ipl-logo

On Leaving Asia Essay

1113 Words5 Pages

Analytical Essay 1
Why did Japan’s reforms succeed while the Qing and Joseon’s reforms failed? This paper argues that Japan’s successful reforms were due to their adoption of Western ideas and values, and the abandonment of traditional practices and governance, while the Qing and Joseon dynasties failed in their reforms because of their inability to adapt to the modern world and embrace change, their education system, and their cruelty. To make my argument, I will do a close analysis of “On Leaving Asia” by Fukuzawa Yukichi, a primary source that highlights the author’s endorsement of Japan’s modernization and rejection of traditional Asian values in favor of Western ideas and civilization.
Fukuzawa compares the spread of Western civilization …show more content…

He states, “If we were to discard our old conventions, that government also had to be abolished.” This quote speaks to the idea that in order for Japan to fully embrace Western civilization and implement reforms, they had to abandon their traditional way of thinking and governance. It highlights the sense of connection that cultural, and government systems play in shaping a country's ability to adapt to new challenges. Japan seemed willing to abandon its traditional ways of thinking, enabling it to create better systems for the modern world. It was Japan’s willingness to abandon traditional ways of thinking that allowed them to cast aside its old conventions and succeed in creating a new path towards progress and modernization, setting it apart from other Asian countries that failed to …show more content…

Fukuzawa articulates this observation by stating, “Not only were we able to cast aside Japan’s old conventions, but we also succeeded in creating new axle toward progress in Asia.” This observation shows that Japan was successful in not only discarding its old ways of thinking but in creating a new path toward progress and modernization. Japan’s ability to implement reforms by embracing change set it apart from the Qing and Joseon dynasties. Fukuzaw’s quote, “Their love affairs with ancient ways and old customs remain as strong as they were centuries ago,” offers a contrasting point of view to his earlier observation. These quotes showcase the difference in attitudes towards progress and modernization between Japan and the Qing and Joseon

Show More
Related
1312 Words | 6 Pages

Feiler first attempts at tearing down the social customs of Japan are unsuccessful. Japanese schools inspire strict obedience and conformity within their students and teachers. To the Japanese, exams are more important than individualism. “As it had done in the past, Japan adopted a foreign prototype and transformed its alien character by implanting a Japanese heart.” Feiler’s findings are based on the transformation of Japan’s school system by the Americans after WWII in which an emphasis of “democracy” and “individual freedom” were meant to be the core of student’s education.

Read More
220 Words | 1 Pages

In the 19th century china and japan were under pressure when the west opened up foreign trade and relations. The industrial revolution created a wide gap between them and the west and left them behind in technology and the military. They both signed unequal treaties that forced them to open their ports and cities to foreign merchants. Both country's reacted very differently and this will be the topic of this essay.

Read More
3516 Words | 15 Pages

All throughout history, numerous nations have tried to conquer the islands of Japan. However, no matter how large their invasion forces were, those who tried never fully succeeded. Of all those who attempted to conquer Japan, arguably the most famous of all were the Mongols, who tried to subjugate the Japanese people twice, one in 1274, and the other in 1281. The leader of the invading armies, Kublai Khan, wished to expand his people’s influence and culture across the Tsushima Strait, and into the islands east of China. But, try as they may, they could not tame the people that called these islands home.

Read More
511 Words | 3 Pages

Some historians believe the Ottoman Empire and Japan were relatively different from c. 1750 to 1900 due to the differing political structures, including the stability of each country’s government and means of operation in response to enlightenment philosophy and industrialization. However, due to both countries’ thriving economic structures because of similar reform changes and social resistance against conforming to modernization ideals, their development from c. 1750 to 1900, during which industrialization faced both countries, is drawn to be very similar to each other. To begin with, the adoption of western ideals and enlightenment principles widened the gap between the Ottomans and the Japanese. Not only did the Ottoman Empire suffer massive corruption in the 1800s, prompting its rapid decline, but it also experienced civil unrest across the country as a result of ethnic nationalism, resulting in a weak central government.

Read More
672 Words | 3 Pages

When related to Immanuel Wallerstein’s “World Systems Analysis”, the Meji Restoration developed Japan into a core country. As a dominant power, they took advantage of periphery countries for labor and every opportunity to become a world

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

In The Way of the Subjects, from the Japanese Ministry of Education (August 1, 1941), taught Japanese students that their nation will be the next order and other Asian countries will be ruled under their emperor’s hand (Doc A). “An old order... (European and American)... is now crumbling. Japan is the foundation source of the Yamato race. Manchukuo is its reservoir and East Asia is its paddy field” (Doc A).

