ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of College Athletes

2048 Words9 Pages

Chelsea Oliver
Professor LePrevost
ENG 131
November 30, 2014
Should Colleges Give Their Athletes Funds Beyond Their Scholarships?
Since the birth of collegiate sports by Ivy League schools the idea of paying college athletes has been upon debate [over one hundred years]. Before 1940 recruits from Ivy League schools were paid to play without being enrolled in the school. Because of this, the NCAA (National Collegiate Athletics Association) adopted a “Sanity Code” in 1948 that limited financial aid for athletes to tuition and fees, and required that aid otherwise be given based on need (qtd. in Johnson and Acquavira). In the early 1950’s, with the threat of several southern schools bolting from the NCAA, the code was revised to allow athletic …show more content…

Student athletes are not exploited. The exploitation of student athletes is essentially saying that collegiate athletics is comparable to a plantation. According to a journal written by Dennis A. Johnson, Ed.D., and John Acquaviva, Ph.D. “The coaches are the overseers who get work from the laborers (players) who provide riches for the masters (universities) while receiving little for their efforts.” They also mention how slaves weren’t free to leave the plantation and how it is comparable to an athlete not being able to excuse themselves from a letter of intent or transfer without the consequence of sitting out a year. However, these student athletes are made aware of the consequences of their actions and more than likely sit down with their coaches and discuss advantages and disadvantages before making big decisions like …show more content…

Student athletes shouldn’t be considered employees because they are students first then athletes. The NCAA is dedicated to insuring collegiate athletes remain amateurs; these athletes have forgotten playing is a privilege and not a right. With today’s society in demand to be paid for redundant tasks because of the current state of the economy, these athletes have found themselves getting washed into the idea of getting paid beyond their scholarship thinking it will solve some, if not all of their financial problems when this belief hasn’t been fully thought through. A free education is an acceptable form of payment for amateur athletes because knowledge is power, and education is

Show More
Related

Summary Of Ryan Vanderford Pay For Play

905 Words | 4 Pages

Ryan Vanderfords’ article published in the Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal explores this issue of whether or not college athletes should be paid beyond what they receive in scholarships. Vanderford is currently a law associate at a law firm in Los Angeles, California. He played sports throughout high school and college, so the author can relate to this topic. The payment of college athletes has become a more prominent issue in today’s society then it has been in the past. He argues that at major universities, student athletes help the school generate their revenue and therefore should be paid.

Read More

Summary: The Case Of Paying College Athletes

893 Words | 4 Pages

In their journal “The Case of Paying College Athletes”, John Siegfried and Allen Sanderson point out many discrepancies in NCAA policies, but do not support monetary payment. They argue: “College athletes are in fact currently paid, in the sense that the majority receive grants-in-aid that cover most – although not all – of their college expenses.” (Pg. 127). After this statement, the authors detail the demanding payments varying depending on each college

Read More

Summary: Student Athletes Should Not Be Paid

1036 Words | 5 Pages

In the documentary schooled: the price of college sports I learned that the NCAA does not treat student athletes like employees but these students are treated like slaves it all started in 1971 when the young Caucasian man by name of started playing college football for TSU, he was the running back for the team and when he caught the ball in running he was hit by two other players from the opposing team which caused him to be paralyzed for the rest of his life. Most of the players feel that they should be paid for playing college sports but the NCAA believes that a student who gets a full scholarship to play any sport at a university should not be paid because they are being paid with a free education, room, and board, and free meals, the NCAA

Read More

Summary: College Athletes Should NOT Be Paid

1721 Words | 7 Pages

Sports reporter, Kate Murphy, succinctly summarizes an overwhelming standpoint that many people seem to cite in her article "Privilege, not a job: College athletes shouldn 't be paid. " First, she stipulates herself that student-athletes technically fit the criteria of hardworking employees. She also acknowledges that it is nearly impossible for athletes to balance a job while adhering to their strict schedules. However, because student-athletes are "living the dream" and are supposed to drink up the passion and sacrifices of their game, seeking compensation is grotesque and un-sportsman like. This argument rides on the coattails of "purity."

