ipl-logo

The Misrepresentation Of Madness Within 2010's Black Swan

2951 Words12 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Biomedical model of mental illness essay

Flying to Nowhere: The Misrepresentation of Madness within 2010’s Black Swan Alexandra McChesney 701e Lauren Munro April 12, 2023 Darren Aronofsky’s Black Swan creates a whirlwind fantasy world which plagiarizes harmful stories and perpetuates negative stereotypes of Madness. Beyond the stereotypical portrayal of a Mad person within the 2010 movie, its creation has encouraged hordes of unnecessary discourses on diagnosis, and brought the ballet world into the spotlight. This essay will explore misrepresentation of Madness within Black Swan and the responses of the film written by many psy(ch) academics, and others. When portraying Madness in media many visually presenting art, all follow similar formats …show more content…

The medical model’s preference and usage of illness-based language towards Mad experiences, and its prevalence in media today has allowed many people to feel comfortable or find enjoyment in diagnosing Nina. While the diagnoses are ones that have been associated with harmful social stereotypes, reason for incarceration, eugenic practices, and general mistreatments from society, the inappropriate nature of these online comments do not end at their evaluation of DSM criteria. The language used to discuss this character, and her experiences as a Mad person continue to undermine her abilities and constantly make her identity front and centre in conversation about her. Many of these online takes on her “illness” come from mental health centres or sites centered on psychological conditions and care. The Psychological Care and Healing Center in Los Angeles diagnosed her with having anxiety with obsessive compulsive disorder, and eating disorder, substance abuse, and a personality disorder, as well as saying the character was “beautifully and disturbingly portrayed” with “too many issues”. The American Academy of Private Physicians diagnosed both Nina and her mother with schizophrenia and said, “While viewers are uncertain of her mother’s mental illness status, the genetic factor may be present”. In an article …show more content…

S., & Abraham, A. (2016). Exploring the Uncharted Territories of Human Psyche as Represented in Darren Aronofsky’s Film Black Swan. Spiritus Scientiae, 19. Retrieved March 2, 2023, from https://www.christiancollege.in/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Spiritus-Scientiae-2016-Vol-1.pdf The Black Swan Movie and psychological illness. PCH Treatment Center. (2019, August 19). Retrieved April 12, 2023, from https://www.pchtreatment.com/the-black-swan-movie-and-psychological-illness/#:~:text=There%20are%20simply%20too%20many,She%20dabbles%20with%20substance%20abuse Burstow, B. (2005). A critique of posttraumatic stress disorder and the DSM. Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 45(4), 429–445. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022167805280265 Campbell, R. H., & Wilkening, G. L. (n.d.). Movies in the classroom: Black swan. AAPP. Retrieved April 12, 2023, from https://aapp.org/perspective/2016/07/309618#:~:text=Black%20Swan%20depicts%20a%20young,company's%20production%20of%20Swan%20Lake Donaldson James, S. (2010). 'Black Swan': Psychiatrists Diagnose Ballerina's Descent. Retrieved 2023, from https://abcnews.go.com/Health/Movies/black-swan-psychiatrists-diagnose-natalie-portmans-portrayal-psychosis/story?id=12436873. Donnelly, T. (2012). Vogue diagnoses: The functions of madness in twentieth-century

Show More
Related
1249 Words | 5 Pages

Kevin Breel wanted to break down this barrier when he gave his speech about his experiences with depression and suicide. Breel remains open and honest about his feelings toward how society reacts to openness about mental health issues. While doing so, he makes his point with the use of pathos. In his appeals, he remains forthright in his means of communication. To demonstrate his desire to bring attention to mental health, he does not just share his story but also draws in support for depression.

Read More
720 Words | 3 Pages

Malcolm Gladwell’s Something Borrowed tells of Dorothy Lewis, a physchatrist who studied serial killers for over twenty-five years. When playwright Bryony Lavery’s play “Frozen” debuted on Broadway, Lewis received non stop calls from friends and acquaintances telling her that she “really ought to see it,” (Gladwell) because one of the main characters was also a psychiatrist who studied serial killers. Lewis was reluctant to see the play, having spent so much of her life studying serial killers, she told her friends “I need to see that as much as I need to go to the moon.” Eventually, a woman from the theater where “Frozen” was playing called Lewis and requested she do a talk-back after one of the performances. Lewis, delighted, asked for a copy of the script so she could read it in preparation.

Read More
500 Words | 2 Pages

My imaginative piece titled ‘Emotional Storm’ uses stylistic features to express the themes of loss, emotional release and acceptance. The purpose of my text is to share a perspective to my readers on how feeling vulnerable can lead to the betterment of oneself. It is inspired by Donna Tartt's statement on how “there are such things as ghosts... Only now, we call them by different names. Memory.

Read More
1447 Words | 6 Pages

Stuart Hellie Ms. Meyers American Literature I 2_ March 2023 Hysteria in Modern and Past Societies According to Merriam-Webster, hysteria is defined as “ a psychoneurosis marked by emotional excitability and disturbances of the psychogenic, sensory, vasomotor, and visceral functions. When people in past or present societies let their emotions control their actions, it negatively affects how that society functions and the individual people within it. Hysteria has been shown throughout The Crucible and other events throughout history.