Read More
724 Words | 3 Pages

During the time Commodore Matthew Perry was eager to be the first American in Japan, in 200 years, to bring a letter of friendship, peace and trade to them, Theodore Roosevelt was sending his own letter to stress his thoughts on pushing the Japanese as to prevent war and them migrating to the United States. Although these two documents differ in tones and views, they both have impacted our history. Through the eyes of the sailors who had the privilege of sailing with the Commodore, had a view, that day was going to change history. Once they could see the Japanese shores, they started noticing some differences right away between this closed off country and the rest of the world. “Old fashioned” are the words that were used to describe their

Read More
450 Words | 2 Pages

This illustrates that Japanese rulers may have been faced with problems involving religious and social disparities, requiring a leader who could reunify and weld

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

From 1868-1889, the Meiji Restoration period transformed the ‘backward’ nation of Japan and created the groundwork for a modern nation (Campbell). This government signed the Charter Oath in 1868, which committed them to modernization with clear Western influences, such as political participation from all classes, freedom to choose jobs without historical constraints, and permission for public discourse. Emperor Meiji and his progressive leadership also strove to advance Japan’s technology, to ‘keep up’ with Western prowess, particularly with the military. Similar to the Western ambitions of colonialization and expansion, Japan also adopted a new form of imperialism to expand its influence throughout East Asia (Hayes, 151). China and Korea were engaged for this purpose, with their biggest success being the Korean annexation.

Read More
828 Words | 4 Pages

Nowadays, many of the characteristics of both the Korean and Japanese cultures are traced back to Chinese influences. China was seen as a model society by growing nations because of large size and historic success in all sectors of the country. China played a crucial role in the maturity of Japan and Korea since they were able to advance both culturally and politically. In most cases, the cultural interworking’s of the three countries are

Read More
2834 Words | 12 Pages

In this paper, I argue that the significant change in the portrayal of the Ainu people from the Tokugawa to the Meiji era can be attributed to various factors, including shifts in the belief system of the ruling class, changes in genetic inheritance objectives, and political goals. During the Tokugawa era, depictions of the Ainu were influenced by the current politics of the state, which were aimed to create a hierarchical, fixed system centered on imperial expansion and the maintenance of established trade relationships built on the political borders of the vassal states. During the Meiji period, however, the state's emphasis shifted toward assimilation and ethnic homogeneity as part of its broader goal in creating a unified nation-state and strengthening national identity. In addition to these economic and political shifts, the rise of inclusive racial theories was a significant reason for these assimilationist policies and the possibility of assimilating the

Read More
711 Words | 3 Pages

Freedom, Liberty, and equality , would these traits really work? These were the thoughts that ran through many great philosophers of the 17th and 18th century philosophers. These great minds were after one thing and it was to give rights to the people and they would realize their oppression of their rights through reason and questioning thing around them. Philosophers during the enlightenment era tried to expose the government and return rights to citizens through reason. They questioned how the poor were viewed and why it was them being controlled and oppressed.

Read More
790 Words | 4 Pages

“To guard against external influence, they also worked to close off Japanese society from Westernizing influences, particularly Christianity. When the Tokugawa shogunate grew increasingly weak by the mid-19th century, two powerful clans joined forces in early 1868 to seize power as part of an “imperial restoration” named for Emperor Meiji.” This restoration was the beginning of the end of feudalism, or the way of structuring society around relationships derived from the holding of land in exchange for service or labour, in Japan. The Tokugawa regime acted to exclude missionaries because of suspicion of foreign intervention and colonialism. Eventually, they issued a complete ban on Christianity in Japan.

Read More
712 Words | 3 Pages

Elliot Guereca & Gustavo Sanchez 6th Period Japanese Imperialism in Korea “ Japan saw itself as having to protect Korea from foreign countries” During the 18th and early 19th century the world experienced new changes in world powers with imperialist countries and countries who experienced imperialism. One example of this would be Japanese imperialism in Korea during 1910-1945, a 35 year harsh change in Korea’s culture, impacting both countries in negative and positive ways in the years to come. Everything started during the Meiji period, a period where Japan saw change within its government creating a centralized bureaucracy.

Read More
794 Words | 4 Pages

Currently, Japan is often known for having a very distinct culture, cultivated due to their relative isolation as an Island country. Indeed, many people reference the Tokugawa Edicts as the reason for this perception. However, while Japanese civilization is certainly a highly distinctive society, it also has strong ties to Chinese culture that began long before the Tokugawa era. In fact, as early as the first century A.D., the people of Japan were sending missions to China; they established a trade and tribute based relationship. This initial relationship gave way to the later Chinese influence that would shape Japan.

Read More

More about On Leaving Asia Essay

Related Topics

Open Document