ipl-logo

Shop Class As Soulcraft Analysis

747 Words3 Pages

1. The purpose of this article is to persuade the general public that not every high school student needs to strive to attend college because this will not only be a waste of time and money, but will also present them a career that they have trouble discerning the value of what they do.
2. The article does have a bias. Matthew B. Crawford believes that it is time to question what a good job appears to be like, both the security of the job and the worthy of being honored both considered as two key aspects.

3. In the book, Shop Class As Soulcraft: An inquiry into the value of work, Crawford traces the evolution of shop class and its immediate withdrawal from our educational system. He reveals how college preparatory education now works to produce …show more content…

In today’s society, not only are blue collar workers becoming more rare, many people are now aiming for the health field because of how seemingly stable the career is and its prospects. Within the past year, three whole pharmacy schools have open in California alone, which begs the question of what exactly is occurring in the economy right now. While there is a large supply of workers looking to find jobs, the demand is slowly but surely decreasing because many students are being pushed to aim for a “money-making” career as opposed to lower division ones. However, this would only lead to our downfall because just like how darkness is needed to complement light, we need people working as mechanics and plumbers to complement the ones working as lawyers and dentists. For there to be the existence of “good,” the “evil” must exist somewhere for the good to be promulgated. Otherwise, if society was to continue on this path of engendering pharmacists, doctors, and dentists without curtailment, those fields will eventually “crash” and many graduates fresh out of school will be left with a degree on paper that will barely serve to contribute to their earnings and well-being. Somewhere and somehow, an equilibrium needs to exist between people aiming to become blue collar worker and other endeavoring to work as an allied health professional. Without the equilibrium, the job economy will be found to be in a precarious situation where any move could result in a recession. People who do not need to attend college should not enroll in college and should stop with a high school diploma because continuing further on will only help to put the economy on the precipice of stability and

Show More
Related
1089 Words | 5 Pages

Short-response prompt (15 points) In a speech to high school students, a business owner makes the following statement: "Nowadays a high school diploma alone will get you nowhere in life."   Write a short argument either for or against this statement. Be sure to include a clear claim and to provide and respond to at least one counterclaim. Use specific details from your own experiences and observations to develop your argument.

Read More
782 Words | 4 Pages

Not everyone entering college will finish graduating with a degree, which leaves a lot of debt and no degree. For those who don’t pursue a higher degree, there should be different options to learn skills needed for the work force. Short-term vocational and career training is all some jobs require, a lot of careers don’t require bachelor degrees. Skill sets that employers desire are pushed aside to prepare students for college. The concept of apprenticeship should be more active today, it trains faster and teaches management in the workplace first hand.

Read More
1660 Words | 7 Pages

In today’s society, it has been found out that college graduates have a hard time seeking a job and end up with a sky-high student debt. This reality then poses a question, is going to college worth the time and money? An essay in the New York Times published in May 2014 entitled, “Is College Worth It? Clearly New Data Say,” by David Leonhardt states, “For all the struggles that many young college graduates face, a four-year degree has probably never been more valuable” (33). In his essay, Leonhardt sets the stage by describing the struggles a college graduate might have such as student debt, no work after graduating, and accepting jobs they feel overqualified.

Read More
1540 Words | 7 Pages

In the article, “Should Everyone Go to College,” authors, Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill’s, published by the Brookings Institution, discusses the benefits of a college education. The article begins by mentioning the arguments related to the requirement of having a college degree while entering the middle class in the United States. Having a college degree reminds people that higher education is the best advancement humans can make to allow them to make more money in their lifetimes, rather than if they just had a high school education. A fact that does not get much attention is not all college graduates, or college degrees, are equal. Even though Owen and Sawhill focus, in general, alternative career paths may result in equally lucrative

Read More
630 Words | 3 Pages

Michael Metzdorf Dr.Tomko WRT-101-039 3/4/16 Comparing and Contrasting Two Articles Both articles, “Are Too Many People Going to College?” and “Blue-Collar Brilliance,” differ in many ways from each of the author’s own experiences. The first article “Are Too Many People Going to College” argues a bachelor’s degree is a necessity and your ticket into the working world. If a person doesn’t get a 4-year-college degree society will judge him or her as being not as smart or less than someone who possesses a bachelor’s degree. However, “Blue-Collar Brilliance” argues that while it’s still important to get a bachelor’s degree, there are still some good high paying jobs that don’t require any college education at all.

Read More
706 Words | 3 Pages

School Wide Writing Project Former superintendent, Lawrence B. Shlack argues in his article, Not Going to College is a Viable Option, that too many students believe that going to college is the only option after high school in order to be successful. The main purpose of this article is to convince students to be less narrow-minded on the topic of post-high school decisions and effectively provides the reasoning behind his logic and provides alternatives. As a retired superintendent, Schlack proves that he has sufficient credibility and knowledge of high school students and what most of them are thinking. The use of pathos and ethos combined with his credibility appeals to the readers strongly by making the article relatable for most high schoolers.

