ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Guantanamo Bay

982 Words4 Pages

Guantanamo Bay

In recent discussions of Guantanamo Bay, a controversial issue has been whether this facility does harm or good to the United States. On the one hand, some argue that it should remain opened. On the other hand, however, others argue that it should be closed. Although Guantanamo Bay is located on foreign soil, it is a national security facility that keeps the United States safe from terrorists. As a symbol of security, Guantanamo Bay should remain opened because it gives the Unites States people the safety they need, it is the safest place to keep the detainees, and it is a safe interrogation center for the detainees.
Guantanamo Bay was opened on January 11 2002, after the attack of 9/11. That devastating event in American …show more content…

According to May Clifford, “Where else can they go? Not to any country where they might face summary execution or torture.” This means that if the detainees were to be transferred to other facilities, they would be killed or tortured. Guantanamo Bay does not kill nor do they torture the detainees which is why this facility is the safest for the detainees. Edwin Meese explains,”The conditions of detention there are safe, secure and humane and comply with national and international standards, including Common Article 3 of the Geneva Conventions.”. The detainees are secured by the Geneva Conventions, which are treaties for the treatment of civilians and prisoners of war. These treaties state that the prisoners can not be treated in a severe way nor can they be punished. Therefore, the detainees can’t be treated inhumanely. If the detainees were transferred to a facility in America, they would immediately be granted the rights American citizens have. That means they have a right to be appointed a lawyer.Not to mention how costly and the amount of time it would take to set up a new facility for the detainees. If at some point the United States decides to create another facility for these terrorists, it would be a waste of time because there is already a facility in which they are treated well and there would be no funds to support the creation of a new prison for the detainees.No American citizen would …show more content…

Lawful interrogations are being made to detainees to know their intentions. Edwin Meese III comments, “We have learned a great deal from them during long-term, lawful interrogations.” This shows that the interrogations worked. Without these interrogations, the United States wouldn’t be aware of the intentions of the terrorists and it wouldn’t be possible to defeat the enemy. Guantanamo Bay is the safest interrogation center for detainees.In other facilities, they are tortured and forced to speak. Guantanamo doesn’t do that. John Bellinger asserts, “The prison is now expertly run by the military in a humane way that is consistent with international legal standards.” Which means that the detainees are treated in a humane manner and they wouldn’t be put in a position where they had to be tortured to speak about information they know. Why would the military officials want to torture or force the detainees when they have information that the United States need to prevent another terrorist attack? Committing such a thing will result in only resentment from the detainees and that means no information could be obtained.With no information, there is no way the United States can know what is coming their way. Thus, detaining the detainees at Guantanamo Bay for interrogation, is an advantage for the United States to get an idea on what actions should be taken to prevent another attack. Guantanamo

Show More
Related
565 Words | 3 Pages

And according to section 3 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, “every child deprived of his or her liberty must be separated from adults.” Omar Khadr was not granted his right to be separated from the adults in Guantanamo

Read More
699 Words | 3 Pages

Mahatma Gandhi, the preeminent leader of the Indian independence movement states “You can chain me, you can torture me, you can even destroy this body, but you will never imprison my mind.” This is important because torture is brutal on the body and mind. The article “Torture’s Terrible Toll” by John McCain is more convincing then the article “The Case for Torture” by Michael Levin because McCain provides more logical reasoning, he adds his own personal experience of being a captured prisoner during the Vietnam War, and he creates an emotional bond with people around the world. Through more logical reasoning McCain Argument is more valid than Levin.

Read More
155 Words | 1 Pages

The prison camps were acompanied by about 120 soilders per camp. They were fed but, the camps were not sanitary. Prisoners enjoyed playing sports while at the camp but, soon the camps started to flood with people. Over10,00 people flooded into the salisbury camp. With all of the overflow of men lack of food came.

