ipl-logo

Oliver Wendell Holmes Approaches To The Determination Of Individual Value

471 Words2 Pages

• The approach to the determination of the value of the individual proposed by Oliver Wendell Holmes was based on a philosophical concept of individual worth. Holmes believed that each person had their own intrinsic value and that it was important to understand and consider the individual circumstances in each case in order to fully appreciate their value. He argued that each person should be treated as an individual, regardless of their social class or status, and that the value of a person should never be judged by the prevailing standards of the day. His approach was based on the idea that each person had a unique value and that it was important to recognize this value in order to ensure that justice was done.
• Meanwhile, Dr. Liebbrandt's approach to the value of the individual was more focused on legal implications. As an applied expert at the Nuremberg Medical Trial, he was tasked with evaluating the individual cases of those accused of war crimes in order to determine the appropriate punishment. He sought to determine the culpability of the accused and to assess the evidence presented in order to determine the …show more content…

Firstly, the challenge posed by Oliver Wendell Holmes' approach to individual value is the difficulty of determining what constitutes an individual's value in a philosophical sense 1. Because there is no single definition of value, it is difficult to assess the individual circumstances of each case in order to make an informed decision. Secondly, the challenge posed by Dr. Liebbrandt's approach is determining the appropriate punishment for those accused of war crimes. This requires a thorough evaluation of the individual circumstances of the case and an understanding of the legal and moral implications of the decision. In both cases, it is essential for researchers to be aware of the complexities of the situation in order to ensure that justice is

Show More
Related
1189 Words | 5 Pages

From a well educated background, his qualifications verify his interpretation to Martin Guerre’s case. Not only was he present for the trial, he was one of the ten judges overseeing the case. He was also a skilled lawyer and professor at a university. He

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

According to newspapers at that time,“the Nuremberg Code didn’t seem to apply to the United States”(Skloot 133). It was unsettling to many at that time that American doctors felt above the rules. this allowed Skloot to emphasise our emotions of fear of doctors above the law and what the could have done. In the modern world one should have not feared the men who were supposed to heal them. One example of doctors who felt above the law was Dr. TeLinde.

Read More
1193 Words | 5 Pages

He also wants the reader to better understand and contemplate how these moral decisions impacted the course of the war and postwar era. He asks the difficult moral questions that challenge the moral clarity and high ground that we tend to view the World War II with. Richard Overy begins Why the Allies

Read More
763 Words | 4 Pages

Blumberg writes, "Several of the accused had close ties to one another and a long-standing grudge against the Putnams" (Blumberg, 1). This quote highlights the personal vendettas that drove the accusations and underscores how easily societal norms can be weaponized against individuals through manipulation and coercion. The trials resulted in significant harm to the accused and their families due to unchecked hostility. Harrison Bergeron portrays how poor leadership can lead to a loss of individuality and personal choice.

Read More
1493 Words | 6 Pages

Eroy Brown was a convicted murderer who faced several trials throughout his life. The outcome of his trials was influenced by several factors, including the evidence presented in court, the jurors’ biases, and the actions of the prosecution and defense. One of the most significant factors that influenced the outcome of Eroy Brown’s trials was the evidence presented in court. In some cases, the evidence was conclusive and left no doubt as to Brown’s guilt or innocence. For example, in one of his trials, Brown was convicted of murdering a fellow inmate based on eyewitness testimony and physical evidence found at the scene of the crime.

Read More
752 Words | 4 Pages

Acts of treason, actual or supposed, litter American history, but questions of loyalty in American history is determined more often by opinion than facts. The various reactions to treason display a fundamental issue regarding loyalty and disloyalty in American history. Loyalty and disloyalty are driven by a similar, but different, essential driving factor that is mostly determined by public opinion. By using specific examples, it is easily detectable that the fundamental issues with deciding a person’s loyalty, which is intertwined with the roots of loyalty and disloyalty that drive the two principles, are public opinion and cause.

Read More
177 Words | 1 Pages

In result of the great depression, president Herbert Hoover fabricated the theory of “rugged individualism”, which is the idea that people succeed through their own efforts. During Hoover’s presidency he rejected the proposal of government action and relied on private charities and the local government to help feed and clothe those in need, he also did not want the government to create new jobs because that would increase government spending. Furthermore, congress passed the Hawley-smooth tariff which raised the average tariff rate to the highest it has ever been in American history. Moreover, the tariff aimed to protect American manufactures from foreign competition, however it also damaged American sales, this resulted in imports to cost

Read More
815 Words | 4 Pages

At the end of World War II, President Harry S. Truman dropped two atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. But was it justified to end World War II or was it just for his greed for power projection? In this trial, the former president was tried for war crimes against humanity, with the punishment being sentenced to death by hanging. The jury vote guilty. We chose this because of testimony given by witnesses, Truman’s official atomic bombing order, and the impact of the closing statements.

Read More
532 Words | 3 Pages

Jefferson believed that true freedom and equality of the American people rested in their ownership of land as farmers, and that seeking wealth would corrupt the American

Read More
969 Words | 4 Pages

The purpose of these trials were to seek justice for those who could no longer speak. Many jewish doctors and high ranking officials were put on trial as jewish families sought justice for their fallen family members. 4,600 German documents were admitted as evidence during these trials. A main topic covered by these trials were the Nazi medical experiments. Twenty-three head doctors were tried during this time.

Read More
1602 Words | 7 Pages

In the words of one Allied prosecutor, “the Nazi leaders committed a major offense against the conscience which mankind has today evolved from his status as a human being” (Menthon, 191). Crimes against humanity addressed the most egregious and immoral actions of the Nazi party, actions that surpassed the material violation of laws. The Allies felt these acts deserved separate examination and punishment as they insulted and degraded the evolution of humanity and modern society. To demonstrate the seriousness of the offenses, the prosecution called multiple witnesses to narrate the atrocities they experienced.

Read More
1968 Words | 8 Pages

Advantages of the trial: 7 Nuremberg Principles: The definition of what

Read More
515 Words | 3 Pages

We are all governed by our conscience, a persons conscience is what shapes our decisions about what is right and what is wrong. But what happens when our conscience disagree’s with the law of the country we live in? Today millions of civilian’s all over the world are imprisoned because their conscience cannot reconcile the killing of another human-being as as acceptable. These civilians are known as conscientious objectors. This report brings the past and the present together to bring light to the darkness conscientious objectors face over the world.

Read More
809 Words | 4 Pages

The pursuit of self-gratification and preservation forms only a minute part of this concept. Promotion of personal liberties and control in the various aspects of an individual’s life and situation has been a major part of American history since its very dawn. Individualism first appeared in America in the early 17th century with the arrival of the Pilgrims, a people facing religious persecution in their home country of England. While they did indeed band together as a group under a common cause, their fight for the ideals of personal liberty was an individualistic one.

Read More
575 Words | 3 Pages

The individual freedoms guaranteed by our founding fathers and written in the constitution, become the first causalities when our leaders decide to declare war. The first ten Amendments of the Constitution, commonly known as the Bill of Rights are the foundation of this nation’s laws, and is the benchmark of how our government treats the citizenry. Many times in our history leaders took actions to suspend personal freedoms in the name of “war”. A few examples are, the killing and repatriation of the Native American, the Japanese and German internment camps during World War II in the name of war and national security concerns. For the purposes of this paper the main focus will be on the time from the 1950’s to today.

Read More

More about Oliver Wendell Holmes Approaches To The Determination Of Individual Value

Related Topics

Open Document