ipl-logo

Similarities Between The Great Gatsby And Their Eyes Were Watching God

1735 Words7 Pages

The novels The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald and Their Eyes Were Watching God follow the lives of Jay Gatsby and Janie Crawford, respectively, exploring the depths of their love life and personal values. Wealth plays a big part of each story, however, with differing importance to the main characters. Janie is not materialistic, and cares not how much money she has, but whether she is happy or not. Gatsby, on the other hand, cares only about wealth and convinces himself he is in love with Daisy, equating financial success with love and happiness. Their class, the themes and materialism that is shown in the novels reveal the place of wealth in their lives, showing how commodification is either negative or positive.
Despite both Gatsby and Janie being stuck in a liminal space between lower class and higher class, they both react to that fact in completely opposite ways; Gatsby tries to climb to the next clique in vain to gain love, while Janie treats money and love as completely separate things, with love being more important than money. Throughout the novel, Janie strives to find love; meanwhile, her grandmother marries her off to an …show more content…

Janie, particularly with her husbands, is commodified and treated like an object; on the other hand, Jay Gatsby commodifies people, treating them as something he will gain from. Janie is treated as a worker by her first husband, Logan. He expects her to assist him with the farming work, even though she was married off to Logan to have someone to provide for her. Janie argues that she cooks dinner, so she shouldn’t have to help in the fields. Logan agrees, for a short time at least. He then sets off to buy her a mule so she can work, and then she runs off with Joe. Now, Joe treats her as a trophy wife and doesn’t allow her to do

Show More
Related
866 Words | 4 Pages

Love, life, and death. All of these things is what really gave these characters ambition. The main ambition of each character was different but over all the same. In the novel The Great Gatsby, Gatsby just wanted to live a happy life with Daisy and make her happy. And in the other novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, Tea Cake he wanted to be with Janie and make enough money for both of them.

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

Love is a mystery for many people, everyone has their views on what love should be and it is way more than just a definition in a dictionary. Love takes patience and time and not just forcing to find it. In the story, Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurstone, the main character Janie Crawford is raised by her grandmother who forces her to marry an older wealthy man. Janie 's realizes that isn’t what true love is and runs off with another man called Jodie. After many years she realizes that marriage didn’t work out either, after Jodies dies she meets a man called TeaCake who she falls for and runs away with.

Read More
844 Words | 4 Pages

Joe treats her disrespectfully and represses her constantly. Part of the reason he does this is to show his dominance and power in the town. This is shown when she stands up for herself and embarrasses Jody in front of the town. The book explains, “Janie had robbed him of his illusion of irresistible maleness that all men cherish, which was terrible” (79). Jody’s repression was most common in the form of verbal abuse.

Read More
574 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout the two novels--Their Eyes Were Watching God and The Great Gatsby the protagonists are conveyed as showing affection for many people within their lives, whether it be through riches (materialistically or figuratively), sacrifice, or protection. The manner in which they show their love is widely accepted amongst many peoples. In the novel--The Great Gatsby, the protagonist, Jay Gatsby, shows his affection for Daisy Buchanan through his riches--he purchases the expensive, luxurious mansion located transversely from her humble abode to ensure his closeness to her; in doing so, he manages to lure her from her husband, reminding her of the history they had shared together previously, “Can’t repeat the past? [...] Why of course you can! ”

Read More
1649 Words | 7 Pages

Gatsby Vs. Janie Rough Draft Janie and Gatsby spent long portions of their life trying and trying again to get closer to their dream of spending their life with the perfect person to live the perfect life. Janie got closer because unlike Gatsby, who never got to spend more than a day with Daisy, Janie took the chance of complete failure by running away with an almost complete stranger just so she could live the rest of her life how she had hoped that it would've gone when she envisioned it. In the book Gatsby portrays himself as being someone who has a long line of family that has lived in wealth with high levels of education and success.

Read More
242 Words | 1 Pages

Love encompasses a variety of different emotional and mental states, typically strongly and positively experienced, ranging from the most sublime virtue or good habit, the deepest interpersonal affection and to the simplest pleasure. Love is the one thing every flesh and blood loves to enjoy unconditionally. Like Jay Gatsby, many components of the paragraph in that opens the blockbuster Their Eyes Were Watching God plays into Janie Crawford and how she positions the gender roles that the author narrates. Janie experiences different kinds of love throughout her life. Unlike Jay Gatsby who experiences love early on and eventually goes searching for the love of his life.

