ipl-logo

Criticism Of Narco Analysis Test

2214 Words9 Pages

i. Contents ii. Table of Cases iii. List of Abbreviations Chapter – I Introduction • Research Objectives • Research Questions • Hypothesis • Research Methodology Chapter – II Nacro Analysis Chapter – III Analyze Scientific Evidence and Tests Chapter – IV Criticism of Narco Analysis Test Chapter – V Conclusion & Suggestions Bibliography • Primary Sources • Secondary Sources Webliography Table of Cases List of Abbreviations INTRODUCTION This research paper tries to link science, law and ethics. This paper tries to answers various questions relating to narco analysis. It concentrates more on India. Firstly, as researcher heals from this country and is curious to answer questions that deals with both modern science and law. Secondly, …show more content…

Narco-analysis is a term that has been derived from Greek word narkç which means "anesthesia" or "torpor". How men with sound mind lie? A person is able to lie by using his imagination. In the Narco Analysis Test, the person’s imagination is neutralized by making him semiconscious (hypnotic-like state). In the narco-analysis test, the person’s inhibitions are lowered by interfering with his nervous system at the molecular level in this state, it becomes difficult for him to lie and his answers would be restricted to facts he is already aware of. Experts inject the person with Sodium Pentothal or Sodium Amytal. Truth serum is colloquial name for any of a range of psychoactive medications administered to a person by an expertise. The dose usually depends on the person's sex, age, health and physical condition. A wrong dose can result in a person going into a coma, or even death. This process of investigation is fatal if proper care is not taken. Narco-analysis test can be exploited by the therapist. The narco-analysis test is one of the scientific tests used to nail the culprit. The Evidence Act is completely silent on such employment of scientific process. This paper makes an effort to answer questions about validity and admissibility of these tests in Indian courts, advantages and disadvantages, is the procedure for narco analysis violative of the rights against self incrimination, …show more content…

Musto “It is generally held that the constitutional immunity from self-incrimination does not apply to a compulsory examination to determine the defendant's physical or mental condition for the purpose of testifying thereto, provided the defendant is not compelled to answer any questions, with the answers being used testimonial on trial.” Unfortunately, not a single medical association in India has spoken out against such participation. Legal battles about the admissibility in courts of information collected by using narco-analysis and lie detection continue even as physicians, psychiatrists and forensic doctors in India continue to violate medical ethics by participating and assisting in these interrogation sessions. CRITICISM OF NARCO ANALYSIS

Show More
Related
679 Words | 3 Pages

On April 6, 2016 at approximately 11:45am, a local police station got a call about a hostage situation at a local pharmacy. When police and medical examiners got to each crime scene, they learned that all of the hostages were given drugs and had overdosed on them. Some of the pills, in powder form, were found near the victims. One of the victims was stable enough to tell the investigators that the power on the floor were the drugs they were forced to take. The medical examiner found out each hostage was given either unknown A or unknown B.

Read More
1325 Words | 6 Pages

Case in point, the people and partners of the faulted case that they have chase down use and system of making the murdering substance found in the PC of the charged. It doesn't absolutely give an unmistakable bearing on who really expected to use the substance and for what reasons. Thusly, it would have been more profitable for the specialists to use diverse means, for instance, directing the rebuked in wording for spurring her to concede her exercises and the honest to goodness explanation behind death by watching her behavioral cases. It doesn't simply change the behavior of the individual also her future. It is by virtue of through coordinating, she gets the chance to remember her slips without control hence making unadulterated points of view of doing what she does and conceding her past unacceptable exercises.

Read More
1404 Words | 6 Pages

Facts Angelique Lavallee killed her common law partner, Kevin Rust, by shooting him in the back of the head late one night after a party at their home. Lavallee was frequently a victim of physical abuse in the relationship, defining her as a battered woman. She made several trips to the hospital for injuries, such as bruises, fractured nose, black eye and multiple contusions, excused by unbelievable reasons. Witnesses testified to seeing and hearing the abuse committed by Rust onto Lavallee prior times to the party as well as at the party that evening. The shooting occurred subsequent to an argument that Lavallee and the deceased had been having in the upper level of the home, after Rust had reportedly told Lavallee to kill him or he would

Read More
443 Words | 2 Pages

In the case of Colorado v. Connelly, Connelly approached an officer and said that he wanted to confess to a murder. After being read his Miranda rights, he still wanted to continue with his confession. He was taken to the station and again advised of his rights. He confessed to a murder and even led police to the scene of his admitted crime. He was held overnight and questioned again the next morning.

Read More
607 Words | 3 Pages

The author also states that because manufacturer’s are no longer providing correctional centers with the drugs, the states are considering bringing execution methods from centuries ago back in practice. Alternative execution methods such as the electric chair are being considered. The discontinued legal drugs and shortage has caused secrecy in how the drugs are obtained. Because correctional centers are buying drugs from the Indian black market illegally, the Drug Enforcement Administration

Read More
584 Words | 3 Pages

Since the time decision about Daubert was made, later decisions of the supreme court have increased the Daubert’s application to all expert fields, not only in those which is technically scientific. The impact of Daubert, though, is not restricted to federal courts for many stated have also accepted the Daubert test for acceptability of testimony. The Daubert implication also extended towards scientific forensic anthropology. Daubert has offered many applications in federal courts.