Read More
1388 Words | 6 Pages

Delbanco explains how students have changed their reasons for attending a college when he states, “...yet on the assumption that immersing themselves in learning for the sheer joy of it, with the aim of deepening their understanding of culture, nature, and, ultimately, themselves, is a vain indulgence” (222). Secondary education has become too expensive for learning to be an indulgence. Students only go to college to get a degree in order to gain a high paying career. Davidson explains how dire the situation with low paying job is by saying how the process should work, “Only through productivity growth can the average quality of human life improve” (339). Unfortunately, the productivity growth only leaves a bigger pay gap.

Read More
979 Words | 4 Pages

College not only allows you easier access to a steady above minimum wages but also access to more life itself. Imagine yourself as a 80 year old grandparent, you could die pretty much anytime at that at age, but you can spend more time with your future family if you decide to get a Bachelor’s degree. I know this may sound as ludicris as the early 2000’s rapper, but according to the Center of Desease Control (CDC) “Between 1996-2006, the gap in life expectancy at age 25 between those with less than a high school education and those with a bachelor’s degree or higher increased by 1.9 years for men and 2.8 years for women. On average in 2006, 25-year-old men without a high school diploma had a life expectancy 9.3 years less than those with a Bachelor’s degree or higher. Women without a high school diploma had a life expectancy 8.6 years less than those with a bachelor’s degree or higher.”

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

Informational Report   Trade schools have received a bad reputation due to invalid stigmas surrounding the subject. Back when trade schools were new to the post-secondary education system, the school’s effectiveness was debated. Scholars believed trade schools didn’t properly prepare students with the life and professional experience they needed to be successful. How could one learn to think critically and creatively in a trade school like they would in college? This was the previous mindset held against vocational schools, and what began as negative opinions, lead to lingering stigmas surrounding the world of trade school (1867, 87 Notre Dame L. Rev.).

Read More
833 Words | 4 Pages

Factory jobs and other blue-collar jobs keep the working college student performing well in college to get out of those blue-collar jobs. The author supports all of his key points lightly, but effectively. While only barely giving examples, he illustrates why the factory job life has pushed him to do well in college. He has used his personal experiences to press him in his classes versus the experiences of his classmates that work mainly retail or restaurant jobs. The author has become more humble through his working experiences and uses it to better his education.

Read More
1090 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout the essay, Charles Murray stresses the idea that college is the wonderland of finding oneself and to find the career that one would want to follow for the rest of their lives. “College is seen as the open sesame to a good job and a desirable way for adolescents to transition to adulthood. Neither reason is as persuasive as it first appears.” Murray, C (2008) Practically spoken, this is not normally the case. College is a fair amount of work, much more work than one would normally acquire through any course of a high school or secondary school setting.

Read More
571 Words | 3 Pages

In the article “Not Going to College is a Viable Option”, Lawrance B. Schlack claims that going to college is already regarded as the best option after high school by public, but not going to college is also an important choice. However, his article is not very effective or persuasive. The writer tries to build a trustful foundation for the article by using ethos. However, the credibility he built is not very suitable for this topic. In the first sentence, he indicated that all the “retired superintendent” suggest that superintendents always tell students not go to college is a better way to explain themselves.

Read More
1019 Words | 5 Pages

A rising issue in today’s society is deciding whether or not college is worth the cost. There is an extreme amount of pressure that is forced upon high school students by parents, teachers, and peers to further their education and attend college. However, there is research that challenges the thought that college is the best possible path for a person to take. College may be a great investment for some people, but it is not meant for everyone. This is supported by the arguments that colleges are expensive, jobs do not always require a college degree, and students are forced to choose a lifestyle before being exposed to the real world.

Read More
1328 Words | 6 Pages

In recent years, the economy and job outlook has become super competitive throughout the States. With so many people seeking and applying for the same job, employers can only afford to hire a very small amount of people. As a result, they choose the best qualified applicant, which most likely means the applicant with the highest education. With competition increasing exponentially, it is becoming more and more difficult to find, let alone keep a job. That is why college is a necessity in today’s society.

Read More
474 Words | 2 Pages

Then they would really be educated.” Support for Refutation: The counterclaim is wrong that we don’t need a college degree for future jobs because on support #1 it says you don’t need a college degree for those jobs but some of them do because some are high tech and about working in hospital and if you want to learn more you would go to college. “ In order to succeed. Your desire for success should be greater than your fear of

Read More

More about Shop Class As Soulcraft Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document