ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Elgin Marbles

1000 Words4 Pages

Who owns history? This image, containing the Elgin Marbles, has been debated over for centuries by many historians who question the legality of Lord Elgin’s ownership over them. (see Appendix A) Sculpted in the 5th century BCE, The Greek Marbles are a collection of sculptures attached to the Parthenon in Athens, Greece, before they were removed by Lord Elgin and shipped to the British Museum in London in 1801. Some historians believe that the Elgin Marbles should be returned to Greece because they represent a vital and central part of Greek cultural heritage and they believe they were removed illegally by Lord Elgin. However, evidence supports that the Elgin Marbles should remain in the British Museum as it would provide a larger educational benefit and put the history of Greece in the context of surrounding countries. Additionally, Elgin was given permission to remove the Marbles in the form of a firman. Therefore, the Elgin Marbles should remain in the British Museum because they are more accessible to a greater number of people and are put in the context of world history. Along with the educational benefits, …show more content…

The Trustees of the British Museum believe that there's a “great public benefit to seeing the sculptures within the context of the world collection of the British Museum, in order to deepen our understanding of their significance within world cultural history.” The Elgin Marbles in London are an important representation of ancient Athenian civilization in the context of world history. Each year millions of visitors, free of charge, admire the artistry of The Elgin Marbles and gain insight into how ancient Greece influenced – and was influenced by – the other civilizations that it encountered. Because of these many educational benefits that are possible with the British Museum’s ownership of the marbles, The Elgin Marbles should remain in

Show More
Related

Dbq Museum Collection Analysis

477 Words | 2 Pages

She writes, “The standard apology for museum sales activities, ‘Because we need the money. ’”(Source D). This describes the gift shop aspect of the museums and how it is not well regarded among both museum patrons and art connoisseurs alike. Even though this system of earning money is not what the public would like to see, it is still essential to running the

Read More

Arguments Against The Kennewick Man

519 Words | 3 Pages

With both cases of the Kennewick Man and Elgin Marbles, there is controversy on who should own the artifacts or sites that was found. There are good claims from both sides on who gets to keep it. The arguments goes from culture and tradition, property, history, and science. In this prompt, the Kennewick Man is the main focus. Some Native American tribes, scholars, and the federal government are fighting for right to own the remains.

Read More

The Follower Problem Analysis

184 Words | 1 Pages

The 8th grade class took a 4 day trip to Washington. We did many things to explore Washington D.C. including visiting monuments. Some people think differently of how a monument should be made. Good monuments to some people could be to make people remember about the person or thing being remembered or to just reflect the person’s life or importance. In “The Follower Problem” by David Brooks, David thinks a good monument should show power and authority.

Read More

Navy Jack Flag Artifact

834 Words | 4 Pages

For people, especially younger children, a way to feel a strong connection to the past is through objects that representation of that time in history. For example, after my grandmother passed away, I received one of her many rosaries, allowing me to remember our bond and the influence she had in my life every time I hold her heirloom. In today’s world, one of the only places in which a person is able to see historic artifacts and feel the connection to the piece of history that it represents is a museum. With the vast amounts of electronics available to the public, people, especially of a younger age, find less time to visit a museum and to learn about their heritage. The results of nationwide poll conducted as a part of the survey of public participation in the arts shows that “21% of adults in 2013 visited” an museum, which is drastically lower than previous nears and is predicted to continuously drop

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Parthenon Marbles

326 Words | 2 Pages

The Elgin Marbles are a great piece of Greek history,Greek culture and Greek heritage, but half of that history was taken 2395 kilometres away from where they belong. The Greeks want the Elgin Marbles to be returned to their homeland. What are the Pros and Cons of the Marbles being

Read More

Lansdowne Herakles Analysis

693 Words | 3 Pages

On our field trip to the Getty villa this semester, we had to choose an art piece that stood out to us among the many there. The task at hand seemed easier than it was, as there were many art pieces that held my attention. One thing I kept in mind was that many of the Greek art pieces were either recovered from the bottom of the sea or were Roman duplicates. This meant finding background and details about them would be challenging. Of the art pieces, the Statue of Hercules or the “Lansdowne Herakles” was the one that I chose to write about.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Should Monuments Be Removed?

837 Words | 4 Pages

However, these monuments are history and although they may not be suitable for a public place nowadays, they are sure a great piece of history for a museum. These monuments are part of all that is left from a certain period in our history. Even though the Confederate period, for example, is not the period of the United States that many are proud of it still happened and it is still history. These monuments should be saved for the sake of knowing about the past, not for personal gain. Some monuments can stay in public for everyone to see.

