ipl-logo

Review: Was The Battle At Vimy Ridge Truly A Turning Point In Canadian History

1550 Words7 Pages

Aiden Jajo
Mr. Kennedy
CHC 2D
May 1, 2015
Vimy Ridge: Was the Battle at Vimy Ridge Truly a Turning Point in Canadian History? Neil Armstrong, an American Astronaut, and first person to land on the moon, once said these notorious words, “This is one small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind.” These words were said as he landed on the moon, and forever changed history. This was a milestone and a turning point in space exploration for both the United States of America, and for Canada as well. Another turning point in Canadian history was the battle of Vimy Ridge. The Battle of Vimy Ridge truly was a turning point in Canadian history for several reasons; Prior to Canada’s attempt, both the French and British attempted to capture Vimy, unfortunately …show more content…

The battle shows Canada's ability to act independently and without Britain’s command. It gave Canadians the chance to been seen as equal to countries like France and Britain. General Arthur Currie was able to outsmart any of the British and French generals plans when he came up with the idea of the creeping barrage. The creeping barrage resulted in a swift capture of Vimy ridge and less deaths than both the British and French failed attempts. “The Canadian achievement in capturing Vimy Ridge owed its success to sound and meticulous planning and thorough preparation, all of which was aimed at minimizing casualties.” (Canada) The biggest achievement in winning the battle at Vimy was that both France and Britain attempted to capture Vimy Ridge and failed. This shows that although we were not seen as equal to those countries, Canada had the ability to accomplish conquests that even the British and French could not. In this battle the Canadians received the recognition we deserved. Furthermore, Canada's victory had minimal help from allied countries; all divisions of the Canadian army joined together and executed their training. This was Canada's first sense of individualism. “The French and British had failed to take Vimy ridge from the Germans and it cost them thousands of lives. The task fell to the Canadian army to take the ridge.” (CBC) The fate of the task fell into …show more content…

Veteran Affairs. “The capture of Vimy Ridge.”
Veteran Affairs. Canada Government, n.d.
Web. 10 Dec. 2008. <www.veterans.gc.ca/eng/rememberance/history/first-world-war/vimyridge>

“Pride at Vimy Ridge.” Le Canada. Canada Broadcasting Corporation, 19 Dec. 2001. November 22. 2014 <www.cbc.ca/history/vimy>

Brewster, Hugh. “At Vimy Ridge, Canada’s greatest WW1 victory.” Toronto: scholastic, 15 Jan. 2006

“Canada Gets a Seat at the Table.” Canada wartime experience 2.4 (7 Mar. 2005) Pg.1
<https://www.umanitoba.ca/canadian_wartime/grade9/students/dafoe_intro.shtml>

Morton, Desmond. “Significance of Vimy Ridge.” Vimy Foundation. Vimy Foundation, 12 Oct. 2011. Web. 26 Nov. 2014 <www.vimyfoundation.ca/signifigance>

Stechyson, Natalie. “Vimy marked Canada’s birth as a nation.” National post. National post, 9 April. 2012 web. 27 Nov. 2014 <http://news.nationalpost.com/2012/04/09/vimy-ridge-marked-canadas-birth-as-a-nation-g-g-says-on-95th-aniversary-of-battle/ >

Kennedy, Mr. “Vimy Ridge.” Vimy Ridge 1917: Birth of a Nation. (pg.3)

“Significance of Vimy.” Battle of Vimy Ridge. Canada at war, 3 Sept. 2007. Web. Nov 30. 2014

Show More
Related

Battle Of Vimy Ridge: Source Analysis

656 Words | 3 Pages

Source III portrays that Canadian nationalism was created by the victory of the Battle of Vimy Ridge and how the battle unified and strengthened Canada as a nation. The source embraces civic nationalism and illustrates how a strong sense of patriotism for one’s country can be founded and can further inspire and establish nationalism. For example, the Canadian soldiers that fought at Vimy Ridge were patriotic and fought for Canada, and the results and rewards of the battle were significant to the war. At the time, German leaders and soldiers that fought at Vimy Ridge would disagree with the source, as they believed the Battle of Vimy Ridge did not considerably influence the outcome of the war. They would argue that although the location and

Read More

Vimy Ridge Research Paper

498 Words | 2 Pages

Vimy Ridge was one of the greatest battles of Canadian history, it was part of the opening phase of the British-led Battle of Arras, a diversionary assault for the French Nivelle Offensive. This essay will describe the success of the Canadian troops, the battle’s significance, and the importance of the positioning with respect to the geography of the land. The actual battle took place 5:30 am Easter Monday April 9th 1917, but the planning of the attack took place for more than 5 months beforehand starting in November of 1916. Rehearsals and training also occurred, and the soldiers were trained specifically for each position in the war.

Read More

How Did The Treaty Of Versailles Affect Canada

548 Words | 3 Pages

This essay will talk about the negative and positive effects of the treaty on Canada. Canada's military underwent massive changes not only after but before the treaty as well. One of the most notable changes was the Canadian military’s shift towards an independent military stance. Evidence of this can be seen in world war I with Canada's contributions to the war effort during the war. Both the battle of the Somme and Vimy ridge were great examples of this.

Read More

How Did The Battle Of Vimy Ridge Promote Canadian Nationalism

818 Words | 4 Pages

Over a four month period, both sides suffered huge losses, including almost 25,000 Canadians. The Battle of Vimy Ridge also played a very important role in generating Canadian nationalism. Vimy Ridge is a seven-kilometre ridge of land in northern France. In 1917, the Canadian Corps was ordered to capture this ridge. When the battle began, thousands of Canadians came out of the trenches and advanced towards the German line.

