ipl-logo

Summary Of Mistreatment Of Dead Bodies By Joel Feinberg

753 Words4 Pages

In this article, “The Mistreatment of Dead Bodies,” author Joel Feinberg argues the misunderstanding of using cadavers for organ donation, and research. Feinberg discusses the modern issue many people have with attaching sentimental value with a dead body, letting their values outweigh and halt the necessary uses for cadavers (31). Cadavers being used for medical training, organ donation, and forensic research, provide as great utility for people. Feinberg states that in 1978, a dispute between a California Congressman and The Department of Transportation developed when The Department of Transportation began to use cadavers in place of dummies in collision tests for more detailed research. These detailed tests would cover every gruesome angle …show more content…

Despite their plea against the Congressman’s request, The Department of Transportation faced setbacks in their for years (31). Feinberg points out that many people (like the Congressman) don’t seem to have a problem with typical research done in a lab on a cadaver, yet when the setting changes to a more distasteful extreme (Like smashing a cadaver into a wall), a person’s view on the research does too. Feinberg addresses this issue as “appeal to sentimentality,” that is, individuals place value on symbols, ignoring real life issue (32). He goes on to acknowledge this argument through William May’s, “Harvesting the dead”, which outlines the argument of sentimental value placed in dead people, stating how using them in any weakening manner also weakens sentimentality for humanity (34). Feinberg addresses May by pointing out how sentimentality over a dead body should be the last thing in consideration when it comes to a person’s life, concluding that a person in desperate need of an organ is far more valuable than a cadaver that’s no longer using the organ …show more content…

We all are really nothing more than organic tissue. Feinberg does an excellent job at drawing out the problem people have getting attached to the dead. He shows that we are attached emotionally to the dead as our treatment towards such represents our humanity. Yet I don’t think he looked deep enough, only skimming the surface as to why we have a problem with using cadaver unconventionally. Feinberg concludes the reason for the disgust people get when observing corpse being used as test subject is based on the value we place on corpses; He draws the line there and really goes any deeper into the reason for the sentimentality. I think the reason for the sentimentality, and the symbolism placed on a corpse is the based on the value we have for ourselves. Where Feinberg sees sentimentality and symbolism on the dead as an ideation of a person’s humanity, I see the it as maps to a deeper underline issue, the thought of lost. People our selfish, and despite how negative that sounds its true, and good that we are. Our selfishness is the reason we invest so much time into ourselves, keeping our bodies nourished and growing. This selfishness is why we mourn death, the company of other helps us grow, and keeps us supported. When a person dies, we lose that support. Everyone has evolved with this type of need for other. The idea of loss and not being anymore

Show More
Related
815 Words | 4 Pages

In a small Southern California town, a woman calls police to report her husband never returned from his afternoon run. The police determine that Robert Dorotik was a marathon runner and suspected he had experienced a medical episode until they discover his body the next morning. Initial examination indicated death by blunt force trauma to the head. Additionally there was a rope around Bob’s neck and signs of strangulation. The tire tracks around the body implied the body had been dumped at the location.

Read More
331 Words | 2 Pages

In the short passage by Kierstin Koppel titled “Humanizing Morticians,” she uses a lot of figurative language to give a mortician a wonderful personality. Koppel’s first sentence even depicts a very vivid scene, “The corpse lies bare under a white sheet waiting to be dissected and reconstructed through a series of surgical procedures” (Koppel). This sentence does not only describe an interesting scene, but it also grabs the reader’s attention by explaining what the passage is going to be about. Later, Koppel begins to explain her own point of view when it comes to being a mortician.

Read More
373 Words | 2 Pages

Many bodies are donated to science but they are not all treated well. David Wagoner Professor of anatomy at Indiana University wanted the bodies to be treated fairly. The meaning of the David Wagoner poem Their Bodies is that the students of Indiana University should be gentle with the bodies. In the first stanza of the poem it describes how his parents were good people and then the second stanza says that the students should treat them just how they would have treated them. The second stanza says, “You should treat them One last time as they would have treated you” (Wagoner 2.2-3).

Read More
1622 Words | 7 Pages

Mistakes are inevitable. Before Hurricane Katrina most individuals evacuated the areas that were likely to be flooded. Hospitals, including Memorial, were not required to evacuate like everyone else. This meant that over two hundred patients were still in the building and even more staff when Katrina hit. Five Days at Memorial by Sheri Fink explores what happened inside the hospital during the aftermath of the storm and the legal battles that persisted long after the week people were trapped inside the building.

Read More
712 Words | 3 Pages

There have been numerous cases where false conviction has ruined someone’s life. This too, happened to Tammy Marquardt (Wynne), a middle-aged woman currently 43, who had lost all three of her sons during her early twenties due to the false charges of smothering and murder that imprisoned her. It changed her life completely. She would have never expected to go from being a regular single mom to being a criminal, but she did. This is her story.

