ipl-logo

Slave Narrative Critique

1843 Words8 Pages

“Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl”: Annotated Bibliography
Burnham, Michelle. “Loopholes of Resistance: Harriet Jacobs ' Slave Narrative and the Critique of Agency in Foucault.” Arizona Quarterly: A Journal of American Literature, Culture, and Theory 49.2 (1993): 53-73. Print.
In the article Burnham analyzes the loopholes of resistance and retreat not only in Harriet Jacobs ' Slave Narrative but also compares those elements and components to those used in the work of Foucault showing the philosophic background in the writing. The author evaluates specific individual subjects through the analysis of institutional structures and the impact of the surrounding environment on individuals. The behavior, actions and decisions of Harriet …show more content…

Foreman also focuses on the hidden and revealed meanings and topics in the slave narrative comparing it to another writing “Our Nig”. Thus, the author casts light on the literary tradition and genres of Afro-American women either living through the issues of slavery and related problems or witnessing those problems finding expression in their literary works. Foreman shows the parallel between Wilson and Jacobs, as well as other female authors of that period of time using different themes in their works and mostly showing the weakness and despair of women. Jacobs shows the inner strength and power of women who continue struggling with problems and challenges in their life hoping for the better and happier future, and this makes her different from other Afro-American women in the literary field. Foreman identifies the common aspects of slave narratives written by different authors, as that genre usually “combine elements of history, autobiography and fiction” (Foreman 314). Usually women tell their personal stories and suffering, conflicts and challenges experienced in the context of some historic events helping the readers to get involved into the context and understand the topics and meanings revealed in the writing. Such narratives help revealing the truth about the treatment of the black population attracting much attention to the problem and acting as a call for …show more content…

This book casts light not only on the meaning of the narrative but also on its impact on the community and acceptance of slavery in general. Frintrop stated that it was much more than “a typical antebellum slave narrative since it can be characterized as a public document which provides an insight into the spirit, psyche and history of an African American slave woman who fights for an antislavery reform” (Frintrop 2). The author identified many topics covered in the narrative, including the cultural discrimination and violent treatment of blacks by white Americans, the domination of white culture in the community, the suffering of women during slavery, and so on. Harriet Jacobs was the first black woman who was not afraid of describing slavery as it was in reality showing the challenges for female slaves and their treatment by white masters. Frintrop also focuses on the cult of true womanhood mostly linked to upper class, white women increasing the gap between poor blacks and white women in the community. The community created specific standards proving people 's status and behavior, and this only promoted the growth of slavery worsening the relationships between blacks and

Show More
Related

Harriet A. Jacobs Archetypes

127 Words | 1 Pages

Harriet A. Jacobs was born a slave in North Carolina in 1813 and became a fugitive in the 1830s. She recorded her triumphant struggle for freedom in an autobiography that was published pseudonymously in 1861. As Linda Brent, the book 's heroine and narrator, Jacobs recounts the history of her family: a remarkable grandmother who hid her from her master for seven years: a brother who escaped and spoke out for abolition; her two children, whom she rescued and sent north. She recalls the degradation of slavery and the special sexual oppression she found as a slave woman: the master who was determined to make her his concubine. With Frederick Douglass 's account of his life, it is one of the two archetypes in the genre of the slave

Read More

Angelina Emily Grimke

525 Words | 3 Pages

At the age of five, she witnessed the atrocity of a male slave being whipped to death. This monstrosity can be seen in the picture of a slave’s scarred back; seeing this, one can only imagine how it affected Sarah. Only three years later, the slave girl her father had assigned “constant companion,” suddenly died. Sarah was compelled to lobby for equal rights for women because of her lack of education as a young woman. She dreamed of continuing her education, but this was denied to her by her father because she was a woman.

Read More

Harriet Ann Jacobs Research Paper

341 Words | 2 Pages

Professor James T. Downs gave an interesting lecture on the masking of epidemics after the civil war. His take on the Harriet Ann Jacobs’ story was something that extremely captivated me because I had not known much about her story. Harriet Ann Jacobs exposed the reality of what it meant to be a slave and gave a different perspective from that of Harriet Beecher Stowe. Despite all, she did to expose the conditions that former slaves lived in, and the progress that she helped create in the 19th century, many whites did not believe that Jacobs wrote her own story. This was due to the basis that she was poor and black.

Read More

Significance Of Incidents In The Life Of A Slave Girl

1718 Words | 7 Pages

Harriet Ann Jacobs known to the public as Linda Brent and Frederick Douglass both were the victims of slavery and succeed to escape its clutches. As they possessed the skill of literateness, after becoming free members of the American society, they decided to write down their experiences of living as slaves to share what they had witnessed. Consequently, “Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl” is the fruit of Linda Brent’s labor, and Frederic Douglass delivered his testimony in “Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave”. Additionally, this is not the point where their similarities diminish. They were also involved into abolitionist movement and work as social reformers which gained them recognition and esteem amid Northerners.

Read More

Essay Comparing Frederick Douglass And Harriet Jacobs

486 Words | 2 Pages

After having read both Frederick Douglass’s Narrative and Harriet Jacobs’s Incident 1. How were Douglass and Jacobs similar and different in their complaints against slavery? What accounts for these differences? In both the inspiring narratives of Narrative in the Life of Fredrick Douglass by Frederick Douglass’s and in Incidents in the life of a slave girl by Harriet Jacobs the respective authors demonstrate the horrors and disparity of slavery in there own ways.

