I agree that McGinn 's theorem seems more appealing than Judaism 's laws due to the ethics behind it. While yes Judaism 's laws for treating animals are clear cut, they are only there to emphasize how the person could treat other people around or near them. While in McGinn 's theory, he states that animals should not be treated and used like inanimate objects. Finally he defends his points on animal treatment in the Vampire, and Shuman scenarios which lead me to lean towards his theory instead of Judaism 's
My uncle’s mother suffered from a disease, I’m not sure what it is, but similar to the speaker of the poem I was in a second person perspective because personally I didn’t know her very well, but could feel the sorrow in the people around her. The disease in which my uncle’s mother suffered from made her “live in the past” as she had almost no recollection of what was currently going on. Similar to the speaker saying “He remembers himself, / A younger man, in a tweed hat (A)”, as My uncle’s mother remembers herself when she was taking care of my uncle in his youth, since she would carry a large teddy bear around in which she treated like a baby. Along with remembering herself when she was younger, my uncle’s mother completely forgot her love or care for her family currently, as she lives in her own world.