ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Declaration Of Independence By Thomas Paine

673 Words3 Pages

Thomas Paine’s pamphlet “Common Sense,” Paine lists reasons as to why the colonies should unite and separate from England. Paine argues strongly the point of “Monarchy and Hereditary Succession” really well by explaining the state of inequality of man and the inadequacy of hereditary succession.
In this section, Thomas Paine argues the ignorance of having a monarch and the biblical beliefs against it as it creates an unequal society and transgressions. He states: “But there is another and greater distinction, for which no truly natural or religious reason can be assigned, and that is, the distinction of men into KINGS and SUBJECTS.” (Paine). The distinction between kings and subjects causes an unnecessary division between mankind and therefore …show more content…

“For all men being originally equals, no ONE by BIRTH could have a right to set up his own family in perpetual preference to all others for ever, and though himself might deserve SOME decent degree of honours of his contemporaries, yet his descendants might be far too unworthy to inherit them” (Paine). The descendent of the throne may be a fool and have no idea how government works leaving the inhabitants defenseless and at a disadvantage as rival empires or nation can attack and usurp the throne and lead to turmoil or anarchy. It also goes against the concept of “all men are created equal,” being royal by birth is a straight contradiction and creates further unnecessary division. “Another evil which attends hereditary succession is, that the throne is subject to be possessed by a minor at any age; all which time the regency, acting under the cover of a king, have every opportunity and inducement to betray their trust” (Paine). A minor as the ruling king may have no grasp onto what they’re doing and maybe swayed against doing well for society. Paine argues this point really well as the colonies should not be able to face this inconsistency and have the possibility of a child ruler, this helps, highlight the argument into help declare independence as Monarchy is a flawed system of government which is basically viewed as a tyrannical type of government allowing them no representation in Council nor having any say in society at all, along with oppressing basic human

Show More
Related

How Did Thomas Paine Contribute To Independence

432 Words | 2 Pages

Thomas Paine, was a well-known English writer and advocate of American Independence. Thomas Paine is most known for his publication of, Common Sense which focused on the efforts of achieving independence from Great Britain and highlighted the equality of rights for all individuals. Thomas Paine, “arrived in in Philadelphia late in 1774 and quickly became associated with a group of advocates of the American culture” . After his arrival, he became knowledgeable with the current government at the time, and what their stance was in terms of becoming independent from Britain. He continued to make efforts of change, and argued that if we stay connected with Great Britain, problems that arose in the past will continue to reoccur if we do not seek

Read More

How Did Thomas Paine's Writing Affect The Declaration Of Independence

277 Words | 2 Pages

First, public opinion had a huge impact on the Declaration of Independence because of protests created by colonists, impactive writing like Thomas Paine’s Common Sense, and acts given to colonists like the Intolerable Acts and the Tea Act. The Olive Branch Petition affected the Declaration because the entire reason for it being created was for the purpose of claiming the rights of Americans but also staying loyal to the British Crown. Parliament didn’t read it, which angered the colonists. This began new protests by the colonists who thought that they deserve rights. Also, Thomas Paine’s writing affected the Declaration because one writing, Common Sense, discussed how the colonists needed independence, which changed minds of many people

Read More

American Revolution Dbq Essay

360 Words | 2 Pages

He explains that even if civilians chose to have a ruler, that does not validate the King’s child as a ruler too. Thomas Paine’s argument can be used to convince colonists to declare independence from Great Britain because the British follow this monarchy which spreads inequality. It also gives the Colonists

Read More

How Does Thomas Paine Use Rhetoric In The Crisis Number 1

1307 Words | 6 Pages

Paine furthers his point by stating, “Britain, with an army to enforce her tyranny, has declared that she has a right (not only to tax) but ‘to bind us in all cases whatsoever,’ and if being bound in that manner, is not slavery, then is there not such a thing as slavery upon earth. Even the expression is impious, for so unlimited a power can belong only to God.” (Paine 161). Most, if not all, of the colonists were heavily religious people who placed God above all else. Paine points out that what the British King is doing is something that should only be in God’s power, going as far as calling it “impious”.

Read More

Thomas Paine's Rhetorical Strategies

371 Words | 2 Pages

Thomas Paine's most effective rhetorical strategy has to be his incessant allusions to different Biblical elements in order to arouse the idea of independence. One of the best examples of this comes as early as the first paragraph, where he discusses the absurdity of Britain's claim that they have the right to bind all of their citizens in every matter or case. However, Paine retorts with a response of his own, saying, "for so unlimited a power can belong only to God. . . ." (1). Here Paine, knowing that most of his readers are devout, Protestant churchgoers, briefly introduces the notion that Britain is overstepping its authority in such a way that it's almost as if they are trying to play God.

Read More

Common Sense Vs. Plain Truth By Thomas Paine And James Chalmers

1069 Words | 5 Pages

According to Paine, “Even though people of the colonies were paying taxes and were pushed into wars caused by British, they were unfairly not represented in the British Parliament”. (109) Since Paine’s main goal is to target the common man of the society; he directs his argument by using the Bible and emotions to back up his own discussion. Paine indicates that all people are born equally and there is no one given the power to rule over other human beings. Then he uses Bible quotes to explicitly disagree with the presence of Monarchy rule used by the Great Britain.

