ipl-logo

Similarities Between Charter Rights And Quebec's Need For A Distinct Culture

496 Words2 Pages

Perhaps the most unsettle period in Canadian political history, the Quebec Referendum of 1980 and a vote to the remain part of Canada, led Ottawa to initiate a balancing program to promote Charter Rights, while protecting Quebec’s language and culture. The Meech Lake and the Charlottetown Accord were developed to address this situation. However, through a compare and contrast it can be deduced that the Charlottetown Accord provided the best balance for Charter Rights and Quebec’s need for a distinct society clause.

During the 1960’s Quebec began to argue that it was a distinct society due to their language, culture and history. The Quebecois therefore argued that this claim was valid and its status be indicated in the constitution. Interestingly, the concept of a distinct society has received a mixed reaction from Canadians. Most often, they argue that every province is distinct from another, since their culture, population and regional values and custom all differ from the other provinces in the Confederation. However, the claim that validates Quebec’s notion as a distinct society is their language. Afterall, both accords address the distinct society clause as the link to the fact that Quebec is the only province that has a francophone majority population (textbook Pp.558). Moreover, they both indicate that the it is in the provincial government of Quebec’s interest to protect and promote the French language (textbook Pp.558). …show more content…

The reformed constitution is organized around three principles that oppose the recognition of Quebec as a distinct society (textbook Pp.457). The first principle indicates that the equality of all Canadians citizens, second indicates the equality of all cultures and cultural origins in Canada and third the equality of the 10 provinces of

Show More
Related
425 Words | 2 Pages

Montreal, 28th August. A new controversial bill proposed by the sovereigntistParti Quebecois ‘revives’ tensions between English and French-speakers in the Canadian province Quebec. Since the Parti Québécois, that advocates for national sovereignty for the province Quebec, came to power a ’language war’ has been going on. For the political party of René Lévesque was in a new language law in 1976 a high priority.

Read More
846 Words | 4 Pages

She summarized the French settlement and the battle between British and the French, and she clarified the difference between Quebec and the rest of Canada “By 1900, about three quarters of Canadians used English in government, business, and daily life” (par 11) After that, she mentioned that in 1977, “Quebec’s legislature made French the province’s sole official language” (par 13). In order to prove that is has been a long time ago since the French language been official language in Quebec. Patricia used the map to describe how the French culture spread in Quebec. She includes statistics about Canada and U.S. in her article which reflects the difference in population, GDP, Geographic Area, and the most important the number of official languages which is two in Canada, while zero in the U.S. to reveal the different rules and elements between Canada and the U.S. and to show the reader that Canada has two languages and the French language is an official

Read More
685 Words | 3 Pages

“Canada’s road was evolutionary, not revolutionary.” To what extent do you agree with this question? The road to Canada’s independence was evolutionary due to changes and factors such as the formation of the new country, the new leading government and it was mostly made of negotiations to find what will best fit the new country. After the English took over New France, at that time called Lower Canada.

Read More
738 Words | 3 Pages

In the text, “Changing Anglo-Quebecer Self Consciousness,” the author, Michael Stein, questions the transformations of political consciousness among English-speaking Quebecers, since the election of the Parti Québécois government in 1976. Early on, key concepts emerge where the author defines the terms “anglophone” and “non-francophone Quebecer” which are mutually used. However, Stein makes a clear differentiation between those who are virtually English-speaking, inclusive of Anglo-Celts, Jews, Germans and other early immigrant arrivals, and those who nevertheless generally utilize their language of origin such as the more recent Italian, Greek, and Portuguese immigrants. Furthermore, the main objective of the text is to bring attention to the often disregarded yet ongoing psychological changes of

Read More
331 Words | 2 Pages

The next thing to consider on Quebec referendum is whether or not the Quebecois are seeking separation or a special recognition as a ‘distinct society’. John C. Parkin’s quote, “The problem for a lot of people is that they don't really know what they want…” best describes the situation the Quebecois are in. In the past two referendums, Quebec emphasized on sovereignty-association and the acceptance of a unique society. During the second referendum, the separatists nearly seceded but was denied by a slight majority of 50.58 percent. According to an article from the Vancouver Sun, many Quebecers seek independence for reasons that are unrelated to economics and the cost of separating.

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction Something of an enigma in that he was solidly socialist in his foundational views, themselves built on a Christian ‘social gospel’ which sought to improve industrialised society through the use of the biblical principles of charity and justice, at the same time Tommy Douglas worked with and through the capitalist system that he abhorred. An implicit nationalist in that he held the good of the Canadian people above other countries, Douglas was predominantly anti-liberal as he believed that public ownership was the next evolution of democracy, replacing a system where the “major economic decisions affecting the lives of ordinary people are not made by…the government of this country.” ’ (Aivalis) While he has now passed away his track records in both the national and provincial

Read More
1301 Words | 6 Pages

(Sociocultural: A Problem-Based Approach, 2016). The Mountie myth is one of the stories that employ the ideas of Canada’s open-mindedness and justice towards its minorities to create national identity. The Quebec referendums from the 1980s to 1995 and the Calgary pact that were made in September 1997 present the past as a ‘heritage’ of tolerance. The story of Canada’s tolerant nationhood has often been framed in terms of its policy of “multiculturalism”, a policy defined in official government ideology as a ‘fundamental characteristic of Canadian heritage and identity’. Canada is often described as a ‘cultural mosaic’ in order to distinguish it from the American culture ‘melting pot’ (Mackey, 1998).

