ipl-logo

Similarities Between Lion And Talking To My Country

919 Words4 Pages

Identity encompasses the memories, experiences, relationships and values that can make a person feel belonging to something greater than self. Two texts which explores the concept of identity are Garth Davis’s Lion and Stan Grant’s Talking to my Country. In Davis’ film, the protagonist, Saroo, was adopted into Australia by the Brierley family and developed an identity crisis as he was stuck in between by the flickering flashbacks of his impoverished birth family and his loving Australian adoptive parents. On the other hand, Grant’s memoir, Talking to My Country, explores the disconnection and marginalisation experienced by the Aboriginals in the dominant Australian culture due to the ongoing impacts of colonisation. Despite, these differences, …show more content…

While this was shown through Saroo’s disconnections between his Indian heritage and his inability to settle with the flashbacks of his childhood, in Grant’s book it was shown through Stan’s marginalisation in the Australian society and him being unable to forgive the traumas his people went through historically.

In both texts, the two protagonists had occasions where they are unable to connect with culturally linked people which weakens the sense of identity. In the university scene, when Saroo is asked whether he is born in Australia, he replied “Yeah” but immediately clarified that he is from “Calcutta”, this reveals that Saroo is in a dilemma as he naturally classifies himself as Australian but still wanting to associates himself with his Indian heritage. After Saroo said this, Prama and Bharat – fellow Indian students from Calcutta – questions “which part” of the city he is from, he subconsciously answered “I’m adopted, I’m not really Indian,” resisting to reconnect with Indian cultural due to his adoption in Australia, revealing …show more content…

In Davis’s film, after the party scene at night, Lucy argues with Saroo, suggesting he “need to face reality” and stop search for his birth family; however, Saroo can’t settle with the fact that “his real brother and mother spend every day … looking for [him]” and “the pain they are in not knowing where [he is]. This argument resulted in the breakup with Lucy, and they later went back together after Saroo “found home” on Google Earth. Through the use of plot, Davis directs the audience to view the development of Saroo’s identity sparked by love was extinguished by his obsession to search for home due to his inability to overcome his traumatic pasts. Furthermore, during his search for home, he refuses to tell his adoptive parents what he had been up to, and he tells Mantosh that you are “not [my brother], we are different” in the dinner scene, revealing that he is denying his identity as Mantosh’s brother and even as a Brierley. On the other hand, Stan’s struggle to reconcile is due to the historical traumas happened to the Aboriginals. Stan thinks “identity is a two-way street – we need others to see us as we see ourselves.” (p.172) However, during the Olympic games, he sighs “what on earth did we have to rejoice? The theft of our land? The murder of our ancestors? The pillage and plunder of our culture and traditions? …”

Show More
Related
412 Words | 2 Pages

People thirst to discover their identity. Most will believe that they discovered and made their identity, but they didn’t. In Hal Borland’s “When The Legends Die”, It shows how a young indian boy’s (Thomas Black Bull) identity changes throughout his miserable life. Identities are formed more by society than by their owners.

Read More
410 Words | 2 Pages

Australian identity and what constitutes Australian culture are prominent ideas explored by Peter Goldsworthy’s Maestro. Throughout the novel, there is a strong sense of cynicism towards Australian culture as it is painted as ambiguous and indefinite. This is established through the analogy of Paul representing Australian society and his parents representing the British influence on Australian culture. Goldsworthy also explores the European influence on Australia through Kellar’s character. Goldsworthy’s broader message is that Australian identity is in fact quite complex and open to interpretation due how culturally diverse it is.

Read More
458 Words | 2 Pages

we heard a howl of humiliation that echoes across two centuries of dispossession, injustice, suffering and survival,” alluding to the concept of community and

Read More
854 Words | 4 Pages

The fact that the Australian voice is recognisable contributes to its inclusion in the Australian identity. It is important to understand these voices because they steep various voices in our rich history, continually develop, and ultimately shape who we are today.

Read More
1811 Words | 8 Pages

This cinematography of the close-up shot highlights how the threat of globalisation is right at their door due to the growing global economy. The diegetic sound of the knocking in conjunction with the non-diegetic sound of the voice-over highlights the importance of cultural identity and a sense of belonging in the face of change. In the contextual 1990s globalisation was beginning to peak and the historical place in time is represented to impact the cultural identity within Australia.

