themselves…which made all clear” he realizes that “the ‘conditions of life’ conspire to defeat the spiritual fulfillment which is human love. But love did exist and continues to exist despite this defeat” (246). Therefore, Selden’s “faith” allows him to “penitent” so that the “word” may be symbolically spoken to each other. Moreover, Pizer argues “life seemingly defeats the human effort to believe in a spiritual force in life, but in fact that belief transcends defeat both in its functional force in human affairs during life and in its permanence despite the transience of life”

Show More
Related
1475 Words | 6 Pages

Nature is not only the trees, leaves, and, soil but, it encompasses a wide variety of things that cover both physical, mental, and even spiritual elements. Most important to Feige is that “Nature is infinitely large and varied”, omnipresent throughout the world (9). Nature can not be confined to a single presence but underlies in everything in the world. By Feige’s definition of nature “A body’s flesh blood and bone” also fall into the natural order of the world which expands nature’s reach to all of mankind. The main idea Feige stresses to the reader about nature, is that everything from a wooden farm to the American Republic is rooted in the natural order of things.

Read More
825 Words | 4 Pages

It is common for people in everyday society to conform to society’s expectations while also questioning their true desires. In the novel, The Awakening, by Kate Chopin, the main protagonist Edna Pontellier is said to possess, "That outward existence which conforms, the inward life that questions." In other words, Edna outwardly conforms while questioning inwardly. Kate Chopin, uses this tension between outward conformity and inward questioning to build the meaning of the novel by examining Edna’s role as a wife, mother, and as nontraditional woman in the traditional Victorian period. Edna outwardly conforms to society’s expectations by marriage.

Read More
1401 Words | 6 Pages

In the story, Kidd’s use of characterization successfully reveals the theme that people's lives are more complex than they appear. Kidd demonstrates this theme using the characterization of Lily, T. Ray, May, and Deborah. One character that Sue Monk Kidd uses to portray the theme, is the main character Lily. In the beginning of the story, the author shows that Lily can be both mature and immature at times. An example of her maturity in the text is when she says, “People who think dying is the worst thing don’t know a thing about life” (Kidd 2).

Read More
642 Words | 3 Pages

In Edith Wharton’s most remarkable novel, Ethan Frome, the main character, Ethan Frome, is in love with a prohibited woman… his wife's cousin. His wife, Zeena, is a sick woman who has a villainous essence to her and an irrevocable hold on Ethan. Mattie Silver is Zeena’s cousin and the woman Ethan is infatuated with. Through Ethan’s eyes, Mattie is described as youthful, attractive, and graceful basically everything Zeena isn’t.

Read More
734 Words | 3 Pages

Naturalism is a type of literature that attempts to apply scientific principles of objectivity and detachment to its study of human beings. Naturalism took place from 1890-1915. Some characteristics of Naturalism include: Survival of the fittest, violence (force vs. force), animal imagery, determinism, and taboo topics. Also, Naturalism is aimed at the lower class and is about the darker side of life. Ethan Frome is a novel written by Edith Wharton in 1911.

Read More
334 Words | 2 Pages

The House of Mirth, written in 1905 is an exemplary novel narrated through the eyes of an upper class woman. Through

Read More
1407 Words | 6 Pages

Edith Wharton masterfully weaves mythological references and influences throughout "The Age of Innocence" to enhance the narrative's depth and explore timeless themes. Through the characters of Newland Archer and Ellen Olenska, Wharton draws upon the foolish "hero" archetype and the figure of the forbidden temptress, connecting their struggles to those of mythological figures such as Orpheus and Helen of Troy. The Goddess Diana and the myth of Icarus symbolize the power of societal expectations and the potential consequences of deviating from them, as well as the damaging nature of man to misinterpret and discredit the true depth of the women in their life. By incorporating these mythological elements, Wharton highlights the enduring nature

Read More
3463 Words | 14 Pages

As a text seemingly disparate from Edith Wharton’s other novels, scholarship surrounding Summer has tended to focus on gender and power constructions between Mr. Royall and Charity Royall. Recent scholarship, however, has focused on the social and cultural aspects of Summer. Elizabeth Ammons has taken a stark stance, problematizing Wharton’s portrayals of race by reifying normative racial constructions of the early twentieth century (68). Anne MacMaster notes the centrality of racial representations, though they appear to be marginal concerns to the plotline, in Wharton’s other work, The Age of Innocence.