Read More
1528 Words | 7 Pages

The state started to build a case against the defendant due to the sexual act that occurred between him and the victim, which lead the criminologist to take samples of the semen and ultimately test for results (Police chief magazine). When time approach for an item to be tested the result came back inclusive due to the technology at that time being used was not qualified to conduct a proper reading on the DNA test. The packet was only able to show if a victim was raped or not (Police chief magazine). After realizing that the technology needed to be updated to better enhance the police investigations (Police chief magazine). The Criminologist worked years to come up with several different ways to test one items by DNA, fingerprints, and/or Hair samples, which resulted in the test be 99.9% reliable when convicting a criminal (Police chief magazine).

Read More
1574 Words | 7 Pages

Opiate group participants had to be stable on an opiate agonist for at least 2 weeks prior to testing. Potential participants were excluded from both groups if there was history of a neurological condition, a psychiatric disorder, heavy alcohol use, brain injury, used illicit drugs in the 24hrs prior to

Read More
590 Words | 3 Pages

The program for the exam is CAT, which is a method for administering exams that combines computer technology with a recent measurement theory to cause the exam to be extra efficient. CAT is used for the NCLEX mostly since it reduces the occurrence of "easy" questions that “high-ability” candidates receive, and reduces the occurrence of "difficult" questions that low-ability candidates receive. It is also advantageous for security purposes, meaning it is harder to cheat on this test, than in previous tests. While taking the test, every time a candidate answers a question, the computer re-estimates their ability based on the their previous answers and the difficulty of those questions. In other words, if they continue to answer questions right, the test will become increasingly difficult, and if they continue to answer questions wrong, the test will become easier.

Read More
88 Words | 1 Pages

The study was done on patients who were in the emergency department and were prescribed opioids. They interviewed patients at home. It consisted of two different interviews. The research assistant looked to see where the opioids were being stored and to see if they were being safely stored. Twenty five patients gave consent to be part of the study.

Read More
1077 Words | 5 Pages

For example, agencies have been established with the sole intent to manage drug use and distribution and technology has been exclusively developed to detect the presence of drugs. Yet, evidence has indicated that such exhaustive efforts have been relatively unsuccessful. First, it has been assumed that drugs have perpetuated violence in society and based on this rationale, it was believed that by the suppressing the pervasiveness of drugs that incidents of violence would simultaneously diminish. However, reality has failed to align with the expectations that had initially been anticipated. Research findings have suggested that the decriminalization of drugs would result in a less adversarial drug market in which conflicts have tended to arise among dealers as well as between dealers and buyers (Common Sense for Drug Policy, 2007, p. 21).

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

Drugs are the dangerous substances that will destroy the consumer both physically and mentally; therefore, it is necessary to determine these substances restrictively. In order to do that, I am strongly assuring that the drugs should be legalized. There are three main reasons why the drugs should be legalized: diminution of crime rates, health guarantee, and extending of drugs regulation. Drugs are one of the crime sources, although not by the drugs, itself, but the condition. Illegal drugs are rare products that could not be found in the normal market, the cost for its rarity is totally expensive.

Read More
765 Words | 4 Pages

The continuous use of narcotics results in addiction, and financial struggles due to the costly upkeep. “Financial problems are one of the major side effects of drug and substance abuse” (Buaggett, 2015). Addicts cannot adequately take an active role in the economic activities, as the use of drugs inhibits the abilities of the users to earn a daily living. Due to the instability of finances, this would result in selling personal belongings to continue funding the substance of choice, and depending on the addicts living situation, this could lead to losing their house or being removed from their current housing. While being under the influence, an addicts voice of reason is jeopardized, resulting in criminal activities which raise the chances of being apprehended by the law enforcers, as well as, heavy fines are imposed.

Read More
986 Words | 4 Pages

Recently, people being calling that they have freedom to do what the want—using drugs, and proposing legalizing using drugs. This essay will discuss drug legalization issues only in America by giving valid data and considerate suggestion to explain why researcher believes drug should be legalized in the U.S. Drug can lead to multiple social problems and potential threats in most case, and there are several reasons why the US is currently suffering from serious drug problems. The US has a great amount drug user: according to the statistics provided by the U.S Federal Government, An estimated 3.6 million people met diagnostic criteria for dependence on illegal drugs in 1999, including 800,000 youths between the ages of twelve and seventeen (America’s Drug Use Profile, p.1). In recent years, there has been a worrying trend of young drug addiction and the lower age of drug users. Age between 18-25 years, current use of any illegal drug has been rising since 1994 and currently stands at 18.8 percent.

Read More
2169 Words | 9 Pages

The crimes had become more sofesticated, more organized,more deceitful, and even more difficult to get hold of. The system of policeing that is followed in india is still very old and the changing world demands for a much effective system, that will be more focused on speedy investigation and justice to the victims. The world around us is changing and the morden police is required to bring in an equilibrium in the socity, but in doing so the police face a lot of difficulties be it reguarding the laws in force of the probpems of purgery various problems because of policical pressure or the obsoleteness of the police Act. This article aims to point out the various problems faced by

Read More

More about Criticism Of Narco Analysis Test

Related Topics

Open Document