ipl-logo

The Argument Against Animal Bill Of Rights

1004 Words5 Pages

In the past few decades, humans have become more and more self-centered rather than becoming more aware of the dangers they are putting animals through. Animal right activists have been trying to put a stop to harmful animal experiments which in the end are only benefiting humans. The Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) is a well known group that for the last 36 years has been trying to establish an Animal Bill of Rights in order to protect animals’ legally. The presented Bill of Rights would protect animals from life-threatening experiments as well as provide safety to their physical and psychological necessities in order to live a healthy life. Animals should most definitely not be given a Bill of Rights in order to secure them from inhumane …show more content…

As stated by ProCon.org, more and more evidence is being aroused about animals becoming “largely ineffective” when being used to test new medicine (Akhtar). Medicine is used in the everyday lives of humans, animals are not the same therefore they do not react to certain things they way humans do. Animal testing is not as accurate as humans were led to believe, money is being wasted for no reason since the medicine does not end up working on humans. Scientists are a major group that would disagree on the fact that animals are not similar to humans. Humans have evolved from apes; justifying that humans and animals really are similar. On the one hand, the ALDF has a strong point about the way humans treat animals, but creating a Bill of Rights to protect animals is exaggerating. The argument for an animal Bill of Rights by the ALDF addresses a major issue. The United States has already enforced laws and acts to protect animals from being treated poorly by humans; it is up to the humans to take into action those …show more content…

The group points out the fact that animals are not given the same rights as humans in their argument when they make the statement “deprived of legal protection.” In other words, the ALDF has a vision that all animals should be treated the same as humans in every aspect. The ALDF has yet to grasp the concept that animals do not have the cognitive ability to understand rights, if given any. According to BBC News, animals are considered to not have a “sense of morality” or “an understanding of their duties” when put up with others; therefore they should not be given the same rights as humans (Bennett-Jones 2). An animal’s brain is not wired to work the same as a human’s; which does not allow them to understand concepts such as legal rights and protection. Philosophers, such as Rene Descartes, have proven and informed others that animals are “no more than complicated biological robots” which only displays how animals are not as complex as the ALDF describe them to be (Descartes BBC). An ape, for instance, has the complexity to learn sign language, animals such as koala’s or giraffe’s do not have the same wired brain. Infinite amount of Animal Right Activists may disagree with the thought of animals not being able to grasp the idea of having rights and protection. While it is true that some animals have been taught sign language, most have not,

Show More
Related

Summary: Do Animals Need A Bill Of Rights

486 Words | 2 Pages

Animals having rights will change medical research, for example, If we do not have animals to experiment on to cure cancer, positive medicine for illness or disease then the death rate will go up. Testable Samaniego 1 products that a person uses on a daily bases such as, make-up, skin products, hair products, etc. Experiments can also be a good use to animals, “a 300 pound gorilla named koko was taught sign language and has mastered more than 1,000 signs and understands several thousand english words.” That being said, animals can be a helpful use for many things, making the world a better place.

Read More

Blackfish Bill Of Rights

615 Words | 3 Pages

This law would hinder medical research. There won't be that much of an impact if some animals were to get a bill of rights. In the film blackfish it showed how the whales get frustrated of being in a pool their whole lives, that's why they sometimes attack the trainers at Seaworld. Studies done by Rifkin showed that apes show the skills necessary to learn sign language. Some animals are need of a bill of rights because there's people that have domesticated animals and all they do is mistreat and abuse them.

Read More

Change Of Heart About Animals 'By Jeremy Rifkin' Hooked On A Myth

1066 Words | 5 Pages

Bill of Rights for Animals Animals may not reason, talk but they can forsure suffer. In the articles, “A Change of Heart About Animals” by Jeremy Rifkin “Hooked on a Myth,” by Victoria Braithwaite, both authors attempt to persuade us that we should enforce a bill of rights for animals. Therefore, the human race have to be obligated to not pass those limits for animals and their rights, because animals are vulnerable and defenseless. They are so similar to us, humans, so shouldn't they be treated with the same rights we have? Why do they have to be discriminated because their called animals?

Read More

ASPCA Interest Groups

1035 Words | 5 Pages

As we know, most of the time, there is loopholes, and where there is loopholes, there is exemptions to the mistreatment of these defenceless animals. Primarily, these include agriculture animals that Americans consume such as cows, pigs, chickens. Secondly, animals used for their fur such as bears and sheep. And lastly, animals that are used for experiments. These animals are the “loopholes” according to David Masci, who surveyed 1,003 Americans on how they view animal rights.

Read More

Machan's Arguments Against Animal Rights

1408 Words | 6 Pages

One topic that many scholars are debating right now is the topic of animal rights. The questions are, on what basis are rights given, and do animals possess rights? Two prominent scholars, Tom Regan and Tibor Machan, each give compelling arguments about animal rights, Regan for them and Machan against them. Machan makes the sharp statement, “Animals have no rights need no liberation” (Machan, p. 480). This statement was made in direct opposition to Regan who says, “Reason compels us to recognize the equal inherent value of these animals and, with this, their equal right to be treated with respect” (Regan, p. 477).

