ipl-logo

Similarities Between Luther And Machiavelli

1666 Words7 Pages

Luther’s and Machiavelli’s Views on Generosity Archit Khosla While Luther’s opinion on generosity is intertwined with his views on faith and God’s magnanimity and mercy, Machiavelli takes a more practical and brutal approach where he advises the ruler to use the virtue of generosity only when it is advantageous, in fact, Machiavelli advocates being miserly in order to consolidate power. While Luther’s style of writing is more religious and spiritual in nature, Machiavelli’s view is highly political. While Luther talks about how the church should propagate the God’s message and not get embroiled in politics, Machiavelli expounds on how essential it is for a ruler to be prudent and practical to the point of being ruthless. Luther wanted his …show more content…

Their arguments center on the need for longevity and eternity. Machiavelli does so by suggesting tactics as to when the ruler should be generous and when he should not. For example, he says that Caesar, Cyrus and Alexander were only generous when it came to giving away the belongings of those they had plundered and that this made them successful rulers. Therefore Machiavelli argues that the purpose of generosity or being miserly at the opportune moment increases the length of the reign. Throughout the book, his main aim is to provide the ruler with tactics and tricks to amass and consolidate power and increase the time for which he rules a country. In the same way, the purpose of Luther’s argument is to provide man with a set of guidelines to experience long, healthy and a sin free life. He instructs his readers that God (Christ) is eternal, omnipotent and cannot sin and if they are faithful to Christ, then Christ’s generosity would extend to them, and they too would live sin-free long lives. Therefore, one can see that Luther, too, links generosity to a long lasting life. However this counterargument can be overcome by looking at the ways Luther and Machiavelli describe the virtue of generosity. Machiavelli aims to use generosity for a selfish need and Luther talks about God’s generosity as something

Show More
Related

Protestant Reformation Dbq Essay

798 Words | 4 Pages

In document 7 Selections from Martin Luther’s 95 Thesis, it described how Martin Luther said that one cannot buy forgiveness or their way into heaven, and that God will give them salvation for free if they ask. He also said that the Church only wants money and does not care about god. The Church was being immoral by selling the indulgences which led to the corruption of the Church. The people realized the Church was wrong and started to question their

Read More

How Did John Locke Influence The American Constitution

542 Words | 3 Pages

We find traces of his philosophy in modern politics by how people running for seats of power make many promises in their campaign and once the people elect them, they may fall short in accomplishing their promises. Where Machiavelli mentioned using cruelty, one can say this applied to the rise of Hitler’s reign by how he punished the Jew’s and other minorities all the while maintaining a merciful appearance for those who supported

Read More

Protestant Reformation Dbq Essay

1281 Words | 6 Pages

As Luther is fighting the corrupt Papacy he writes this, “Faith is a living, bold trust in God’s grace, so certain of God’s favor it would risk death a thousand times trusting in it.” Luther writes this to show what true religion is, to show what a truly faithful person should do, believe in their God and give him every bit of faith from someone's person. The Papacy hates Luther not because he is wrong, but because he is right, which means if Luther was right and the masses believed him all the power that was held by the church would crumble into nothing; most importantly though the Papacy members personal power would crumble into nothing. During the early phases of the Reformation, Luther wrote the 95 Theses, which described everything he found wrong with the church at this time. The Theses was the catalyst, which set off the ticking time bomb of corruption and irreverence.

Read More

Protestant Reformation Dbq

1066 Words | 5 Pages

A large portion of this pertained to the Catholic church selling indulgences which were, as described by the Church, a full or partial pardoning of sin that could be used to free anyone of transgression, especially late friends and family. One reading explains that a huge problem in Luther’s eyes was that people no longer felt that they had to go any further for forgiveness once an indulgence was purchased because they saw it as a “catch-all” system. People could pay for salvation instead of relying on faith. Luther believed sola fida, that Christ’s salvation should be achieved through faith alone, and not by giving the church money (moodle reading April

Read More

Luther's Attitude Towards Jews

1306 Words | 6 Pages

Luther states his purpose by pointing out that he should “warn the Christians to be on their guard against [Jews].” He urges Christians to stand up against Jews. In the last part, Luther offers seven draconian proposals on what should be done with the Jews, who do not want to convert to Christianity: their synagogues and schools should be burned; their houses should “also be razed and destroyed”; “their prayer books and Talmudic writings” should be taken from them; their rabbis should “be forbidden to teach henceforth on pain of loss of life and limb”; “safe-conduct on the highways be abolished completely for the Jews”; “usury be prohibited to them, and all cash and treasure of silver and gold be taken from them”; they should be subjected to harsh labor. Dean Bell also states that Luther’s attitude toward the Jews seemed to become more radical after 1538, and particularly so in his last work, On the Jews and Their Lies. It may sound shocking by Luther’s vulgar blast if this book is only taken into account, and one may think that Luther is a brutal and cruel anti-Jews.

