ipl-logo

Rhetorical Analysis Of Being Fat Is Ok By Paul Campos

959 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The Politics of Obesity in America Essay

Take Off of The Obesity Crisis Being overweight has been a concern of the US government and citizens for a while now. Many people have been debating about how the obesity crisis has been affecting people and businesses. Who's fault is it and how can we solve the problem are questions often asked by concerned citizens, the government and most importantly overweight people. If these groups can figure out how to solve the overweight crisis we are having, it could ultimately save lives. In his article “Being Fat is Ok” Paul Campos, a law professor at the University of Colorado, talks about how he believes the BMI and the diet industry, are both just scams to make the government and diet industries money. He argues his opinion of the lies that …show more content…

In an article published by the Harvard School of Public Health, the authors claim that muscle and bone are more dense than fat, this makes weight gain as an adult an important determinant of weight-related health—few adults add muscle and bone after their early twenties, so nearly all that added weight is fat (HSPH). Now Campos proclaims he runs quite a bit and is great physical health, but he is an adult and some of his weight may not be muscle. The BMI is not a great determining factor in trying to see if you are overweight or not, although it does give you a good idea of where you are at. Therefore, he may think his BMI is unreasonable but it may be completely …show more content…

The first lie is "We know that fat people are less healthy than thin people because they are fat." Campos declares that there is no solid scientific bases around this claim and that no studies show that being over-weight and having health issues correspond. He also argues that obesity is a made up disease and has no connection to health issues. But being overweight has been linked to type 2 diabetes, heart disease, stroke and many more diseases. The second lie is "We know that fat people would be as healthy as thin people if they lost weight." Campos argues that one cannot know whether losing weight will help or hurt a person, and one person could be at an increased health risk then someone who is the same weight just because they dropped weight. We can not say they will be as healthy as thin people depending on any health problems they got while overweight. But, they will be much healthier then overweight people and how they were before. The last lie is "Fat people can choose to be thinner." Campos shows that diets often end in failure, as his statistics show 90-98% of people on diets do not succeed. Campos also points out that people who were on diets end up weighing more then their comparable groups that never started dieting. The main reason people on diets do not succeed is because they believe just eating or not eating certain things, or taking a pill is

Show More
Related
1506 Words | 7 Pages

Fat Land Book Review Every new year brings with it a host of new pressing issues and challenges that our nation must confront and overcome, and though economic and global concerns certainly deserve a large part of our attention, as a nation we have almost entirely forgotten or ignored many problems that have been plaguing us for decades. Chiefly among these concerns is the ever growing obesity epidemic, which has seen a dramatic increase over the past several decades and looks to be continuing its trend into our near future. In his book, Fat Land: How Americans Became the Fattest People in the World, Greg Critser delves into many of the significant causes behind this staggering increase in girth our nation has been experiencing, and offers

Read More
334 Words | 2 Pages

In the article “The Fat Tax,” Jonathan Rauch ironically discusses the new public policy concern with obesity. Although the article is a satire, it’s economic analysis is actually valid. In order to get his point across, Rauch uses sarcasm, appeals to logos, and degrades the issue of obesity to help Americans better understand the “big picture.” Moreover, if the diet of American consumers does not change then maybe advertising more exercise to lose weight will cut down the obesity rate; but to be just as effective, enacting the fat tax will improve health as well.

Read More
1008 Words | 5 Pages

In his article Are You Responsible For Your Own Weight?, policy analyst Radley Balko argues that the Government has no business interfering with what individuals eat. Kelly Brownell, a Yale Chairman, and Marion Nestle a New York University professor state otherwise by arguing that the Government should intervene to create conditions that lead to healthy eating. Balko has a strong argument led with in depth examples, logical support, and credentials to support his tone along with minor fallacies. Kelly Brownell and Marion Nestle fail to go more in depth about her argument, but rely heavily on trying to counter the claims given by the opposing side. The lack of rhetorical devices in her article and inadequate organization weakens her tone as well as the appeal to their audience.

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

The documentary “Supersize Me” is illustrated by the results of medical assistance and analysis done by professional doctors. Spurlock visits several doctors that will help him maintain healthy and on task during the produce of the challenge he is taking on, he gets his cholesterol checked, as well as his weight, blood pressure, sugar, liver function and the fat he has throughout his body. The tests and analysis done kept worsening more and more as time proceeded. It resulted that throughout the thirty day experiment of eating nothing but mcdonald's meals he gained twenty-four and a half pounds. This documentary is fulfilled with logic, from the increasement of his weight and the worsening of his health to the amount of money people spend daily on junk food from different fast food restaurants.

