ipl-logo

Review Of Race, Immigration, And American Gatekeeping, By Erika Lee

645 Words3 Pages

The article that I chose to write an article review on is “The Chinese Exclusion Example: Race, Immigration, and American Gatekeeping, 1882-1924” by Erika Lee. In this article, Lee argues that Chinese exclusion introduced a strict ideology of racialized nationalism, where categorizations of race, class, and traditions classified certain groups of people as being undesirable. She then argues that due to the transformation of the United States' identity as a nation of immigration, Chinese exclusion set into motion strong government intervention in immigration that exists to this day. One piece of evidence she uses to support the first part of her argument is a testimony by H. N. Clement, a San Francisco lawyer who testified at the 1876 hearings about Chinese immigration. Lee writes that Clements utilized a combination of themes of racial difference and national sovereignty to articulate his philosophy: “Citing contemporary treatises on international law, Clement argued that the greatest fundamental right of every nation was self-preservation, and the Chinese immigration question was nothing less than a battle for America's survival and future" (Lee, 2002, pp. 3. 4. Using the XML tool. Through this example, Lee defends her thesis by exemplifying …show more content…

20). Lee utilized this quote to defend the part of her argument where Chinese exclusion transformed the immigration sentiments within the United States. Thus, the United States was forced to enact laws to surveil Chinese immigrants and bar those who were ineligible from coming into the country through laws targeting their nationality that have modernized parallels to this

Show More
Related

Chick Wo Case

211 Words | 1 Pages

Asian Americans were using the judicial system to fight for their rights and have the same rights as a citizen. For example, a very successful case it was the “Yick Wo v. Hopkins” Yick Wo was not an American Citizen he goes to the Supreme Court and argues that the laundry ordinance violated his rights under the fourteen amendments, his right to due process and equal protection, furthermore Yick Wo won the case. This was the first case that the Supreme Court help a Chinese person who was fighting for his rights and did not ruled against him for not being a citizen. A case that was not successful was “United States v. Ju Toy” he was a Chinese man and was born in the U.S Toy went to China and returned to San Francisco but on his return he was

Read More

Examples Of Lee In East Of Eden

1617 Words | 7 Pages

When Samuel Hamilton, a fellow immigrant, suggests that Lee can escape having to hide his intelligence by going to China, Lee reveals, “‘I did go back to China… It didn’t work. They said I looked like a foreign devil; they said I spoke like a foreign devil. I made mistakes in my manners, and I didn’t know delicacies that had grown up… I’m less foreign here than I was in China’” (Steinbeck 123).

Read More

Chinese Exclusion Dbq

235 Words | 1 Pages

Eventually, the United States repealed the Chinese Exclusion Act by President Roosevelt signing the Magnuson Bill in 1943. [1] Though the repeal of the Act ended white American worker and legislator's discrimination of the Chinese it proves that the U.S. was wrong to implement the exclusion. That is because it did not work. In fact, it had a positive impact on the Chinese communities with unity, support, workmen ship, courage, and pride. They became strong-willed and overcame the obstacles of the exclusion law with the paper system and the formation of China town networks.

Read More

How Did White Americans Support The Chinese Exclusion Act Of 1882

872 Words | 4 Pages

“Why did white Americans support the passage of the Chinese Exclusion act of 1882” This act was passed because the immigrating Chinese were finding success and the whites who were in direct economic competition with them were scared to lose their high social presence to someone who they saw as very different to them. My first piece of evidence comes in the form of A political cartoon drawn by Thomas Nast for a northern magazine called Harper's Weekly, in which he displays a representation of America protecting a Chinese man against a mob of distraught German and Irish thugs. One of the signs carried by these thugs had the words “If our ballot will not stop them coming to our country the bullet must” (Thomas Nast) written in bold. From this,

Read More

Uncle Sams Thanksgiving Dinner Analysis

1167 Words | 5 Pages

Although sharing identical titles and depicting presumably interchangeable scenes, Thomas Nast and G.F. Keller’s political cartoons, Uncle Sam’s Thanksgiving Dinner, illustrate the East and West coast’s contradictory opinions toward the prevailing issues of immigration and its relation to their differing views of the immigrants’ social status, specifically in regards to the Chinese. Written four years after the conclusion of the Civil War and heavily published in the prominent political magazine, Harper’s Weekly, Nast’s cartoon portrays a simple binary of race consisting of an in-group and out-group, with the Chinese as members of the out-group, in reality but incorporated into the national body in Nast’s idealistic depiction. In contrast, Keller’s image, published eight years later in

Read More

Caged Birds Chapter Summary

813 Words | 4 Pages

One of this week’s readings focused on Ch. 5, “Caged Birds,” in Professor Lytle Hernandez’s book City of Inmates: Conquest, Rebellion, and the Rise of Human Caging in Los Angeles, 1771-1965, and this chapter was particularly interesting because it further explained the development of immigration control in the United States. As a continuation from the last chapter, there was a huge emphasis in the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and the Geary Act of 1892. This essentially prohibited Chinese laborers from immigrating to the United States, as well as eventually requiring these people to comply with regulations. “Caged Birds” encapsulates the events afterwards, as the book heads well into the early-1900’s. The disenfranchisement of immigrants develops towards further exclusivity because “[by] 1917, Congress had banned all Asian immigration to the Unites States and also categorically prohibited all prostitutes, convicts, anarchists, epileptics, ‘lunatics,’ ‘

