ipl-logo

The Palestinians Are The Other, By Edward Said

426 Words2 Pages

All throughout time people have been “the other.” Pratt refers to the other as being “Someone who is perceived by the dominant culture as not belonging, as they have been culturally constructed as fundamentally different in some way” (320). In Edward Said’s essay, the Palestinians are the other. In Said’s essay he provides several photographs taken by Jean Mohr, which depict the everyday lives of Palestinians. Said, himself is a Palestinian. In many photographs like the ones on page 13, are known as ‘exiles’ which are a series of portraits without names, without contexts. Images that are largely unexplained, nameless, mute.(12) Said looks at them even though he cannot speak first hand to the actual people who were photographed, except through a European photographer; Said analyzes the photographs. …show more content…

A village of settled nomads near Bersheeba,(13) look very uncomfortable, they have no clue as to why they are being photographed and recorded. The man in the bottom photo doesn’t even look towards the camera, it’s like he’s actually trying not to look directly at the camera/ photographer, possibly he feels intimidated. In the top photo the women remains covered, while the young child looks into the camera with a gaping mouth, he looks scared or possibly just surprised after all I doubt they agreed to be photographed. Said, concludes “There was the embarrassment of people uncertain why they were being looked at and recorded. Powerless to stop it.” (14) I think the people are treated like a new species, being looked at through a microscope in this case a

Show More
Related
236 Words | 1 Pages

Throughout one’s experiences in life, one has endured so much pain, so many hardships, that it is nearly incomprehensible to not lose hope. In the book, Night, by Elie Wiesel, Elie himself experiences the most horrific idea of the century, the bane of Jewish society; the holocaust. The holocaust was a rigorous attempt made by Adolf Hitler and Nazi Germany to eliminate the entirety of the Jewish people, who he blamed for his country’s misfortune and poor condition. Elie depicts his entire journey as he struggles to survive throughout his book, and at the same time shows the agony of his and the other prisoners. In the book, Night, Elie Wiesel shows the segregation of Jews from numerous objects, the fear created in the camp from multiple methods,

Read More
556 Words | 3 Pages

“‘I have terrible news,’ he said at last. ‘Deportation.’ The ghetto was to be completely wiped out. We were to leave street by street the following day” (Wiesel 11). Throughout the vast novel, Night,by Elie Wiesel, the protagonist Elie had gone through agonizing experiences, for the duration of the gruesome and unspeakable genocide.

Read More
371 Words | 2 Pages

Elie Wiesel, in his novel, Night writes about how during the Holocaust, Jews faced brutalizing and had to overcome tremendous difficulties. He adopts a mournful tone in order to explore the idea that the Nazi persecution was atrocious with struggles in humanity. Through personification. Wiesel implies, trying to find strength from within can lead to isolation of the soul. Wiesel uses personification to demonstrate loneliness: “I shall never forget Juliek...

Read More
514 Words | 3 Pages

These photos tell the gruesome truth of the Armenian genocide, they demonstrate the suffering the Armenians went through, the starvation clear by the malnourished bodies and also show the significant number of the dead, as proof of the genocide. The photos also show the innocence of children during the genocide, as they watch on horrible scenes of the dead or other dying children. This furthermore proves of the attempt at genocide, as there is no discriminating or reluctance; men, women and children were all

Read More
1290 Words | 6 Pages

In war, there is no clarity, no sense of definite, everything swirls and mixes together. In Tim O’Brien’s novel named “The Things They Carried”, the author blurs the lines between the concepts like ugliness and beauty to show how the war has the potential to blend even the most contrary concepts into one another. “How to Tell a True War Story” is a chapter where the reader encounters one of the most horrible images and the beautiful descriptions of the nature at the same time. This juxtaposition helps to heighten the blurry lines between concepts during war. War photography has the power to imprint a strong image in the reader’s mind as it captures images from an unimaginable world full of violence, fear and sometimes beauty.

Read More
1527 Words | 7 Pages

“A traumatic experience robs you of your identity” (Dr.Bill). Concentration camps during the agonizing Holocaust disallowed their prisoners to obtain a personal identity. The renowned memoir, Night, written by Holocaust survivor, Eliezer Wiesel, published in 1954 expands the apprehension of the life altering challenges and torment the Jewish society encountered from 1933 to 1945. Identity consists of an individual's distinctive characteristics, beliefs and mannerisms which was forbidden for the Jewish hostages of the Holocaust to attain. Elie’s identity was shaped and reshaped by the traumatic experiences the Jewish community persevered through.

