ipl-logo

The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas Rhetorical Analysis Essay

1823 Words8 Pages

Sumedh Anantha

Le Guin goes on a rant

The idea of having a perfect society with no pitfalls is an idea that has been explored countless times throughout history whether it be presented through music, literature or pieces of art. It’s an idea with no boundaries that can be subject to multiple avenues of thought and expression with a variety of deeper meanings behind the curtain. One such piece of media is Ursula LeGuin’s short story “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas” where she presents a utopian society with an allegory that is quite unique. Omelas is a beautiful city where everything is prosperous and enjoyable however that comes at a cost. A child is locked inside a basement and is forced to subside in detrimental conditions for the …show more content…

The author creates a vivid and powerful emotional response in the reader by using language that is both descriptive and evocative.For example, the child’s hygienic situation is described using sentences such as “It is naked. Its buttocks and thighs are a mass of festered sores, as it sits in its own excrement continually.”The description of the child's physical appearance and condition is intended to elicit feelings of pity and compassion from the reader, as well as a sense of outrage at the injustice of the situation. She also tugs at the reader's strings with the usage of imagery to highlight the stark contrasts between the celebrations outside and the conditions inside the basement where the child lives. The image of the child in the dark basement is contrasted with the "blare of trumpets" and "joyous clamor of bells" that can be heard throughout the city. This contrast is intended to create a sense of cognitive dissonance in the reader, forcing them to confront the ethical dilemma at the heart of the story. She uses the child as vehicle to support her message about why looking at society in utilitarian terms is a bad idea. This usage of an innocent child as a message is not unique to just "The Ones Who Walk …show more content…

Roemer’s article, “The Talking Porcupine Liberates Utopia: Le Guin's "Omelas" as Pretext to the Dance”. In the article Roemer examines the themes of sacrifice and liberation in the story. Early in the analysis Romer states "By focusing on the child, the story asks the reader to confront the moral and ethical implications of a society that values the happiness of the majority over the well-being of the minority." (Roemer).This quote embodies my saying from above about having a sense of moral bankruptcy that the citizens of the city had as they turned a blind eye towards the suffering of the child for their personal benefit. Roemer’s analysis lands at the same message but through a different means. Roemer argues that the character of the child in the story represents the marginalized and oppressed members of society. By using the child as a metaphor, Le Guin highlights the ethical problems with utilitarianism and the need for a more compassionate and just approach to society. Roemer suggests that Le Guin's story can be read as a call to action, encouraging readers to work towards a society in which the needs and desires of all individuals are taken into account. Within the article Roemer also talks about the unique ending that LeGuin’s story has and goes more in depth about the further meaning and reasoning behind this artistic choice that the author chose. "Le Guin's provocative

Show More
Related
329 Words | 2 Pages

In the intercalary chapter number 25, Steinbeck shows the decay of morals and also physical decay in the chapter. He contrasts land that is used naturally for its nutrients, and land used, or in Steinbeck’s eyes, wasted for profits. The chapter has some apocalyptic overtones throughout. Steinbeck uses vivid imagery and harsh statements to convey his message. The chapter seems to show how there are consequences for interrupting the lands life force to line ones pockets.

Read More
194 Words | 1 Pages

In “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas,” Ursula Le Guin invites readers to witness life in a beautiful utopian city, where citizens enjoy boundless contentment and life itself is a victory to be celebrated. Though idyllic, the city Omelas and its inhabitants are portrayed as a cut above the blissfully ignorant utopian stereotype- they are not “naïve and happy children,” but rather “mature, intelligent, passionate adults whose lives were not wretched.” Le Guin is aware how fantastical such a concept might sound, and through her nameless, omniscient narrator she earnestly attempts to persuade readers to take Omelas at face value. The narrator appeals for input from readers’ own minds, encouraging the audience to supplement the concept of Omelas

Read More
838 Words | 4 Pages

Puritan’s harsh beliefs represented the beginning of the Nineteenth Century in the newly colonized America. Their community ruled with an iron fist: unforgiving, pitiless, stern. In The Scarlet Letter, Nathaniel Hawthorne expresses his disagreement with puritan priorities by revealing the hypocrisy widely practiced throughout their community. Hawthorne’s utilization of dim diction aids in the establishment of his scornful tone, while inclusion of symbols and intricate juxtaposition all serve to accentuate the Puritan’s duplicity. All these factors combine to develop a critical tone which rebukes puritan society.

Read More
723 Words | 3 Pages

Consequently, one of the two men that are stationed behind this child seems to be smiling and enjoying the fact that they are terrorizing this child, while the other seems to be angry or fed up with the fact that a child is even in the equation. All of this strongly adds to the appeal of pathos which strengthens the posters' effect that it has on the audience’s feelings or emotions of a child being left home alone by themselves. The audience viewing this poster may feel a sense of sadness along with a bit of anger because they may feel bad that a child is left home by himself during a family vacation and on top of that, it is also the holidays. The sense of anger may come because the viewer may be angry at the child’s family and think to themselves, “what kind of people leave their child behind and dos not come back to get them?” Also in the background of the picture are Christmas lights and snow which helps the viewer understand that this film is developing around the holiday