Read More

Jason Newman's Essay 'Asian Americans In US History'

302 Words | 2 Pages

Author Jason Newman writes on the history of Asian Americans in the United States in his essay, appropriately titled, “Asian American in U.S. History”. The essay describes the treatment of Asian Americans in the United States, along with the legislation passed against them. To open his essay, Newman writes, “Many Asian Americans have struggled against recurrent stereotypes that cast them as permanent outsiders despite their long history in the United States.” Afterward, Newman describes the early immigration of Asian Americans to the U.S. Specifically, he uses Chinese Americans to illustrate the negative reaction Americans had towards Asian immigration, listing the many laws passed to bar Chinese immigration into America.

Read More

1950s Dbq

1152 Words | 5 Pages

In 1952, some residents of a neighborhood in San Francisco were victorious in keeping the neighborhood 100 percent white. A former Chinese Nationalist was trying to move his family in, but the residents did not want them. One of the many reasons was because of their presence, it would depress property values. However, all of the reasons added up to the fact that the family was Chinese(document 6). An argument is made that whites and minorities did things together.

Read More

Racial Fault Lines Analysis

1871 Words | 8 Pages

Chapter six examines the anti-Chinese sentiment with the emerging class antagonism and turmoil between white capitalists and workers. The unwelcomed arrival of Chinese immigrants brought along their own social organizations such as the huiguan, fongs, and tongs. These types of social organizations secured areas of employment and housing for Chinese immigrants in California. This social structure that was unknown to Anglos led them to also categorize Chinese on the same level as Indians by depicting them as lustful heathens whom were out to taint innocent white women. These images were also perpetuated onto Chinese women, thus, also sexualizing them as all prostitutes.

Read More

Chinese Immigration In The 19th Century

1135 Words | 5 Pages

The fear of Chinese immigrants was not purely due to economic reasons. In reality, Chinese workers and culture were seen as invasive and pervasive with contradictions to American values. Therefore, Chinese workers were not only seen as economic opponents, but as an epidemic that can erode away the very fabric of American society (Ryo

Read More

Stereotypes Of Asian Immigrants

1197 Words | 5 Pages

According to Jeff Guo and Daron Taylor from Washington Post, when Asian immigrants arrived during the mid-1800s, they were met with intolerance as “the popular media often portrayed them as scoundrels, degenerates, and job-stealers.” Additionally, writer Jonathan Freedman pointed out that “the debased and racist attacks on Chinese” had led to the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which was one of the early methods to limit immigration, or specifically Asian immigration. Also, fear of Asian immigrants taking control was a prevalent factor for the Exclusion Act. For example, a literature titled “The Rise of Fu Manchu” depicts of “an Asiatic villian” who plans to take over the world. It wasn’t until after the second World War when Americans opened their arms of acceptance and appreciation towards Asian immigrants.

Read More

Shut The Door Dbq

558 Words | 3 Pages

" This quote gives a deeper explanation of Americanization and demonstrates another thing immigrants went through when they first came to

Read More

Anti Chinese Immigration Dbq

922 Words | 4 Pages

Although the Chinese only took undesirable jobs with low wages that the “whites shunned,” Americans labeled the Chinese as “unfair labor competition” and a threat to their economic stability. Racism and economic hardships due to a loss of jobs, was “a major reason why the dominant white population wanted to exclude” the Chinese. Due to societal pressures and discrimination, Chinese Americans were denied “basic civil rights...equal protection under law...nationalization… [and] immigration to the U.S.,” as their basic liberties were taken away with racism. Although the Chinese Exclusion Act was created to improve economic conditions, it included anti-Chinese sentiments that the Chinese were a threat to white labor and the purity of the white race in America, causing much conflict and violence to occur between white Americans and the Chinese.

Read More

Chinese Exclusion Act Essay Thesis

821 Words | 4 Pages

Thesis: The Chinese Exclusion Act. A document that was first signed in 1882 by President Chester A. Arthur. This was and still is important because it was the first law that restricted immigration into the United States. This document was signed because Congress was concerned about keeping white “racial purity,” even though the Chinese population consisted of only 0.002 (two thousandths) percent of the whole population.

Read More

The Yellow Soil Thesis

728 Words | 3 Pages

The beliefs about allowing immigration in the Unites States are not present. The president's beliefs about the foreign policy and allowing immigrants to have the same opportunities which include jobs, and education are not equal. Chinese immigrants were looked upon by White Americans, as American Indians separated themselves from African Americans. I think this article should explain that everyone is equal and has their own rights to individualism. I think that individualism is important to every citizen and is not shown very much in the

Read More

More about Review Of Race, Immigration, And American Gatekeeping, By Erika Lee

Open Document