ipl-logo

Softwood Lomber Dispute Between United States And Canada

787 Words4 Pages

Introduction
The softwood lumber dispute is one of the longest and controversial trade disputes between the United States and Canada. The dispute actually represents a number of disagreements due to the difference in lumber “production” process in Canada and the US, which affects the trade between the two nations. The disagreement began in the early 1980s, when the US lumber producers complained to the US Department of Commerce about the unfair practices of Canadian lumber industry and it is still a talking point in today’s negotiations and a solution for this problem doesn’t seem to be imminent and practical. At the heart of this long-lasting softwood lumber debate, is the United States' claim that the Canadian government is unjustly subsidizing …show more content…

In 2016, it: accounted for about 7% of Canada’s total exports, injected roughly $23 billion into Canada’s economy, directly supported about 211,075 jobs across the country, including an estimated 9,700 Indigenous people and generated more than $1 billion in revenue (2015) for provincial and territorial governments.1 Canada is one of the largest lumber producers and exporters in the world. Around 80% of the Canadian timber production is intended for export, making it a vital aspect of the Canadian economy. Canada sells its forestry products to over 100 countries; its biggest export markets are the United States, the European Union and Japan. The US is heavily dependent on the import of timber from Canada, as domestic supplies are insufficient to meet the customers’ needs. Softwood lumber (cedar, Douglas fir, pine, spruce) is extensively used throughout North America in building constructions, furniture, interior and exterior woodwork, etc. In addition, one of the major current problems that Gordon Ritchie, the former Canadian ambassador for trade negotiations, pointed out in his discussion on “Sunday Edition” is that Canada heavily depends on trade with the US. Over the past decade, most of the Canadian policies were short-sighted, meaning that Canada was more focused on improving trade relations with the US than with the rest of the world. As there is a pretty high chance that the NAFTA will be dissolved in the near future, the trade barriers will go up between these two countries and it will result in firms panicking in the short run2. They will start to contract their production, and they will start laying off staff, as a necessary procedure to decrease their cost. This will affect all of the industries across the country, including the lumber industry (even though NAFTA doesn’t include barriers reduction of the lumber industry, but as all industry contracts, it will inevitably negatively impact the lumber

Show More
Related
221 Words | 1 Pages

In 1968, and MacDonald & Owen Company started their company. Archie Macdonald, who already was very successful in the lumber company business decided to take a risk and start his own company Mr. Macdonald built his company upon” high-quality and unbelievable service” that is still the drive of MacDonald & Owen today. “Profits will come if you just do it right”, is a quote that is used with MacDonald & Owen’s employees and this slogan continues to dictate all business transactions with the company’s customers and vendors alike. In 2001 leadership of MacDonald & Owen was fully turned over from Archie MacDonald to its current owner, David Twite.

Read More
628 Words | 3 Pages

Controversy Surrounding the Keystone XL Pipeline To build or not to build, this choice will impact the relationship between the US and Canada and determine the level of dependence the US will have on countries that are not so friendly. “TransCanada’s proposed Keystone XL Pipeline would transport oil sands crude from Canada and shale oil produced in North Dakota and Montana to a market hub in Nebraska for delivery to Gulf Coast refineries. The pipeline would consist of 875 miles of 36-inch pipe with the capacity to transport 830,000 barrels per day” (Parfomak, Pirog, Luther and Vann 4). The construction of the Keystone XL Pipeline would strengthen the United States economy, provide energy security and have minimal environmental impact. “The Keystone XL project would create $1.1 trillion in private capital investment at no

Read More
1127 Words | 5 Pages

While both Pennington and Baker are covering the 1891 and 1911 elections respectively by looking at the two different parties, the Liberals and Conservatives, both are quick to point out, if not consciously, that making free trade the key election played to MacDonald's, and the Conservatives' strengths, while taking advantage of Laurier's, and the Liberals', weaknesses surrounding free trade. The combination of the articles serve as a direct contrast between the Liberal and Conservatives during both the 1891 and 1911 elections, due to the fact that free trade, in even the smallest of possible formats, became the central election issue. According to Pennington there was a clear division within the Liberal Party itself over this issue, with the intellectuals within the Liberal Party aware that even pushing any form of free trade would be fine line between in-acting legislation that was enough to satisfy the biggest proponents of free trade, the farmers in the rapidly expanding western provinces, while

Read More
611 Words | 3 Pages

The disputes that revolved with a strong stance taken was that any magazine that was printed outside the country and imported was considered foreign with a tariff enforced at the border entry point and preferential tax deductions for advertising could also be made on the same determinations at the borders. This has helped in the increase of internally produced magazines sales,job creation and feel of patriotism by the indegineous canadians other than having imported media and news about your country

Read More
1213 Words | 5 Pages

100,000 manufacturing jobs were lost to the FTA in the early 90’s,a burden which fell disproportionately onto poor working class women, centred mostly in Quebec. Restructuring meant a relocation of jobs from native industry towards a growing service economy, with the frictional unemployment of this time increasing poverty rates by 17.8% by 1995. Fiscal policy during the Mulroney years mirrored the United States in its gradual reduction on social spending and the continuing transfer of taxation from business income to the incomes of Canadians. Fearful that higher regulation would result in further capital flight, the Mulroney conservatives found capitulation an easier pill to swallow. Canada’s trade relationship with the United States understandably increased, rising to 73.5% of total export in 1989 to 80.8% a decade later.

