ipl-logo

Pieter Stuyvesant: A Comparative Analysis

526 Words3 Pages

In the early years of migration to the Americas Jews, like in most parts of Europe, were not welcomed in some communities under the Catholicism power. This then caused some problems of confusion of rules and execution and caused fear for the Jews under the new Constitution, however then creating a time of hope for the Jews in the United States. In the first document of letters between of Pieter Stuyvesant a director of the new colony and Dutch West India Company who Stuyvesant is working under, giving a background of Jews in the Americas getting started under religious toleration. Then with the other two documents show how the Jews get religious freedom in the United States during the antebellum period. Creating hope and forming a new safe …show more content…

However the Company has the same fear but care less about it and cares more about the money they would loss if they lost the Jews community in the company. Thus they created a petition for the Jews to live in there area but not ask for support from the company or the community because of there poor state. Stuyvesant still having a problem with giving Jews liberty but once describing the allowed types of liberty given help get Stuyvesant and the Company on the same page. Giving Jews some liberty but not full liberty, which at that time was how most religions were viewed with religious tolerance and not full liberty. Full religious liberty was given to all even Jews under the new Constitution of the United States. Many were confused and concern of there liberties under the new Constitution. Many wrote the president to ensure and clarify there liberties and as for the Jews ecstatic to hear the answer from the president of complete religious freedom. Washington gives the reply echoing the idea of full religious freedom rather then just toleration and sharing his religious views of rational thinking and natural rights given to all people and government needed to stay

Show More
Related
812 Words | 4 Pages

He as a proven record defending religious liberty. The First Amendment to the U. S. Constitution declares, “ Congress shall

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

A long time ago, people who were Jewish had to face a crucial discrimination ever since others blamed them for killing Jesus. Nobody exactly knows what the truth was but believes in religion books where the elders’ deformed words of Judaism were recorded. Based on the “Sister Rose’s Passion” documentary, Rose Thering — a Roman Catholic Dominican Religious Sister — questioned this false belief towards the Jewish people and dreamed of a world without religious prejudice, wishing teachers to educate their students to make her dream a reality. No one, especially including the Jews, should be raced or hurt by any opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience. Throughout the movie, Sister Rose encourages everyone to “Be an Upstander, Not a Bystander” for the Jews.

Read More
1135 Words | 5 Pages

Back in the 17th century Europeans were traveling to the New World for many reasons, such maybe for profit, like planting tobacco, those would be the colonist who would settle in Virginia. The people of the Plymouth Plantation came to the colonies, because of their children losing touch with their British roots while living in Holland. “ We were all ignorant, and supposing to make our passage in two months, with victual to live. ”(Smith 3) Everyone who travelled to the New World faced hardships that were very hard to endure, but it was “God’s will”.

Read More
1664 Words | 7 Pages

European Jews faced years of anti-Semitism, leading to mass emigration from their home counties many coming to America. Many Jewish historians question whether the anti-Semitism differed from Europe to America and whether today if anti-semitism still exists for American Jews. Both Shapiro’s We Are Many and Katz’s Why is America Different discuss the issue of American Anti-Semitism and prove that there is still Anti-Semitism within the American community.

Read More
816 Words | 4 Pages

While in the White House, President Truman was said to have been barraged with supporters of a Jewish state persuading and pressuring him to go in favor of the making of Israel. At the time, many countries including America did not want Jewish people living in their country. A couple were jealous of the success they were having on business. Even though many of us do not want to admit it, a lot of people know that the U.S. had a dark history of anti-semitism. Many Jews had wanted to come into the United States, but they were not allowed in because of the U.S. immigration quotas and even voted against letting Jews in America.

Read More
732 Words | 3 Pages

Germany, on the other hand, had problems with religious freedom and “found themselves worshiping the wrong religion” (Foner 109). Due to religious conflicts, the local citizens of Germany formed a group of people who wanted to migrate out of Germany to go to the East Coast of North America in order to acquire land and feed their families. In an document Letter by a Swiss-German Immigrant to Pennsylvania, by Johannes Hanner, it showed Hanner was directing his message toward his “dearest Father, Brother, and Sister and Brother-in-law” (Foner 112) in August 23,1769. Hanner described his experience, living in Pennsylvania, as a fulfilling lifestyle where one can simply earn money for food and farm. Hanner also described America as a “free country” (Foner 112).

