ipl-logo

The Columbian Exchange: Film Analysis

2022 Words9 Pages

The Columbian Exchange was a term coined by Crosby in 1972 describing the environmental effects of Columbus’ discovery of the continents of America. This phenomenon essentially led to the homogenisation of the New World and the Old World with the exchange of animals and plants and therefore to some extent the environment of both worlds. However, the emphasis on the advantages the Old World had over the New World and the large losses of lives of the New World natives as a result of the exchange might skewer the magnitude of the impacts of the exchange on both worlds. For instance, the exchange may be portrayed as a one-sided complete take over and transformation of the New World by the Old World rather than as a mixing of different aspects of …show more content…

Instead of the image of Europeans transforming America in their image, the film describes a new global environment born from the interaction of the New World and the Old World after the Columbian Exchange. Highlighted in both films is the horse and its establishment with image of the Native American. The horses that escaped ran wild and flourished in the wide plains of North America. This was a blessing for the nomadic tribes in the Central Plains who then domesticated these wild horses which helped them in their bison hunts (Kersken & Trebbi, 2009). This shows an emergence of a new culture from the mixing of the New World and the …show more content…

Domesticated animals were a key reason for difference between the level of civilisations in the New World and the Old World and along with diseases, gave Europeans an advantage in the New World. Although the Columbian Exchange saw the exchange of animals and plants between both worlds, the impacts on the New World were portrayed to be of a greater magnitude to the extent that the New World was almost transformed into the image of the Old World (Kersken & Trebbi, 2009). This portrayal focuses on the mortality of the natives and the ecological imperialism but takes attention away from other interactions between the New and the Old World. Therefore, a more balanced view of the Columbian Exchange creating a new global environment from both the Old and the New would be more reflective of the current world we live in where environments are no longer isolated from one another and can affect one another at many different

Open Document