Read More
1003 Words | 5 Pages

However, this system would not be fully realized until the 1930s (443). Laurier also attempted to gain access to the American markets through ‘trade reciprocity,’ which had been negotiated and re-negotiated since before confederation (Beaulieu and Emery 1083). However, these deals were subject to the ire of Canadians and Americans alike. Laurier’s Trade reciprocity involved the comprehensive and simultaneous decrease in tariffs on certain goods between Canada and the United States (Beaulieu and Emery 1083). While the agreement was approved in America, there was some consternation over the deal in Canada with the Conservatives fighting the deal in the House (Beaulieu and Emery 1083).

Read More
903 Words | 4 Pages

Following the Stock Market Crash in 1929, Canada and the rest of the world reached all time low economic statuses. Farmers occupied Canada’s Prairies at the time predominantly

Read More
715 Words | 3 Pages

Just 29 years after the American Revolutionary War, America and Great Britain were back to butting heads. This time it was not over the matter of independence, but over a cluster of reasons. Little by little, the British were starting to disturb the Americans. These reasons included British attempts to restrict U.S. trade, the Royal Navy’s impressment of American seamen and the arming of Native Americans. During the war, the Canadians sided with the British while the indians chose to fight on both sides.

Read More
1133 Words | 5 Pages

As it stands, however, Canada’s environmental policy has been very poor, consistently ranking as one of the worst offenders, when compared to other developed

Read More
656 Words | 3 Pages

Reciprocity and free trade are two distinct debates which has occurred at separate periods throughout Canadian history. Both are periods in which the Canadian and U.S. governments attempted to broker a deal which would lower tariff walls and allow good to move smoothly between the countries. Reciprocity occurred in 1911 when the Prime Minister Laurier attempted to implement free trade with the U.S. Free Trade is prominently in terms of the 1980’s in which the government under Brian Mulroney wished to once again implement a free trade deal with the U.S. in 1911 free trade was defeated and the government of Robert Borden won an election on the issue. In 1988 once again an election was held on the issue of free trade, this time it was successful and implemented following the election. Free trade has had a very significant history within Canada.

Read More
636 Words | 3 Pages

Idle No More is a movement that emerged in late November 2012. It is a movement that was created to protest the passing of Bill C-45. It is created by four women in Saskatchewan: Nina Wilson, Sylvia McAdam, Jessica Gordon, and Sheelah McLean (Graveline, 2012: 293). The movement is indigenous led, with a large percentage being youth and women organizers, and is a grassroots movement. Thus meaning that all the protesting and raising awareness is spread locally and then nationwide.

Read More
1167 Words | 5 Pages

The relationship between the United States and Canada is another great result of the interplay of democracy and political culture and one of the greatest results of the was the NAFTA. There have always been people who were not particularly happy with the relationship of Canada and U.S, especially those who felt like it was not benefitting Canada, and there also people who doubted that the free trade agreement would ever work. As Inwood states, “the great debate that raged in Canada around the 1988 election concerning free trade was deeply resonant of the political culture of the country and touches on all aspects of public administration” (p.47). The arguments against free trade stated that Canada would not be able to integrate well into the system and that there would be more to lose than gain, while continentalists felt that it was nothing more than an opportunity and economic arrangement (Inwood, p.47). Canada had to make sacrifices when it came down to decision-making and traditional trade remedies, “Moreover, in political culture terms, the free trade debate has become a flash point for those who argue for the supremacy of the free market versus those who argue for a positive, interventionist state-all of which has a direct impact on public administration” (Inwood, 47)

Read More
533 Words | 3 Pages

The welfare state developed in Canada because of the influential effect of business that has a powerful relationship with the federal government, even at times where Conservative or Liberal parties were in power. Through economic development, the state helped raise the qualifications for the labour force, while reducing their expectations at the same time. Along with that, the state gave businesses its bailouts, subsidies, funding guarantees, and infrastructure, at this time. Comparing Canada and the United States helps to outline what is discrete about Canadian politics. In Canada, businesses were never exposed to the same kind of strict anti-combines rules and regulations as those found in the US.

Read More
768 Words | 4 Pages

People who observe Canadian politics agree that there are divides along regional lines within the country that have political consequences (Cochrane and Perrella, 2005). To understand western alienation in Canada, one must first understand the terms regionalism and alienation. Regionalism can be thought of as an individual’s sense of belonging to a particular neighborhood, province, city or area (Cochrane and Perrella, 2005). Alienation is the sense of being ignored, marginalized or left out. Western Alienation, therefore, refers to the sense of alienation felt by the western region of Canada compromising British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba from the central provinces of Ontario and Quebec.

Read More
1220 Words | 5 Pages

Canada is an international leader in forest management in my opinion based on several fact and statistics. We live in a world today where we need to realize and understand the importance towards sustainability. Sustainability holds powerful meaning when introduced into the term ecological footprint, Canada does an exceptional job at managing our forestry and sustaining in proper means. Canada’s commitment to monitoring has pulled us aside from the rest of the world. Our forest laws and harvest regulations go hand in hand with each other, this affects our economy.

Read More

More about Softwood Lomber Dispute Between United States And Canada

Related Topics

Open Document