Read More
677 Words | 3 Pages

In the first article “Resisting the Moralization of Eating”, by Mary Maxfeild she ¬argues many things against the other author Michael Pollan about how we need to change how the American people eat, and how the government needs to handle obesity better in the United States. This portrays to the other article “Escape from the Western Diet” by Michael Pollan in many ways, as well as many challenges. “The challenge we face today is figuring out how to escape the worst elements of the Western diet and lifestyle without going back to the bush” (Pollan 437). In this paper I will go over many subtopics including: Obesity, health, and food.

Read More
1020 Words | 5 Pages

Junk food is responsible for the growing rate of obesity. This is outlined by David freedman in his article of “How junk food can end obesity.” David Freedman has credited the “health-food” motion, and followers of it along with Michel Pollan. Freedman claims that if the America desires to stop the obesity epidemic, or at least reduce its effects, they must shift to the fast meals and processed meals enterprise for assist, now not the “health-food” movement.

Read More
1089 Words | 5 Pages

Put Down That Cheeseburger! “What incentive is there for me to put down the cheeseburger?” asks Radley Balko in his article "What You Eat Is Your Business." He argues that, obesity does not belong in the public health crisis. He claims that obesity is not a problem that should be dealt at the cost of public money but should be dealt at a personal level by every individual.

Read More
1610 Words | 7 Pages

In “What You Eat Is Your Business,” Radley Balko tackles the issue of who is responsible for fighting obesity. Balko argues that the controversy of obesity should make the individual consumers culpable for their own health and not the government (467). As health insurers refrain from increasing premiums for obese and overweight patients, there is a decrease in motivation to keep a healthy lifestyle (Balko 467). As a result, Balko claims these manipulations make the public accountable for everyone else 's health rather than their own (467). Balko continues to discuss the ways to fix the issue such as insurance companies penalizing consumers who make unhealthy food choices and rewarding good ones (468).

Read More
644 Words | 3 Pages

Milca Jara Professor Katz ENC1102 17 February 2016 Slowly Dying “ Today more than a third of U.S adults are obese” (Majerol). This portrays that America is not taking responsibility of its nation, by creating a safer food industry and rising labels of MSG for its buyers in order to properly educate them in what they are buying for themselves, and their families.

Read More
990 Words | 4 Pages

America is one of the most obese countries in the world, known for apple pie and an excessive amount of McDonald’s. As a culture, there is a lack of self control when it comes to the foods we consume. People often over consume and over indulge, which has wreaked havoc on the health and well being of those who give in to these temptations. The issue is that large corporations and even our own government play a role in helping feed the problem; they care more about profitability and benefiting the business than the health of the consumer. The health of Americans is declining and more chronic diseases and health problems are appearing as a result of unhealthy diets, but there are many different methods that can help fix this issue.

Read More
656 Words | 3 Pages

Americans today are well-known for their eating habits. With all the options the food industry gives us it makes it hard to go to the grocery store and resist picking up that bag of barbeque-flavored chips or blueberry flavored candy. Due to these processed foods obesity is a growing epidemic in our country and who is to blame for it? In an article entitled “What You Eat is Your Business” by Radley Balko, Balko argues for less government intervention. Balko believes is it our responsibility to take care of ourselves and make it a priority.

Read More
1133 Words | 5 Pages

The Health at Every Size (HAES) movement has become a popular alternative to the dominant scientific discourse on obesity, particularly among fat activists and the fat acceptance movement as well as some nutritionists eager to avoid an over-emphasis on body weight in their work with clients. First developed by American psychotherapist and nutritionist Linda Bacon (2010), the main argument of HAES is that good health and physical fitness can be achieved regardless of body size. As such, the approach agrees with the assertions made by many other obesity sceptics that fatness does not necessarily cause ill-health and premature mortality and that losing weight may not improve health status (see here for my previous post on the contentions of obesity

Read More
1518 Words | 7 Pages

Obesity is a major problem in the United States, and with all the special privileges given to its people, America has become very lazy. With portion sizes rising and physical activity decreasing, it is easy to see how the rates on obesity has risen over the years in America. Obesity is a major problem that needs to be resolved because it affects all people of every gender, age, and race are at risk of being obese. Obesity rates in America have nearly doubled rather tripled within the last twenty years due to the many privileges that the American people have before us. Something must be done to overcome decrease the

Read More
1029 Words | 5 Pages

As a hole there should be more restaurants that promote healthy food choices. Obesity in the United States is out of proportion and something need to be don , not necessarily at the point of government intersection but this needs to be fix some way somehow. ”public health experts say that an unhealthy diet and the lack of exercise are still the two biggest culprits. ”-Felix gusson.

Read More
2068 Words | 9 Pages

(Dray, Sarah.) Most suppose that by going on diets, losing weight, and going back to their original eating habits is acceptable. These actions are simply making matters worse for them. “People who diet gain more weight than those who skip the diet route altogether (Dr. Axe.) ”

Read More

More about Rhetorical Analysis Of Being Fat Is Ok By Paul Campos

Related Topics

Open Document