ipl-logo

The Legitimacy Of Government Intervention In The Triangle Factory Fire Case

1871 Words8 Pages

The 1911 Triangle Factory Fire case addressed the legitimacy of government intervention of sweatshop working conditions. The court ruling was that the two factory owners, Max Blanck and Issac Harris, were acquitted of the manslaughter charge at the first trial. (DOC 2 Reader, 72) I believe that the casualties were not only victims of the fire, but also victims of the bad influences of the progressive era. From my perspective, the outcome was an unjust judgment in the US history. Through the lens of intersectionality, we are allowed to see that sweatshop workers experienced double oppressions from structural racism and structural sexism that limited their choices of occupations and class inequality that exaggerated imbalanced power between laborers …show more content…

According to the PBS documentary, garment workers had complained about their working conditions before the fire happened. The general strike covered nearly all sweatshops in New York in order to gain more protection for garment workers. During the industrialized strike, Triangle Factory owners hired local muscle and prostitutes to beat their employees. And policemen only caught workers if they fought back. Then those workers would be fined and even be put in the jail. Since the police and city hall were against the general strike, labor union got little attention. (Wignot, Triangel Fire) In this case, Triangle Factory workers had very little power compared to their employers because they were lower-class working people and the bosses were upper-class and wealthy. They could never improve their working conditions as individuals because they would be fired if they complained about their jobs to the bosses. So the labor union was the best way to combine their resources and power together collectively to create benefit for all workers. Since it would be difficult to replace a large amount of workers, strike was an efficient way of getting attention. However, the factory owners could not allow those young girls to teach them how to run their business. “They are biting the hands that feed them,” said in the PBS documentary. (Wignot, Triangle Fire) Because of their wealth and social status, they had the money and power to bribe local policemen and judges while average working-class people did not had chance to know those people. If the factory girls had been upper-class people and worked for Triangle Factory, the owners would have not been dare to hire people to beat them or pay off policemen to arrest them. The girls would have had peaceful conversations with the bosses about the working conditions because they have had balanced

Show More
Related
337 Words | 2 Pages

Kate Leone was a worker during the Triangle Factory Fire. Kate Leone was one of 8 children. Her parents were Italian Vito (Victor) Leone and American Luisa Kischlin. Kate was 14 when she joined her cousins Michelina Nicolosei and Annie Colletti as workers on the 9th floor of the Asch Building.

Read More
710 Words | 3 Pages

The Triangle fire took the lives of 146 immigrant women workers, who either died in the flames or jumped from a far height. First and foremost, they were mostly Jewish and Italian, these women worked on the 8th & 9th floors where hundreds of sewing machines operated under supervision and the tragedy of the fire brought widespread attention to the threatening sweatshop conditions of factories, and led to the development of a series of laws and regulations that protected the safety of workers. The factors of Production all involved land, labor and Capital. Land involves the natural resources, Labor which is human resources. Capital, man-made resources.

Read More
854 Words | 4 Pages

Politically the Workers had much support. The workers brought the Governor of Nevada out in support of their strike. The workers brought to his attention on how the Elardi family has done them wrong and by doing so, this led all their complaints under investigation. Last but not least was the economic power these employees had for being on the picket line for six years. This shows that the workers had much support from the state, and they were not going to back

Read More
453 Words | 2 Pages

On November 23, 1909, the “Uprising of the Twenty Thousand” started in New York City when a group of women led by Clara Lemlich, a member of the International Ladies Garment Workers Union (ILGWU) and who worked at the Triangle Waist Company, rallied thousands of other female workers to decide to strike the Triangle Waist Company and other businesses such as the Leiserson Company and the Rosen Brothers . Clara Lemlich conducted a secret meeting with other women workers to decide whether or not to go on strike to try and improve their work environment, establish and have the backing of a union, more pay, less working hours and many more demands . The strike was almost ruined from the start when the two bosses of the Triangle Waist Company, Isaac Harris and Max

Read More
1515 Words | 7 Pages

Throughout the past twentieth century, there have been numerous life-changing events that have immensely affected the course of women’s history. Women have fought hard in order to live a better life and without their dedication, commitment, and integrity, women’s lives would not be as they are today. The two most pivotally transformative milestones that have forever changed women’s lives are the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire and the Birth Control Pill. The Triangle Shirtwaist Fire stands out as one of the most important milestone moments in history because dangerous and unsafe working conditions were drastically changed after one hundred and forty-six workers passed away. The Birth Control Pill improved the lives of women and their families

Read More
407 Words | 2 Pages

Naturally, this angered a lot of workers and their families during this time. During the years of 1875 and 1900 many strikes were organized by angered laborers. The goal of these strikes was to reduce excessive work hours and equally low wages. The strikes did not result in

Read More
1581 Words | 7 Pages

The reason that pushed most people to join the strike was a decrease in weekly earnings due to new state legislature reducing the work week but the textile companies didn’t increase the wage to be paying their employees the same amount every week. The reduced weekly income was only the tipping point for many workers they had plenty of other reasons to walk of the job. These reasons included horrible living conditions, hazardous working conditions and wages low enough to only afford bread and molasses for many meals. With conditions being as bad as they were it’s a surprise a big strike didn’t start earlier. The reasons the great steel strike of 1919 started was very different from that of the Lawrence strike.

