ipl-logo

Of If I Die In A Combat Zone, Box Me Home, By Tim O Brien

983 Words4 Pages

Throughout If I Die in a Combat Zone, Box Me Up and Ship Me Home, Tim O’Brien talks of how atrocious and mistaken he feels his time being drafted and shipped to Vietnam was. His reasoning for writing the book is to assert his position that America’s interference in Vietnam was unjustified by showing the true story, with no shortcomings, of life in war, using philosophical teachings of Plato to exemplify unwise courage, and giving dialogue with superiors on the politics of the war. The brutality of war is described graphically as to create a true account of the war and provide basis for his beliefs. The author uses his grizzly account of the life as a troop in Vietnam as a sturdy base for his point. To illustrate, he talks of pieces of his …show more content…

This leads him through schemes of disappearing until he finally winds up debating a Captain serving as a Chaplain on the base. They argue about politics and O’Brien brings up the point that there is no validity for involvement, as there’s no persuasive affirmation saying that if the U.S. wins the war, Vietnam will be a better place (ch. 6). Assuming the U.S. did win, the dictator in power, Ngo Dinh Diem, is a catholic leader in a largely Buddhist country. Unity would be nearly impossible with Diem as a leader. This is reflected by the fact that he only won power of Southern Vietnam through the help of the U.S. rigging the election in his favor. Maybe the people in Vietnam didn’t want to be ruled by communists, but under somebody like Diem, an informally fought war would have probably never found a conclusion. In the same discussion with the Chaplain in chapter 6, O’Brien argues that the lives being lost due to the U.S. taking action are overall not worth it for either country. On the fight to stop communism America got nothing but a large price tag and many dead soldiers of it’s own. Similarly in Vietnam, America’s participation brought nothing but an extension of war time, and millions of it’s own people dead. O’Brien proves correct in his preemptive assessment of the conflict. He again adds to his credibility during the debate by countering the Chaplains emotional responses with submitting that he is only convinced by facts and conclusive evidence. This shows he is in touch with reality and the points he is making have solid ground to them. By doing this, his argument, again, garners more

Show More
Related
201 Words | 1 Pages

O’brien was against the Vietnam War before and after got drafted. As a student, O’brien took a stand against the war, and participated the anti-war protest. In the Chapter, “On The Rainy River,” O’brien is talking about how he thought about fleeing to Canada when he received the draft notice. O’brien had a full-ride scholarship for grad studies at Harvard when he received the draft notice and he could not believed it because he was to smart to go war. Furthermore, he “hated dirt and tents and mosquitoes” ( O’Brien 39), he was not a soldier materiel.

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

In A Viet Cong Memoir, we receive excellent first hands accounts of events that unfolded in Vietnam during the Vietnam War from the author of this autobiography: Truong Nhu Tang. Truong was Vietnamese at heart, growing up in Saigon, but he studied in Paris for a time where he met and learned from the future leader Ho Chi Minh. Truong was able to learn from Ho Chi Minh’s revolutionary ideas and gain a great political perspective of the conflicts arising in Vietnam during the war. His autobiography shows the readers the perspective of the average Vietnamese citizen (especially those involved with the NLF) and the attitudes towards war with the United States. In the book, Truong exclaims that although many people may say the Americans never lost on the battlefield in Vietnam — it is irrelevant.

Read More
970 Words | 4 Pages

If I Die in a Combat Zone, author Tim O'Brien argued that the Vietnam War was evil through his depictions of the harmful actions against the Vietnamese, first hand experiences of the soldiers, and lastly, his opinion throughout the war. O’Brien demonstrates the mutilation and murders of the innocent Vietnamese people by explaining how the soldiers belittled the orientals. The soldiers captured three old men and decided to tie them up (130). These old men were treated poorly by the soldiers because they were being gagged and restrained. Most of the company wasn’t concerned about the old men’s physical condition, since they were prisoners.

Read More
715 Words | 3 Pages

Tim O’Brien uses seemingly true events to describe his overall emotions about the Vietnam war and what he and others did there. “I want you to know what I felt. I want you to know why story-truth is truer sometimes than happening-truth” (O’Brien, pg. 171). This quotation is the foundation of the entire book The Things They Carried, O’Brien uses this base to tell the story of many things that he witnessed. O’Brien’s verisimilitude is used to give real world emotions to a literary work.

Read More
280 Words | 2 Pages

I find Ho Chi Minh’s letter far more persuasive than Lyndon B. Johnson’s. Using ethos, pathos, and logos, he forms a solid argument that supports Vietnam’s stance on the war. He appeals to one’s emotions by expressing the injustices faced by his people, writing, “In South Viet-Nam a half-million American soldiers and soldiers from the satellite countries have resorted to the most barbarous methods of warfare, such as napalm, chemicals, and poison gases in order to massacre our fellow countrymen, destroy the crops, and wipe out villages.” Words such as “massacre” and “barbarous” highlight the severity of these crimes, and invoke feelings of guilt and remorse in the reader. Chi Minh uses ethos to support his logos, or logical, views on the