Read More
858 Words | 4 Pages

Identity is forged through both positive and negative experiences. Identity is built from positive experiences in day-to-day activities. Furthermore, negative experience is vital in the teaching of the important lesson used in the shaping of identity. Garth Davies illustrates this in his film Lion through the experiences of the protagonist Saroo, whose identity is morphed by the positive experiences of his upbringing in Australia and the negative experiences of the struggles of the past. The movie demonstrates Saroo’s resilience in the desolation at the Calcutta train station and his connection to his lacked Indian identity.

Read More
1724 Words | 7 Pages

Throughout literature the constant theme of identity has been explored, with Northrop Frye even suggesting “the story of the loss and regaining of identity is, I think, the framework for all literature.” For characters, true identity isn’t always apparent, it needs to be searched for. Sometimes the inner struggle for identity stems from ones need for belonging. Whether one finds their sense of identity within friends, family, or in a physical “home”. It’s not always a place that defines identity.

Read More
871 Words | 4 Pages

The documentary delves into Adam and Stan Grant's early childhood, offering insight into the treatment and challenges of young indigenous children.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

Set in the 1960s, the novel explores the social, political, and racial issues in Australia at that time. Silvey portrayed the racism and discrimination experienced by the indigenous character jasper jones is a stark reminder of the country's colonial past and the effects of that. For instance if the police found Laura in that area that is known as Jasper's refuge, he is gonna be accused of a crime he didn't commit, he knows he won't receive a fair trial because of his race. This not only highlights the injustice that jasper faces but also draws readers into the world of the novel by reminding them of australia's past and the ongoing struggle for racial equality. The historical context of the novel adds depth and complexity to the world of the text, making it more engaging and thought- provoking for the

Read More
652 Words | 3 Pages

This article discusses the speech given by an Indigenous journalist, Stan Grant who participated in a debate where he spoke for the motion “Racism is destroying the Australian Dream’’. Hence, the main points of this article are mostly evidence given by Grant in his debate to support his idea that the Australian Dream is indeed rooted in racism. One of the main points is that the indigenous Australians are often excluded and disregarded as non-Australians simply due to their race and skin colour. Grant pointed out the incident where AFL player Adam Goodes was publicly jeered and told that he did not belong to his country as he was not an Australian despite the fact that Australia indeed is the land of his ancestors.

Read More
608 Words | 3 Pages

You tell me, and I won’t put it down on the form, No-one will know but you and me”. It’s obvious that the author, Thomas King, is trying to make awareness about the treatment of Aboriginals are facing in

Read More
50 Words | 1 Pages

Belonging to the land and to each other is fundamental to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and their culture. Connections with the land, families, clans and communities are at the core of Aboriginality. It is through these connections that nurture belonging from which Aboriginal peoples identities and cultures emerge.

Read More
1139 Words | 5 Pages

Being adopted from India into an Australian family challenges Saroo, leaving him with a cultural disconnection. As Saroo explains “My identity was shaped by both my Indian heritage and my Australian upbringing. They were two halves of a whole” this creates a reflection on Saroo’s ongoing struggles of integrating these two aspects into his life. Throughout the text, Saroo constantly describes himself as “an outsider, a foreigner” among others, this experience creates a link between a challenge many adoptees face in navigating their origins with their upbringing. As Saroo tries to grow and navigate the complexities of his two identities, he faces an internal conflict among himself where he faces “a kind of reverse culture shock” he explains “in the company of international students I was for the first time stripped of my Indianness.”

Read More
249 Words | 1 Pages

Lion is an Incredible and Inspiring movie, it based on true story, and deserves an Academy Award for best picture. It tells about a 5-year-old boy named Saroo. He is a slum-dweller, he always gets along with his brother Guddu, who does odd jobs to earn money while his mother works as a laborer. They may be poor, but they are a happy bunch until one day, Saroo insists his brother Guddu to take him along for a night job. The 5-year-old gets tired and is left on the station platform by his brother to rest.

Read More
690 Words | 3 Pages

No matter what changes are made, as long as their skin colour isn’t pure white, they will never be regarded as “Australian”. This puts stress on the requirement for migrants to completely dispose of their own identity for an “Australian” identity. The fact that the protagonist claims that he or she has provided the migrants with equality is also ironic. “Learn English to Distinguish ESL from RSL”, the utilisation of assonance and internal rhyme

Read More

More about Similarities Between Lion And Talking To My Country

Related Topics

Open Document