Summary Of Dialectical Journal For Sal And Phoebe

1441 Words6 Pages

Chapter 1: Sal and Phoebe: Deeper Meanings. My thoughts on Salamanca have always been varying. At first, I saw her as rude, or stubborn, “I was not sweet that day. I was being particularly ornery. I wouldn’t sit down and I wouldn’t look at Margaret.” (Walk Two Moons, 10.) But then I realized that she had a good reason. She had lived in the same house her whole life, and she was suddenly moved to this “pint-sized,” or, “pocket-sized,” (Walk Two Moons, 11,) house, she had very good reason to be stubborn. I grew to love Sal. Her oddities, her bravery, her orneriness. She became a best friend to me. Having the book in her perspective was interesting. Her thoughts and feelings often sounded like things I would think, or even say at times. …show more content…

I think she also wrote it like this to show how their relationship, their stories, contrasted with each other. This is something that took me more than one read to work out. In Walk Two Moons, everything is not crystal clear. There is a lot of foreshadowing and a lot of hidden themes, but that’s what makes it so good. This relationship between Sal and Phoebe represents the whole book. With everything that changes in just a few pages, and how everything correlates with everything, it is just like the relationship between them. And just shows how life isn’t solid black or white, but every color in the rainbow and …show more content…

I think that the only true differences are the characters, such as the grandparent's plot having Gramps, Gram, and Tom Fleet was only in that plot, but the Phoebe plot had many characters, such as Ben, Phoebe, Mary Lou and her family, Mr. and Mrs. Winterbottom, Prudence, etc. I think that another difference would be the point of each plot. The grandparent's plot was trying to show Sal’s relationship with her grandparents but was also showing parts of Sal’s past life the intertwined with the story. I think that the point of Phoebe’s story was to show how Sal’s past with Phoebe affected her everyday life, and how Sal felt about some things she would not have been able to blankly state out loud, such as feelings about her father’s relationship with Margaret Cadaver, or Ben. I think that both plots have more similarities than differences, but the differences are more physical or surface-level, and the similarities are deeper meanings that were developed through truly analyzing the book and that differ from the reader’s