Read More
834 Words | 4 Pages

In William Shakespeare’s play “Hamlet”, and Ken Kesey’s novel One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, the sanity of the characters Hamlet and Ralph McMurphy is questioned. While circumstances of these characters cause them to look insane, their motives for acting crazy or irrational come from an underlying agenda: Hamlet wants revenge for his father’s death and McMurphy wants to gain control from Nurse Ratched. The death of Hamlet’s father causes Hamlet to fall into a depression leading to suicidal ideation. McMurphy is a criminal brought to a mental hospital on account of his psychopathic tendencies. Devastated by the news of his father’s death, Hamlet becomes utterly depressed and hopeless, bearing “more grief inside [him] than you could ever see

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

Irrational madness can be good Being mad and acting out doesn't always come with negative outcomes. As crazy as it sounds not only bad things happen when someones mad. In One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest by Ken Kesey, Randle Patrick Mcmurphy is seen as eccentric. Mcmurphy is the leader of the other patients in the ward.

Read More
851 Words | 4 Pages

In Branagh’s film, the director uses the techniques to create madness directly. For example, from the moment Ophelia asks that “Where is the beauteous majesty of Denmark?” (4.5.21) until she leaves her room after saying “good night, good night” (4.5.73), she is in the straitjacket clothes which are for mentally ill people. Also the audience can observe that she is trapped in the compact room with protection surrounding when Gertrude says that she “[…][would] not speak with her.” The film is using the symbols directly related to madness to persuade the audience that she is in the state of mental illness.

Read More
843 Words | 4 Pages

Matthew Arner offers a glimpse into his life as an individual living with a psychiatric disorder in the first person account, A Psychotic Experience. Arner discusses symptoms he experiences that affect his everyday life. He mentions symptoms such as lack of appetite, insomnia, delusions, and suicidal ideations. As the symptoms of his disorder are debilitating, Matthew describes challenges he faces and experiences he unfortunately misses out on as a result of his disorder. He recounts a morning in which he could not go surfing with his brother as they planned because of his poor sleep cycle, a consequence of his insomnia.

Read More
1004 Words | 5 Pages

Mental illness refers to a wide range of mental health conditions. They are disorders that affect how a person thinks, feels and acts. The Silver Linings Playbook by Matthew Quick shows the background of someone living with a mental illness. This book distributes and humanizes what Quick describes as the “mental health community”. Quick portrays mental illness realistically through the main characters because Quick himself suffered from depression and anxiety and hopes that a conversation about mental illness could be started (“Oscar Nominated”).

Read More
669 Words | 3 Pages

Title The renowned psychologist Robert hare’s psychopath checklist-revised or PCL-R for short, is a list of behavioral traits that psychopath’s share or have in common, and it was to my great surprise that Shakespeare’s character Hamlet displays almost every single trait, excluding a few simply because we do not know much of Hamlet's childhood. Throughout the play, Hamlet is known for feigning madness, and he is so convincing that it comes to the point where even his own mother doubts his sanity. Hamlet isn’t faking madness like he says, instead, he is a full fledged psychopath playing at being sane. In modern day society the word psychopath is predefined, immediately conjuring up images of deranged criminals, murderers or rapists.

Read More
767 Words | 4 Pages

Bryanna E. McCool Mrs. Dean British Literature 25 January 2018 Mental Illness in Shakespeare’s Macbeth The Tragedy of Macbeth by William Shakespeare, a play wrought with prophecies, deception, guilt, and death, brings light to the symptoms of mental illnesses and their effects on the human brain’s ability to reason, trust, and act in times of pressure. Both Macbeth and his lady are plagued by mental illness, and the effects of their illness only grow as the play evolves. Macbeth’s symptoms of schizophrenia and anxiety, as well as Lady Macbeth’s anxiety as well as hallucinations that eventually push her to suicide prove that not only can mental illness alter the way a person sees a situation, but it can also drive them to harm others and themselves.

Read More
734 Words | 3 Pages

This paranoia, as well as her delusions of grandeur, are both common symptoms of schizophrenia, developing the case for her mental illness

Read More
884 Words | 4 Pages

In the last few years, the representation of people suffering from mental illness in popular culture has greatly increased, showing actual teenagers that characters and idols have real problems in everyday life. One of the literary leaders in this psychological revolution is the novel, and recent film, The Perks of Being a Wallflower. Throughout this story, the viewer learns about different types of mental disorders from depression, to post-traumatic stress disorder, to schizophrenia. The events that occur throughout this storyline show real-life situations and struggles that teenagers go through. Stephen Chbosky expertly handles the topic of mental illness in the novel and film, The Perks of Being a Wallflower.

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

Psychological disorders are often overseen in movies. In the Black Swan the protagonist Nina Sayers beautifully and disturbingly portrays a person dealing with schizophrenia. In the psychological thriller Nina Sayers is a young dancer working in the prestigious New York City ballet. She is conflicted in being the good person she know she should be or the bad person her heart keeps leading her to be. Nina Sayers is very talented, but she is very reserved.

Read More
1232 Words | 5 Pages

Today there has been an increase in the awareness of mental health. In the sense that society has begun to take notice of how mental health effects each individual differently. The media has begun to incorporate a variety of illnesses to entertain to their audience. However, many have questioned if the media is accurately portraying these mental disorders. I chose to compare two popular movies Frankie & Alice and the 2007 version film Sybil.

Read More

More about The Misrepresentation Of Madness Within 2010's Black Swan

Related Topics

Open Document