ipl-logo

Summary: The Real CSI

579 Words3 Pages

My thoughts
Forensic science is used everywhere. It can be used to arrest and convict someone of a crime. Before watching The Real CSI video, I thought using fingerprints and DNA will get you 100% accurate results. Throughout the video my thoughts about the subject began to change.
In the beginning of the video they claimed that fingerprint identification is infallible, that you’ll be one hundred percent certain with a zero percent chance you’ll be wrong. That was not the case with the Brandon Mayfield case. In the year of 2004, there was a series of explosions in a Madrid subway. It killed and injured nearly two thousand people. After the explosions they found partial fingerprints in a plastic bag that contained the detonators. The examiners analyzed the prints, ran them through the system, and linked them to an attorney in Portland, Oregon named Brandon Mayfield. He claimed he was not a terrorist, that …show more content…

He claimed he was working at a bar filled with customers when the crime was committed. With all of his alibies, he was still charged with a crime he didn’t commit all because they found bite marks on the little girl’s wrist that seemed to match up with him. He was later released from prison when the true murdered was caught.
Is DNA a reliable forensic tool?
I feel that DNA is the only reliable forensic tool because its principles are example of real science. Mentioned in the video, forensic science was developed by law enforcement, but DNA analysis was developed by medical science. A much more reliable source. There may be certain situations where DNA isn’t the best tool to go off of. Like for example if there isn’t an enough quantity of it at the scene of a crime or if it has been mixed with someone else’s (Kaye and Sensabaugh, 2000).
What about

Show More
Related

Evidence Surrounding The Serial Podcast: The Case Of Adnan Syed

940 Words | 4 Pages

His fingerprints were found on a map that was in the glove compartment of the victim's car. The map had the defendant's fingerprints on it, which suggested that he had handled the map at some point. This was used as evidence that he had been in the car around the time of the murder; However it just tells you that he touched a map that was in her car, they were in a relationship so they would have been physically intimate with each other. The presence of his fingerprints on the map found in the victim's car was used as evidence against him at his trial. The serial podcast goes through each one of these outcomes and Sarah Koenig shows that the evidence that they put into the trial should not have been admissible.

Read More

Field Observation Report Stephen Peters Trial

1163 Words | 5 Pages

They also explained how investigators and the detectives investigated the Peters car in quadrants where they take a wet swab and then dry swab to find any prints on or int the car. In addition they fumigated the car and wear orange goggles that help them find more prints and evidence that the human eye can't see. All of these scientific investigative evidence procedures can seem to be detrimental to Herring. However, we learned in class that the CSI effect has no meaningful impact between forensic science show viewers and non-viewers when it came to convict or acquit a defendant. Research suggests that the CSI Effect benefits the prosecution is a myth.

Read More

Penal Code 1405 Research Paper

1964 Words | 8 Pages

The Department of Justice says, "States began passing laws requiring offenders convicted of certain offenses to provide DNA samples. " That DNA evidence can help convict someone of a crime and it helps to uncover more things about the crime itself. Investigators have been using forensic science to help them solve cases since before the 90 's, mostly fingerprints that were found at the crime scenes and on the victims (O 'Brien). DNA evidence has solved countless cases including ones that happened over a prolonged period of time because of the technological advancements there is

Read More

The Fingerprints Of Surratt And Anderson

963 Words | 4 Pages

In the box that contained Cook, he had eleven different fingerprints on the lid. The fingerprints on the tape could not be determined by the forensic expert, Lancon because although he knew who the fingerprints belonged to, he had no idea when the fingerprint was placed. The state only had three fingerprints that connect to Surratt and two prints on the tape that connected to Anderson. On top of that, they ran into a problem where Anderson testified she helped Cook and Kirby move into her trailer, so her fingerprints would show up on the tape because she helped seal everything that was being loaded into her trailer as Cook and Kirby were going to be staying

Read More

Texas Servant Girl Murders (HDSI)

1333 Words | 6 Pages

Comparing simple techniques simply to retrieve a piece of evidence is completely different as we learn more about the science and learn from the mistakes made in the past. Looking back at the 1800’s and comparing the technology of the 21st century, the difference is certainly huge. The increase in technology makes information more vast and more ideas can be shared easily. Many sciences are based off many “what ifs” while forensic science is more factual and attempt to solve puzzling occurrences and events and get down to what truly

Read More

Deconstructing The CSI Effect: Forensic Science And The Media

1731 Words | 7 Pages

(Explain why & cite source)Also Abby’s idea of using computer programming for reinventing the crime scene, to better understand that the shooter was a sniper, wouldn 't be accessible either.(explain why & cite source) Fisher also explains that DNA cannot fall under the assumption of “DNA doesn 't lie.” The reason is because of The Innocence Project, which assist in wrongful convictions of DNA testing. Television explains that any technology identification is 100% correct, no errors can be made.

