ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of H-2A Immigrant Workers

911 Words4 Pages

The Napa County wine industry in California rely heavily on temporary foreign labor to produce wine and keep fields from rotting. Most of the workers that grape farmers hire to work their crops are H-2A visa recipients. The H-2A visa program allows agricultural employers, such as that of vintners, to hire foreign agricultural workers for a specific amount of time. Because of the shortage in American labor, farmers are encouraged to hire foreign laborers to work their fields in hopes to satisfy the demand for wine production. The debate whether the temporary H-2A visa workers are necessary to produce wine and maintain vineyards, remain unsettled and with much controversy. The employing farmers and Attorney General Jeff Sessions have opposing …show more content…

domestic workers, and that they will overstay their visa. In the agricultural industry the H-2A visa program is needed to maintain a steady workforce in the fields. If it weren’t for temporary H-2A visa workers vintners, or grape farmers, would have no success in wine production. Despite the government’s concern, H-2A visa laborers are a necessity to the Napa County grape farmers due to the increased demand for wine production and decreased rate of domestic agricultural labor.
As we are all aware since the last presidential election more tension has become apparent between immigrants (particularly Mexican immigrants) and U.S. citizens, especially when the topic of employment rises. Despite the views each party presents, quality production and labor force are somethings both parties have in common. The fear of illegal residency in the state of California has always been an issue, but lately Attorney General Sessions has linked the H-2A program to be an enabler for illegal residency. This administrative concern leads federal agencies to crackdown on fraud and misuse in the H-2A visa program. And guides the federal government to wholly enforce federal procedures prioritizing the use …show more content…

In California, especially in the wine industry, a vast number of workers are needed to maintain vineyards before they go to waste. Hiring H-2A visa holders to work seasonal crops benefits vintners, the wine industry, and the California economy. In total, Californian growers hired 14,252 H-2A visa workers in 2017, an increase of 3,121 from the previous year; 500 of which will be working the vineyards and wineries in Napa and Sonoma counties (Mohan, 3). Without H-2A visa workers, who maintain vineyards for wine consumption, grapes would be left to rot, causing a negative blow to the agricultural economy. According to Gordon, “Americans drink more wine than any other country, more than 3 billion liters annually. Per capita, we now consume about three gallons a year, triple what we drank 50 years ago” (2). If H-2A visa workers seized to exist, the crops would not get harvested, the vineyards would deteriorate, and vintners would be unable to produce wine. Between the years 2010 and 2015 there was a recorded increase of 14% in wine production making Napa and Sonoma counties the top producers of American wines –producing 85% of America’s wines (Gordon, 3). Production that without the assistance of H-2A visa laborers, would not be possible. And with Napa county wineries’ contribution of $60 billion to the state’s economy annually, the state of

Show More
Related
233 Words | 1 Pages

At this time in the eastern United States labor systems and the use of immigrant labor

Read More
1401 Words | 6 Pages

In 1969, Dolores Huerta reached a stumbling block in which she questioned, “How do I stop eleven million people from buying the grape?” (Huerta, Proclamation of the Delano Grape Workers). The essence of Huerta’s question is that she needed to develop a different strategy that would prevent growers from gaining profits from grape sales. Meanwhile, two years into the grape boycott, farmworkers from Delano, California had gained the support for equal rights from political figures and consumers throughout the United States. Furthermore, Americans from all walks of life were able to sympathize with the farmworkers who merely sought for better working conditions, increased wages, and growers to recognize their union.

Read More
504 Words | 3 Pages

In 1965, the AWA and NFWA joined forces and became known as the United Farm Workers. That year the organization took on the Coachella Valley grape growers. On July 29, 1970, after five years of strike after strike the United Farm Workers signed an agreement with twenty-six grape growers. They would go on to agree to make working conditions for farm workers better and reduce the usage of harmful pesticides. During the 1980s, Huerta was the Vice President of the United Farm Workers.

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

For the next couple of years the NFWA and AWOC conducted a campaign against against the growers and the tea masters. Soon after the NFWA and AWOC came together the United Farm Workers Committee won the first of many representation elections. A few years later the United Farm workers signed a few contracts with a couple of counties winemakers. But some contracts only covered 5,000 of the 250,000 farm workers, the grape strike failed to stop shipments of grapes to consumers. The tea masters union in california challenged the UFW by signing sweetheart contracts with all of the grape growers there.