Read More
371 Words | 2 Pages

This passage occurs as more and more people begin to disappear from Holmes’s hotel in the midst of the World’s Fair including waitresses, stenographers, and even a male physician. Larson's purpose in this passage is to depict Holmes's insanity and psychopathic tendencies as he murders several guests at his hotel. Employing a vivid sense of diction, Larson details Holmes’s methods of murder; he uses words such as “gorging,” “proximity,” “death,” and “panic,” to characterize Holmes’s preferences, including the fact that he avoids bloody murder (like the notorious Jack the Ripper) and enjoys being near his victims while they are on the brink of death. When he murders, Holmes feels a sense of, “possession,” over his victim and believes it is “satisfying.” The vault in which Holmes murdered most of his victims “deadened,” most of the sound- but not all, and when his hotel was full of guests Holmes would, “settle,” for more silent means, explains

Read More
410 Words | 2 Pages

Emma Marris uses many types of persuasive elements in her essay “Emma Marris: In Defense of Everglade Pythons”. In her writing she persuades her readers that the pythons should be allowed to be in the everglades since it is not their fault that they are there in the first place. She uses metaphors to relate to the reader and word choice to enhance her writing.

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

“Children are carpets, they should be stepped on occasionally” (Bradbury). This quote from “The Veldt” by Ray Bradbury helps to tell the overall tone from “The Veldt” and “Puppy” by George Sanders involving the author’s perception on parenting. The quote refers to what the author believes is the right amount of parenting. Not too much, and not too little. Literary devices like imagery, personification, and metaphor help to tell the tones throughout “The Veldt” and “Puppy” by going into detail.

Read More
609 Words | 3 Pages

In this passage, Ezekiel Cheever responds to John Proctor’s curiosity about what a needle in a poppet signifies and why his wife Elizabeth is being accused of using witchcraft against Abigail Williams. Cheever’s response explains his knowledge of how Abigail was afflicted, his possession of strong evidence against Elizabeth Proctor as a court official, and both his and the town of Salem’s tendency to turn to superstition to explain mysterious events. As Cheever explains how Abigail was afflicted by the needles from the poppet, he utilizes a simile when he states that Abigail fell to the floor, after being stabbed, “like a struck beast” (74). Cheever says this to emphasize the abruptness and intensity of the situation and how significant it is that there is no visual perception of anyone

Read More
1122 Words | 5 Pages

Past leaders such as Andrew Jackson, Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini, and Marc Antony are evidence that society does not reward morality and good character in leadership. Society is drawn to leaders that have good rhetoric, propaganda, and charismatic personalities, and society supports them despite their immorality. Society is concerned about stability more than the morality of their leaders and will support immoral leaders in times of crisis to provide stability. In history there have been multiple leaders that have used rhetoric, propaganda and charismatic personalities to gain power, despite their morals.

Read More
696 Words | 3 Pages

Bradbury distinguishes the nursery as a violent environment: “That sun. He could feel it on his neck, still, like a hot paw. And the lions. And the smell of blood.” This description of the nursery enhances all of the violence that takes place within.

Read More
832 Words | 4 Pages

In her allegorical story “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas,” Ursula K.Le Guin describes a utopian society where Omelas’ happiness is made possible by the sacrifice of one kid for the good of the group. The analogy uses a wide variety of symbols and visual representations in an effort to convey enduring life lessons like the one of the there can't be happiness without there being suffering. The narrator explains that it is a happy place and the people who live there make a child suffer.

Read More
530 Words | 3 Pages

Rhetorical appeals reveal the hidden message the character is trying to convey. The rhetoric also highlights the character’s emotions, feelings and the significance of the text. It allows readers to gain a better understanding of the characters. Arthur Miler, the author of The Crucible, highlights the importance of mass hysteria through rhetorical appeals. John Proctor, the tragic hero is a loyal, honest, and kind-hearted individual.

Read More
1662 Words | 7 Pages

Yet no solicitude is yielded, for every man, woman, and child knows that such an act would be a terrible thing indeed. Instead they wallow in their helplessness before awesome justice by shedding bitter tears of anger at injustice. So perhaps Omelas is less fantastical than it first reveals itself to be. Moreover, Ursula Le Guin’s uses immaculate descriptions to create a unique utopia, enabled by dystopian elements in her short story, “The Ones

Read More
586 Words | 3 Pages

Rhetorical Analysis Malala is known for her couragous battle to fight for education for the children in her country, but to me i know her for something else. The way she conveyed her message using rhetorical strategies is how i know Malala. She makes the reader experience in his or her mind what it is to live in pakistan. Malala used very good rhetorical strategies to convey her message and to inspire many around the world, including me.

Read More
2100 Words | 9 Pages

When Maupassant conveys Madame Loisel’s dream he narrates, “She dreamed of great drawing rooms dressed with old silk” The premodifier “great” once again refers to the theme of greed, shown throughout the story. Although she is living in a steady life, Madame Loisel always desires for better. Maupassant can be seen as a misogynist here as Madame Loisel is portrayed as a greedy woman who does not know how to cherish what she currently has. She continues to complain on her plain and ordinary lifestyle even though there are many more underprivileged people living in the society. Women continue to be characterized negatively through Madame Loisel’s expectations on her meals.

Read More

More about The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas Rhetorical Analysis Essay

Related Topics

Open Document