ipl-logo

The Killer Elite: Twain's Argument Against Elitism

1705 Words7 Pages

The Killer Elite: Twain’s Argument against Elitism Throughout human history, a key question among philosophers has been whether or not elitism, or a sense of superiority over others, is good. Mark Twain attempts to answer this question in his novel, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, as he delves into the effects of elitism on society. Twain argues that elitism should not exist in society because it gives people a sense of superiority over others that they will abuse to gain power and control over people. Twain believes that elitism prevents society from advancing as oppressive “elites” lead to unnecessary deaths and discontent. Twain believes that if people feel superior to their peers they will abuse this power to control people even …show more content…

Huck says: “they took their guns along… and [kept] them between their knees… It was pretty ornery preaching—all about brotherly love, and such-like tiresomeness” (121). The author’s word choice, such as equating “tiresomeness” with brotherly love, shows Huck’s sarcasm in describing the sermon. Twain utilizes this sarcasm to shows his doubt that there exists brotherly love between the elites. Twain’s ironic depiction of elites bringing guns to a church, which is supposed to be a place of peace, hints that even if the elites are offered peace, the thirst for superiority would overpower the call for peace. The readers see the elite’s negation of peace right after the sermon when Harney Shepherdson tries to run off with Sophia Grangerford so they can marry. The nobles react violently to this, in contrast with the scene of the sermon where the pastor was calling for peace and love. A gunfight starts between the Grangerford and Shepherdson families that results in the death of Buck Grangerford and his nineteen year old brother. Huck comments in reaction to the Shepherdsons shouting “Kill them, kill them!” as the Grangerford brother tries to escape the gunfight: “It made me so sick I most fell out of the tree… it would make me sick again if I was to [retell how the Grangerfords were killed]” (127). Twain argues two things in this scene. First, he reiterates his point that the elite would ignore peace and choose violence in order to settle disputes in order to maintain superiority. This is shown through the violent reaction both families have towards the marriage. Marriage represents a call for peace and settling all disputes between the two families. It represents a creation of a bond between the two families. It also means that the families would consider each other their equals,

Show More
Related
339 Words | 2 Pages

These actions do not represent well mannered and civilized Christians. Huck believes that this service is “crazy and wild” thus proving that Christians act like buffoons. The juxtaposition of Huck’s thoughts and the Christian’s action reveal the irony of this situation. Huck, the child, is the only rational one which shows that Christians can not behave reasonable despite them being the adults. This emphasizes the fact that

Read More
1258 Words | 6 Pages

Between the church revival mob and the duke and the king as well as the lynch mob scene all topped off with the Grangerfords and the Shepherdsons feud, we find an abundance of examples against human weakness. One thing that Twain wants to warn against is that we can be so swept up in the moment in a crowd that we loose our own opinion and voice as our voice becomes that of hundreds or thousands. Twain also wants to bring to light that people don’t see their actions as negatively in a group than alone. Why could this be? Probable because we think of them as actions outside of ourselves.

Read More
1306 Words | 6 Pages

Twain highlights the absurdity of these characters’ religious beliefs further with the picture of guns stacked in the corner of the church, which is bizarre. Church is a place for to receive forgiveness of your sins, but the Grangerfords and Sheperdsons take guns for protection against each other, failing to see the absurdity of their behavior. Twain is criticizing society by depicting the

Read More
513 Words | 3 Pages

Twain begins by comparing patriotism to religion. In both, one lives by a constant set of rules established by a higher force: the nation’s leader(s) in patriotism and God in religion. However, Twain also separates the ideologies of traditional patriotism and American patriotism, where politicians and the media are the rulers. Twain does this to signify that we are followers of Patriotism, just as many are of religion.

