ipl-logo

Rum Sodomy And The Lash Chapter Summary

1651 Words7 Pages

Rum, Sodomy and the Lash by Hans Turley explores the intersectionality of masculinity, sexuality and identity within the British Royal Navy from 1660 to 1820s. The book sought to explore the connections between sexuality, gender and authority within the historical context of this period. It utilized several pieces of work, including diaries, letters, and popular literature during this time. Further, Turley’s work explores how these cultural forces that shaped sexuality and masculinity throughout the eighteenth century have continued to shape ideas about gender and sexuality following this era and even into society as we now know it. For example, Turley sought to explain that culture within piracy contained hypermasculine ideas which were built …show more content…

In 1757, a sailor who was convicted of sexually assaulting a young male received a beating of 500 lashes, while in 1762, two men received 1000 lashes each for engaging in consensual sex, and in 1806, there were more hangings in England for sodomy than there were for murder offences. Chapter 3 of Rum, Sodomy and the Lash stresses the differences between a pirate’s trial versus a sodomist’s trial in court. Turley explains that pirates are economic criminals, and their crimes directly threaten property. At the same time, sodomites do not put the public in danger but rather challenge the separation between males and females and are no longer a part of the domestic economy and are instead a threat to society’s economic order. It is evident that sodomy was viewed as the worst offence and did not protect the public from real, dangerous …show more content…

Turley explains, “heterosexual desire occupies a dominant place in an emergent middle-class society. This is a society that classifies men and women into separate and interlocking spheres of economic subjectivity”. Moreover, the anonymous author of the work titled Plain Reasons for the Growth of Sodomy explained that men who engage in sodomy could not separate their sexual identity through this “non-human action, and asks the question, “Since he does not act like a man, and he is not a woman, how can he be human?... to the author of Plain Reasons, the sodomite is closer to an “Ape” or a

Show More
Related
217 Words | 1 Pages

The essay In Lieu of Prison, Bring Back the Lash by Peter Moskos he urges the reader to consider the lashing of another individual instead of prison time. In the essay it is suggested to bring the whipping post back to the American system of criminal justice. The reason America's prison problem in which over 2.3 million people are incarcerated. We have more prisoners than soldiers.

Read More
158 Words | 1 Pages

Anything stolen that was valued at more than 5 pence would result in being hung (Elizabethan Crime). Public intoxication, sleeping with anyone but

Read More
1808 Words | 8 Pages

Although British officials consistently widened the definition of piracy, they failed to clearly differentiate the significance between a volunteer and a forced sailor on board a pirate ship. Therefore, nothing contributed to the unpredictability of the later trial proceedings as much as the inconsistency of pirate designations. If seventeenth century piracy trials hinged on the question of violating commissions, those after 1715 rested on determining the accused’s voluntary participation. The court’s determination of a sailor’s status was frequently random and wildly erratic. Worse yet, some justices made no effort to determine the active participation of individuals aboard pirate vessels, leading to instances of brutal rulings even by seventeenth

Read More
480 Words | 2 Pages

Jacoby starts off informing the reader about different scenarios on how the Boston Puritan forefathers went about flogging. For example, he states that in 1632, Richard Hopkins was sentenced to be “whipt, branded with a hott iron on one of his cheeks” (196). However, in modern society this method is not humane, therefore, “ lock them up in cages” (197). Locking inmates in cages is a “sign of manhood, a status symbol” (197). According to Jacoby flogging is cheaper due to the excessive amount of money each inmate cost.

Read More
502 Words | 3 Pages

In Jeff Jacoby’s “Bring Back Flogging,” he compares the punishments for crimes in the 17th Century to the punishments for crimes in the present. Jacoby suggests in his essay that “the Puritans were more enlightened than we think, at least on the subject of punishment. Their sanctions were humiliating and painful, but quick and cheap.” Jacoby makes a good argument to bring back an old punishment policy. He points out that “a humiliating and painful paddling can be applied to the rear end of a crook for a lot less than $30,000 (per year).”

Read More
1159 Words | 5 Pages

A House in Gross Disorder, by Cynthia Herrup, provides a relatively holistic account of the trial and crimes committed by Mervin Touchet, the second Earl of Castlehaven. The trial takes place in 1631, and in that same year he is found guilty of rape, and sodomy, and sentenced to death by the guillotine. Herrup does not write the account in order to prove guilt or innocence, as she is aware that its impossible to conclude one or the other. Rather she focuses on the societal, cultural, and political factors surrounding the case, and this in turn sheds light on the role that patriarchy, order, and reputation played in the 17th century of England in terms of law and order. The case of Castlehaven was significant and unique for a number of reasons: He was a landowning nobleman, he was Catholic and had ties to Ireland, he was accused by his son and his wife of gross and irrefutable offences, and the case against him set a precedence for the future.