Read More
971 Words | 4 Pages

Another long lasting effect of the authorization has been the establishment of Guantanamo Bay. Opened in 2002 by Bush’s administration, the prison camp became a staple in the American War on Terror. Guantanamo Bay remains a highly debated topic in America as some call it a necessity while others criticize the camp for inhuman treatment of prisoners. Many controversial long term effects have been created due to the Authorization for Use of Military Force, and it has left a significant impact on America’s involvement in the War on

Read More
1050 Words | 5 Pages

While analyzing “The Torture Myth” and “The Case for Torture”, it is very clear to see the type of rhetorical appeals used to persuade the audience. Anne Applebaum, the writer of “The Torture Myth” --in context of the decision of electing a new Attorney General--would argue that torture is very seldomly effective, violates a person’s rights, and should be outlawed due to the irrational need upon which physical torture is used. On the other hand, Michael Levin strongly argues that physical torture is crucial to solving every imminent danger to civilians. Levin claims that if you don’t physically torture someone, you are being weak and want to allow innocent people to die over something that could have been simply done.

Read More
893 Words | 4 Pages

About two years ago, a C.I.A. torture report was released, the subject on detainees captured after September 11, who were suspected to be linked to the attack. One of the more famous detainees, Majid Khan, who had been afflicted with Al Qaeda, was captured in 2003 and was held at Guantanamo Bay since 2006. He says that the interrogators waterboarded him twice, was moved among series of C.I.A. operated “black sites” over some months, and the torture still continued. He was beaten repeatedly, hung from a wooden beam for three days, and shackled and starved. He was even submerged in an ice bath, the transparent ice burning his skin like fire, slowly numbing his body.

Read More
873 Words | 4 Pages

Some individuals find solace in being alone; however, imagine being alone in a concrete cell for months or even years? Isolated from the entire world into a small box seems intimidating, but this tactic is used throughout the US prison system. Solitary confinement is as a disciplinary action on the prisoners to ensure their safety and serve as punishment. This issue has raised both ethical and practical questions on its usage through US prisons because of its benefits and drawbacks. Isolated and cramped, for the next months or years, in a small area where the prisoner would sleep and eat is implemented into the prison systems.

Read More
1032 Words | 5 Pages

2016). Using this ethical framework to argue against torture, one needs to consider the violation of the terrorist’s rights. Utilitarians argue that under a scenario where thousands of people are in danger, the well-being of the larger community is more important than neglecting the rights of a single individual (Krauthammer 2005). The simple idea of taking away a person’s autonomy for the sake of others violates rights ethics. To comprehend the violation upon the victim’s rights, it is important to understand how torture feels, “Brian describes his body as having become an object… pain is the central reality; it dominates experience and expression (Wisnewski 2010, 81).”

Read More
1171 Words | 5 Pages

15). They would be quite furious with Guantanamo Bay because they are breaking the U.S. Constitution because everyone has to follow the Constitution and Guantanamo Bay

Read More
507 Words | 3 Pages

Those who find themselves sentenced to time in a penitentiary, jail, or prison are at risk of either being broken or strengthened by the time they spend behind bars. There is a great debate of whether or not the prison system in the United States is positive or negative. The following will briefly highlight the positives, negatives, and possible alternatives for our nation's prison system. First, there is a long list of negatives that the prison system in America brings. The prison system is filled with crime, hate, and negativity almost as much as the free world is.

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

Annotated Bibliography-“How effective is torture in obtaining information?” “Brown Note” Myth Busters. Discovery channel. Artarmon 16 Feb. 2005. Television.

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

In these facilities there is inadequate health care in the facilities, sexual abuse by staff, reports of detainees dying due to lack of medical

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

The United States invasion of Iraq in 2003 was dubbed Operation Iraqi Freedom by US Forces, but it seemed like freedom was the last thing on their minds. Abu Ghraib prison was an occupied Iraqi prison where the US Army held mass incarcerations and sponsored inmate torture. 2007 marked the year that a documentary titled “Ghosts of Abu Ghraib” was produced by HBO and directed by Rory Kennedy. This documentary showed the abuses and injustices inured to the Iraqi prisoners at the hands of the United States Soldiers. Although the guards at Abu Ghraib Prison Complex had personal reservations against the treatment of the prisoners, they were manipulated into authoritarianism by their overzealous obedience.

Read More
1082 Words | 5 Pages

Most of the time when someone is tortured it is because the interrogators are desperate for Important or valuable information. However, why would real “terrorist” give up valuable information that would expose their cause and what they believe in when they know they are going to die one way or the other. This just goes to show that the “suspected terrorist” are in fact suspected and aren’t real terrorist and shouldn’t be

Read More
501 Words | 3 Pages

This is similar to our CIA society today, For torture to happened it can not happen on U.S soil. It must happen some place else.

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Guantanamo Bay

Related Topics

Open Document