Read More

Analysis Of Francione's Argument For Animal Rights

1030 Words | 5 Pages

Furthermore, animals have different demands, wants and needs compared to humans as they are different species that live under different conditions, where humans do not know what the animals want as there is no communication between the animals and humans. Therefore, each species should have a different type of lifestyle and different rights, so the authors argument towards animals and humans having similar rights is irrational. In addition, the authors are against the property of animals by humans yet have six dogs as pets which make them hypocritical since these pets are considered their property. They cannot set an example towards the issue they are discussing, which is the rights of animals not to be property, when they are going against their own argument by having six animals as their

Read More

Animal Bill Of Rights Essay

1225 Words | 5 Pages

Animals help us with many other aspects of life, and have since way back when. Cows help keep fertilized land, lambs provide us with wool, and horses provide us with transportation and sport. The animal bill of rights prevents these animals from being used in our society, thus leading to the destruction of mankind. If we were to stop using these animals to our benefit, we won’t be the only ones suffering. Cows will be unable to stay alive due to predators, domesticated pigs will soon die off from years of being babied by humans, and cats will eventually take over the human ratio by how frequently they reproduce.

Read More

Animal Bill Of Rights Essay

768 Words | 4 Pages

Animal bill of rights Animals play an important role when it comes to a person's average life, but is passing a bill for animal rights going too far? Many will be supportive for passing the bill, but some like myself are a bit skeptical about the idea of animals getting full rights. The animal bill of right's goal is to give animals a voice and protect them from abuse, experimentation, and free them from in captivity. That seems like a great idea for the short-term, but how will it affect our medical research, economy, prices on leather, food, and most importantly the future for all animals?

Read More

Animal Bill Of Rights Essay

591 Words | 3 Pages

Some states, explicitly criminalize a failure to provide an animal in one’s care with adequate food, water, veterinary care, and shelter. Other states cover these violations under vague neglect laws with no clear definitions or minimum standards of care outlined, leaving their interpretation to the whims of law enforcement officials who may be untrained in animal care standard. It would cause other problems because a quieter story has been unfolding behind the scenes in laboratories around the world-one whose effect on human perception and our understanding of life is likely to be profound. And these fellow creatures are more like us than we had ever imagined. Pressured by the animal rights activists and by growing public support for the humane treatment of animals, these companies have financed research into, among other

Read More

Bill Of Animal Rights

614 Words | 3 Pages

If animals have a Bill of Rights then this would affect us because how would we know if the cure for cancer or other diseases really work. If the scientist does the test on a human and it goes bad, the human will die. A Bill of Rights for animals would hinder medical research for doctors and other specialist. Animal and humans are very similar; we have the same organ systems performing the same task in more less than the same way. A human is more valuable than a cow or a pig, that is a fact.

Read More

The Argument For Animal Rights

633 Words | 3 Pages

Animal rights have and always will be a topic of heated controversy and debate, with both sides having their own good and bad points. There is a wide array of mistreatment amongst animals in today’s society, specifically in zoos, which can be said to be prisons for animals. It is an issue of paramount due to the fact of shared similarity between humans and animals, including some animals having high emotional intelligence. Although, it is an unclear issue, and currently I am unknown to a solution and what is right, due to my lack of awareness of the issue and knowledge of zoos, also added to the fact of the morality issue of what is right and wrong since animals tend to be valued less than humans.

Read More

Arguments Against Animal Rights

767 Words | 4 Pages

If people love animals so much why would they mistreat them? “Tens of thousands back laws in narrow areas: animal rescuers may support anti-tethering laws to ‘stop irresponsible owners', misguided home breeders back anything labeled as fighting ‘puppy mills,' and animal shelters support close regulation of pet breeders and rescuers.” (Defending the Freedom to Own Pets). In 1966 the Animal Welfare Act was put into place to help animals that are in need. Animal rights are important because they protect animals against animal abuse, animal containment, and animal smuggling.

Read More

Arguments Against Animal Rights

2004 Words | 9 Pages

The poor treatment of animals is achieved by the fact that there are not enough laws to protect the rights that they cannot establish for themselves. In order to protect these helpless animals, there needs to be a larger amount of ways to go about decreasing the abuse inflicted upon them. The ways that animals are treated is unfair, immoral, and unethical. Animals are taken advantage of in a variety of ways such as household abuse, farm factories,

Read More

Animal Rights Research Paper

691 Words | 3 Pages

For many years now, there has been many people wondering if animals should have rights and how we should treat them if every animal can feel just like us human beings. I feel like animals should have rights because reading all these articles about researchers talking about how animals feel pain when we hurt them or separate them from their families that the animals become emotionally destroyed through what we do. “The petition calls out for the rights of all animals to be free from exploitation, cruelty, neglect, and abuse and enumerates further rights for laboratory animals, farm animals, companion animals, and wildlife”. At the same time there’s farm animals that are being treated really badly because of the way the food market is now,

Read More

Arguments Against Animal Rights

1463 Words | 6 Pages

Animal Rights Animals are being abused every single day and no one really stops the abusers. Nearly half of all animals that arrive in American shelters are euthanized because of a lack of adopters and space. So every week there is at least 80,000 euthanized. Half the population about animals and their rights. Animals are being used and beat like pitbull or any dog fighting, cock fighting, over breeding with poor care, and some people are even animal hoarders.

Read More

More about The Argument Against Animal Bill Of Rights

Related Topics

Open Document