Read More

The Parthenon Within The Athenian Acropolis Of Ancient Greece

298 Words | 2 Pages

Perhaps the work that would be most considered the first Western artistic masterpiece is the Parthenon within the Athenian Acropolis of Ancient Greece. The structure constructed from Pentalic marble by Iktinos and Kallikrates between 447 and 432 BCE, loomed over the ancient city which gave birth to numerous philosophies destined to become the cornerstone of Western civilization, including democracy, but also artistic ideals of architecture and the human form. The simple architecture of the Parthenon, with its emphasis on the vertical and aerial to hint at a connection with the gods, yet heavy-set structure to underscore the connection with the human ties well with the humanistic views of ancient Greece. Indeed, numerous aspects of the Parthenon

Read More

Essay On Confederate Statues

502 Words | 3 Pages

If people truly want to keep the statues, the government should move the statues to a specific museum, so people that want to see the statues can. If people don’t want the see them the people don’t have to. Many people also think that it proves many things about the war and the people and that it is worth it to maintain. Would you want your taxes and money to be misspent on this statue?

Read More

The Pantheon Vs Parthenon

1397 Words | 6 Pages

The design of the Parthenon was reflection of the then current Grecian Empire. According to Silverman (n.d.), “the Parthenon represents the tangible and visible efflorescence of Athenian imperial power. It symbolizes the power and influence of the Athenian politician, Perikles, who championed its construction”. The style and function of the building being a reflection of the culture is reflected in the Orders of the design.

Read More

Lincoln Memorial Essay

830 Words | 4 Pages

People generally are fascinated by things which draw their eyes, may it be attractive or extravagant. The importance of designing a monument to allow the public to honor it or connect with it remains crucial. However, it also happens to be a very serious matter for the design to be appealing and attractive. The monuments which lay upon The Mall in Washington D.C. are nothing but striking. The Lincoln Memorial stands upon a roundabout capturing the attention of all passerby’s, due to Lincoln’s “colossal marble statue” and two of his most outstanding “speeches [are] carved on” the grandeur walls.

Read More

How Did Culture Influence Ancient Greek Art

1023 Words | 5 Pages

Ancient Greek shaped the ideas of the what art should look like, and Greek culture plays such an important role of building the foundation of the western civilization. His ideas is absorbing, spreading and developing along with the conquered by Rome. Greece is kind of materialism, they barely believe the world in the mental, they prefer the world is all made by material instead. All the art work is the best example of Greece philosophy of life. The ideas of democracy, wisdom, religion is reflected in the Greek artwork, also represent the ancient people’s intelligence and creativity.

Read More

Atop The Acropolis Informative Speech

648 Words | 3 Pages

The operational guidelines for the implementation of the World Heritage Convention aim to implement the convention concerning the protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage. The Acropolis meets 5 of the 10 criteria which are why it has been under the protection from the WHS since 1987. The criteria they meet involves adaptation of architecture to a natural site, exceptional influence in contemporary times and Greco-Roman antiquity, bears a unique testimony to the religions of ancient Greece, and an architectural ensemble illustrating significant historical phases since the 16th century BC. The last criteria they meet is directly and tangibly associated with events and ideas that have never faded over the course of history (Centre, U.

Read More

The Style And Function Of The Greek Parthenon And The Roman Pantheon

707 Words | 3 Pages

The Parthenon in Athens and the Pantheon in Rome depict the splendor of these two cultures. Starting with the Parthenon, it was completely constructed in 432 B.C.E by the architects Iktinos and Kallikrates to honor the Athen’s patron deity, Athena, and to house her statue. It is rectangular and consisted of a series of Doric columns. However, it is a mixture of the Doric and Ionic orders. The Pentelic marble, bronze, gold, and ivory are the basic media used in this construction.

Read More

Monuments Men Reflection

1053 Words | 5 Pages

Before I watched the movie, I actually answered that art cannot have equal or greater importance than a human life. My initial reasoning was that one human life has the potential to do much more than what one piece of art can. However, after watching Monuments Men, it made me seriously reconsider my own reasoning on the subject. To those men, the pieces of art meant more than just a monetary value or some symbolic piece of art, the art was an integral part of human history. Europe was one of the oldest and most developed places on Earth, and the art that was being talked about were crucial to our understanding of previous times, like the Ghent Altarpiece.

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Elgin Marbles

Related Topics

Open Document