ipl-logo

New York City Planning Essay

698 Words3 Pages

The United States thus far has in planning has treated people in its’ path as a nuisance to be solved. If we look at planning from Boyer’s (1986) point of view, who highlights planning as a “search for spatial order”, planning has overlooked who its’ order is suppose to benefit. Planning has been treating the masses as a sickness that is named disorder, rather than as beneficiaries.
In 1890, Jacob Rite, published How the Other Half Live, which provided vivid descriptions of the New York City Slums and its’ residents with the majority being immigrants (cited in Hall, 2014). Housing was the major issue to fix, not the people. Most planners attempted to fix the tenement housing with building codes not social reform. However, during the same time, …show more content…

Robert Moses, another famous planner of the 20th century, followed Le Corbusier’s automobile centric thinking of planning. In the later portion the the 20th century large scale planning projects were pushed by the federal Government, including a large number of highway projects after WWII. Robert Moses’ vision of the Cross Bronx Expressway construction in New York City was funded by all levels of government (Cato, 1975). Moses’ Expressway construction displaced nearly 10,000 people over a 14 block portion of the Bronx’s with the direct purpose of placing automobile in the heart of the city (Burns, 1989). He consistently disregarded citizens of the areas he destroyed. Jane Jacobs was the core citizen and organizer of Moses' highway resistance. Jacobs published a book called, The Life and Death of American Cities” in 1961, which criticized planning for ignoring the the people while its’ predominantly male planners focused on planning for the modern inventions of spatial order, like the automobile (Avila, 2014). As a working mother and resident of this area Moses ripped through, she organized and fought highways destroying New York City. Moses saw these voices of dissent as something to be ignore and not worth his time (Cato, 1975). This effectively proves he was not looking to help the residents of New York City, just

Show More
Related

Jacob Riis How The Other Half Lives Summary

1200 Words | 5 Pages

In Jacob Riis’ revolutionary book How the Other Half Lives, Riis details the atrocious conditions of the tenements in New York City at the turn of the century. Riis particularly focusses his initial chapters on the formation of the tenements and their subsequent demise into filthy ruins. In many ways, these tenements paralleled the federal housing projects of the 1950’s. Both populations predominately included impoverished, working class immigrants and minorities. However, the tenements and the projects differ in terms of supportive communities.

Read More

Jacob Riis How The Other Half Lives Summary

1244 Words | 5 Pages

Jacob Riis in “How the Other Half Lives” is about the squalor that characterizes New York City’s working class immigrant neighborhoods. He describes deplorable conditions of these immigrants by providing specific examples, relaying them through quotation and images alike. Riis comments on the injustices that the residents of the tenements faced on a regular basis. So, with his attention to detail, Riis provided the contemporary reader with unsettling images of the poor and marginalized along with a few examples of the benefits of reform and reorganization in the poorer communities, to the benefit of residents. Another observer, Richard T. Ely, in “Pullman: A Social Study” writes about the community of Pullman, Illinois located in the suburbs of Chicago.

Read More

How Did Americans Grow So Quickly Dbq

834 Words | 4 Pages

From riots to invasions, many urban problems arose during the late 19th and 20th centuries. Technology was improving and it was making jobs easier and more productive but American’s were tired and weren’t working. Wage cuts were becoming more popular and economically, the U.S was falling apart slowly. Despite the problems, Americans discovered a way to replace the exhausted Americans who no longer took part in labor. Immigrants from Europe were pulled to New York in hope to find what the Americans had said they’d offer.

Read More

A People's History Of The New Boston Summary

963 Words | 4 Pages

Groups of African-Americans and women fought to prevent destruction of their houses under the Urban Renewal Act of 1949, which gave Boston money to develop its infrastructure. Consequently, this meant older neighborhoods of Boston were slated to get demolished to make way for new residential areas. The Act “rekindled the flame of activism and protest in much of the city” (39). Groups formed such as the Urban Planning Aid and Mothers for Adequate Welfare who fought Boston officials to halt the demolitions and find other ways to improve infrastructure and their lives. Altogether, these acts helped push Boston to become a “a city much more of, by, and for its people,” according to Vrabel.

Read More

Gentrification All Bad Justin Davidson Analysis

1841 Words | 8 Pages

There has to be a realistic solution that can be put into motion to benefit everyone involved. Referring again to his article “Is Gentrification All Bad?” Davidson argues that urban renewal, if done right, is not a monstrous custom that it is painted to be; nevertheless, he reasons that gentrification depends on who does it, how they do it, and why they do it. As a resident in New York, a city where gentrification is as widespread as the common cold in winter, Davidson speculates that those who go into a neighborhood with the intention to renovate houses, or abandoned buildings ought to have a good reason for it. The author points out that “Gentrification does not have to be something that one group inflicts on another…” (Davidson 349), rather, he suggests that everyone, the gentrifiers and the locals, be on the same page when it comes to developing their

Read More

Landlords: The First New York Tenements

1366 Words | 6 Pages

More than sixty-five percent of New York’s population lived in those tenements. Tenements were a large source of suffering for new immigrants and their families. This is mainly due to their unsanitary and overcrowded conditions. The tenement conditions were horrendous and appalling.