Read More

Slavery DBQ Essay

1572 Words | 7 Pages

After the plantation revolution in the 1600s, slavery became a horrible institution driven by the mass production of goods by white slave-owners who were looking to succeed economically. Slaves were treated as disposable commodities and lived hard lives under the brutal hand of their slave-owners. By the 1800s, slavery was natural and very common in the south, and was justified because African Americans were seen as an inferior race who were uneducated and incapable of engaging in society. Since slaves had no political power, especially in the south, they could not fight for their freedom; most were uneducated, so they could not write their accounts down; and even when slaves successfully escaped north, they had a hard time communicating with

Read More

Harriet Jacobs Research Paper

188 Words | 1 Pages

Jacobs later began “to contribute her life story to the abolitionist cause in a way that would capture the attention of Northern white women in particular, to show how slavery debased and demoralized woman” (Baym, 921). Jacobs wrote an autobiography on her life as a slave little girl. In her book she described the kind of treatment African

Read More

Similarities Between Frederick Douglass And Harriet Jacobs

415 Words | 2 Pages

Slavery Frederick Douglass and Harriet Jacob’s stories vary vastly from previous narratives; as former slaves rather than as white northern abolitionists. While both write on their own personal experiences, each autobiography varies deeply in how they chose to write their stories. In Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, Douglass has a primary focus of slavery on a larger level, while in Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl Jacobs focuses her individual relationships and the effects of slavery on them. Although Douglass relies on the power dynamics of slavery to promote abolition, Jacobs uses the communal relationships amongst slaves and slave owners to achieve the same purpose, therefore both use their relationships

Read More

Harriet Jacobs's Incidents In The Life Of A Slave Girl

277 Words | 2 Pages

Harriet Jacobs's autobiography, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl (1861), is the most generally perused female before the war slave account. In relating her background before she was free, Jacobs offered her contemporary readers a startlingly sensible depiction of her sexual history while a slave. Although a few male creators of slave accounts had alluded to the exploitation of oppressed African American ladies by white men, none had tended to the subject as specifically as Jacobs at last decided to. She archived the sexual manhandle she endured, as well as clarified how she had conceived an approach to utilize her sexuality as a methods for staying away from misuse by her lord. Taking a chance with her notoriety in the revelation of such

Read More

Incidents In The Life Of A Slave Girl By Linda Brent

1738 Words | 7 Pages

In 1861, Harriet Jacobs publishes the first full-length slave narrative written by a woman under the pseudonym Linda Brent. In her autobiography, titled Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl, Harriet shines a light on the sexual harassment women endured under the system of slavery, however, with the Civil War in its midst the book didn’t get the attention it deserved until it was later recovered and widely published during 1987. Harriet takes the cultural narrative of the time period, men are superior and a woman's place is in the home, and effectively crafts her own story while dismantling these views (James 1-2). Simultaneously, Harriet grapples with telling the story of Dr. Flint’s, Harriet’s master, sexual pursuit of her and abiding by

Read More

Dr. Jacobs Ethos Of A Fallen Woman

680 Words | 3 Pages

Analogous in form to the spiritual autobiography, the slave narrative emphasizes the difficulty of upholding moral goodness under the weight of slavery. By revealing herself as a “fallen woman” Jacobs creates a hazardous problem, capable of eliminating the sympathies of a primarily white audience. Moreover, Jacobs risks portraying herself as an impure woman, whose virtuousness departs from the piousness and gracefulness typically exemplified by the ideal woman or “angel in the house,” according to the “Cult of True Womanhood.” Therefore, in an effort to preserve the ethos of her argument, Jacobs attributes her unchaste condition to the systemic effects of American slavery. Hoping to destroy the ideology of benign paternalism, Jacobs reveals her consequential ethical dilemma through a faint description of her master’s, Dr. Flint’s, licentious behavior.

Read More

How The Life Of Frederick Douglass Dehumanize

1972 Words | 8 Pages

Throughout American history, many sources display the era of slavery, but little of them exhibit slavery as well as a book called, “Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass.” This book represents an accurate first-hand account of slavery that allows historians to analyze the era of slavery today. According to this narrative, there were many dehumanizing aspects of slavery, which include physical torture and forcing inhumane lifestyle onto slaves. Many of these scenarios of torture were demonstrated in expansive, horrific detail throughout the narrative. Although slaves were immensely dehumanized, this historical piece humanizes Frederick Douglass along with African Americans as this narrative is a marvelous piece of literary art with many

Read More

Jacobs Incidents In The Life Of A Slave Girl

387 Words | 2 Pages

I believe that Jacobs’s treatment of gender in Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl is utilized to emphasize the challenges and hardships that were unique to enslaved women. Jacobs’s focus on enslaved women helped to garner sympathy from her audience that was made up of primarily white, Northern women. The audience is also educated through her autobiography and many misconceptions about slavery held at the time are dispelled in her narrative. An example of an idea about slavery that Jacobs’s narrative corrects is the idea that enslaved women are “sapphires” or “jezebels” who seduce men. White male slave owners used this idea of black women as a way to justify their rape and sexual assault.

Read More

Fredrick Douglass And Harriet Jacobs Narrative Analysis

520 Words | 3 Pages

In Fredrick Douglass and Harriet Jacobs narrative they show how the institution of slavery dehumanizes an individual both physically and emotionally. In Jacobs narrative she talks about how women had it worse than men did in slavery. While men suffered, women had it worse due to sexual abuse. The emotional, physical, and sexual abuse was dehumanizing for anyone.

Read More

My Slave Narrative

707 Words | 3 Pages

William Henry Singleton, a native of North Carolina and former slave, shares his life of both a slave and a soldier in his narrative “Recollections of My Slavery Days”. Singleton was born on August 10, 1835 in Newbern, North Carolina (1). He recalls how is birth was not that great for he was “a black man” (1). According to him, because he was black, it was “believed that he had no soul” (1).

Read More

More about Slave Narrative Critique

Related Topics

Open Document