ipl-logo

Queensland's Criminal Justice System: Reforms To Double Jeopardy And Appeals

1319 Words6 Pages

Strengthening Queensland's Criminal Justice System: Reforms to Double Jeopardy and Appeals. Recent legislative changes aim to enhance the state's criminal justice system and provide greater protections against wrongful convictions and unjust acquittals. The Criminal Code and Other Legislation (Double Jeopardy Exception and Subsequent Appeals) Amendment Act 2023, passed by the Queensland Parliament in March 2023, introduces two key reforms: 1. Expanding the Double Jeopardy Exception 2. Establishing a Framework for Subsequent Appeals Against Convictions Let's examine these changes in detail. Expanding the Double Jeopardy Exception The long-standing principle of 'double jeopardy' has traditionally prevented a person from being retried for an …show more content…

Previously, the only avenue available to a convicted person who believed they had been wrongfully found guilty was to petition the Governor for a pardon. This process is often lengthy, complex and provides little certainty for applicants. The new laws now give convicted persons the ability to seek leave from the Court of Appeal to lodge a subsequent appeal on the grounds of either: 1. Fresh and Compelling Evidence: If the Court is satisfied that there was a miscarriage of justice, it must allow the appeal and either order a new trial or enter a verdict of acquittal. 2. What is the difference between a'smart' and a'smart'? New and Compelling Evidence: If the Court is of the opinion that, on the balance of probabilities, the appellant was not guilty of the offence, it must allow the appeal and enter a verdict of acquittal. This reform is a significant step forward, as it provides a clear statutory pathway for individuals who believe they have been wrongfully convicted to have their cases reconsidered by the courts. By allowing subsequent appeals on the basis of new evidence that was not available at the original trial, the legislation aims to enhance the integrity …show more content…

By expanding the limited exceptions to the double jeopardy rule and establishing a framework for subsequent appeals against conviction, the legislation aims to enhance the system's ability to respond to possible unjust acquittals and wrongful convictions. These reforms, which bring Queensland's laws more in line with other Australian jurisdictions, demonstrate the government's commitment to ensuring that the criminal justice system remains contemporary, efficient and delivers fair and just outcomes for the community. As an experienced criminal lawyer, I believe these changes have the potential to significantly improve the integrity and public confidence in Queensland criminal proceedings. However, the true impact of these reforms will depend on their effective implementation and the approach taken by the courts in applying the new laws. It will be crucial to strike the right balance between the finality of criminal proceedings and the need to correct potential errors, particularly in cases where new evidence emerges that raises serious doubts about the original verdict. Overall, the Criminal Code and Other Legislation (Double Jeopardy Exception and Subsequent Appeals) Amendment Act 2023 represents a positive step forward for Queensland's criminal justice system,

Show More
Related

Mr. Lazarus Flaws Of The Legal System

673 Words | 3 Pages

This case also shows the effectiveness of the legal system in protecting individuals rights to not be tried or punished more than once under section 26. This is shown as the NSW Director of Public Prosecutions had urged that it would be oppressive as he already served 11 months of his sentence therefore the acquittal remained the

Read More

Case Brief Of R V Gudgeon

902 Words | 4 Pages

Question of Law / Issues 1. Whether the appeal should be allowed and a retrial ordered to determine whether the prosecution evidence, or sufficient to convict the appellant, should properly be

Read More

People Vs Knoller Case Study

1150 Words | 5 Pages

When a second-degree murder gets a new trial built on a philosophy of implied malice, the court mishandles its decision by demanding that the suspect must be shown to know that there was a high chance of subsequent death to others from the behavior of the perpetrator. The new trial was settled because of the fault in grasping the term “implied malice. The combination of these components of implied malice makes the trial court’s explanation a flawed one, and therefore a new trial created on this definition is a misuse of choice. The case is remanded for reconsideration on the basis of this

Read More

Dietrich V Queen Summary

991 Words | 4 Pages

He had murdered a security guard in cold blood. This resulted in Olaf Dietrich receiving the life sentence. This decisions biggest affect was the way the Australian government deals with providing legal aid to any individual who may not have access to legal aid, to people may not be affluent enough or to those who have committed such serious crimes to which legal aid isn’t supplied. The decision also affects the way legal aid works itself and how it works in the Australian legal system.

Read More

Essay On R V Loveridge

851 Words | 4 Pages

To measure if justice was achieved, the case must be reviewed with the three main characteristics of justice, Was it fair? Was it equal? Did both parties have equal access? with further analysis of the back story, charges and both parties cases considered with the characteristics of Justice an educated decision can be made whether the case R v Loveridge [2013] NSWSC 1638, achieved Justice Kieran Loveridge was convicted by the courts for an unprovoked attack on 18- year old Thomas Kelly at Kings Cross and assaults on Rhyse Saliba, Aden Gazi, Marco Compagnoni and Matthew Serrao. Kieran Loveridge was also found as intoxicated through the process of the assaults although there is no legitimate proof on how much Kieran Loveridge consumed, but

Read More

Double Jeopardy Clause Of The 5th Amendment

246 Words | 1 Pages

All clauses are adapted to the needs of the country at the present time. Change is always necessary to explore better and newer options. The double jeopardy clause of the 5th amendment hasn’t significantly changed since the constitution was ratified, but rather the way viewed. The Supreme Court's rulings in Palko v. Connecticut,  Benton v. Maryland and Heath v. Alabama show that there has been a noticeable trend towards various interpretations of the same clause over the last hundred years.