Read More
404 Words | 2 Pages

The first article of November 17th’s readings was called Sweatshop Workers, by Miriam Ching Yoon Louie. As stated in the article, “Mexican immigrant women and U.S born Chicana ’s have emerged as the backbone of many of the lowest-paying, most back-breaking jobs” ( Louie 65 ). Going along with that, this article introduced a new connected term of transnational corporations, which housed these low paying and back breaking jobs for Mexican immigrant women in the United States even before they crossed the border. While this article readdressed passed weeks covered topics of immigrant workers, it also added the usually suppressed feminine spin to the topic.

Read More
1261 Words | 6 Pages

The strike became one of the most influential events in the history of United States labor law. The labor law in 1894 in the United States was changed in a significant way after the strike, as it was the first strike that received national attention and tested labor laws. The government intervened in the relationship between employers and their workers. For the first time an injunction by the government was used to break up a strike and block a major union activity. Many industrials and unions were affected by this intervention.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

This strike consisted of the longshoremen who are the people who work the docks who load and unload ships versus the Shipowners. The Longshoremen wanted better working-conditions, better hours, the recognition of their Union. Things that the National recovery Act was trying to provide. The National recovery act was a part of Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal that tried to provide economic assistance to the people by cutting the length of workdays, and would get rid of unsafe work practices. With the passaging of this legislation, the workers had the right to gather representatives bargain with their bosses.

Read More
447 Words | 2 Pages

The union would help to make for more sanitized, safer work environments (“Labor Movement”, n.d.). They helped the workers gain better pay, shorter hours, and an overall happier work environment. All geared toward the laborer, not the employer for a change. At times, the union would organize strikes to try to make the employer do what they wanted; however, at this time they rarely succeeded, as do now. Some employees were met with opposition from the owners or management of the industries almost to an intimidation standpoint so not to join, in which grew worse if they did join.

Read More
1399 Words | 6 Pages

The riot resulted in producing an obstacle for union membership and union authority still felt in several union groups today. Prior to the Haymarket Riot, it was known that factory work was hard. Employees were exposed to dangerous conditions, low wages, and prolonged hours; therefore, in an effect to improve working conditions unions were formed. Companies opposed union so in a attempt to reduce an individual for join on they would add suspected union members on a lists, which barred them from employment. Companies were also known for disregarding laws that the government put in place to protect workers’ rights and in some cases the government historically sided with the companies during strikes giving companies a sense of power.

Read More
2031 Words | 9 Pages

Schneirov argues that the strike was a product of the larger social and economic crisis of the 1890s, which was marked by economic depression, political corruption, and social unrest. He highlights the role of labor unions and socialist organizations in mobilizing workers and promoting collective action. Schneirov also examines the response of the federal government to the strike, which he argues was motivated by a desire to protect the interests of capital and maintain social order. Schneirov's article provides a nuanced and insightful analysis of the Pullman Strike and its historical significance as a turning point in American labor history.

Read More
502 Words | 3 Pages

Thus, “some ten thousand cotton pickers” began a strike. As a result, the Fact Finding Commission declared that “civil rights of strikers have been violated. We appeal to constituted authorities to see that strikers are protected in rights conferred upon them by laws of State and by Federal and State Constitutions”. To put it differently, by unifying together and striking as one, migrant workers were successful in protecting their rights. Unity was fundamental element in the creation of this strike and without it the strike would have

Read More
284 Words | 2 Pages

Lastly, Labor Unions focus on the concept of striking and protesting to emphasize their need for change. The major strikes although end violently and to the point where reinforcements have to be involved receive negative feedback. But an article that was written after the Baltimore & Ohio Road strike states “…those who are engaged in it are not only bold and determined, but they have the sympathy of a large part of the community…” (Editorial New York Time, 1877). Although the Baltimore & Ohio Road strike did not successfully change conditions the benefit came out of the loss.

Read More

More about The Legitimacy Of Government Intervention In The Triangle Factory Fire Case

Open Document