ipl-logo

Rhetorical Analysis Of Violent Media Is Good For Kids By Gerard Jones

965 Words4 Pages

Since the conception of violent media in the 90’s parents have been particularly wary of kids being exposed. Gerard Jones’ “Violent Media Is Good For Kids” offers a rebuttal to the stigma. He starts out the article with an anecdote of his life and how comic books allowed him to embrace his fears and lead him away from bad crowds, and ultimately landed him a career as a comic writer. He argues the idea of violent video games allowing kids to embrace their fears by making them face them and not to run away from them. This analysis will deconstruct the article and identify the thesis, the rhetorical situation and the appeals that the writer uses. To analyze this piece we should look at the title of the piece: “Violent media is good for kids”. This headline catches the eye because it gives an unexpected answer to something people have heard for many decades now. Most articles that talk about violent media are usually against them and have a way to persuade the audience in why they shouldn’t expose their kids to video games like Call of Duty or Halo. However in this article, just by looking at the title the …show more content…

While Jones uses a lot of anecdotes and gives the audience good points towards his thesis, His appeals are riding on the audience’s emotions and does not give enough reason to the effects of violent media on the psychology of the kids consuming it. He definitely talks to a psychologist about it, but that is one person saying that it is good compared to the many who are saying it is bad. It is just not enough to sway the audience into letting them let their kids consume violent media. Violent Media is still an important topic to this very day, especially with the amount school shooting that have occurred since the Columbine Shooting. This topic will keep coming up when dealing with these types of problems and is something everyone should keep in their minds when talking about

Show More
Related
230 Words | 1 Pages

In his essay, “A Pedagogical Response to The Aurora Shootings” (235) Henry Jenkins analyzes shocking events involving public shootings in society. His main objective is to discuss why violence is a prominent factor in our popular culture and how the media inflames the issue. Jenkins does pose his belief that violence should be critically debated in order to research the main cause of violence within people. He also states that people must step out of the “media effects” assumption of violence and expands the scale to the meaning of what violence represents in movies and books. Jenkin states, “To be extra clear, I do not think media is where this debate should be focused” (236).

Read More
200 Words | 1 Pages

All children are different so it is the parent’s responsibility to determine whether or not their children can handle the different media. Some media critics believe that violent cartoons, video games, movies etc. are good for children. Gerard Jones gives an example in his essay “Violent media is good for kids” which he explains how violent media can be good for children, Jones explains his point by giving an example of his son. Jones tells how he exposed his son to marvel comics which helped him in his kindergarten experience. The marvel characters gave Jones’s son the desire of “transforming himself into a bloodthirsty dinosaur to embolden himself for the plunge into preschool” (373).

Read More
384 Words | 2 Pages

In the passage “Violent Media Is Good For Kids” written by Gerard Jones, Jones claims that violence through comics, toys, and the media helps kids to cope with everyday issues. The reason Jones feels this way is because as a child he was taught that violence was ba,d and he did not have a very good experience with coping with his fears. Jones argues that the Hulk helped him through tough times, that his own son using characters to overcome obstacles, and how violence can avoid some negative feelings. In the beginning of the passage, Jones talks about how he was told to stay away from violence as a child, which at first did not help him till he met the hulk.

Read More
367 Words | 2 Pages

In Gerard Jones’ essay “Violent Media is Food for Kids,” he forces the reader to decide whether the argument that there is a direct correlation between violent media and violent children is valid, or if that by denying children the freedom to experience violence through media, society is harming a very important foundation of finding one’s self. I find it similar to the Jude Priest case because two parents banded together to sue a band for allegedly putting subliminal messages in their heavy metal music that caused their sons to commit suicide. While most of the expert witness concluded that there was not enough scientific research to prove that subliminal messages can truly influence someone, nor can Vance or Belknap could really be considered

Read More
247 Words | 1 Pages

Mother Jones is a reader-supported nonprofit investigative news organization, reporting on everything from politics and climate change to education and food. Violent Media is a recurring topic nowadays in the United States, as well as around the World, and the influence it may had on cruel events; specifically the culprits of these atrocities. Gerard Jones unsuccessfully delivers the message of “Violent Media is Good for Kids” with the usage of Pathos and Kairos, lack of Ethos, and inadequacy of the opposing views; promoting a biased article The article “Violent Media is Good for Kids” written by Gerard Jones, from my point of view it seems to be a written opinion rather than an informational paper.

