ipl-logo

Should African Americans Separate Themselves In America Or Return To Africa?

690 Words3 Pages

There are many complications when trying to decide what the future of an entire race in a country should be. In 1962, James Farmer and Malcolm X debated whether Blacks in America should be in favor of separation from whites or full integration into society. Separatism seems good in theory but brings up many new problems that Blacks would have to face. Should Blacks separate themselves in America or return to Africa? If they stay in America, how will they form the economy of their state? If they return to Africa, how will they relate culturally to the natives that presently live there? Blacks should have favored integration because separatism was utterly impractical. The largest problem with separatism is that of the availability of land. There are two options for Malcolm X and the Nation of Islam if they want to separate; they can ask for a plot of land within the US, such as a state, or they could try to relocate to Africa. According to Farmer, “before a large part of land could be granted to Negroes… it would have to be approved by the Senate” (521). The likelihood that the Senate in …show more content…

Farmer brought this up by replying to Malcom’s proposal, “the fact is that the cultures are so very different… you have much more in common with me or with several people whom I see sitting here than you do with the Africans” (526). He proved this point by adding “they speak Swahili or some other language and you would have to learn those languages” (526). Relations with the native people of Africa would be extremely hard because of the vast differences in the American culture of the Blacks and the African culture of the natives. Farmer suggested that integration was the better option because “this is our country as much as it is White American” (526). America was the country of both Whites and Blacks. It would not be practical to give up the country that their ancestors had literally

Show More
Related
1032 Words | 5 Pages

, Reference re Senate Reform 2014,

Read More
120 Words | 1 Pages

However there were some that moved to America and Stayed, but that does not mean they were uprooted and didn't want to go back to their homeland. They were just more settled down and had probably started families.

Read More
260 Words | 2 Pages

He continued to explain that white and black people, in America, come from different backgrounds, they both share the same origins. Therefore, America denying black people rights granted to all humans is immoral. His second claim is that white people separate black people from humanity in

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

Why do people leave their homeland? Some people are forced out, other people leave willingly with a smile on their face. Perhaps they were being discriminated against, perhaps they just wanted to make a little bit more cash. The people of the Plymouth colony were not allowed to practice their religion in England so they came to the New World. The people of Jamestown heard about the riches in the New World and high-tailed it to the New World to get rich.

Read More
171 Words | 1 Pages

While Stokely Carmichael and Charles Hamilton have similar beliefs to Malcolm X from the economic and political side, they differ in their idea of African Americans integration into the current established society. In chapter 2 of the Black Power book, Carmichael and Hamilton present a similar belief to Malcolm X, believing “black people must redefine themselves, and only they can do that”. Throughout this country, vast segments of the black communities are beginning to recognize the need to assert their definitions, to reclaim their history, their culture; to create their sense of community and togetherness” (Black Power). This quote takes a similar stance to Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X through the vision that African Americans must

Read More
599 Words | 3 Pages

Integration would require an eventual acceptance of an outside culture which had been incredibly loathed within the existing communities. In a way Malcolm was warning the African Americans that even though the civil rights movements is optimistic in its approach of reaching equality, the outcome is unrealistic. One could even argue that the reason Martin Luther King Jr was the prefered representative of the civil rights movement over Malcolm X was due to the fact Dr. King wanted to integrate. By choosing to integrate instead of separating, that decision allowed the racist population of the United States to continue its oppressive nature again the black population which had carried on from the Eras of Slavery and Jim Crow. Instead of openly demonizing African Americans like they did before the 21st century, the oppressive bourgeoisie was now using the media to misrepresent the population and now, more than ever, people are starting to stigmatize black people with uneducated

Read More
496 Words | 2 Pages

Americans now and past, have been divided by many things. A major division of our people was race. America's past was littered with black inequality. There have been some Black American leaders who have not given in to racial division such as Harriet Tubman, and Melba Pattillo Beals, and Frederick Douglass.

Read More
1531 Words | 7 Pages

With the dominance of the government in the house and its ability to restrict and limit debate the Senate becomes one of

Read More
1385 Words | 6 Pages

After slavery was ended in the late 1800’s, many African Americans were tasked with the burden of integrating into a society that most of them only knew as servants. This posed a fork in the road for the common African American. Do they assimilate as quietly as possible and learn how to contribute to the American society and economy as a working man? Or do they continue their everlasting fight for even truer equality in America by fighting for voting rights, civil rights, and a higher education opportunity for them and their children? Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Du Bois both argued their views on the dilemma that faced their people, with Booker aligning more with the first question and Du Bois associating himself with the second, while refuting Washington’s vision.

Read More
682 Words | 3 Pages

The United States is a country built on the principles that there should be freedom, equality, and fundamental human rights for everyone who is a resident. However, we have seen time and time again the selective inclusivity of who is worthy of these values, which results in the exclusion of racial minorities. Enslaved Africans were brought to the Americas as a subordinate class that would forever remain that way up until today. White Europeans were able to construct their notions of whiteness in opposition to the blackness of the enslaved Africans. Thus resulted what would become a caste system that permeated into structures such as the education system where these inequalities are reproduced.

Read More
597 Words | 3 Pages

In Martin Luther King’s “ I Have A Dream”, in paragraph two he states “One hundred years later, the life the Negroes is still crippled by the mandates of segregation and the chains of discriminations.” To clarify, one hundred years later from when the Emancipation Proclamation was signed to the very day Dr. King gave his speech, the Negro were free but lack their civic rights. The Negroes were still struggling with segregation and racial discrimination. In the same paragraph, Dr. King illustrates, “One hundred years later, the Negro is still languishing in the corners of American society and find himself an exile in his own land.” Dr. King supports the argument that the American society is basically turning against them.

Read More
1236 Words | 5 Pages

They had many more rights than they had before however they still experienced a large amount of hate. African Americans migrated during the Great Migration due to poor living conditions and treatment in the Southeast of the United States (Phillips 33) . “For many blacks, their departure from the South was a response to, and a defiance of, the coercions used to keep them bound to segregation” (Phillips 39). In the 1920’s, treatment of African Americans was different, blacks were able to do more such as getting a job however, some felt as though the hate they would get for it wasn 't worth it. Although, there would always be challenges that African Americans would have to face such as landowners supporting the passing of laws meant to control the mobility of blacks, limit their wages, and minimize their chance to purchase and own land (Phillips 33).

Read More
516 Words | 3 Pages

In modern ages, there have been many problems in terms of racial and cultural division. To get past this stage, we need to learn from the lessons Malcolm X and Nelson Mandela tried to give us from their memoirs. From Malcolm X, the society can learn that through motivation, determination, and education, people can get to freedom. From Nelson Mandela, the people can learn that through love for one another, trial and error, and peaceful protests, we can change the society we live in, one step at a

Read More
946 Words | 4 Pages

They discriminate African Americans and they separate

Read More
1401 Words | 6 Pages

He believed that blacks should focus on economic elevation by concentrating their efforts on farming and industry. He thought it would lead to black socio-economic progress, opposed to the outright demand of social equality. Atlanta Exposition Address argues three major points: 1) blacks should focus on industrial education (to accumulate wealth) instead of higher education, 2) give up the insistence of civil rights, and that 3) whites should give black southerners a chance to prove

Read More

More about Should African Americans Separate Themselves In America Or Return To Africa?

Related Topics

Open Document