ipl-logo

Review Of Bill C-31: The Act To Amend The Indian Act

2901 Words12 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essays on the indian act

Canada has mistreated its Indigenous people for centuries. The Indian Act (1876) is just one of many ways the government forced their colonial ways of life onto the Indigenous people already living here. It was extremely sexist and gave the Indigenous people very little rights. Bill C-31: The Act to Amend the Indian Act, also known as the new Indian Act, was introduced in April of 1985 by the Canadian government to address the issues regarding discrimination within the Indian Act. The government created this bill with the intention to emphasize equality and give Indigenous communities more self-governing rights. A woman's Indian status is now determined by her own heritage instead of her husbands. This is a victory for many women but this also …show more content…

Children who have parents that are both registered under Bill C-31 will be registered under section 6(1); children with only one parent registered under Bill C-31 are registered under section 6(2) and will have fewer rights than the children registered under 6(1). A lot of people registered under section 6(2) are children of women who were stripped of their status and had to get reinstated under this new bill. Many people who consider themselves to have indigenous heritage remain ineligible to be a Status Indian. These people include the descendants of those who previously had “half-breed” land or money script, those from families or bands that were left odd band lists or were never registered, and some women who gained status through marriage and then lost by divorce or other circumstances. This new category in which some Indigenous people are registered only continues the pattern of gender inequality. There are still so many people who deserve status that are not eligible to get …show more content…

It removed clauses from the Indian Act that restrained a woman's ability to be registered and based their heritage on who they married but it was not a perfect remedy. Many women were forced to live new lives or lost their sense of identity. These women who are suffering have been heard and continue to suffer until Canada finds a better solution. A main goal of the Act to Amend the Indian Act was to give bands more self-governance and although they do have more power than they did from the Indian Act, they are still largely controlled by the government. Bands have also been strained on resources with the flux of Status Indians and they have been given no federal help. The new bill came with new problems. Many people are getting discriminated against based on which Act they have been registered under. A lot of people who were accepted before are now getting hate because their status has been taken away. A lot of people view the passing of this bill as a perfect permanent solution but neglect to see all the negatives that have come with it. Canada is trying to amend for their past mistakes but the passing of this bill does not make up for the decades of alienation and inequality Indigenous people have been faced with. The government should actively be trying to find another,

Show More
Related
644 Words | 3 Pages

They continued to resist against the Canadian government's attempts to assimilate them, and to use their land for projects that would cause their communities harm, such as building oil pipes, and an incredible amount of other causes impacting Indigenous peoples. Throughout the history of Indigenous people, before Canada was even a country, they have resisted the attempts of colonizers to take their land, and attempt to take their culture as well. Paragraph #2 for Response Questions #4 A specific historical moment mentioned in the timeline that connects particularly well to “The Right to be Cold” by Sheila Watt-Cloutier is the education heading in Dr. Susan Dion’s talk. The policy paper detailing more Indigenous control of their own communities' education under the Education headline was fought for by the National Indian Brotherhood, and it led to the Canadian government giving back control of Indigenous education back to Indigenous people.

Read More
296 Words | 2 Pages

In his essay “To be Indian in Canada today”, Richard Wagamese relies on logos to explain the struggles and obstacles that come with the Federal Court’s decision to recognize Metis and non-status Indians in Canada as “Indians” under the Constitution Act. He then begs the question, “what does it mean to be Indian in Canada today?”(Wagameses). Being First Nations himself, Richard Wagamese knows firsthand all barriers that come with being Indigenous in Canada today. While using logos Richard Wagamese implements many different statistics and percentages in his essay to show the hurdles that Indigenous people face: “To be Indian in Canada today is to see youth languish in chronic unemployment and malaise, endure high rates of alcohol, drug and solvent

Read More
1172 Words | 5 Pages

In many cases, Indigenous peoples were subjected to exploitation, discrimination, and violence as a result of the Treaty and its implementation. From the perspective of the Crown and settlers, Treaty 6 was seen as a necessary step in the process

Read More
199 Words | 1 Pages

It also took away the tribal ownership of most tribes. The act moved Indian families onto their own land, and took away Indian children away from their families and sent them to boarding

Read More
286 Words | 2 Pages

In 2002, Canada followed Homeland Security of United States and came up with an immigration plan. The bill was called “Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.” The focus of the bill was to stop people entering Canada and seeking asylum who will endanger the safety of the Canadians. The bill introduced strict law for people who will try to put the life of Canadians at risk. The law allowed immigration to remove people from the country who may pose a threat to the country.