Read More
536 Words | 3 Pages

Money and fine clothes could not mend the defects or cover them up; they only made hem more glaring and more pathetic.” (136)Even though he was a “white man”, he still acted as a slave. Twain is proving that the nurture, or family that someone is raised by shapes their true

Read More
744 Words | 3 Pages

The two families meet together at a church service; the service is about brotherly love (Twain 110). Everyone comments on how inspiring the message was, but yet they are murdering each other whenever they have the chance (Twain 110-111). Both of the families act like hypocrites, and Twain uses them as satire to point how society

Read More
2101 Words | 9 Pages

On their journey, they meet people from different walks of life, engage in a decades long feud, and even attend a circus. However, this novel is not all fun and games. Mark Twain blatantly demonstrates his beliefs in

Read More
676 Words | 3 Pages

Huck begins to see the hypocrisy between the family feud as they begin to bring guns to church. For a white man to commit such an amoral act of possibly disrupting peace in a tranquil community is something greatly satirized by Twain indicating that all whites no matter their class or wealth have all committed amoral acts, some to a higher degree than others. Huck thinks to himself while seeing the families fight says “It made me so sick I most fell out of the tree… I wished I hadn’t ever come ashore that night to see such things” (152). The family feud that has lasted for years had only caused pain for both families, something long forgotten but still continued satirizes the way that slaves are abused.

Read More
1270 Words | 6 Pages

“Always do what is right. It will gratify half of mankind and astound the other,” as Mark Twain states on morality. Huck exemplifies this statement perfectly through his morally sound actions and defiance of the crude normalcies of this time. In Mark Twain’s novel, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, the reader can see how Huck’s morals are put to the test through his inner conflict with society’s norms and what they consider to be the right thing to do. Huck confronts slavery, frauds, dishonesty, and social norms.

Read More
1740 Words | 7 Pages

These families are breaking the rules of society and bring negativity into church. Bringing the guns builds a contrast to the preaching about brotherly love. Church is supposed to be a place of peace and freedom in opinion. Twain uses this scene to criticize how people practice religion and to change Huck’s view on religion. People just follow religion without thinking.

Read More
673 Words | 3 Pages

Batzer (2015) notes in the critical article that, “ Twain exposes a power struggle between the adults and children, often reflected through their discourse with each other” (p.86). Through our adolescent we want to control our own life just to live out the selfish

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

Their home had beautiful furnishing, decorations, and pictures on the wall and looked more like a town home than a country house. The family seemed polite and well mannered but this picture of sophistication crumbled when Huck learned of the feud between the Grangerfords and the Shepherdsons. At church these two feuding familys sat on opposite side with their guns and ironically listened to a sermon about brotherly love and everyone “said it was a good sermon” but later turned around in the day and killed each other when they learned that a Grangerford girl and Shepherdson boy had run away together (120). Huck heard some Shepherdsons yell, “kill them, kill them,” which made him, “so sick” that he “wished that [he] hadn’t ever come ashore that night, to see such things” (127). Huck learned that although they might seem civilized from the outside, with their nice family and home, they really were rather

Read More
452 Words | 2 Pages

When looking for the meaning in Twain’s quote, it is important not to confuse ignorance with stupidity. Twain’s meaning of ignorance might be somewhere along the lines of refusing to accept that this one thing is true or can never change. For example, in more recent years, equality for all humans has been rapidly spreading across America. The Women’s Rights movement is a prime example of the truth behind Twain’s quote.

Read More
926 Words | 4 Pages

Huckleberry Finn and Civilization Merriam Webster defines the act of being civilized as being brought “out of a savage, uneducated, or unrefined state,” (Webster) yet within The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Huck’s interactions with supposedly civilized society depicts civilization as both savage and hypocritical. Although the members of educated society perceive themselves to be sophisticated and refined, whereas the lowest class members are viewed as barbaric, Huck’s encounters with Miss Watson, the Shepherdsons, and Aunt Sally push him to reject their civilized notions since their beliefs depend heavily on material wealth and not what is right or wrong. In this sense, Huck pushes the ideals of society away with every encounter since

Read More
768 Words | 4 Pages

Whether intentionally or unintentionally, Twain places the reader in a situation that requires much pondering of meaning and deep, intelligent insight into the commonalities performed by leading political

Read More

More about The Killer Elite: Twain's Argument Against Elitism

Related Topics

Open Document