Read More

Summary Of The Sentencing Reform Act Of 1984

461 Words | 2 Pages

“The Sentencing Reform Act of 1984” The article, “The Sentencing Reform Act of 1984” (2015), written by Eric Girault, persuades the audience that the enactment of the law did not reduce crime in societies, but was misappropriated, which caused a negative impact on families and their communities. Girault describes this by sharing his personal anecdote on receiving a harsh prison sentence for a non-violent crime as a first time offender. He uses trustworthy resources in order to substantiate his claim. Girault’s intended audience for this piece of writing is the general public, specifically those that lack knowledge of the law and its due process.

Read More

Conditions That Gave Rise To The Reform Of The Bail Act 2013 (NSW)

656 Words | 3 Pages

The Bail Act 2013 (NSW) is a crucial piece of legislation that outlines the legal framework for granting bail to persons who are charged with an offense in New South Wales. In 2014, the Act underwent significant reform due to concerns about the effectiveness of the existing bail system in achieving justice. This essay will discuss the conditions that gave rise to the reform of the Bail Act 2013 (NSW) in 2014, the specific changes to the Bail Act 2013 (NSW), and evaluate the effectiveness of the law reform in achieving justice. Conditions that gave rise to the reform of the Bail Act 2013 (NSW) in 2014 The reform of the Bail Act 2013 (NSW) was triggered by a number of factors, including the increasing rate of reoffending by people on bail and concerns about community safety.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Juries In Australia

1543 Words | 7 Pages

The relevance of juries in the Australian criminal system given the expansion in modern technology has been questioned regarding the effectiveness of ordinary people judging complex legal issues. The jury system was developed in England between the 12th and 15th century, in a time when courts relied more on the theory of a jury judging its own peers. With complex evidence presented in courts and the advances in technology available to the average citizen, the use of the jury system has been reported to have problems regarding the comprehension and impartiality. There are many pros and cons to the jury system currently in use in our Australian legal system, for the jury system to be able to work coherently with our legal system these pros and

Read More

Causes Of Wrongful Convictions In Australia

119 Words | 1 Pages

Wrongful convictions are a problem that most government officials won’t admit. The United States and other countries such as Australia have been susceptible to these miscarriages of justice. This can arise from a snowball effect of scenarios such as witness misidentification, perjured testimonies, coercive methods of interrogation, prosecutorial misconduct and ineffective counsel. These are some of the reasons that can potentially lead innocent people to be convicted of crimes they did not commit. The thousands of exonerations in the United States has caused concern for other nations to reevaluate their criminal justice system.

Read More

Comparing The Criminal Law And Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2023

1273 Words | 6 Pages

The Criminal Law (Coercive Control and Affirmative Consent) and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2023: A Landmark Step in Combating Domestic Violence in Queensland. On March 6, 2024, the Queensland Parliament passed the Criminal Law (Coercive Control and Affirmative Consent) and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2023. This marks a significant milestone in the state's efforts to address the growing issue of domestic violence. This groundbreaking legislation, also known as "Hannah's Law," aims to tackle the serious and ongoing rise of domestic violence offences, with a particular focus on the insidious nature of coercive control. The Bill was introduced into Parliament on October 11, 2023, by the Honourable Shannon Fentiman, Minister for Health,

Read More

Overview Of The Queensland Jury Act 1995

1254 Words | 6 Pages

1.0 Introduction Section 80 guarantees the right to trial by jury. The Queensland Jury Act 1995 provides the current legislation which decrees that all trials on indictment must be by jury. In the ninety years since this legislation was passed, an increase of trial complexity has occurred, leaving many jurors with the inability to comprehend the information and evidence procured in a trial. This proceeds to make lay juries ineffective and unreliable. To remedy the situation, specialised juries should be introduced to minimize the amount of incorrect verdicts, misunderstandings in court, jury misconduct, and avoidance of jury duty.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Wrongful Conviction

949 Words | 4 Pages

With millions of criminal convictions a year, more than two million people may end up behind bars(Gross). According to Samuel Gross reporter for The Washington Post, writes that also “even one percent amounts to tens of thousands of tragic [wrongful conviction] errors”(Gross). Citizens who are wrongfully convicted are incarcerated for a crime he or she did not commit. Many police officers, prosecutors, and judges are responsible for the verdict that puts innocents into prison. To be able to get exonerated many wait over a decade just to get there case looked at, not many are able to have the opportunity of getting out.

Read More

Literary Techniques Used In To Kill A Mockingbird

662 Words | 3 Pages

I want you to think about those people that you like, that are in your inner circle, and then about the people on the outside of your circle. Why are they outside? Is it, just possibly, because they are different than you? Or because you’ve heard something about them? Or possibly just looking at them, you feel like there is something wrong about them?

Read More

Katherine Knight Case Study

1046 Words | 5 Pages

(2) A person sentenced to imprisonment to life for the crime of murder is to serve that sentence for the term of that person’s natural life. The fact that Katherine Knight was sentence to life imprisonment for the murder of John Price reflects society’s standards in that nobody should get away with taking somebody else’s life, especially in the way in which Katherine did. 6 THE EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF THE LEGAL SYSTEM IN ACHIEVING JUSTICE Once Katherine Knight pleaded guilty to the murder of John Price, the court was able to sentence her quite efficiently once all evidence was heard. The efficiency of this case and also the fact that Katherine Knight received the harshest penalty possible in Australia for her horrific crime shows how justice was achieved.

Read More

More about Queensland's Criminal Justice System: Reforms To Double Jeopardy And Appeals

Open Document