Read More

Amanda Knox Case: Defense Of Fallacies Of The Guilty Verdict

1251 Words | 6 Pages

However, after a critical examination of the evidence revealed serious flaws in the case against her with lack of forensic evidence, lack of motive, and improper collection of evidence. One of the most important pieces of evidence in a court case is the forensic DNA evidence. At the crime scene, there was

Read More

Research Paper On Brandon Mayfield

599 Words | 3 Pages

Brandon Mayfield was wrongfully accused of being the bomber in 2004 Madrid Train Bombings. On March 11, 2004 Al -Qaeda inspiring terrorist initiated a bomb attack on the train killing 193 people and wounded over 1,000. As a result, the crime was investigated, and two fingerprints were retrieved from a bag. When the fingerprints came back there were 20 possible matches, and Brandon was one of them. In the past Brandon was in the military and was arrested for a misunderstanding, which caused his prints to be in the system.

Read More

Dennis Brown Dna Evidence

1097 Words | 5 Pages

An absurd amount of innocent people in the nation, have fallen victim to a disorganized legal system, and are suffering because of it. Dennis Brown, and James Harden, are two examples of this, and can relate because of it. They’ve been falsely convicted, without DNA evidence, but the truth of the case is finally revealed with their release. Dennis Brown, a black male from Louisiana, has been one of many people that have been wrongfully convicted without proper DNA evidence. First off, he’s been falsely convicted of rape and burglary.

Read More

CSI Agent/Forensic Science Technician

2181 Words | 9 Pages

Being a CSI agent offers tons of exciting action with interesting daily tasks, mental challenges, and modest educational requirements compared to most occupations. CSI agents experience many interesting daily tasks, they first walk through the crime scene to determine what evidence is available and collect it. According to Chron, DNA experts use bodily fluids and substances to identify criminal subjects even in cases that are very old. Using small details such as fibers, hair, paint, glass, pollen and food residue, that discovers case specifics. This shows that CSI can uncover things with the smallest pieces of evidence to catch suspects.

Read More

Dna Fingerprinting Lab Report

1726 Words | 7 Pages

This was achieved by identifying the suspect. According to the gel, suspect number two’s DNA was found at the crime scene. This is known because the crime scene DNA and suspect two’s DNA both traveled the same distanced. And said before DNA is very polymorphic; no two pieces of DNA will be the same when cut by the same enzyme (Edvotek, 2014). This is also shown in Hyun-Jung Choi’s lap report.

Read More

Long Beach Crime Lab Case Study

320 Words | 2 Pages

What equipment they had to use and what evidence they could process onsite. Also what evidence which gets sent to the LA crime lab, were they have more equipment to process the evidence. They only had a handful of employees who had one area they worked on and they solely work in that area. Each person in the lab had to be able to lift fingerprints, and collect evidence. But, then they only focus on one part of the evidence.

Read More

A Good Girl's Guide To Murder Sparknotes

562 Words | 3 Pages

Murders that are left unsolved leaves family members puzzled and wondering. It is important that we solve murders so we can stop the victim from doing it again. I already know a bit about DNA evidence from my KWL chart crime research, but I would need to learn more about its specific application in cold cases. In my preliminary research, I learned that DNA has helped solve many cold cases over the years. There have been cases where decades-old evidence was retested with updated technology and resulted in identifying the victimizer.

Read More

Forensic Science Case Study

665 Words | 3 Pages

Science has come a long way over the years. It has helped countless every day struggles and cure diseases most commonly found. What you don’t hear about however is the advancement of forensic science. Forensic science has helped solve countless cases of murder, rape, and sexual assault. In the case of John Joubert, it helped solve the murders of three young boys with one small piece of evidence that linked him directly to the crime.

Read More

Importance Of Dna In Forensic Science

1251 Words | 6 Pages

DNA in forensic science The majority of cells making up the human body are diploid cells carrying identical DNA, with the exception of haploid gametes and red blood cells. Several types of biological evidence such as blood and hair are commonly used in forensic science, which is the scientific study of evidence for crime scene investigations and other legal matters. Forensic science is used for the purpose of DNA analysis, this is the analysis of DNA samples to determine if it came from a particular individual. DNA analysis is done by obtaining DNA samples from an individual; next, a large sample of DNA is produced from amplified selected sequences from the DNA collected.

Read More

More about Summary: The Real CSI

Related Topics

Open Document