Read More

Pros And Cons Of College Athletes Get Paid

103 Words | 1 Pages

College schools provide for student athletes enough. They pay for everything provided for the the students whether it’s scholarships or playing in the school games. Through it all it really doesn’t matter if they (the athletes) get paid for, it’s the opportunity that the coaches and university give them to play on the

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of NCAA Amateurism

1918 Words | 8 Pages

This altered the definition by allowing financial aid awards based on athletic ability. It allowed universities to recruit solely on talent and pay tuition for school. It did not cover room and board, but was only a clear attempt to regulate illegal activity per the bylaws and still ban full athletic scholarship. (Kahn, 2006). It was abandoned in 1952 since many institutions already awarded athletic scholarships although it was

Read More

Annotative Bibliography: Should College Athletes Be Paid?

1014 Words | 5 Pages

We as students, professors, and parents we need to demand that NCAA changes their unfair rules and compensates the students athletes for their Annotative bibliography Entman, L. (1970, February 05). Elite college athletes should be paid:

Read More

College Athletes Rhetorical Analysis

1103 Words | 5 Pages

College sports is one of the best-known entertainments around the world. But for the athletes, they are students first then athletes second. For college student-athletes, there are a variety of scholarships and grants to help pay for college or college debt. However, some critics say that student-athletes should be paid a salary like pro athletes would, with help from scholarships or grants. The authors of, College Athletes are being Educated, not Exploited, Val Ackerman and Larry Scott, argue that student-athletes are already paid by free education and other necessities.

Read More

Annotated Bibliography: Should College Athletes Be Paid

904 Words | 4 Pages

Mike says”Students all over the world work hard at the sport that true love and don’t get a lot in return for it”. While college athletes may not exactly be employees, they are more than just students. Consider the life of a student-athlete, though. The average Division I football player dedicates over 43hours per week to his sport, meaning that he spends more than a typical American work-week training and playing football, in addition to his class work. Their work, which generates exorbitant amounts of money year in and year out, deserves Compensation.

Read More

Piggy's Sins

696 Words | 3 Pages

The phrase I will be analyzing is “Man is a fallen being. He is gripped by original sin”. There are two possible interpretations of this phrase which will apply to Lord of the Flies. Both of these are related to Abrahamic religions and the phrase is referring to “The Original Sin” or the Seven Deadly Sins. This novel took place in 1954 where the majority of England was Christian which is an Abrahamic religion so it would not be surprising that this is what the author was hinting towards.

Read More

Should College Athletes Be Paid Thesis

1439 Words | 6 Pages

Summary: This article shows support for paying student athletes. The article compares student athletes to prisoners because they work countless hour for only the bare necessities. The author strengthens his argument by stating that Nick Saban makes 7 million dollars a year , and Jim Harbaugh makes 9 million a year. The author is trying to show that universities give the money to the wrong people. He believe that student athletes do most of the work, and they should get a piece of the pie.

Read More

Should College Athletes Be Paid

551 Words | 3 Pages

After dissecting the dilemma of payment for college athletes, one may discover that oftentimes the only incentive college athletes receive is a full athletic scholarship to the college/university, as opposed to a salary. There must be a reason as to why the college athletes do not receive a salary even though they generate billions of dollars for the NCAA. There are numerous sources illustrating pros and cons regarding whether or not college athletes deserve to be paid. Some argue that athletes should be paid because they are forced to endure unhealthy environments and unfair treatment, struggle through the “plantation system”, want support for themselves, etc. Opposers of this argument state that athletes should not be paid because of financial irresponsibility, education equaling money, university offering more than education, loss of passion for the game, etc.

Read More

Should College Athletes Be Paid Essay

743 Words | 3 Pages

College Athletes are like Slaves Did you know 400,000 students participated in athletics, but only one of every 25 of those students went on to compete professionally? Even though some people think they should do it for free, college athletes should be paid. College athletes play for free. Some people consider a scholarship a payment, but some schools don't offer much.

Read More

College Athletes Should Be Paid

1072 Words | 5 Pages

In 1957 the NCAA finally gave in and there was a vote to allow scholarships for athletes (Sack). Although this has helped many collegiate athletes the question of concern is whether

Read More

College Athletes Deserve To Be Paid

1538 Words | 7 Pages

College athletes put in a lot of time, effort, and work into the sport they’ve played since they were young, but they aren’t getting paid for it. These student athletes deserve to be paid because they put in countless hours of hard work and balance sports with school work. The first reason athletes in college do deserve to be compensated is because they don 't have time to fit in work with a school and athletic schedule. College athletes don’t have time to get a real job. Student athletes have a very busy schedule, they don’t have time to fit in a job.

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of College Athletes

Related Topics

Open Document