Read More
946 Words | 4 Pages

However because of his studies and research he found out that most parents are apathetic to the fact that their children’s social skills have decreased by 40% as well. Gerard Jones knew this would happen through his logical reasoning’s, or past experience and common sense, and began to advocate for violent media. According to Melanie Moore Ph. D., “Children need violent entertainment in order to inescapable feelings…” Children need to be exposed to violence in order to express their feeling to others

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Sternheimer begins with introducing us to a “first person shooter” game called “Doom”(214). With this multi-billion dollar game industry rising, she points out that there are three school shooting cases that the press emphasizes the shooters being “video-game experts” (215) to the game Doom, only making the “critics’ predictions” (214) about video games come true. Sternheimer begins by explaining how video game violence has become “folk devils” (214). This term allows media and politicians to “channel the blame and fear to remedy what many believe to be a growing problem” (214). Politicians are one of the main factors in targeting video games as the leading cause of violent behavior in teens, according to Sternheimer.

Read More
514 Words | 3 Pages

Rhetorical Reflection These five articles all deal with the controversial topic relating movie violence and violent attacks in real life. A majority of the articles do find a correlation between the two forms of violence. However, some conclude that media violence can attribute to real violence it is not the only variable causing the aggression.

Read More
3056 Words | 13 Pages

There is a reason adolescents today play violent, bloody video games. It is for this same reason that we go to see “jump-scare” films, or adult thrillers. There is something deeply mysterious and moving in the darkness of the human soul. Not just the physical damage we can induce, not just the blood we may pour, but the psychological terrors of our subconscious. It is within these shadows that we lurch in mad voyeurism to watch the unwatchable and, for a while, feed the monsters inside us all.

Read More
1097 Words | 5 Pages

Teenagers are exposed to violence through the internet regularly, and it also prepares teenagers to read Night. Of adolescents ages twelve to seventeen, 97% have played video games, and studies show 90% of video games rated for children ages 10 and up contain violence and other harsh themes. Although many parents control their child’s exposure to violence, many still view it through the internet and in the news, as many significant acts of violence occur weekly. As a majority of teenagers are aware of violence, seeing or reading it does not come as a large surprise as they are able to understand Although many believe it is too violent for adolescents to read, Elie Weisel avoids that

Read More
1861 Words | 8 Pages

Analysis of Gerard Jones’ “Violent Media is Good for Kids” In the article called “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” by Gerard Jones, a renowned comic- book author, is arguing that violent media can be helpful for children, rather than be overly harmful. Parents aren’t taking the time to really look at how helpful violent content could possibly be for their child. Yet, violence can help children learn how to reach for their own inner power that they may have never been able to find before. Furthermore, children as they grow up may even go towards violence that presents justice, rather than the negative types of violence.

Read More
1735 Words | 7 Pages

Violent video games have been relevant in society for decades now, every year the question is raised that if violent video games are to blame for all the criminal behavior in modern day society. Many factors go into whether violent video games can really be made up to be a scapegoat for criminal behavior becoming more abundant in today's society but research from many sources has come to shed light on the matter and make sense of it all. The reasoning and deducing for thinking such negative effects can be inhibited on people is because everyone perceives violent video games differently and perspective comes in to play whether it's thinking violent video games are harmless or the thought that violent video games are corrupting modern day society and

Read More
1490 Words | 6 Pages

Media violence has become a controversial topic in the world today. Owing to the rising technology, children are beginning to show increasing violent behaviors. The debates on the effects of media ranging from screen media, video games, and books have a long history. Due to this, there is a speculation over what is the leading cause of the increasing violence in children. Some people argue that there is a relationship between media violence and real-life violence.

Read More
1431 Words | 6 Pages

William Belson (1980) found the link between violence and television after doing a research with 1565 teenage boys in London. They were interviewed about their watching habits over ten years. The study revealed that a child saw someone being shot or killed on television is likely to be less caring, and sensitive towards other people. The more violent television programs these teenagers watched, the higher rate of aggression they would be affected (Adian

Read More
983 Words | 4 Pages

A recent content analysis by the research organization Children Now shows that a majority of video games include violence and about half of the violent incidents would result in serious injuries or death in the "real" world. Claim1 Research involving British primary schoolchildren found that the length of time young people spend playing games, rather than their content, could have an effect on their behavior or school performance. But it concluded that fears that generations of young people are growing up with their development impaired by exposure to violent video games are no more likely to be borne out than previous “moral panics” over television and other media. Playing one-player games is not always negative if you do it moderately.

Read More

More about Rhetorical Analysis Of Violent Media Is Good For Kids By Gerard Jones

Related Topics

Open Document