ipl-logo

Ralph Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

930 Words4 Pages

Nishanth Mekala
Mr.Collins
English 9
15 March 2023

The character differences between Ralph and Jack

“Government is necessary, not because man is naturally bad... but because man is by nature more individualistic than social.” Thomas Hobbs. This quote is an ever-present theme in the novel Lord of The Flies by William Golding. The novel is about a group of British boys getting stuck on an island in the Pacific. The story follows the boys as they try to maintain some figment of society and order but in their attempts, they fail to do so. This struggle to maintain order is ever present in the 2 main characters Jack and Ralph as they fight each other to determine who has the proper methods for maintaining order. There attempt to make society …show more content…

Jack on the other hand is the fact that he is too power hungary and always looks for ways to increase his power but decrease others. In the novel, the boys start as a bunch of kids trying to establish rules. They then select their leader. They select Ralph as he is the one that blew the conch. Ralph takes this in stride and says yes and becomes the leader of the tribe he tries his best and organizes the tribe somewhat decently but then the narrator says “Ralph…would treat the day's decisions as though he were playing chess. The only trouble was that he would never be a good chess player.”(Golding 117pg). This shows that Ralph is a bad leader because it says he's bad at chess. Since Ralph thinks that all decisions today are like a chess game Ralph just does not know how to properly lead him. If you put someone that does not know how to lead in a position to lead then they will be very ineffective at their job. The second instance where Ralph is shown as an …show more content…

As the story goes it becomes more and more apparent that Jack is losing himself to the forest and is becoming a beast this also leads to the fact that he was becoming power-hungry and a savage. When he says” I’m not going to play anymore. Not with you...I’m not going to be a part of Ralph’s lot—”(golding) This quote exemplifies jacks power struggle since he is leaving the group. He wants to be a leader and since he did not get to be a leader he leaves the group and makes his tribe. This also leads the the destabilizing of the tribe as they have lost on of the more prominent figures this was a very selfish and power-hungry move as since he did not get what he liked he destroyed the tribe and made his own with him at the center. Another quote that exemplifies Jack's hunger for power was” Bollocks to the rules! We’re strong – we hunt! If there’s a beast, we’ll hunt it down! We’ll close in and beat and beat and beat”(golding 91pg) This quote shows that jack is becoming a savage boy since he is rejecting rules and is restoring to violence to solve all his problems. This leads to many fo the boys following him in abandoning rules which in many cases are the fundamental corner stone of society with out them society would not function and would fail. Jack is hear

Show More
Related
969 Words | 4 Pages

This statement from Ralph shows his responsibility by taking initiative and being the one who has the tribes best interest at heart. Ralph does not care if he is leader or not, he just knows that in order to be successful and possibly be rescued they need to keep order, and that can be done by making someone the leader. The last example of Ralph being responsible is when he… Ralph being responsible helps his relationships for the most part because without this quality, the island would fall apart and they would never be rescued. But, sometimes the boys do not like his rules and this causes tension. In the end, his responsibility was important because it helped both him personally and the rest of the tribe make it as far as they could on the

Read More
790 Words | 4 Pages

From the beginning, Ralph always wanted communication within the tribe and cared about the boys’ opinions. He implemented rules which helped secure order at meetings and gave the rest of the boys a chance to voice their thoughts. Ralph was able to prove his concern for the boys’ thoughts by risking his position as chief. From this, it is understood that Ralph was a selfless leader who was constantly putting survival and the boys before his high position. As seen throughout the novel, communication was a major belief Ralph had and every time something went wrong, he called a meeting to make sure everyone knew the issue and knew how they could fix it.

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

There is a struggle over power and who has it as Jack was jealous of how Ralph was voted the official leader of the group originally as Jack wanted it, he took his first official chance to become the chief of the kids other than his hunters. Jack doesn’t know how to lead a group full on with all of their burdens and needs and he will surely kill them all in some sort of

Read More
917 Words | 4 Pages

Although throughout the book that changes. With no adults around and losing authority Ralph changes everything they know about civilization. Now the boys turn on Ralph to the point where the boys on Jack’s side want to kill him. This decivilization leads to chaos and trouble.