Read More
793 Words | 4 Pages

Madelyn Smith Ms.Reid English 11 Law 25 April, 2023 The Vietnam War was a horrifyingly gruesome and deadly altercation in which America sent hundreds of thousands of kids to fight in a grown man's war. Close to 60,000 American soldiers and 250,000 Vietnamese soldiers were killed in this fight of nonsense, in which the lives of innocent civilians and soldiers alike were taken, all while making no political progress. In the historical fiction, The Things They Carried, Tim O’Brien presents stories that show how the soldiers cope with the war, in order to depict the trauma and horror they experienced, ultimately illustrating that the soldiers who went to Vietnam lived through horrid battles and show their fear of uncertainties through their

Read More
543 Words | 3 Pages

The Things They Carried, written by Tim O’Brien, illustrates the experiences of a man and his comrades throughout the war in Vietnam. Tim O’Brien actually served in the war, so he had a phenomenal background when it came to telling the true story about the war. In his novel, Tim O’Brien uses imagery to portray every necessary detail about the war and provide the reader with a true depiction of the war in Vietnam. O’Brien starts out the book by describing everything he and his comrades carry around with them during the war. Immediately once the book starts, so does his use of imagery.

Read More
852 Words | 4 Pages

American Novelist, Tim O’brien, in his book, Going After Cacciato, illuminates the daunting effects of the Vietnam War by delving into the mind of a young soldier, Paul Berlin. The theme of discontinuity and trauma is revealed as the novel jumps back and forth from reality and fantasy. The book focuses on Berlin, on guard at the observational post as he recounts the tragic deaths of members in his squad and imagines a story of him and his squad chasing after Cacciato. The sudden change of scenes in each chapter creates discontinuities, contributing to a feeling of confusion. This is the author’s attempt to emulate the influence of war onto a soldier — disorientation.

Read More
1033 Words | 5 Pages

At one point he discussed his personal feelings about the war and stated how much he had been persuaded and remained persuaded that the war was and will always be “evil” in his eyes (pg. 18). Before he’s officially in Vietnam, O’Brien meets with the military chaplain on base at

Read More
1232 Words | 5 Pages

O’Brien who was drafted for the Vietnam War, questions why he is present in the Vietnam War, and how the wars form in the first place. “A war of national liberation or simple aggression? Who started it, and when, and why? What really happened to the USS Maddox on that dark night in the Gulf of Tonkin? Was Ho Chi Minh a Communist stooge, or nationalist savior, or both, or neither?

Read More
1383 Words | 6 Pages

The Vietnam War was a war that most Americans at the time were not happy with. They did not agree with why we were sending young men to die in a foreign land. Tim O’Brien was one of those Americans. He did not try to hide the fact that he did not support the vietnam war. He was open about having thoughts about avoiding the draft and fleeing to Canada but instead he stayed in America and did not try to flee

Read More
338 Words | 2 Pages

There are many different views on the Vietnam War (1945-1975) and to this day America’s involvement is contentious. Source 1 clearly shows the fear the US had over America potentially falling to the ‘domino theory’. America’s fear of communism had increased after World War Two once it began spreading worldwide through Eastern Europe, Africa, Cuba and East Asia. This fear is what would lead to America’s involvement in the Vietnam War. America claimed they would help South Vietnam put an end to the ‘dangerous conditions’ the war was causing.

Read More
231 Words | 1 Pages

The Vietnam War was bloody, and it saw unprecedented ways of acquiring superiority onto the field by relying on higher body counts and an incessant use of bombardments that far surpassed any previous wars that the U.S. were involved with. With the turmoil that was caused not only in the field of battle, but away from it, Vietnam was a war that seemed to cause more harm than good since it didn’t contribute any benefits towards America. After the stereotypes of the cold war became too powerful to allow for American acceptance of Vietnamese independence, the war was inevitable with no other possibilities presenting themselves in the minds of the American government. It was a costly war for the United States politically, socially, and economically.

Read More
1202 Words | 5 Pages

Being drafted as a young man, his tour began in 1969 as a foot soldier and ended his tour in 1970. During a grenade attack, O’Brien was hit with shrapnel and was sent home, in which he later received the Purple Heart. O’Brien tells his side on how he felt during this time period and the struggles of Vietnam. The book itself sets the scene in the time period of Vietnam and gives a sense of fear as he explains the horrific and graphic events that occurred while on his tour. As a way to cope with the long lasting memories, pain, and effects of the war, O’Brien began to write about the ordeals he went through as a young man in the Vietnam War and the honorable men who he served with.

Read More
645 Words | 3 Pages

The Vietnam War leaves a legacy of moral confusion with each and every soldier who serves. Soldiers are fighting for a cause they do not necessarily believe in, killing people who do not necessarily deserve it, and watching their brothers die beside them. Tim O’Briens’ book, The Things They Carried, illustrates the soldiers struggle to define morality throughout the confusion of the war. On the Rainy River, Tim O’Brien faces what he feels is his moral obligation to answer his country’s call and fight in Vietnam, and a personal moral issue with the reason for the war.

Read More

More about Of If I Die In A Combat Zone, Box Me Home, By Tim O Brien

Open Document