ipl-logo

Secondary Source Evaluation Assignment: Frankenstein And The State Of Nature

1683 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Frankenstein textual analysis essay commentary

Secondary Source Evaluation Assignment: Frankenstein and the State of Nature Ethos: Professor Sir Jonathan Bate is an accomplished academic who has made significant contributions to literary scholarship and education. He holds the Foundation Professor of Environmental Humanities position at Arizona State University (Bate 1). Professor Sir Jonathan Bate possesses the position of Senior Fellow in Research at Worcester College, Oxford University, and Trustee of The Hawthornden Foundation, in addition to his position as Foundation Professor of Environmental Humanities at Arizona State University. Previously operating as the Provost of Worcester College, Gresham Professor of Rhetoric in London, and Professor of Shakespeare and Renaissance Literature …show more content…

I agree that Shelley's work presents a nuanced perspective on the relationship between science and nature. Like the author, I believe that Frankenstein challenges the idea of a clear dichotomy (division) between the enlightened pursuit of scientific knowledge and the natural world. In the novel, Victor Frankenstein's ambition and unchecked pursuit of scientific knowledge leads to disastrous consequences. However, it is important to note that Shelley does not condemn science itself but rather the irresponsible and unethical use of it. This aligns with the author's argument that science can be a force for good if handled wisely and used with good intentions. Moreover, the article's comparison between Frankenstein and Coleridge's "The Rime of the Ancient Mariner" sheds light on shared themes of science as a threat to nature and the division between the enlightened and nature. This comparison deepens our understanding of Frankenstein and highlights the broader Romantic concerns about the consequences of human interference in the natural …show more content…

It has been shown that she was grappling with significant philosophical and moral questions of her time, exploring the potential benefits and risks of scientific advancement. In terms of Romanticism, the article has highlighted the movement's preoccupation with the relationship between humans and the natural world. It has demonstrated how Frankenstein encapsulates Romantic concerns about the consequences of disrupting the natural order and the potential for reconciliation between the enlightenment brought by science and our innate connections to nature. Lastly, the article has reinforced the value of the novel form in exploring complex ideas and themes. Through its analysis of Frankenstein and its connections to Coleridge's poem, the article exemplifies how the novel can provide a rich and multifaceted exploration of philosophical, social, and moral issues. In conclusion, this article has deepened my appreciation for Frankenstein, Mary Shelley's brilliance as a writer, the principles of Romanticism, and the power of the novel as a literary

Show More
Related
1348 Words | 6 Pages

Frankenstein, Or, the Modern Prometheus: The 1818 Text. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994. Print.   Konnor Fenwick Immoral Justice Period 3 English 12 Honors The justice system presented in

Read More
1007 Words | 5 Pages

Alike Shelley, he cautions his audience about a civilisation which has been corrupted by science and technology – however, while Shelley’s text results from the contradictions in ethics of her context in Romanticism and Rationalism, Scott deduces the late 20th century conundrum of scientific knowledge as a commercial product. Thus, Bladerunner and Shelley’s Frankenstein both result in a discussion of contextual ethical dilemmas involving the exploitation of science for personal

Read More
1424 Words | 6 Pages

The article discusses ways that “Frankenstein” should serve as a lesson and impact the actions of present-day scientists. Van Den Belt focuses on an overarching theme of the novel, which is the possible dangers of scientific exploration. He writes, “The story is commonly taken to imply a dire warning about the dangers of scientific hubris” (Van Den Belt). Victor Frankenstein, the main character of the novel, is an iconic example of a science experiment gone wrong. In many different aspects, the story should be studied by explorers to prevent the repetition of Frankenstein’s errors.

Read More
960 Words | 4 Pages

Society today is greatly affected by science. Cell phones, computers, and social media are just some of the many facets of technology that we use in our everyday lives. To most people, this technology is wonderful, but Mary Shelley provides us with a caveat. In her novel Frankenstein, science and the pursuit of knowledge are recurrent themes. The novel starts off with Walden trying to make a discovery in the North Pole, and follows with a story about how Victor Frankenstein deals with his creation.

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

Kyle Lyon Professor Ed Steck AWR 201 F3 14 April 2015 Annotated Bibliography Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein. Ed. Hunter, Paul J. Norton Critical Edition.