Read More
1543 Words | 7 Pages

In Marcus Rediker’s Villains of All Nations, pirates Mary Read and Anne Bonny are represented as being vulnerable, emotional, extraordinary women. Both being born illegitimate children, Rediker poses an understanding, empathetic treatment of these women, despite their representation of ‘liberty’ emanating from the brutality of piracy. The constant referral to Read and Bonny as female pirates indiscreetly implies that Rediker interprets their participation in piracy as delicate, which is unjust. Females and delicateness were a dominant association in the 18th century. Rather than referring to the two women simply as pirates, Rediker uses the phrase female pirates to imply that their participation on ship was neither masculine nor violent.

Read More
545 Words | 3 Pages

Jeff Jacoby provides a strong argument in “Bring Back Flogging”, suggesting that we should adopt a few of the punishments of the Puritans. This argument is built on logical appeal, emotional appeal, and his own personal credibility as a writer. Providing statistics and information, Jacoby creates the logos, or logical appeal, and ethos, or personal credibility. In Addition, he uses ethos, or emotional appeal to force the reader to think about what they believe is morally worse. In “Bring Back Flogging”, Jacoby says Puritan forefathers punished crimes with flogging, including whipping and branding; however, in current times we tend to put a person in jail, no matter the crime.

Read More
1044 Words | 5 Pages

This author brings into light the observation of nonheteronormative sexual behaviors amongst different kinds of animals. Johnson explains how before this published work, it was assumed that every animal only expressed heterosexual behavior because it was much easier to do. He expresses his own personal experience of this idea as well, “it was easy to assume I was straight too; I did so for the first eighteen years of my life” (582). Johnson includes himself in his essay to break this idea of what is natural and what is unnatural, because so far as one can see everything is changing and new things are always being discovered.

Read More
1004 Words | 5 Pages

Additionally, in both time periods, a majority of cases are never reported to the police. Out of 1000 cases , only 310 are reported and I would assume a similar percentage was true in the 18th century, due to reasons regarding purity and marriage mentioned

Read More
614 Words | 3 Pages

Fornication, in particular, was a familiar problem. The punishment for fornication was a fine of ten pounds or a public whipping – and applied equally to both parties,” (Sommer 2). Another crime that had an unfitting punishment was adultery. Its punishment was to wear a big scarlet “A” on their chest for the rest of their lives or even death in some cases (Puritan Life 2). All in all, Puritan Law gave people more ways to justify abuse of others than it gave people protection from abuse of others.

Read More
569 Words | 3 Pages

In the reading by Peter Redman, he raises the argument that the ‘AIDS carrier” becomes the central representation of the HIV epidemic and how the representations of HIV cannot be narrowed down to one cause. In addition, the ‘AIDS carrier’ is represented as monster and the carrier spreads HIV from the deviant subpopulations to the mainstream. Also, AIDS has been connected to social and moral issues and singles out groups like gay men, black people, and young single women. These groups are then viewed as diseased subpopulations and that causes others to feel disgust and panic. The heterosexual men are then afraid to have physical or emotional contact with men in general and that’s why boundaries of heterosexual masculinity were produced.

Read More
591 Words | 3 Pages

Stephanie Camberos Mrs. Ybarra Phil 1C 21 October 2016 Unnatural by society or Nature? Being in favor of homosexuality, John Corvino brings up several arguments and counter arguments as to why homosexual sex is deemed as unnatural in our society. Is it unnatural because majority of society chooses to portray it in such a way or is it unnatural for nature related reasons? John Corvino in this reading discussed both sides when viewing homosexual sex as “unnatural”.

Read More
879 Words | 4 Pages

While we prefer life in jail, they preferred death. To conclude, a significant extent of the nature of crime and punishment changed between social classes and over the years since the Medieval Period. This is seen through the significant groups that were involved in medieval crime and punishment, the effects of a person’s social class on crime and punishment, the sort of crime each punishment was used for and the difference between crime and punishments between the Medieval Period and today. The Medieval Period lasted from 476 CE to 1453 CE, with different punishments for each crime committed by different social

Read More
642 Words | 3 Pages

ESSAY 2 During the Colonial period it was believed that crime was a sinful act that occurred because of the combination of inherent human weakness and the strong influences of the devil. Thus, the church was a key player in determining the rigid standards of crime and punishment in society with the goal of keeping social order for the survival of the colony. Punishments were severe and public to amplify deterrence, including banishment for minor crimes such as heresy and death for being an unruly child. Similarly, during the Jacksonian period crime was viewed as a somewhat contagious “moral disease” that needed to be both cured through hard labor and contained through isolation to avoid the corruption of others. This increased reliance on

Read More

More about Rum Sodomy And The Lash Chapter Summary

Open Document