ipl-logo

Similarities Between The Lottery And Harrison Bergeron

1108 Words5 Pages

Out of the the stories that are introduced “The Lottery” and “Harrison Bergeron” share a unique theme. In Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” the society is under an operation of justice that does not treat their individuals fairly. In the short story “Harrison Bergeron” which was written by Kurt Vonnegut the individuals are also under unfair scrutiny in their society . These short stories were written within the span of ten years apart. “Harrison Bergeron” was first introduced in 1961 and “The Lottery” in 1970. Jackson’s work portrays in a village where the characters partake in traditions that are highly coveted throughout the tribe. Vonnegut’s story “Harrison Bergeron” is based in a futuristic society where everyone is equal in every aspect. …show more content…

Through in these dire situations it can be looked at has unfair, but according to their society everyone is equal in each jurisdiction. In “The Lottery” Tessie Hutchinson, wife of Bill Hutchinson, is the enforcer of the event. She was outspoken at times, and concluded the tradition is not fair even though everyone has the same equal opportunity of being selected. When it comes down to the selection, she is livid over a tradition that has been practiced for generations. She has the right to because this tradition is misogynistic.”The ritual of the lottery itself like the society it seems to preserve, is patriarchal.”(Whitter). The society she is placed in is completely ran by the men of this establishment. The women were not allowed to even grab their own slips of paper for the lottery, their spouses were the only ones allowed. There was a widow among the crowd, so she was not allowed to draw. She had to force her son to draw for her even though she felt she herself felt he wasn't of age to do …show more content…

In “Harrison Bergeron” one character in particular is Harrison Bergeron. He was hampered with heavy handicaps throughout his entire life. He was blessed with the whole package, however with the government's strict rules he could not show his talents. Harrison fought vigorously for his freedom from his handicap that hinder his abilities. Although, he does go on to become a psychopath and declare he is emperor; He was drove through the harsh life he had to endure for being talented. Tracy Cross, who has a PH.D, elaborated on this injustice in a short article.Using that same understanding when thinking about the educational needs of students with gifts and talents creates an unnecessary limitation on their intellectual growth.(Cross). Cross elaborates that the children have the rights to social contracts that should further their gifts and talents.Cross also argues it should not be limited, but encouraged to further their minds to be special.Then goes on to mention the No Child Left Behind act that most states have implicated into their educational system. Leaving all of the specially gifted unchallenged in their environment. These acts will actually make the gifted students regress to just the minimum and not strive for more. In “Harrison Bergeron” the elders of this society control everything and make it impossible for anyone else to ever come to power. More than likely their own children resume their

Open Document