Read More
969 Words | 4 Pages

The author describes how Jews were mostly found in business, commerce, and public and private service and theyservice. The Jews were in general more highly educated than non-Jews. She points out that several Jewish politicians and intellects had socialist inclination, and even though this did not apply to the whole Jewish population, they were still stereotyped as socialists, internationalists, and revolutionarrevolutionistsy. This exaggerated stereotype led many Germans to distrust the Jewish community and to consider themJews as enemies of the German nation. The author also mentions that the Jews were accused of neglecting their military duties because most of them failed to enlist in the military.

Read More
1099 Words | 5 Pages

Although all the colonists all came from England, the community development, purpose, and societal make-up caused a distinct difference between two distinct societies in New England and the Chesapeake region. The distinctions were obvious, whether it be the volume of religious drive, the need or lack of community, families versus single settlers, the decision on minimal wage, whether or not articles of agreements were drawn for and titles as well as other social matters were drawn, as well as where loyalties lay in leaders. New England was, overall, more religious than the Chesapeake region. Settlers in New England were searching relief for religious persecution in Europe. Puritans, Quakers, and Catholics were coming in droves to America searching for an opportunity to have religious freedom.

Read More
1306 Words | 6 Pages

However, it is impossible to understand Martin Luther’s position on Jews, without exploring the framework in which he wrote. Bell points out the context including “the historical perceptions of and interactions between Jews and

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

Isaac M. Wise was a Rabbi that wrote several editorials in his weekly journal The Israelite.   The Israelite held a strong influence in the mid-west and south during the 1800s and “exerted a powerful force in the formation of Jewish public opinion on Jewish and national problems” (1). Wise expressed his stance as neutral in regards to politics during the Civil War. Yet, it became obvious through Wise’s editorials that he was not a fence-sitter, but rather a Peace Democrat; Wise believed in neither the extreme abolitionist’s nor the extreme secessionist’s political views.

Read More
1379 Words | 6 Pages

It assisted the Jewish emigrant from departure from Russia to establishing his new location in another country to the extent that they no longer need assistance. Supported by well-to-do Jews, one of their experiments was immigration to Galveston, Texas. A middling success, in 1909 (773); 1910 (2,500); 1911; (1,400). By 1913, the threatened competition to nativists and the ‘strange’ religious rituals Jews exacted political retribution from the Texan

Read More
1230 Words | 5 Pages

With so many religions, it is no wonder why we have so many different people on this earth. Not one person is the same, and not two people think alike. The Ordinance of 1784 was the start of making a change to how the government should be run. Soon after the revision of the Ordinance, President Washington wrote a letter to the Touro Synagogue, in 1790, regarding freedom of

Read More
1050 Words | 5 Pages

The arrival of the first Europeans in the Americas is dramatically captured through the many writers who attempted to communicate what they saw, experienced and felt. What is more, the very purposes of their treacherous travel and colonization are clearly seen in their writings; whether it is poetry, history or sermons. Of the many literary pieces available today, William Bradford and John Winthrop’s writings, even though vary because the first is a historical account and the second is a sermon, stand out as presenting a clear trust in God, the rules that would govern them and the reason they have arrived in the Americas. First of all, William Bradford provides an in-depth look into the first moment when the Puritans arrived in the Americas. In fact, he chronicles the hardships they face on their way to Plymouth, yet he includes God’s provision every step of the way.

Read More
759 Words | 4 Pages

We ought be extremely informed on our surroundings in different countries per say about Adolf Hitler regime and its anti- Jewish policies. The anti- policies were the persecution of Jews a central tenet of Nazis ideology. The Nazi Party members publicly declared their intention to the Jews from “Aryan” society and to repeal Jews’ political , legal,and civil rights. Jews were considered a “race”. The Nazis also thought, that the Jewish Religion was irrelevant, and the Nazis attributed a wide variety of negative stereotypes.

Read More
948 Words | 4 Pages

“Religious liberty might be supposed to mean that everybody is free to discuss religion. In practice, it means that hardly anybody is allowed to mention it.” ― G.K. Chesterton Many occasions in the United States history have shown that religion has caused many controversial questions. These questions have brought the American Justice System to a running halt, leading society to begin to ponder about the importance of freedom of religion, true meanings of the free exercise and establishment clause, and if there should be limitations imposed on the free exercise of one’s religious beliefs.

Read More

More about Pieter Stuyvesant: A Comparative Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document