Read More
1304 Words | 6 Pages

Despite its good intentions, Drimonis contends that the French Language Charter may cause non-francophone populations to become marginalized. She contends that a more nuanced approach to language policy may aid in fostering an inclusive society and bridging the gap between linguistic communities. Moreover, as we know, the book emphasizes the experiences of “the others” in Quebec, and Drimonis makes the case that their identity, language and culture should be preserved and acknowledged. She contends that acknowledging and appreciating the diversity of Quebec society is the best way to resolve the tensions and conflicts that surround language, culture, and identity in the province. Additionally, more understanding of the tensions and struggles surrounding identity and belonging in Quebec may be gained from Drimonis’s examination of the media and political debates around integration.

Read More
1515 Words | 7 Pages

Institutional and historical analysis often portray the motives of governments, especially in the cases of Quebec separatism and Aboriginal mistreatment. History describes attempts at compromise to rectify the problems by altering political institutions to provide more autonomy to the provinces, witness in various accords and the methods described previously. However, in regards to Aboriginals a historical relationship of exploitation and eradication sheds on the systemic issues that Aboriginals cope with and the institutions that caused them. As scholars of Canadian politics, it is important to consider historical and institutional analyses when looking at any issue, as it reveals the underlying motives of actors in regards to the cleavages that comprise a state.

Read More
1362 Words | 6 Pages

The Dominion of Canada was not born because of a revolution, or a sudden outburst of nationalism. Whatsoever, it was created with a series of conferences and orderly negotiations, which eventually formed Canada. The process of negotiating to make Canada happen was not easy. Each colonies/dominions had their own terms and conditions that must be met in order for them to be part of the Canada that is known to us today. Confederation was necessary for Canada because in the 1860s there were many problems amongst the colonies.

Read More
1122 Words | 5 Pages

In many countries, conflict between different groups of people is inevitable. In Canada, the divide between English-speaking and French-speaking regions has been a prominent political and cultural topic since the birth of the nation. The most well known of these conflicts goes to Quebec. The province has sprouted several movements and parties supporting the autonomy and independence of Quebec. One of those parties is the Bloc Quebecois.

Read More
1219 Words | 5 Pages

Before the Charter, many people may argue that Canada was a free and democratic country. Canadians had the freedom of expression, equality and the principles of fundamental justice. What changed with the creation of the Charter was that rights and freedoms were given constitutional status, and judges were given the power to strike down laws that infringed on them. In 1982, most Canadians agreed that the introduction of the Charter was going to monumental. But on the contrary, over 30 years later, numerous laws have been struck down by interpretation of the charter and remedial techniques that have been developed by courts.

Read More
821 Words | 4 Pages

To call this era of drastic change the ‘Quiet Revolution’ is a vivid, and yet, paradoxical description. The Quiet Revolution was a time of intense socio-political and socio-cultural change in Quebec, which extended beyond Quebec’s borders because of its influence on contemporary Canadian politics. As a result of the effects of the changes that occurred during this Quiet Revolution, most Quebec provincial governments since the early 1960s have maintained political and social orientations based on the core concepts developed and implemented during the Quiet Revolution. As such, there is no doubt that the Quiet Revolution had a significant impact in Canadian History. This impact can be characterized by the prelude to the Quiet Revolution; the demographic evolution of Quebec; the social educational reforms that were put in place; the economic reforms and their impact; the rise of nationalism; and finally, the cultural changes that occurred.

Read More
719 Words | 3 Pages

The improvement of the rights of the Canadian Immigrants Canada, as one of the biggest immigration countries, welcomes people from all over the the world and forms a representative multicultural atmosphere in today’s society. Over these few decays, the country has always been consummating the laws to provide immigrants equal rights and freedoms, and better treatments they could receive. However, Canadian immigration laws were not unprejudiced and it eventually caused a “legal discrimination” before 1976. The legal rights of the immigrant groups have improved significantly because of the demands of developing the country, the influences of the wars, and the globalization of the world. Since 1880s, more immigrants and foreigners came to Canada because of the railway construction project.

Read More
833 Words | 4 Pages

Also, it is very important to note the fact that Canada is a multinational culture and there are differences among provinces and between Anglophone Canadians and French

Read More

More about Similarities Between Charter Rights And Quebec's Need For A Distinct Culture

Related Topics

Open Document