Read More

Thomas Jefferson And Niccolo Machiavelli's The Morals Of The Prince

762 Words | 4 Pages

Machiavelli argues the perfect prince will be both feared and loved by his people, and if unable to be both he will make himself feared and not hated. Machiavelli believes it is much safer to be feared than to be loved because people are less likely to offend and stand up against strong characters, also people are less concerned in offending a prince who has made himself loved. Accordingly, Machiavelli believes generosity is harmful to your reputation and the choice between being generous or stingy, merciful or cruel, honest or deceitful, should only be important if it aids the prince in political power. All in all, Machiavelli believes the ruler must be a great deceiver and do what is essential to uphold power over the

Read More

Compare And Contrast Machiavelli And Martin Luther King Jr

1187 Words | 5 Pages

How can we tell the true essence of a man? Why is it that we focus on the outward image of a person so much that we blind our eyes from the true spirit of the individual within? Unintentionally, we separate people based off the judgements we preconceive and conclusively bypass the full essence of a person There once were two extremely intellectual men who enlightened the world with their own unique optimism and opinions. Niccolo Machiavelli and Martin Luther King Jr. set off sporadic flames of change within their individual eras that ignited revolution and constant metamorphosis amongst society. Although Machiavelli had a more deterred conception when it came to certain ideologies and moral principles, it as because of honesty that people began to broaden their viewpoints of life and welcome new ways of thinking,

Read More

Martin Luther Dbq

661 Words | 3 Pages

Martin Luther’s reasons for challenging the Catholic church changed after he translated the New Testament. Before the New Testament was translated (document A), Martin Luther had a very respectful tone displayed through his writing. In document A, Luther was bothered by the practice of indulgences, but continued in his letter to say that he was not blaming anyone. 18 years later in Document B, Luther had translated the New testament and realized that the Pope was misinterpreting the scriptures. He was then very disrespectful through his words and blamed the Pope for taking people’s money and by so believing that the person who paid for the indulgence was saved.

Read More

Generosity And Martin Luther's He

739 Words | 3 Pages

So, in Machiavelli’s point of view, as a politician, the purpose and intentions of one’s generosity is solely to get to their desired position, in this case the prince. The politicians will say numerous things they will do when they become a prince; however, once they actually become one, they no longer feel obliged to keep their promises, and most of the promises they made were merely to get the votes. This results in only a small fraction of the promises being kept, and these kinds of politicians are not so hard to find even in today’s

Read More

Martin Luther Dbq

1173 Words | 5 Pages

Prompt: Compare and contrast the motives and actions of Martin Luther in the German states and King Henry VIII in England in bringing about religious change during the Reformation. During the 16th century as renaissance inspired changes in education and art ,humanist ideas also impacted religion. Major dissatisfaction with the Roman Catholic Church and its traditions made it easier for people to trigger a movement to reform the church and its teachings. There were two reformers Martin Luther, a german theology professor, who came to realise a new comprehension of Christianity, and King Henry VIII, who desired divorce which he could not get because of the disapproval of the Catholic Church. While the motives of their strong persuasion of

Read More

Erasmus Vs Machiavelli

1034 Words | 5 Pages

Machiavelli believed that men will follow a ruler as long as the ruler serves their interests, and a quick to turn against the ruler unless they fear great punishment. Machiavelli would say that it is best to be feared rather than loved as long as the fear does not cause hate, which he believed to be perfectly possible.

Read More

Luther Vs Machiavelli

1044 Words | 5 Pages

In machiavelli’s “The Prince”, machiavelli argues that,“At this point one may note that men must be either pampered or annihilated. They avenge light offenses; they cannot avenge severe ones; hence, the harm one does to a man must be such as to obviate any fear of revenge” (Machiavelli 30). Humanist believe and stress stress the potential value and goodness of human beings, but machiavelli states that really men can be very selfish in politics and must do what is necessary to survive, even to be kill and be feared. Luther also preached against Humanist teachings, since he is a christian.

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Protestant And English Reformation

1085 Words | 5 Pages

Starting from the statement that Christians receive salvation through faith and the grace of God. Luther also stated, “The churches rituals did not have the ability to save souls. ”Also Luther talked about how the Church and the Pope make errors often. This had gone from a need for reforming indulgences to a whole

Read More

Qualities Of A Good Man In Machiavelli's The Prince

1284 Words | 6 Pages

A leader’s cruelty enables him to make the decisions necessary for the kingdom, while also being miserly to keep the people happy. I think that Machiavelli’s advice provides a sound basis on how leaders today can lead. On other hand, others may argue that Machiavelli’s advice leads rulers astray and rather rulers should be kind and generous because morally that is the right thing to do. No matter the interpretation of how a ruler should lead, Machiavelli's analyst of a leaders provides insight into everyday life and causes leaders today to think about how they

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Climate Change

1524 Words | 7 Pages

Climate Change: The Facts, the Effects, and the Arguments Before humans and before human's were industrial enough to cause a significant impact on earth's climate, climate change was caused by many natural factors including changes in natural greenhouse gas concentrations. The natural "greenhouse effect" is caused by heat-trapping gases. These gases absorb heat that is radiated from the earth's surface and then radiates the energy back to the surface. Our climate is dependent on this warming effect, without which the earth would be about 60 degrees Fahrenheit colder (U.S Global 14). Without this warming effect we would not able to live, nor would we be here to begin with.

Read More

More about Similarities Between Luther And Machiavelli

Related Topics

Open Document