Read More

Jean Domat's Social Order And Absolute Monarchy

1340 Words | 6 Pages

In Conclusion Thomas Paine was able to prove that monarchies weren’t the correct form of government for the Europe and much less the American colonies. He demonstrates how monarchs can have a severe impact on many people both directly and indirectly. Paine also manages to establish a precedent in which society was able to prosper and be at peace before monarchs took over. Domat’s belief in absolute monarchies is flawed because even though it similar to other natural relationships the one between monarch and subject is just one in which the monarch holds all the power and and can abuse of that

Read More

Paine's Argument For American Independence

887 Words | 4 Pages

The author begins by invalidating any rally for peace maintained by the loyalty of hereditary succession, saying “The whole history of England disowns the fact” (Paine 21), followed by evidence of the many civil wars fought by the English. By evaluating these facts, the reader is able to clearly see how hereditary succession does the opposite of its purpose: it establishes quarrels and thwarts peace. Paine also considers the belief that the British government is credited with American prosperity, and because of this, Great Britain will always be of necessity to America. Though Paine refutes this immediately comparing the belief to these absurd notions: “…because a child has thrived upon milk, that it is never to have meat, or that the first twenty years of our lives is to become a precedent for the nest twenty” (Paine 25). Paine even disproves the necessity of reconciliation between the colonies and Great Britain with two major points.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Declaration Of Independence

644 Words | 3 Pages

The Declaration of Independence, Good Or Bad? The Declaration of Independence was just signed as most people should know, but what most people don't know or haven't decided is whether the Declaration is good for us and will lead to a great positive country or is it bad and not work out for us as a country. This a big decision to step away from The British Empire and try to make it on our own. What I say here and now am that I strongly believe that The Declaration of Independence is great for us as a country.

Read More

Compare And Contrast The American Revolution And Inglis

713 Words | 3 Pages

Paine is against America having a connection with Britain and a single person having power. As Paine expresses, King George III is not and should not be able to be in power of the colonists because mankind is created to be equal and therefore kings should be “disapproved by nature” (Paine 217). Not only does Paine express his anger at the topic of a ruler for all, he also voices that America is connected to whatever Britain does and whatever problems Britain has: implying that America has no say what so ever under Britain (Paine 218). Paine is suggesting that Britain is not only hurting but also is subordinating America and its colonies, so a declaration of independence is in need.

Read More

How Did Thomas Paine Give Me Liberty Or Give Rise To Independence

766 Words | 4 Pages

“It is wholly owing to the Constitution of the people, and not to the constitution of the government that the crown is not as oppressive in England as in Turkey.” We should give power to someone who is fair and not self-centered. Paine stated “from the errors of other nations, let us learn wisdom” to advise us to avoid repeating the past in the future from learning about bad past experiences. Paine argued for American’s separation from England by comparing the Kings that Great Britain has had to what a government should be

Read More

Common Sense Dbq

943 Words | 4 Pages

In conclusion, Paine very clearly voices his negative opinions towards hereditary succession and monarchy. He was able to provide biblical reasoning against monarchical forms of government, which was important, considering his audience in America. He was also able to provide logical reasoning against hereditary succession, such as the age issue that it can present. This document was successful in opening American’s eyes and persuading to not have a monarchical government when they declared independence from

Read More

Robert Filmer's Two Treatises Of Government

1778 Words | 8 Pages

Introduction Robert Filmer (1588 – 26 May 1653) and John Locke (August 29, 1632 – October 28, 1704) both wrote theory on government. They explored a myriad of topics ranging from the state of nature to the dissolution of a government. One particular concept that they both address is the relationship of the father of a family to the king of a state. When discussing this subject, both authors are similar in their argument structure, their idea of the role of the first father, and his fatherly obligation to care for his seed, but they differ on the natural rule, autonomy, and political power of the father. Filmer’s Argument Sir Robert Filmer was an English political theorist and in his greatest known work, Patriarcha, he argued that one could attain the greatest liberty in the world if they resided under a monarchy (Filmer, 4.1).

Read More

Comparing Paine's Common Sense And The Declaration Of Independence

488 Words | 2 Pages

Thomas Paine's Common Sense and The Declaration of Independence both speak against the heinous acts committed by the British and the stripping of natural human rights. Some of these natural rights include life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Both documents advocate the separation from Great Britain. The colonist's belief in the superiority of the republican self-government based on the natural rights of the people found its clearest American expression in Thomas Paine's Common Sense and The Declaration of Independence.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Declaration Of Independence

951 Words | 4 Pages

The Declaration of Independence includes five parts. The five parts are the introduction, the preamble, the indictment of George III, the denunciation of the British people, and the conclusion. All five parts have a definite purpose and are very important to the document itself. The introduction serves to point readers to having a positive view of America and sets up for the rest of the Declaration.

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Declaration Of Independence By Thomas Paine

Related Topics

Open Document