Read More
1155 Words | 5 Pages

The Wrong Road to the Right Place Satisfaction is unreachable. There will always be a desire for more. For something that seems impossible. Yet one still strive towards it.

Read More
1336 Words | 6 Pages

Gatsby meets and falls in love with a girl named Daisy but he is too poor to support her and is tied into the war. After the war, Gatsby goes on to learn to play the role of a gentlemen and becomes very wealthy through engaged in illegal transactions that are only rewarding to his wallet. After altering his past and reshaping his present life Gatsby moves into a mason across from Daisy. Night after night Gatsby founts his money by throwing massive parties for all to join. He throws these parties and invites everyone in hopes that one day Daisy might come

Read More
747 Words | 3 Pages

F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby describes the life of Jay Gatsby in the 1920’s. The novel shares his love story and his loneliness. A major question the author raises is how does wealth impact class structure and society? Fitzgerald answers this question through the distinction between “New rich” and “Old rich” and the significance of East and West Egg.

Read More
447 Words | 2 Pages

Those who solely focus on wealth may have completely empty lives. In The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald highlights the fact that wealthy people have meaningless lives. He does this by using rhetoric that shows the carelessness, materialism, and ironies in their lives. In order to show this, Fitzgerald implements rhetoric and stylistic devices that show the emptiness of the characters throughout his novel that reinforces his theme that if materialism, not God, drives one, one’s dreams and hopes will eventually implode. To support his theme of emptiness, Fitzgerald facilitates ironic rhetoric to show the characters’ emptiness, weakness, and eventual destruction.

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

In the novel The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald characterizes the 1920s as an era of decayed social and moral values. One of the major themes explored in this novel is the Hollowness of the Upper Class. The entire book revolves around money including power and little love. Coincidentally the three main characters of the novel belong to the upper class and throughout the novel Fitzgerald shows how this characters have become corrupted and have lost their morality due to excess money and success and this has led them to change their perspective towards other people and they have been portrayed as short-sighted to what is important in life. First of all, we have the main character of this novel, Gatsby who won’t stop at nothing to become rich overnight in illegal dealings with mobsters such as Wolfsheim in order to conquer Daisy’s heart.”

Read More
1332 Words | 6 Pages

In F. Scott Fitzgerald 's The Great Gatsby, as Jay Gatsby delves into his pursuit of wealth and need for materialism, his hopes and aspirations become shattered in a world of unobtainable and unreachable possibilities. While Jay Gatsby confidently believes that material excess will ultimately bring about love, admiration, and prosperity, the audience understands that the possession of material objects does not always lead to the possession of these intangible virtues. The richest and happiest man is the one who sets the joy and happiness of others in the center of his wealth. As Jay Gatsby dedicates himself to winning over Daisy Buchanan and falls in love with her aura of luxury, Gatsby becomes overwhelmed with an unremitting desire for money and pleasure that eventually triggers his downfall. He has one purpose in life: to attract Daisy with his ornate house on West Egg and with his overflowing sum of money.

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

Gatsby Thematic Essay In the novel The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, lots of connections are drawn through various thematic subjects presented in this novel. One of these connections is between love, wealth, and social status, which are all very prominent subjects within The Great Gatsby. The relationships between various characters within the pages of this written work make one message very apparent: Love can be regarded as flimsy and deceitful when it is dictated by one’s wealth and social status.

Read More
1208 Words | 5 Pages

The Great Gatsby is a novel written by F. Scott Fitzgerald and narrated by a man named Nick Carraway. This novel was written with the intent of showing the readers how morally corrupt the 1920s were. Throughout the novel, characters abandon their moral values for a materialistic lifestyle. The novel depicts a great picture of the roles men and women played in the 1920s. Even with the changing roles of men and women, they continued to rely heavily on whom they were married to and what social class they belonged to.

Read More
1873 Words | 8 Pages

The characters in the novel pretend that they have their lives all figured out, but through their successes their downfalls and emptiness can be seen, to prove that money cannot buy happiness. Jay Gatsby is the newest and upcoming star in New York during the 1920’s. Through his business and inheritance he is one of the richest men of his time. One may think that his abundance of wealth would lead him to be eternally happy, but he is the opposite. Gatsby longs for his love of Daisy, which is his personal American Dream.

Read More

More about Similarities Between The Great Gatsby And Their Eyes Were Watching God

Related Topics

Open Document