ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Cross-Class Coalitions

814 Words4 Pages

Despite the middle-class prevalence over progressivism, instances occurred where middle-class reformers worked with the working-class and cross-coalitions. Coalitions became vital for building legislation that addressed urban America. In their efforts to pass bills and reforms, cross-class alliances had to unite for a common cause. Therefore, different partnerships encompassing men and women, as well as a collaboration between the middle and working classes formed to battle the abuses of the sweatshops as a way to protect the male breadwinner through shared language and to seek women’s suffrage. Regardless of cross-class alliances, tensions and the difficulty of working together made these alliances fragile. As noted earlier, sweatshops became …show more content…

Therefore, cross-class coalitions discovered a shared gendered language to strengthen their push for reform. Throughout 1890-1910, middle-class reformers viewed Eastern European Jewish immigrant’s homes as sweatshops where boundaries of home and work became blurred, and homework forced women into the workplace. Reformers argued that sweatshop brought immigrant working men and women together, which would lead to sexual promiscuity. [18] By using immorality and racial debasement as an argument, reformers tried to avoid sexual promiscuity by conducting inspection campaigns, and proposing strict immigration and licensing laws to relocate sweatshops away from home and to distance male workers from women. Reformers also saw the homework shop, a sweatshop located in tenement home, as a danger …show more content…

[22] Both workers and inspectors still viewed the sweatshop as a health menace. However, they shifted their understandings of sweated work from a language based on race and class to one of gender. The Joint Board of Sanitary Control (JBSC) was also formed to push for the eradication of women’s homework using gendered language and scientific reform as a way to strike the heart of the sweatshop. The JBSC, along with the anti-sweatshop coalition, argued removing the garment from the home to the industrial, modern, and mechanized factories in urban areas would alleviate some of the tensions. [23] Therefore, the push to modernize garment work led to the creation of spacious, sanitary, and regulated “model shops.” [24] The JBSC’s language of organizing and reform and the ILGWU’s potential to relocate the workplace helped protect workers health, and preserve the ideal of the male breadwinner. [25] As cross-class alliances defended the male breadwinner, paradoxically they also sought to help women acquire

Show More
Related
129 Words | 1 Pages

In New York City, the Triangle Shirtwaist Company employed mostly women to make shirts. The working conditions in this factory were much the same as other factories at this time, that is to say, unsafe. The women had only one exit which became crucially important when in 1911 a fire started and there was only that exit, an elevator, which became completely overwhelmed, and an ill-prepared fire escape that became strained to the point that it broke. In the end, 145 people lay dead, all but 23 of whom were women, and half were teenagers. This tragedy put a spotlight of attention on the plight of women workers and led to the adoption of labor laws that not only imposed strict regulations on factory owners, but actually enforced them.

Read More
694 Words | 3 Pages

The dangers of working in factories gave a great perspective of what it was like to do a man’s job, but women weren’t afraid. They desired equality and

Read More
487 Words | 2 Pages

This unification of men and women in a time where patriarchy reigned in the workplace and women were not taken seriously shows the significance of this strike not only for factory workers but also for

Read More
1195 Words | 5 Pages

Founded in 1903, the Women's Trade Union League (WTUL) challenged the bossism politics of Tammany Hall. They believed, “All working women, whether native born or immigrant, deserved respect and recognition on the workplace and in society” (page 4). Inspired by the rhetoric and the desperate need for better conditions, many women joined the unions and eventually decided to call for a general strike. There was the “great uprising” where shirtwaist workers went on a massive strike to modify changes in the girl’s working conditions (Document 9). Throughout history, women had little power over their lives and this new alliance of women led to the “Uprising of Twenty Thousand” which paralyzed the shirtwaist industry.

Read More
81 Words | 1 Pages

In the beginning of the 19th century the job quality declined dramatically. People who owned businesses quit caring about the conditions of their workers and only cared about their business. Factories, mills, and other work places earned the nickname sweatshops because they were always overcrowded with no ventilation and there was little pay and long hours. This eventually caused the workers to become angry forming groups among each other to help fight the system and earn better quality in the

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

As time went on the factories got cleaner, workers received better pay and shorter working hours. It all seemed like a fantastic dream to the employees at large factories as their lives slowly changed from horrible to livable situations. “Those comforts are not used only by a few, but are within the reach of almost all men,” (Document #9). Although the rich entrepreneurs enjoyed the spoils of what would now be considered sweatshops for a long time, the poor was not left out. Everyone’s life improved, no matter how little, as the reforms took effect.