Read More

Examples Of Negative Sensationalism

1640 Words | 7 Pages

Negative Sensationalism Throughout the week, talk shows such as Maury and Jerry Springer are displayed on our TV screens. Whether or not a person is a vigorous viewer, the storyline of the show comes up in a conversation at least once a week. Talk shows regularly take a look into the life choices of a certain person or group of people. In the text “In Defense of Talk Shows”, Barbara Ehrenreich raises the question of the moral conflicts presented in talk shows and presents the idea that they are an exploitation of lower class people.

Read More

Urbanization Dbq Essay

861 Words | 4 Pages

Poor people were able to get help with money, city hall was more orderly, they really changed the entire urban

Read More

The Progressive Er The Late 19th And Early Twentieth Century

461 Words | 2 Pages

They advocated for the establishment of housing and sanitary codes, the creation of parks and recreational areas, and the improvement of public transportation. They also worked to eliminate slums and tenements and provide city residents with a better quality of life. These reforms aimed to provide a more livable environment for American city dwellers. However, despite their efforts, the Progressive Era reformers faced significant challenges in implementing their reforms. For example, political machines and entrenched special interests often obstructed their efforts to create a more responsive

Read More

Dbq On American Urbanization

1507 Words | 7 Pages

Inspired by european city rebuilding projects, American cities started clearing away older neighborhoods and creating grand avenues with impressive buildings. The only problem with the growing population was finding housing for the new residents. In Document 6 Nash explains how urban geography changed with emerging central businesses, few people living downtown, middle class residential areas stretched out beyond working class neighborhoods, and the growth of the suburbs which led to better transportation. Many of the rich lived in palatial mansions in the heart of the city while the moderately well to do took advantage of less expensive land on the outer edges of the city thus leading to what was known as the growth of the suburbs. However the poor could not afford housing in the city or in the suburbs and this led to the growth of tenement housing.

Read More

Robert Moses's Positive Effects On Society

571 Words | 3 Pages

The Geography of Nowhere, written by James Kunstler, discusses Moses and how his work impacted society forever. Through the construction of infrastructure,

Read More

The Urban Displacement Project: Redlining And Gentrification

2136 Words | 9 Pages

These color-coded maps designed by the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation (HOLC) were crucial in the development of American cities; an area’s desirability levels were largely based on the racial and ethnic composition of its residents (The Urban Displacement Project). People of color were largely assigned to places designated as hazardous or “blighted”. Residents who lived in these areas were unable to secure loans, buy property, or fix the existing structures (The Urban Displacement Project). This practice propelled forward a viscous cycle of disinvestment that led to the slow disintegration of neighborhoods considered “blighted” by the HOLC. The Urban Displacement Project.

Read More

Black Men Stereotypes

1714 Words | 7 Pages

One way in which this fear is implemented is by increasing the inequality between races. Urban planning, in particular, has played a large role in this as it has historically advantaged some people while putting others at a disadvantage. From gentrification and racial disparities in law enforcement to practices such as blockbusting and redlining, it is apparent that policies and decisions made by city planners were not designed to benefit everyone equally. Particularly the Housing Act of 1949 and the Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956. Both of these policies displaced residents through the use of eminent domain and condemnation laws (Budds, “How Urban Design Perpetuates Racial Inequality – And What We Can Do About It”).

Read More

What Were The Dangers Of The Second Industrial Revolution

496 Words | 2 Pages

The disgusting living conditions were certainly a negative issue at the time. In order to create homes for the influx of new immigrants, old one-family homes were changed into tenement buildings that could fit three or four families. These tenements,

Read More

Death And Life Of Great American Cities By Jane Jacob

341 Words | 2 Pages

Stated to be “one of the most influential critics of US planning orthodoxies holding sway during the 1950’s and 60’s,” Jane Jacobs, the American – Canadian writer and activist, is a central figure in the urbanisation of city planning. Published in 1961, her famous assault on modernist misconceptions casted by architects, is documented in her book “The Death and Life of Great American Cities,” one of the most influential and paramount critiques of traditional planning. It evaluates the failure of the modern movement to provide the social redemption the famous architects promised, changing the traditional attitude towards planning and the way cities are perceived. In this essay I will be discussing Jane Jacob’s criticisms and alternatives to

Read More

More about New York City Planning Essay

Related Topics

Open Document