Read More
1835 Words | 8 Pages

In Mary Shelley’s novel Frankenstein, scientist Victor Frankenstein creates an abomination of nature by raising the dead. The creation of his monster has disastrous consequences, not only for Victor and his loved ones, but the very existence of his creation violates the natural order. The different ways that characters interact with nature and the differing consequences they face emphasize the idea that nature is ideal when it is unviolated by man and science. Moreover, Shelley shows that nature always has some form of control over the characters, further suggesting that humans must learn to live in harmony with the natural world in order to avoid its wrath. Victor Frankenstein's interactions with nature are varied, demonstrating the consequences

Read More
874 Words | 4 Pages

The Duality of Nature in Frankenstein: From the dawn of human civilization, man has always been transfixed by the work of the natural world. He has told myths to explain it, and researched it endlessly to understand its power. In a way, human progress from small enclaves to powerful civilizations can be marked by the expansion of natural bounds. We have created vaccines to ward off disease, electricity to light the dark, and even genetically engineered new organisms to feed a massive and growing population. In the 19th century, the literary Romantic period seems to be a reaction to such progress.

Read More
974 Words | 4 Pages

Furthermore, Shelley examines the relation that Frankenstein and his monster have towards relevant motifs of Enlightenment such as science, religion, and humanity. To begin with, the era of Enlightenment was characterized by numerous scientific discoveries in Europe. Advances were made in various scientific fields such as astronomy, physics, and mathematics. They caused large controversies which had a deep impact on people’s thinking about God and religion.

Read More
357 Words | 2 Pages

Mary Shelley’s novel Frankenstein is a masterpiece that explores the ethics of science and the human condition. It is a novel that has become a classic work of literature, with its enduring themes of ambition, creation, and morality. The story revolves around a young scientist, Victor Frankenstein, who creates a living creature from dead body parts, only to be horrified by the result of his experiment. One of the dominant themes in the novel is the pursuit of knowledge and the dangers of ambition.

Read More
648 Words | 3 Pages

Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, which was originally written in the early 19th century, tackles many themes. The story follows Victor Frankenstein on his journey of scientific advancement through creating life from dead beings. Something we see pictured all throughout the book is the questioning of the morality of advancements in science. I believe Mary Shelley is attempting to instill a warning into the minds of curious people. She is not only trying to warn that scientific advancements can be harmful, but also that everything under the scope of influence that humanity has is consequently subject to this harm.

Read More
1245 Words | 5 Pages

Frankenstein Literary Criticism Frankenstein, or the Modern Prometheus, is filled with motifs of Nature and companionship. During the Romantic period or movement, when the novel Frankenstein was written, nature was a huge part of romanticism. Nature was perceived as pure, peaceful, and almost motherly. As we read the novel through Victor Frankenstein 's perspective, we the readers can see how romanticized-nature is perceived as by those who find comfort in nature. This novel also contains, in addition to romantic elements, heavy-filled gothic scenes and descriptions.

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

In Mary Shelley’s Romantic novel, Frankenstein, an over-ambitious young scientist, infatuated with the creation of life without a female and the source of generation, breaks the limits of science and nature by conjuring life into a lifeless form constructed from stolen body parts. The young experimenter confesses his monstrous tale that defies nature to a captain who shares his desire for glory and the pursuit of knowledge. Though a Romantic novel itself, Frankenstein serves as a critique of part of the philosophy behind Romanticism, that is, the promotion of radical self-involvement that celebrates the individual’s pursuit of glory and knowledge. Both the lone captain and the young scientist seek glory from their quest for knowledge but ultimately their pursuits end disastrously. Throughout the novel, Shelley warns against excessive self-confidence, the ambitious overreaching in the acquirement of scientific knowledge, and the arrogant pursuit of glory, using the young scientist as a forewarning to the lone captain against his

Read More
1191 Words | 5 Pages

Numerous research has concluded that several emotional bonds exist between humanity and nature that can impact everything from attitude to anxiety. Novels of the romanticism period, a significant literary era that encompassed most European works written in the early 1800’s, are most known for describing the impacts that nature has on people and implying that unexpected consequences can arise out of this relationship; Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein is a prime example of such a novel. The prime conflict of this 1818 science-fiction story occurs between the titular character, Victor Frankenstein, and a monster he creates through his own scientific innovations. Because of Victor’s abandonment of the monster, it becomes intent on destroying the scientist’s

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

At first glance, Frankenstein may appear to be simply a novel about a monster. In reality it not only challenges reader’s beliefs on the power of science and nature over man, but the power of females as well. All of which show Mary Shelley’s responses to the scientific and industrial revolutions of the 18th century as well as the feminist issues of the time period. The entire novel showcased very clearly how Shelley felt about the issues of her

Read More
883 Words | 4 Pages

Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein Critical Analysis About the author Naomi Hetherington is a member of the University of Sheffield, the department of lifelong learning. She is an early researcher in sexuality, religious culture, the 19th-century literature, and gender. She holds a BA in Theology and religious studies, an MA and a Ph.D. in Victorian Literature. She currently teaches four-year pathway literature degree at Sheffield University for students who have already attained foundation degrees. Among the books, she has written the critique of Frankenstein.

Read More

More about Secondary Source Evaluation Assignment: Frankenstein And The State Of Nature

Related Topics

Open Document