Read More
1447 Words | 6 Pages

In the 1990s an update of the H2A program claimed that the program was importing thousands of workers to the United States. Arguably one of the most important aspects of the H2A program was that “guest workers” were contracted and by that contract were allowed workers’ compensation coverage, housing inspections and transportation. This was a vital improvement because undocumented workers were not entitled to such allowances. More so, the program presented a chance for Mexicans to work in the United States legally which was an appreciated opportunity for Mexican workers. This program clearly promoted new and improved benefits for Mexican

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

Without access to an immigrant workforce, many California farmers would have trouble harvesting their crops. The people believe that California can best determine who is a threat to the state and who is

Read More
715 Words | 3 Pages

It was growing largely, having 1700 families as members by 1965. Grape pickers were paid about one dollar an hour in California. Another union was fighting against grape growers, too. They worked together to form the UFWOC (United Farm Workers Organizing Committee). Cesar led a 300-mile march of the grape growers.

Read More
1707 Words | 7 Pages

The deplorable working conditions of illegal migrants In his article “In the Strawberry Fields” Eric Schlosser examines the illegal labor market of the strawberry industry. Thus, the author describes the main problems that migrants face while working in the fields of California. Thus, the majority of the workers are illegal migrants of Hispanic origin that are ready to work at any cost as they need to earn at least something for their living. Among the major problems that migrants suffer from it is possible to mention the following: poor working conditions, mistreatment, low wages and sharecropping.

Read More
1182 Words | 5 Pages

In Alabama alone, a Mazda car plant will soon open up, and is expecting thousands of new employment opportunities. Along with this,agricultural policies were put into place. Many people worked on farms during this time, and these events made things difficult for

Read More
1177 Words | 5 Pages

The H-2A program affects farmers, as this process is risky, very expensive, comes with a long list of responsibilities and has proven not to be a timely process for the employers of H-2A migrant workers. Although immigration has become necessary to the U.S. agriculture industry for numerous reasons. The effects of the H-2A policy are damaging to this already diminishing empire, these effects are high-risk factors for employers, multiple exorbitant expenses and an unprogressive-timing process. For farmers, once an H-2A worker is officially employed the employer is 100 percent liable for the actions of that worker within a local, state and international

Read More
422 Words | 2 Pages

Although fighting for farmers’ rights has been done in the past, the Farm Workers Movement in the 1940s was the peak of farm workers’ rights. In 1964 the Bracero Program ended, giving farmers a chance to form a union. As reported by the PBS documentary, Filipino farm workers sought an opportunity to strike in the Coachella area where grapes harvest fast. The strike was over in one week and growers gave in to the demand of a wage of $1.40.

Read More
795 Words | 4 Pages

He was a grape farmer working from 6 am to 7 pm almost more than 13-hours a day his salary was $2.56 an hour from that salary he had to support his family that was still living in Yemen. Many migrant farm workers who pick these fruits travel across the country and cross borders to fill the agriculture jobs in the U.S that U.S citizens are not willing to take. (McKenzie, 2015). Agriculture jobs is not an easy job, but these migrant farmworkers are willing to fill these physical exhausting jobs because of the economic hardship, and the lack of jobs in the there country, therefore, courtiers that have these immigrant farmworkers should recognize immigrants for their hard work.

Read More
1314 Words | 6 Pages

Farm work is often seen as a man's job which leads to many individuals to view it as an easy-paying job. Not all farm workers are illegal immigrants, nor is it an easy job to do as

Read More
1208 Words | 5 Pages

For example, when Alabama enacted a bill that made it more difficult for the undocumented population to live and work there, the agricultural sector suffered greatly (Weigel). Undocumented workers were prompted to leave the state, and the the agricultural sector struggled to replace the labor force that was so heavily saturated with undocumented workers (Strupp). Farms spent a great deal of money training new workers, and many people did not want to do that kind of work (Weigel). The U.S. agriculture industry relies laboriously on undocumented workers and immigrants, and it is necessary to have such workers in order for the agriculture industry to survive

Read More
1244 Words | 5 Pages

Vagrants camp is a vineyard primarily planted with Chenin blanc grape variation. Chenin blanc is a type of grape which is used to (i) produce white wine or (ii) blend with Sauvignon bland or Chardonnay to create a fresh zesty dry wine. Despite that the grapes were picked at 24.5 Brix, but because these grapes were used to produce cheap wine that was usually blended with other varieties, however this was not a major concern when compared to weight of the fruit. Upon deciding whether or not to pick the grape, the interns should estimate the maturity of the grapes with these criteria: sugar content, acid content, pH level, color, ease of removal from pedicels, texture/skin features, aroma, flavor, chewy character, after taste and tannins. They

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of H-2A Immigrant Workers

Related Topics

Open Document