ipl-logo

Susan Moller Okin's Justice, Gender, And The Family

696 Words3 Pages

In Justice, Gender, and the Family, Susan Moller Okin presents a critique of modern theories of justice. She claims that these theorists make fatal assumptions regarding justice in the family. For example, she claims that John Rawls assumes that a family is inherently just and fails to consider how gender fits into the original position and veil of ignorance. He neglects the difference of opportunity in the family and the way that gender has a role as the primary school for justice. Okin believes that women must be included to create a satisfactory theory of justice that remedies the modern inequalities that we still see in families today. I am going to extend Okin’s claims to the institution of arranged marriages, specifically in the Indian culture. It is important to understand arranged marriages because they perpetuate societal and gender injustices through it’s process.
Okin describes the asymmetrical aspect of power in the family and the vulnerabilities of marriage. She claims that women are susceptible to the vulnerability with the anticipation of marriage. “The cycle of women’s …show more content…

If we apply the veil of ignorance to this system taking into account gender, in theory each person would understand the injustices that are continuing and attempt stop them, because they may be in that situation. Arranged marriages would give each gender equal opportunity to voice their opinions in the matchmaking process. Families would understand that there should extra pressure to ensure that one gender know a specific set of tasks because they are expected to once they are married. Under the veil of ignorance, people can truly understand and attempt to remedy the injustices that may be overlooked. Susan Moller Okin is able to stress to us the necessity of considering gender when formulating theories of

Show More
Related
426 Words | 2 Pages

In India almost all weddings are arranged by parents; As Nanda mentions, “I must let my parents choose a boy for me because here we have a chance to enjoy our life and let our parents to do this work and warring for us” (479), a quote from an educated Indian girl. But in the US, American parents rarely arrange the marriage their children. Nanda compares and contrasts

Read More
1657 Words | 7 Pages

The film "Dadi 's family" is about a family in Northern India. In the movie, we are introduced to a family that consists of a big extended family living in one household. This film explores the idea of family and the roles that women play in Dadi’s household. In the film, we are introduced to six roles that are performed in the day to day household. The six roles exposed in this film are the roles of women as a daughter, mothers, mothers-in-laws, daughters-in-laws, sister-in-laws, and sisters.

Read More
1612 Words | 7 Pages

However, today there is growing awareness of how harmful they can be, especially for young women. Arranged marriages lack the element of love and mutual consent, leading to a lack of normalcy for young women. This part of my essay will talk about the dangers of arranged marriages for young women. Firstly, arranged marriages restrict young women’s freedom of choice. In many cases, young women are forced into marriages against their will, often for the sake of financial gain or to maintain social status.

Read More
1559 Words | 7 Pages

Since the earliest times in history, women were treated inferior to men. From birth, she would face constraints on her economic independence, legal identity, and access to her property. These restraints would narrow her choice of marriage or spinsterhood. Her economic dependency was ensured by her father or husband, and women were not permitted to own land (Berkin 4-6). After she wedded, all of a woman’s rights and property became that of her husband's (Berkin 5-6).

Read More
594 Words | 3 Pages

The document "On the Equality of the Sexes" by Judith Sargent Murray reveals the author's arguments on gender inequality in America. Published in 1790 in the Massachusetts Magazine, Murray's thoughts on the matter of women's education stems from her own experience on denied opportunities because of her gender. She was not allowed to attend college for the simple fact that she was a female, but had studied alongside her brother while he was preparing for college. This shows that despite her sex, she was just as capable as a male in terms of intellectual capacity and it was unfair that she was not allowed to further this pursuit.

Read More
1024 Words | 5 Pages

Baier also gives the example of childrearing and how it is usually women who disagree with this method because of “justice perspectives”. Another issue that arises is the difference between the justice and

Read More
342 Words | 2 Pages

Susan Okin argues that public sphere as well as private sphere are both relevant when talking about power, fairness and justice. Men are dominant in public sphere; where they rule and govern, but their self -interests are somehow restricted by the laws of the society. On the other hand, an individual family setting also constitute of a patriarchal society. Where men show dominance over women (wife, mother or sister), makes decisions for them sometimes even against their will. Okin is totally against this and demands for equal rights for the role of women in both public and private sphere “It is clear that the structure of the family and the distribution of roles and responsibilities within it must be significantly altered in any theory in which