Read More

Vimy Ridge Research Paper

512 Words | 3 Pages

Historian Desmond Morton stated “By 1918, the British retained little more than tactical command of the Canadian units in France... In military terms, if not yet constitutional law, the war transformed Canada from a colony into a junior but

Read More

Why Is The Battle Of Vimy Ridge Important For Canada

573 Words | 3 Pages

Many Historians believed that the victory of Vimy Ridge was a memorable and unreal moment for Canadians. At that time, Canada was known to be a part of the British Empire. This meant that if Britain was to go to war, then Canada would automatically have to go to war as well.1 The Battle took place on April 9, 1917 and it was a huge victory for the Canadians.2 The significance of the battle of Vimy Ridge to Canadian history was that Canada became famous for its heroic soldiers, its large sacrifice and it was the birth of Canadian patriotism.3 To begin, the battle of Vimy Ridge was not just considered to be the greatest achievement for Canadians, but it became famous for the clever tactics which the Canadian troops used during the war.4 To start off with, The Battle of Vimy Ridge was the first battle in which Canadians from all over the land fought as a united team.5 This gave them an advantage and brought them much success during the war because they outnumbered the Germans.6 This is witnessed when Brigadier General A.E.Ross announced, "In those few minutes I witnessed the birth of a nation.

Read More

How Did The Battle Of Vimy Ridge Affect My Community

762 Words | 4 Pages

The Battle of Vimy Ridge and Its Impact on My Community In April 1917 – at the height of the First World War – the Canadian Corps captured the coveted Vimy Ridge from the Germans. It was a battle that shaped Canada’s historical identity but resulted in over ten thousand casualties. Young men from Canadian cities and towns like Oshawa, Ontario were killed in action or died of wounds. Roads were built, schools were named, and monuments were erected in their honour.

Read More

Why Is Vimy Ridge Important

1218 Words | 5 Pages

Vimy Ridge would go in the history books as one of the most important battles in Canadian History. The tactics, the platoons and the strategies would determine the failure or accomplishment of this

Read More

Canadian Victory At Vimy Analysis

672 Words | 3 Pages

Many historians and writers consider the Canadian victory at Vimy a defining moment for Canada, when the country emerged from under the shadow of Britain and felt capable of greatness. Canadian troops also earned a reputation as formidable, effective troops because of the stunning success. But it was a victory at a terrible cost, with more than 10,000 killed and wounded. The Canadian Corps was ordered to seize Vimy Ridge in April 1917.

Read More

How Did World War 1 Affect Canada

1266 Words | 6 Pages

All of these battles were greatly impacted by the Canadians and without some of them (Vimy Ridge in particular) Canada may not have gained any respect from other

Read More

Arguments In Support Of Participation During World War I

355 Words | 2 Pages

Body: 1st argument in support of position, examples and/or evidence Canadian citizens eagerly volunteered to participate in World War 1. 33,000 men volunteered for the military near Quebec and the Canadian Patriotic Fund launched a fund to support soldier’s families. Despite the soldiers being inexperienced and insufficient for the dangerous Western Front of World War 1. 2nd argument in support of position, examples and/or evidence Despite the poison gas and the disintegration of the allied Franco-Berber troops, the Canadians managed to launch a counterattack on the advancing German troops during the Second Battle of Ypres. The Canadians and Germans fought to the death until the Battle of Frezenburg and Bellewaardre, where the Princess Patricia’s Canadian Light Infantry successfully thwarted the final German advance in Ypres.

Read More

The Battle At Vimy Ridge

214 Words | 1 Pages

The battle at Vimy Ridge was a defining moment in Canadian History because it gave Canada a sense of nationhood “The Battle of Vimy Ridge marked ‘the birth of a nation’ for Canada, says Governor-General David Johnston” (Postmedia news). It was the first time all four Canadian Corps fought together in the history of the war. The victory of ‘taking Vimy Ridge’ was celebrated, and two months later Viscount Julian Byng was promoted out of the Corps and Arthur Currie became the first commander of the Corps. The 60’000 casualties in the war, made Vimy the most symbolic of Canada’s overall sacrifices. This pushed Prime Minister Borden to ensure a separate representation at the Paris Peace Talks after the war.

Read More

Canada's Level Of Unity In 1918

1095 Words | 5 Pages

Canadians became an independent nation in 1918; however, they were not much more united than they were in 1914. One of the events that brought Canadians together was the battle at Vimy Ridge. Vimy Ridge was a piece of land covered in trenches and machine guns, which were occupied by the Germans. Canadians soldiers went under special training weeks before

Read More

Essay On Canada In The 20th Century

783 Words | 4 Pages

Canada wanted to be recognized for their war efforts, and they opposed to further fight without representing their own country, indicating that they could be independent, a step towards developing their constitution. Next, the notable war records and successes in battles such as Vimy Ridge won them recognition on the Treaty of Versailles. Prime Minister Robert Borden, in the Liberal-Conservative Handbook , ‘Equal status or Equality of Nationhood', stated, "The highest future for this Dominion lies within this Empire upon conditions of equal status." This statement by Borden foreshadowed Canada’s important role in the Paris Peace Conference and the eventual signing of the Treaty of Versailles. This was a significant milestone in Canada’s history and the signing showed the world that Canada is a new independent nation that can support and represent

Read More

Role Of War In Canada

963 Words | 4 Pages

During WWII, Canada played a crucial role in the Battle of the Atlantic and the air war over Germany. They contributed troops to the allied forces and punched far above their weight for a small nation of then only 11 million people. Because of Canada’s oversized role in the War, it established itself as a middle power. This position helped define Canada in a number of ways, primarily being one of the first non-great powers to help build the United Nations. It earned respect from other countries and with The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO).

Read More

More about Review: Was The Battle At Vimy Ridge Truly A Turning Point In Canadian History

Related Topics

Open Document