Read More
447 Words | 2 Pages

Erb 4 In conclusion Bill C-51 is a very controversial piece of legislation and infringes on some basic rights and freedoms that us as Canadian citizens deserve such as allocating more power to police services and security institutions, raises privacy

Read More
802 Words | 4 Pages

"One of the most damaging consequences of residential schools has been that so many Survivors, their families, and whole communities have lost the connection to their own cultures, languages, and laws. on page forty-six, the author mentions, "The opportunity to learn, understand, and practise the laws of their ancestors as part of their heritage and birthright was taken away." The law significantly impacted Indigenous people, making it more difficult for them to accept reconciliation. The laws protected people from their wrongdoing and stripped away Indigenous laws. As the author stated on page forty-eight, "Decisions not to charge or prosecute abusers allowed people to escape the harmful consequences of their actions.

Read More
1554 Words | 7 Pages

Firstly, he created the 1969 White Paper, which aimed to assimilate Indigenous people into Canadian culture. “He [Trudeau] and Jean Chrétien, his minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development at the time, proposed in a White Paper in 1969 that the special legal relationship between First Nations and the government of Canada be severed and all Indigenous Peoples fully integrated into Canadian life” (Blake & Donaldson, 2021). The 1969 White Paper was met with vigorous opposition from Indigenous leaders all across the country and it sparked the beginning of a new era of Indigenous political organizing in Canada. Trudeau soon recognized that his largely assimilationist policy was not likely to convince anyone that it was either workable or just. Subsequently, he fully understood the conditions and treatment of Indigenous people in Canada and did not do anything to help them; “Trudeau understood fully the conditions in which many Indigenous Peoples lived in 1969.

Read More
1063 Words | 5 Pages

This statistical information suggests that there are more efforts made to place children of Indian decent with family, as mandated by the ICWA policy. There are multiple reports that state the Act is not being implemented and that the courts and agencies continue to fail at ensuring that the policy is being followed. The 2013 New York Times Article: The Indian Child Welfare Act Provides Necessary Protection, written by Terry Cross states “Yet, despite the law, Indian children continue to be placed outside of Indian homes, even when their families are willing and capable of raising them”. The actual impact of the policy also indicates multiple conflicts related to the lack of placement with individuals of non Indian decent. The 2016 article “American Indian child welfare law under fire, written by Barini Chakraborty, shed light on the backlash of the law.

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

All reserve (crown land) would turn into private property where land tax would have to be paid with the little land all First Nations people are left with. All benefits would be lost that were once promised. Indian affairs would be on its way to extinction within the fiver year period after the legislation would pass. It scared many aboriginal people because of the lack of jobs and discrimination towards Native people. An Interview from Rose Charlie she describes “The discrimination towards my people is so great the only way I could get a job is if I say I am Hawaiian how does the government expect us to assimilate us when we can’t even find jobs, it will not fix anything” (may, 2001).

Read More
1064 Words | 5 Pages

Indian women were more powerful then they appeared to be on the surface. The Indian women had more power within their little community than many European women had. Indian women often owned whatever possessions the family had. “Women had the right to demand a divorce, and in a 180-degree turn from the European system, it was the male who was left without possessions. Rather than being patronized as delicate creatures with limited stamina and intellectual powers and prone to error and emotional bondage as European women were, Indian women were respected for their value to their villages.

Read More
139 Words | 1 Pages

Gender relations in Indian Societies majorly differed from that of those in European Society. In opposition to European societies, where men dominate everything, Indian societies were matrilineal, where children become members of the mother’s family. Women played an important part in religious ceremonies, took part in tribal meetings and helped to select male tribe leaders. In addition all property was owned by women. Women had a lot more freedoms in Indian society.

Read More
1151 Words | 5 Pages

Firstly, the Indian Act did not allow Indigenous peoples to sell their cows or crops without the

Read More
1265 Words | 6 Pages

The aim of this policy in Canada consisted in breaking down discriminatory attitudes of dominant ethnic group toward non-dominant groups. It was supposed to be done by supporting ethnocultural communities in their wish to maintain their heritage cultures and, at the same time, by ensuring full participation in the larger society. The basic idea was that if people from non-dominant ethnic groups coming to, or living in, Canada got an opportunity to maintain links with their culture and simultaneously got an opportunity to participate in a larger society, both dominant and non-dominant groups would be at advantage. In other words, the fundamental goal of the policy implied enhancing mutual acceptance among all ethnocultural groups (Berry,

Read More
3423 Words | 14 Pages

The space called national heroes has traditionally been occupied by men or as Anne Mclintok declares, ‘nationalism is gendered’ (1). Indian women have always been relegated to the private space of home in the process of nation building, throughout the times of the freedom struggle of the country, the era when the notion of India as a nation, germinated in the public sphere. The association of women with the metaphorical label of being the ‘mother’ of the nation exemplifies the degree of involvement allowed as an agent in the workings of Indian society. This trend continues till date. Any exemplary achievement by a woman in India is grounded in traditional markers defining women in relation to men and their label as such in the cultural context.

Read More

More about Review Of Bill C-31: The Act To Amend The Indian Act

Related Topics

Open Document