Read More
807 Words | 4 Pages

When Cather had to move to Nebraska, she hated it for the first year or so. This shows Naturalism because she sulked over the fact that she had to move. Likewise, in the story, Alexandra had gone through some tough times. Cather wrote, “She began to wonder whether she would not do better to finish her life alone. What was left of life seemed unimportant.”

Read More
917 Words | 4 Pages

Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s, “The Yellow Wallpaper”, exhibits the domestic entrapment of women by society in the 19th century by adopting a naturalistic approach to the mood, tone, and other literary elements used in the short story. Naturalism is a genre of literature that started in the late nineteenth century, around the time “The Yellow Wallpaper” was published, and is originated from realism. According to literarydevices.net, naturalism focuses on “natural forces predetermining a character’s decisions” while realism is about free will and the decisions a character makes in response to a situation. The major forces that control our unnamed narrator’s actions in “The Yellow Wallpaper” are her figurative and physical environment and her relationship with John.

Read More
1787 Words | 8 Pages

Khadija Alasow ENG 337 Final Essay Oppression and suppression of Lily’s identity The notion of Identity is made up of individual qualities and/or beliefs that are inherent in one’s character. The identity also plays a role in how they portray themselves to others. However, if society isn’t accepting of your beliefs and values one will attempt to mask their true identity and adopt the given one. Written in 1905, Edith Wharton’s novel The House of Mirth portrays the downfall of Lilly Bart ……..consumed with superficial materialistic .

Read More
2406 Words | 10 Pages

That is, not only does her mother arrive in town, putting a stop to her schemes, but also the protagonist’s natural biological body disrupts her plans through pregnancy. Indeed, John Richetti argues that: “The early eighteenth-century amatory novella…out one part of the antithesis I am working with: …the heroines are visited by overwhelming and ineffable…passion, obsessions that preclude self-examination and make a mockery of agency and self-consciousness” (336-337) in his essay “Ideas and Voices: The New Novel in Eighteenth-Century England.” The “Shock of Nature” (69), of labour, starts while she is still in town and under her mother’s dominion. The protagonist’s mother is a “severely virtuous” (68) lady, and upon finding her daughter ill, feels “Pity and Tenderness” (69), which is then “succeeded by an adequate Shame and Indignation” (69). Her mother hears Beauplaisir’s story after finding out the truth of her daughter’s schemes.

Read More
1752 Words | 8 Pages

Settling in the same place in the world compels you into involuntarily getting used to the social norms that are expected from you. However, once people touch upon different countries, they observe that etiquette changes from person to person, let alone by crossing the Atlantic. For some people, it could be considered scandalous to not perform according the country’s etiquette and social norms, but there are some who are more open-minded about the idea of social norms. In this essay, I am going to discuss this notion that different authors such as Henry James and Edith Wharton faced by crossing the Atlantic; the different social norms that vary from place to place and the rebellion against having particular social norms, especially when it

Read More
902 Words | 4 Pages

The concept of naturalism is common in American literature. Naturalism was developed in the nineteenth century when scientific advancements were at a peak in society. These advancements ushered a more naturalistic way of writing and prose. This way of writing is demonstrated through the works of Jack London’s, “What Life Means to Me”, and Stephan Crane’s, “An Open Boat”. Within these stories, both of the protagonists are placed in unfortunate situations that are beyond the ability of the characters to control.

Read More
2131 Words | 9 Pages

Edith Wharton is an important, though neglected novelist in the history of American literature. Her novels study the status of the women and explore their relationship with men in a male dominated society. Again and again she presents the state of exceptional, rising, ‘New Woman’ of the turn of the century to break out of her compressible role and attempting a venture rebellion. The Age of Innocence is on the theme that deals ironically with the affluent social world of New York. The novel has a theme of entrapment and the struggle of the intruder, both to maintain an adult sense of self in a childish society and to rescue a trapped male from that society.

Read More

More about Naturalism In Edith Wharton's The House Of Mirth

Related Topics

Open Document