ipl-logo

The Framing Of Immigration By George Lakoff And Sam Ferguson

967 Words4 Pages

There are millions of undocumented immigrants that are living along side with the 300 million Americans in the United States. In the article, The Framing of Immigration, by George Lakoff and Sam Ferguson, undocumented immigrants are negatively framed or labeled as “illegals” because of their status. They believe that they should not be labeled as “illegal,” rather they claim that undocumented immigrants should be not framed as “illegal” and be treated equally just as American citizens. The undocumented are not criminals nor terrorist, they are humans and they deserve a chance. Lakoff and Ferguson also emphasize that America should not solve the immigration problem on its own. With these reasons, they use evidence such as the House of Representatives …show more content…

George W. Bush used the reform as a platform to express the issue that undocumented immigrants come to America to take away jobs and use public services illegally (18). This frames undocumented immigrants as “illegal” and are directly labeled as a criminal just like murderers and rapists (Lakoff & Ferguson, 21). The word “illegal” is not a correct term for undocumented immigrants since the word is dehumanizing (20). No immigrant should be seen lesser than a human just because they do not have documentation. Lakoff and Ferguson counter argue their position by commenting that in today's society we do not call others who break the law “illegal.” Murderers, burglars and kidnappers are not labeled as "illegal" even though they have broken the law. So why should undocumented immigrants be the only ones framed as "illegal?" Lakoff and Ferguson emphasize that undocumented immigrants that cross illegally are not committing a crime of a high degree such as murder, but instead are committing a "violation" which is less extreme …show more content…

They argue that the only way that this immigration problem can be solved is if America does not work on its own but work alongside with other countries that have high emigration rates to find solutions to stop people from leaving their homelands (Lakoff & Ferguson, 26-27). If the immigration problem can be reduced starting from the migrants home countries, there would be less people traveling to America. Lakoff and Ferguson acknowledge the idea of increasing the border security and respond by emphasizing that higher security will lead to more dangerous crossings, and people will do whatever it takes to cross, causing more casualties

Show More
Related
483 Words | 2 Pages

In his opinionated news article, “Ignorant Immigration Reform”, author David J. Bier asserts his opinion on a bill that will reduce the legal immigration by 50% in the United States. Bier supports his position by discussing how the bill won’t reduce immigration, stop the way immigrants are affecting the Americans wages and how they’re following Canada’s footsteps by concentrating on the skilled immigrants. Bier’s purpose is to notify the government of basic facts that they should know before making such claims, in order to bring into light what the real issue is. He writes in a very direct and sincere tone for the government and general public to inform them on false information that the government is claiming that the bill will do. Bier makes it very clear on where he stands on this issue by using credible facts, briefly explaining the opposing side's viewpoint, but he also shows that he’s very bias.

Read More
157 Words | 1 Pages

Jason L. Riley is an American journalist, who works as a member of the editorial board of the The Wall Street Journal editorial board. Some of this work includes “Mistrusting Obama on ISIS—and Refugees”, “Liberals Don’t Want a Discussion About Race”, “The False Income-Inequality Narrative”, and a lot more articles. In “The Mythical Connection Between Immigrants and Crime”, Riley discusses how it is not true that immigrant are not criminals. He argues that” that immigrants—regardless of nationality or legal status—are less likely than the native population to commit violent crimes or to be incarcerated”. I will use this article to argue against the claims that some people make against undocumented immigrants, on how every undocumented immigrant

Read More
661 Words | 3 Pages

Bob Dane, the Executive Director of Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), believes that the immigration system is broken and in need of repair and reform. He said that FAIR’s positions are on immigration policy not immigrants themselves. But I struggle with this statement because immigration policy and immigrants are directly intertwined. You cannot influence immigration policy without affecting the lives of immigrants everywhere. Since my group is researching whether religious and faith-based organizations should be free to serve illegal immigrants regardless of their legal status, we asked him about the relationship between immigration and justice.

Read More
1703 Words | 7 Pages

Annotated Bibliography Beadle, Amanda Peterson. " Top 10 Reasons Why The U.S. Needs Comprehensive Immigration Reform." ThinkProgress. © 2016 - Center for American Progress, 10 Dec. 2012.

Read More
372 Words | 2 Pages

Many scholars have broadly revealed the guises under which U.S. immigration policies have racialized and criminalized immigrants from Mexico and other Latin American countries by engaging them as low-cost employment without offering paths for citizenship (Chock 1996). Immigration Policy does not want the ‘illegals’ to be anything but. Because it benefits the system to have them. Yet here we have all of these nominees trying to stop the ‘immigration problems’, and as Lakoff’s framing article explains. One cannot understand the issue as a cheap labor issue when it is framed as an ‘immigration problem’; concurrently a solution to the ‘problem’ will never address cheap labor since it is not within the immigration framework (Lakoff 2009).