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

If Jack could avoid gaining power, he might have not gone corrupt, killing his friends and attempting to kill Ralph before being saved by a british naval officer. While in the book the boys are a symbol of savagery, while the officer is a symbol of stability and

Read More
931 Words | 4 Pages

At the beginning of the novel, Jack is the leader of the choir boys on the island. There is another leader on the island who was chief of all of the boys and Jack did not approve, and this quote describes how they chose the chief. “Let him be the chief with the trumpet-thing.” (Golding 22) Jack is the kind of character that wants power and leadership, therefore he was jealous and wanted power for himself. Towards the middle of the novel, nobody agrees with Jack.

Read More
564 Words | 3 Pages

Ralph is the protagonist of Lord of the flies, a novel that explores the natural behavior of man. Throughout the book, Ralph experiences a lot of character development, being introduced at the beginning of the novel as a handsome, thoughtful, charismatic person who is a natural leader, he quickly gains the support and respect of all the boys on the island and is promptly elected leader of the island. Ralph's election kickstarts a rivalry between him and one of the older boys Jack, who believes he should be the one in charge. Jack repeatedly challenges ralphs authority as Ralph's leadership is repeatedly put to the test.

Read More
434 Words | 2 Pages

Although Jack expresses strong desire to become chief, the boys elect Ralph as a leader, suggesting an air of charisma that made him worthy of his position. He believes a leader has to “think, be wise… grab at a decision”, someone who can look after others and keep the group in

Read More
870 Words | 4 Pages

Jack says that he is unwilling to be a part of Ralph’s group any longer. This goes to show that he has left the civilized part of him behind in favor of his savage side. If Jack had stayed with the civilized boys, then the two groups would still be as one and the conflict between the Jack and Ralph would not have reached the high peaking point of which it

Read More
843 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the novel, Jack consistently demonstrates a disregard for rules and a desire for dominance and power. When he leads the boys in hunting and violence, he taps into their savage and primal instincts - including Ralph’s. As Jack proclaims, "The conch doesn't count at this end of the island" (Golding, 150) it becomes evident that he prioritizes dominance and power over order, authority, and the established rules on the island. In the midst of their destructive rivalry, Jack’s failures teach Ralph important lessons. Witnessing Jack’s inability to maintain the signal fire makes Ralph recognize the value of collaboration, communication, and planning for survival.

Read More
599 Words | 3 Pages

Jack was the leader of the choir boys, before arriving on the island. He wanted to be Chief, but Ralph had more votes. Ralph, the representor of civilization, gave Jack control over his choir boys, so he made them hunters. Throughout the novel, we see him grow from a hunter to a savage. This transformation affects all the characters in the book, as he decides to leave Ralph’s tribe and make his own.

Read More
1282 Words | 6 Pages

Kunwer Chhatwal Mr.Frey Honors English 9127 Works Cited 10 May 2023 Humans are the downfall of their own societies Societies often fail due to the defects of human nature and behavior. In William Golding's novel Lord of The Flies, the idea that human flaws can derail a society is emphasized throughout the story. Since their early days on the island, two of the main characters, Ralph and Jack, constantly fight for leadership and power. However, although both are natural leaders, their views on society and ideas are very different. Ralph is a narrow-minded leader who is indecisive and often unassertive, while Jack is controlled by his thirst for power and need to defy authority.

Read More
243 Words | 1 Pages

Jack’s desires power above all other things turns him into some sort of Satan. He becomes furious as he loses the election to Ralph and keeps on pushing the boundaries of his subordinate role in the group.

Read More
372 Words | 2 Pages

The rise and subsequent demise of the ability to uphold civilized structure os tester in the novel, Lord of the Flies written by William Golding. Jack and Ralph are two characters that challenge each other for the ability to govern the other boys. Although through a democratic compromise, Ralph is chosen as chief, Jack tests Ralphs ability to lead. Throughout a series of negligence for his elected leader, Jack proves his desperation to become leader. This series includes ignoring Ralphs orders, breaking rules and forming a rival tribe.

Read More
2038 Words | 9 Pages

Ralph's attempt at leading the boys demonstrates the overbearing extension of governmental power. Jack contradicts Ralph’s leadership and the authority of the conch: “‘Who are you, anyway? Sitting there telling people what to do. You can't hunt, you can't sing―’ ‘I'm chief. I was chosen.’

Read More

More about Ralph Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

Related Topics

Open Document