Read More
1678 Words | 7 Pages

Women are told that they should feel lucky if a man chooses to marry them. We see an example of an arranged marriage in the film when we are introduced to Darshini, who is the first daughter in law and Sita who is the second daughter in law to Dadi. Darshini and Sita had arranged marriages with Dadi 's two sons. The process of Darshini and Sita being arranged into marriage is that both of the women were forced to leave their homes and start their new lives in Dadi’s home. Inside the household, the film shows some of the aspects of the daily lives of the daughter-in -laws.

Read More
984 Words | 4 Pages

and Berland Associates from November of 2008, states that the majority of people in the United States view the treatment of women at home as equal to men, whereas in the press, workplace, political settings, or the armed forces, treatment does not remain equivalent in treatment (Scherer 26). Progress has made steady yet gradual milestones towards the goal regarding women’s rights, but when it comes to the question of when dramatic change should take place, “the time is now”

Read More
528 Words | 3 Pages

Therefore, arranged marriages can and will lead to losing money for both spouses, startup family feuds, and cause a child of that parent to fell that they have no power to pick their own person to start a relationship with. The information from these paragraphs proves and shows why arranged marriages can lead to an awful lifetime for that certain person. The reader who is reading this argumentative essay should listen to these arguments about how arranged marriages will most likely ruin your

Read More
1297 Words | 6 Pages

Love, Trust, and Family Renowned film critic Roger Ebert has praised Mira Nair’s Monsoon Wedding for the way that it “leaps national boundaries and celebrates universal human nature.” Indeed, despite the many differences that seem to divide people, there are also aspects of life that are present in the lives of everyone that can be used to relate and understand those with a different background. Throughout the story, the creators allow their audience to relate to a traditional Indian family through the emotions they share with the characters and the way that they deal with issues involving, love, trust, and family while still understanding the many differences between traditional American culture and the culture of those within the film.

Read More
1086 Words | 5 Pages

Arranged marriage is a controversial practice in many cultures around the world. However, studies have found that roughly 85 percent of Indians prefer to engage in this tradition, and have a higher rate of marrital success than a marriage based on personal choice. (Dholakia, 4) Yet, even considering these statistics, it remains a concept that is met with dissapproval, thought to be archaic and demeaning to those involved. Chittra Banerjee Divakaruni’s short story Clothes depicts a young woman transition, from being obliged to follow this cultural norm, and the shifts in her mentality throughout this process. It is not unreasonable for the reader to view the protagonist, Sumita, to be a victim of this presumably inhumane practice.

Read More
877 Words | 4 Pages

In our advanced 21st century, it is hard to imagine our society as anything short of perfect. After all, we have come a long way from our seafaring ancestors. However, the reality is that despite how we may sometimes avoid seeing it, our society is anything but perfect. A very prevalent issue today is that despite laws being set in place to enforce the equal treatment of men and women, women all over the world today still face poor treatment and discrimination. Because of how deep and long this problem has run, revising discriminatory laws may not abolish discrimination and legislating laws that endorse gender equality may not necessarily create equality.

Read More
1282 Words | 6 Pages

Gender Inequality Gender inequality is a characteristic of social structure according to which different social groups (in this case men and women) have certain differences resulting in unequal opportunities. Gender inequality is associated with social construction of masculinity and femininity as oppositional categories with unequal social value (Ferree, 1999). One of the main problems in gender theory is the problem of dominance. Together with race and class gender is a hierarchical structure that could to provide both opportunities and oppression (Ferree, 1999). Gender inequality can exist in different forms, depending on culture, region, religion and other factors.

Read More
1707 Words | 7 Pages

In her essay “Justice, Gender and the Family”, she claims that the prevailing theories of justice exclude the system of gender and the traditional family as settings where justice standards should also be applied, resulting to family issues negatively impacting women’s equality of opportunity. Justice in the family is necessary for justice in greater society to happen. Okin believes that gender inequalities should be addressed legislatively, such as anti-discrimination employment laws and paid maternity

Read More

More about Susan Moller Okin's Justice, Gender, And The Family

Related Topics

Open Document