Read More
590 Words | 3 Pages

Illegal immigration has raised the question: should illegal aliens stay in America? By letting them stay, they pose as a potential threat of copious issues. Some Americans postulate that everyone deserves a chance at a better life, and then there are some Americans that do not desire foreign invaders inside their home country. The issue is that many immigrants are drawn to America like a magnet because of the American dream. The conception of this is to live a vibrant and prosperous life, by hard work and dedication.

Read More
311 Words | 2 Pages

In the actuality there are two types of immigrants. There are the “Aliens” which is an extremely discriminatory term; these immigrants from Europe and several countries overseas that come to the United States with a Visa and they remain in the country illegally after their visa expired. On the other hand, there are the ones who cross the borders illegally; these immigrants are called “Undocumented” because there is no record of them. It is basically as if they did not exist. Homeland Security has no idea that they are in the country.

Read More
1769 Words | 8 Pages

“The American story is a story of immigration. I would be the last person who would say immigrants are not important to America.” — Phil Graham, circa 1960. This quote may be from the mid-20th century, but it keeps its significance with the everlasting controversy on immigration and immigration laws. However, this is not the only time that the United States has experienced immigration controversies.

Read More
1078 Words | 5 Pages

Undocumented immigrants live with fear of deportation every day of their lives. Those with control of state institutions who do not consider undocumented immigrants as worthy American residents in our society, take advantage of their power by instilling fear of deportation. The restrictive federal and state laws towards migration in the U.S. has become a way to keep undocumented immigrants and their families living in the shadows. Arrocha (2013) claims that the paradox of the U.S. migration seems be that our free democratic republicanism is viewed as the land of freedom, equality, and justice. Yet, these undocumented immigrants aren’t treated equally or given the freedom to live in our society without intimidation.

Read More
1020 Words | 5 Pages

Immigration has always been a major part of American history. Each year, hundreds of thousands of people travel to the United States in search of a better life. Of the 1.49 million immigrants who traveled to the United States in 2016, 150,400 immigrants were from Mexico. There have also been many people from Mexico who have immigrated illegally to America, with 5.6 million Mexican unauthorized immigrants living in the U.S. in 2015 and 2016. The large scale of immigration, both legal and illegal, has brought up issues such as national security and the U.S. economy.

Read More
526 Words | 3 Pages

However the reform did nothing about removing the immigrants who remained illegal. The reform was also unsuccessful because during the draw up of the bill, the bill's sponsors ended up watering down the sanctions on employers to attract support from the business community. Under the final law, all employers had to do to avoid sanctions was to make sure their workers had paperwork that "reasonably appears on its face to be genuine. " If the documents were decent fakes, that wasn't the boss's problem. So with there being such an easy way out of punishment employers continued to do as they pleased.

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

To the people who live here in the united states hearing illegal immigrants, they automatically think “mexicans” or as should be called hispanics. To those who known that they are coming here illegally or know that they are already here, they know them as hard workers, family oriented people, people who want better than what they had in their country. The united states is not really impacted by illegal immigration in a way that they make it sound. They are the ones who are helping the U.S. in jobs no one want to do as in working in the farms and picking crops.

Read More
1125 Words | 5 Pages

In some people’s minds, they automatically assume yes, but in reality, it’s a no, immigrants tend to perform labor, and do minimal jobs that Americans don’t, and won't do, so they mistake that as immigrants taking ‘Americans job’, but it’s actually a missed opportunity. One reason for people not taking the jobs is because of the hours, the next reason is the pay might not satisfy a legal immigrant, and people born in America, another reason is it wouldn’t be able to support a regular American family, but they will be able to support an illegal immigrant. The downside is that the policymakers disagreement is the weak labor since the spread immigrants flow has made a dramatic change seeing that the H-B has issued down by twenty- five percent in 2010. The last reasoning is American people want to have a debate on if immigration is stealing American jobs, but according to evidence immigrants actually increases job opportunity and incomes of Americans. This is wise because even George G. Borjas’s long-run estimates suggest that immigrants raise the wages of people with high school diplomas.”-

Read More
850 Words | 4 Pages

The United States of America, being a country founded by immigrants, is known all over the world as the land of great opportunities. People from all walks of life travelled across the globe, taking a chance to find a better life for them and their family. Over the years, the population of immigrants has grown immensely, resulting in the currently controversial issue of illegal immigration. Illegal immigrants are the people who have overstayed the time granted on their US, visa or those who have broken the federal law by crossing the border illegally. Matt O’Brien stated in his article “The government thinks that 10.8 million illegal immigrants lived in the country in January 2009, down from a peak of nearly 12 million in 2007.”(Para, 2) While some argue that illegal immigrants burden the United States of America and its economy, others believe that they have become essential and are an important part of the US, economy.

Read More
1397 Words | 6 Pages

In other, words the government should focus on fighting terrorism and violence. Instead of deporting innocent people. Blaming immigrants for crimes committed in the U.S. is not going to solve the problem. Crime is not a valid reason to prevent and block the passage of an immigration

Read More

More about The Framing Of Immigration By George Lakoff And Sam Ferguson

Related Topics

Open Document