Read More
468 Words | 2 Pages

Industrialization in the United States created increased employment opportunities in factories and metropolitan regions, liberating women from conventional homemaking responsibilities. Consequently, women sought independent lives, gaining financial independence and personal expression (Source 4). Women from various racial and cultural backgrounds, particularly those from working-class neighborhoods, entered the workforce, advocating for better working conditions and fair pay. These advancements shattered preconceived notions of gender roles, laying the groundwork for future women's rights

Read More
1378 Words | 6 Pages

During the 20th century, both white and black women of the middle class pushed to better the society and improve lives of the working class and immigrants. Settlement houses were established across country, which are evidences of reaching beyond class division. Factory conditions were improved by limiting working hours and appointing investigators to enforce rules. The moral being of children were also taken into consideration. Women activists challenged the traditional role of women by advocating the pursuit of personal interests and free love.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

This collective biography recounts the lives of Fannia Cohn, Rose Schneiderman, Pauline Newman and Clara Lemlich Shavelson, four working-class, immigrant, activist women who organized to dismantle state-sponsored class-based and gender-based oppression and to improve the lives of working-class women beginning in the 1900s. Having immigrated from Eastern Europe to New York City amid the women's labor uprisings of the early 1900s, each woman took in the protests, boycotts and unionizing happening around them as a call to action and remained active in the working-class movement through the 1960's. Orleck summarizes her reason for choosing these four women as a quest to give faces and names to the many working-class women whose stories are buried underneath layers of white, bourgeois feminism or the heaps of stories about sexist, white men fighting against class inequality. Orleck hopes Common Sense

Read More
742 Words | 3 Pages

Women’s roles in factory life exemplified the shift away from agriculture work, and the increase in the number of women working outside of the home for little pay, acts brought about by the advent of the Industrial

Read More
859 Words | 4 Pages

Until the Progressive Era, many minorities, including women, were denied what is now considered a basic right either through law or tradition. Women’s suffrage faced opposition due to fear from influential groups. For example, the liquor industry did not find it within their interest to support suffrage because of the fear of women voting for prohibition, which force their companies into bankruptcy (Danzer 522). The owners of textile factories were disturbed about the fact that women have been more likely than men to vote in favor of child labor restrictions (Danzer 522). These child labor restrictions could force the owners of companies to hire adult workers, who they viewed as more expensive and more likely to strike (Child).

Read More
886 Words | 4 Pages

A speech given by Julia Richman emphasized the necessity of women helping other women to succeed ( Document 6 ). Richman, a pro-women’s rights, pro-equality organizer, wanted all women to know it was their duty to stand up for each other and for immigrant women, who are incredibly vulnerable. Public speeches such as Richman’s convinced women that there was power in numbers and that by joining forces with other women, they could force employers to treat women better and make the workplace safer. Another factor that inspired a massive shift towards employee power was the national presence and influence of labor unions and other workplace-reform groups. An excellent example of this notoriety can be seen in Document 4, an article written by Samuel Gompers, the leader of the AFL, and a staunch advocate of the “closed shop” who spoke out constantly about the plight of workers.

Read More
810 Words | 4 Pages

Not only were most women uneducated, but if a woman was educated, she likely attended a women’s college that lacked resources. However, most women didn’t have access to these colleges, so instead, they worked in factories for close to 50 hours a week. The conditions in these factories were grueling; women were crowded in moldy rooms with large machinery, no sanitary restrooms, and no protective equipment. Although many groups of lower-class men also worked in similar conditions, women and small children were taken advantage of. Their small and delicate hands were perfect for dangerous textile machinery and many were too scared to question their hourly wages, which meant that they were taken advantage of.

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

It is a difficult task to challenge the social and economic policies of a country, especially one as patriotic as the United States during the post wartime Red scare era of the 1920 's. labor unions could account for this as they saw their membership fall from a high of 5 million in the 1920s to a mere 3.6 million by 1923(Rosenzweig 353). A combination of Supreme court decisions, Employer pressures and in many cases a lack of a strong leadership seen in previous individuals like Samuel Gompers contributed to this. Yet this trend surprisingly didn’t remain consistent as the great depression emerged around the 1930s. In fact they tripled there membership during the 1930s(Rosenzweig 429).They opened up, recruiting millions of women in their causes

Read More
1716 Words | 7 Pages

These women scrounged for jobs and were often met with contempt from many who felt they were stealing jobs from men, the true breadwinners, yet despite the animosity, the amount of employed women increased by 2 million (Ware). And in the 1940’s, partly due to WW2, women again saw an increase in these aforementioned numbers and the trend towards female equality

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Cross-Class Coalitions

Related Topics

Open Document