Read More
1109 Words | 5 Pages

“The Immortal life of Henrietta Lacks,” is a realistic account of an African American woman in the 1950’s who is now known to have immortal cells in the scientific community. Henrietta Lacks had her cells stolen from her in 1951 at Hopkins hospital after being diagnosed with cervical cancer. The term stolen is used to describe taking something considered valuable to another without permission. Surprisingly, even after her death, Ms. Lacks’ cells continued to grow at a rapid growth and have been involved in the advances of the polio vaccine, cloning, gene mapping, invitro-fertilization, and a tool for curing cancer.

Read More
662 Words | 3 Pages

Jessica Mitford paints a very satirical picture of the world of embalming and uses her many talents to convey her claim that embalming is ridiculous and that people need to know what exactly they’re paying for. Her tone, style, and use of quotations remains solid throughout and never falters or has her readers doubt her

Read More
1289 Words | 6 Pages

“The Forgotten Dead” written by authors Carrigan, William D and Webb, Clive is a book about the mob violence against Mexicans in the U.S from 1848-1928. This book in an attempt to figure out who these women and men were, why they were lynched and by who, when these events occurred and where, and most importantly, why were their deaths forgotten. The Forgotten Dead provides substantial evidence of how such a violent period could have occurred and why it was over looked by so many in history. Webb and Carrigan contend that mob violence against Mexicans was forgotten because it was never fully studied, lynching’s were divided amongst black and white ethnicities, and there was an enormous amount of animosity towards the Mexican population at the

Read More
649 Words | 3 Pages

People experience severe loneliness and depression after the loss of a loved one. Immediately following the death of a loved one people begin to regret the time they could have spent with them. They feel as if they took advantage of their happiness

Read More
860 Words | 4 Pages

Blood was not the only remains used from dead people, other parts of the body was used that was believed to restore patient’s health. “Human fat was supposed to alleviate rheumatism and arthritis, while a paste made from corpses was believed to help against contusions” (Bethge). It was thought that the dead would help cure sickness the living had but it did not save many lives. The living would get sicker which lead to death. Consuming humans was not an effective technique to cure

Read More
495 Words | 2 Pages

In her 1967 essay Behind The Formaldehyde Curtain, Jessica Mitford utilizes the rhetorical devices of diction and verbal irony to illustrate the unthinkable, little-known truth behind the North American funeral industry and its manipulation of death. Through her choice of diction used when describing the process of an embalmment, Mitford shows us the horrifying and questionable truth behind it, prompting us to question the American funeral industry's ethicality. In the 9th paragraph, Mitford states during an embalmment, the blood of the deceased person "is drained out through the veins”. The word “drained” could’ve easily been replaced with “removed” or “extracted”, both of them being more suitable and correct terms, but the author chose it because it has a negative

Read More
578 Words | 3 Pages

Because of this visualization, I appreciate the author’s professional discussion of a process which could be considered grotesque. For instance, Roach describes each stage in the process on a cadaver known as “H” who, at first, does not “feel or smell dead” and “looks very much alive inside” (480). Then, by the end of the process, “H” appears dead with “her skin dried and dulled at the edges of incision” (Roach 484). Roach offers additional detailed, scientific descriptions of the organ

Read More
691 Words | 3 Pages

Memory and imagination are central to story telling. Janet Burroway’s non-fiction piece, Embalming Mom, juxtaposes between the present, in which the author is writing, and into the realm of memory and imagination. This short work of creative non-fiction, utilizes memory and imagination from the author’s past in order to cope with the memory of her mother’s death. The author starts out speaking to her mother that she is going to write her into a story. Janet and her mother argue about her role in the story.

Read More
572 Words | 3 Pages

Every single human life is valuable, but is every life worth the same? Some say yes, some say no, but there is no clear-cut answer. The argument consists of two primary reasons for valuing a life: sentimental value, and financial value. Balancing these ideals is a difficult process that normally is avoided, but when fate brings death, they must be brought to light.

Read More
1141 Words | 5 Pages

“Killings” written by Andre Dubus is focused on the main character and protagonist Matt Fowler. Matt is the father of three known children in the story, Cathleen, Steve, and his youngest, Frank. Matt had his children with his wife and business partner Ruth Fowler. In the beginning of the story Matt is laying his youngest son, Frank, to rest in the cemetery after he was brutally murdered by the story’s main antagonist, Richard Strout. At the time of his death, Frank was in school and majoring in economics (63) and had a very bright future ahead of him, after all, he was only twenty eight years old.

Read More

More about Summary Of Mistreatment Of Dead Bodies By Joel Feinberg

Related Topics

Open Document