Read More
587 Words | 3 Pages

With everything that has gone on in their lives, Elie felt a small relief when his father was finally taken away. After the Holocaust, all anyone cared about was food. They didn’t give a second thought to the family they’d never see again until about months or years after the Holocaust ended. Concluding, Night shows how, not only Elie, but everyone changed throughout the Holocaust, their minds corrupted by everything they’ve seen, their self image shattered to nothing, leaving them with no self respect. The Holocaust didn’t only change their physical appearance, but their mental

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

________________ ____ _________________ _________________ _________________ _________________ Working Title : Jewish Resistance: When Arms Go Up & Flags Come Down “Between 5 & 6 million Jews-out of the Jewish population of 9 million living in Europe-were killed during the holocaust.” This quote, derived and utilized in this paper from a website that is most focused upon history and its historical background and contents. The Holocaust was the mass/systematic extermination of a specific race or group of people, places, or things.

Read More
775 Words | 4 Pages

Jews have been oppressed ever since they began to exist as a people. From the Spanish Inquisition to the Holocaust, though many died, few had the ability to withstand the anti-semitism and discrimination and survive. In the book The Last Jew by Noah Gordon, the main character Yonah Toledano witnesses his entire family disappear within a few days, but manages to survive on his own for decades. Living during the time of the inquisition, Yonah learns to adapt to his surroundings and strategically plan how to live through it. Yonah Toldedano was able to successfully evade the inquisition because of his quick thinking, the teachings he received from people he befriended, and most importantly his ability to lie.

Read More
1267 Words | 6 Pages

Edward Said 's memoir, "States", is an interesting take on a man who cannot remember his life in Palestine, a man who has no roots connected to his home country other than the fact that he is Palestinian and how his perspective is based on bias. Contrary, Jane Tompkins ' essay, "Indians", reviews how perspectives can contradict the opinions of others, using her own experiences as examples. Though the two essays concentrate on different topics, they have similarities in their essays. Said focuses on the past with what he knows of Palestine, while Tompkins talks about how she is bombarded by the different perspectives by other researchers, that makes forming her own perspective harder than it was as a child.

Read More
626 Words | 3 Pages

"I had faith in Israel before it was established, I have faith in it now," stated by President Henry Truman in 1948, according to the Jewish virtual library. Truman’s statement sums up Israeli-U.S relations really well, it simply summarizes how well the relations between the two countries are. The instant Israel declared its independence, the United States was there to recognize it. Israel and the United States have been allies since then, and this is reflected by the presidential decisions that were made regarding the State of Israel. This includes the U.S’s decision to recognize the state of Israel, which was carried out by President Henry Truman.

Read More
945 Words | 4 Pages

To find a man who has not experienced suffering is impossible; to have man without hardship is equally unfeasible. Such trials are a part of life and assert that one is alive by shaping one’s character. In the autobiographical memoir Night by Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel, this molding is depicted through Elie’s transformation concerning his identity, faith, and perspective. As a young boy, Elie and his fellow neighbors of Sighet, Romania were sent to Auschwitz, a macabre concentration camp with the sole motive of torturing and killing Jews like himself. There, Elie experiences unimaginable suffering, and upon liberation a year later, leaves as a transformed person.

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

Eli Wiesel, the author of Night, demonstrates dehumanization by illustrating how the Nazis tortured the Jews. The foreign Jews of Sighet were being deported out of their homes. Moshe the Beatle tells Elie of his time in Galicia with great emotion. Elie shares what the Nazis did to the Jews, “Without passion or haste, they shot their prisoners, who were forced to approach the trench one by one and offer their necks. Infants were tossed into the air and used as targets for machine guns” (Wiesel 6).

Read More
1090 Words | 5 Pages

At times, it appears unviable for one’s life to transform overnight in just a few hours. However, this is something various individuals experienced in soul and flesh as they were impinged by those atrocious memoirs of the Holocaust. In addition, the symbolism portrayed throughout the novel Night, written by Elie Wiesel, presents an effective fathoming of the feelings and thoughts of what it’s like to undergo such an unethical circumstance. For instance, nighttime plays a symbolic figure throughout the progression of the story as its used to symbolize death, darkness of the soul,

Read More
1315 Words | 6 Pages

I believe, Ayad brings these two theses together in the final paragraph: “In fact, even if the original photographer saw the image as artistic, subsequent events compel us to try to see the image of the Polish girl with Nazis as journalism. In this endeavor, we must uncover as much as possible about the surrounding context. As much as we can, we need to know this girl’s particular story. Without a name, date, place, or relevant data, this girl would fall even further backward into the chapters of unrecorded history.” (Ayad, par.

Read More

More about The Palestinians Are The Other, By Edward Said

Related Topics

Open Document